Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's not impossible that ds could become a barrister?

162 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 26/10/2022 15:41

I am shamelessly posting here for traffic to try and get some advice for ds1 as I don't know about this to advise him properly.

He is currently in Y11 and predicted all 8s and 9s. He is incredibly driven and focused and has done tons of research into degrees and careers. He has come to the conclusion that he'd like to be a barrister - he's certain at the moment he would not want to be a solicitor. However, his research has led him to believe that unless he does law at Oxbridge he stands next to no chance of securing a pupillage, and that even if he does this will still not guarantee a career as a barrister. He is quoting all sorts of scary stats and basically thinks that without connections and Oxbridge he'll have no chance. He's also concerned that it'll be a 'beggars can't be choosers' scenario and he'll end up helping some corporation pay less tax and/or screw over their employees, which he wouldn't want to do. He wants to go into human rights but has realised this doesn't pay well, which, despite his principles, puts him off.

My opinion is that he is extremely bright and also has other qualities that will make him desirable, such as the aforementioned drive and focus, and that he is likely to get an excellent degree from an excellent university (maybe Oxbridge, maybe not) and that that degree will lead him to some kind of excellent career that he may not even be aware exists at the moment. He's not happy with this response.

Does anyone have any advice and/or experience of people from 'ordinary' backgrounds making it as a barrister and/or people with law degrees having a worthwhile career in another sector? I'm all talked out about this at the moment!

OP posts:
Winterscomingagain · 26/10/2022 20:26

My son studied law in Dundee and went into banking. He's now a vice president at 28 yrs old and wouldn't consider going back to a law career.
His friends who have proceeded with law are working colossal hours and seem to be promised a great deal in terms of future promotion ie: you'll be a director by the time you're 35. In the interim they're not earning a great deal but hopefully that will happen. I've asked him if many have become barristers and he says a few are in the process but also highlights that they were either from legal families or extremely wealthy. Ie: wealthy enough to live in London indepentedly and work as unpaid interns for top law firms during the holidays.
Perhaps he just needs to apply for law and see how things work out.

Zuma76 · 26/10/2022 20:22

I was in the same position. I decided I wanted to be a barrister when I was about 12. I went to a basic state school. I discounted being a solicitor. I did well at GCSE and A level. I studied law at a good uni and did the bar course. I knew the risks but I was confident I was good enough. I didn’t get a pupillage and the interviews I did get I lost out to pupils at Oxbridge.
I do not believe it is because they went to Oxbridge but more because they were better trained though the way Oxbridge operates to handle interviews.

I ended up cross qualifying as a solicitor and it suits me much better actually. I believe that now it is unlikely that chambers select because of Oxbridge. The Bar is more diverse now. Obviously that hasn’t fed through to the judiciary but it will do.
if he is adamant he wants to do it, he has to have excellent grades, a good uni, possibly a masters, legal experience and/ or evidence that he has obtained transferable skills through other work. He should spend a lot of time getting to grips with current issues and be able to confidently debate and discuss issues outside his comfort zone. All applicants will have the grades. To be selected for an interview he needs something different on his CV. I believe I got my interviews due to a quirky hobby.

onemomentintime · 26/10/2022 20:12

SuperGinger · 26/10/2022 20:00

I would never allow my DC to become barristers, it is very stressful, you have no social life in your twenties or thirties, the hours are a killer, sleeping on the floor in Chambers is not uncommon when you have a trial on. Loads of barristers end up divorced, depressed or burnt out.

Human rights is noble but if he is serious and as focused as you say, more commercial stuff would suit him better.

How can you 'not allow' your DC to do something?

I know a lot of barristers in their 20s and 30s through DH as well as plenty in their 40s/40s. Most manage to have a reasonable social life, meet partners, have families etc. Yes they may have times when it's long hours but so do lots of jobs in your 20s.

SuperGinger · 26/10/2022 20:06

Also as someone else mentioned you don't always get paid which is a total bugger and Chambers expenses are awful.

SuperGinger · 26/10/2022 20:00

I would never allow my DC to become barristers, it is very stressful, you have no social life in your twenties or thirties, the hours are a killer, sleeping on the floor in Chambers is not uncommon when you have a trial on. Loads of barristers end up divorced, depressed or burnt out.

Human rights is noble but if he is serious and as focused as you say, more commercial stuff would suit him better.

Basecamp · 26/10/2022 19:53

Friend of mine from uni is a successful barrister. We went to a very middle of the road uni, albeit one with a good law school.

SuperGinger · 26/10/2022 19:46

What area of law is he looking at? To be in a top set, not criminal, you need to be very focused and most are Oxford/Cambridge. State school not an issue but doing mini pupillages and being involved in university debating etc all good, casting his net wide is important. It is competitive but the recruitment process is very fair and many top sets are interested in diversity.

SlipperyDippery · 26/10/2022 19:42

Your son sounds a bit naive with the stuff about human rights. As a lawyer you have to represent your client regardless if you are sympathetic to them or not. Perhaps law is not for him

exactly this. The essence of being a barrister is you fearlessly represent your client whatever your personal views.

I expect it’s teenage naivety which is understandable so doesn’t mean that he can’t still be a good lawyer but please manage his expectations in this regard. You cannot be a barrister and only represent good people.

Greengagesnfennel · 26/10/2022 19:38

Greengagesnfennel · 26/10/2022 19:36

Keir starmer, head of the labour party. Barrister, son of a nurse and a toolmaker. Became head of crown prosecution service.
Are you a troll supporter of the labour party op?

Just looked him up en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keir_Starmer went to university of Leeds not oxbridge too.

Greengagesnfennel · 26/10/2022 19:36

Keir starmer, head of the labour party. Barrister, son of a nurse and a toolmaker. Became head of crown prosecution service.
Are you a troll supporter of the labour party op?

thecatneuterer · 26/10/2022 19:32

Around 20 years ago I had a friend who was a barrister. He was in his twenties, so by no means senior, but seemed to be doing well. He was black, working class and from Peckham. I can't remember where he studied but it wasn't Oxbridge. He was earning enough to afford to buy a lovely flat somewhere central but leafy and drove an extremely posh car (and was constantly being stopped by Police for being black in charge of an expensive car).

BunnyBerries · 26/10/2022 19:30

I second @goldfinchonthelawn
to add that you absolutely don't need to do a law degree. You can go to a great university and achieve the best grade in your best subject. Just look at the public profiles of barristers in top sets.

It used to be until very, very recently that as you need loads of legal work experience, most places knew that everyone was desperate for it, and so offered this unpaid, which is why the richest students only could afford to do it for weeks or months on end, or that they got in solely through connections. I suspect this is not really legal now to open up that necessary work experience to a more diverse set of students.

I think you have to be someone willing to sell yourself and be proud of all you've achieved. Many do a law conversion course after their specialist degree to stand out more, and get experience with advocacy clubs and pupillages in the meantime to get connections. Get in touch with your university careers or employability service from the very first term at university and attend all the legal careers events and apply for all the volunteering and traineeship positions. Human rights however might be one of the absolute top most competitive to get into though.

Technology is also apparently becoming key in the legal sector so any experience in that could certainly give him a boost.

eldorado02 · 26/10/2022 19:26

In addition to all the excellent advice on this thread, I’d Encourage your son to get into any public speaking or debating clubs/extra curricular activities his school might offer. He will learn so much about thinking on his feet and getting his point across in an articulate way, plus any achievements at the national competitions will bolster his application to uni and gaining internship placements.

LaurieFairyCake · 26/10/2022 19:21

crosstalk

Confused

Where did I say a barrister could just call themselves one?

Are you confusing me with someone else?

I just said they didn't have to go to Oxbridge and that they worked on a self employed basis (both of which are true). And yes they do contribute to expenses.

ElspethTascioni · 26/10/2022 19:17

It doesn’t have to be an elite uni. We’ve taken candidates from “new” unis before. I do wish people who don’t have a clue wouldn’t give advise…🤦🏻‍♀️

Duplocrocs · 26/10/2022 19:16

Well is doesn’t have to be oxbridge but it will have to be an elite uni.
But if he’s on track for excellent grades why can he apply to oxbridge at uni? Any relevant experience that would help get him into Oxbridge would also be the sort of experience he can build on in the future

Dotcheck · 26/10/2022 19:15

Croque · 26/10/2022 16:43

That sounds just like my OH. He did not do a law degree but did get a first (following public school). He has brilliant social skills and is funny and a brilliant networker so perhaps tell your DS to focus on building those skills.

He spent many years living off his side hustles (property investment) before he became a superstar performer so it helped that he was never poor. He now chooses to work for about a quarter of the week to hit his six figure annual target.

So, your husband went to public school and is now doing very well?
Blow me down

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 26/10/2022 19:11

My brother is at oxbridge doing law right now, from my understanding of what he has told me, it's not you couldn't sit the bar but unless you have a first from oxbridge you're unlikely to get funding so it's fine if you're rich. He is doing loads of additional work outside his degree and has secured work already. He has met with a few barristers who have explained you can take different routes it's not just one path.

But I will say it's all insanely competitive. My brother was the only kid in the area to go to oxbridge so not saying it can't be done! But he will need to graft.

Summerfun54321 · 26/10/2022 19:08

It’s very hard to make an informed decision at his age. Why doesn’t he just try hard at a-levels, study law at the best uni he can get into and go from there. By the time he’s matured and become a bit more independent he might have a different view of things.

ElspethTascioni · 26/10/2022 19:06

I always wonder at that too @Unseelie - this insistence it’s all about who you know! I can’t pretend it doesn’t happen, but it most certainly is not the norm anymore.

pitterypattery00 · 26/10/2022 19:03

No personal experience of law. But I have several friends with law degrees. Only one - who I've been friends with since we were 3! - is an actual lawyer. He was called to the bar (is that the right phrase?) in New York and in England & Wales but don't think he's a barrister now, is currently partner in top private law firm in London. He is from a very normal family, no private schooling, no law connections in his family. He has worked hard - finished top of his year at Edinburgh Uni, masters in law from Harvard.

The others I know are working in areas related to law rather than as solicitors or barristers - legal advisors for a university, in the navy, and as a specialist in legal information technology for a a large pharmaceutical company (this person did a second degree in IT sponsored by the company - now in a very high paid, senior role). So there are lots of places a law degree can take you.

Unseelie · 26/10/2022 19:03

I was put off becoming a barrister because everyone told me you have to be white, male, and have a oxbridge 1st class degree. I have two of the four requirements so became a solicitor instead.

As my career progressed I started to realise that this was terrible advice: I could easily have become a barrister. I met lots of barristers who hadn’t been to oxbridge. One QC I met through work even offered to retrain me in his chambers, but I couldn’t be bothered to change track by that point.

Tell him to work hard and get top grades and do law at the best uni he can, and to practice public speaking at every opportunity (debating? Drama?) and he’ll be fine.

(If he wants the oxbridge stamp on his CV but doesn’t get in for his degree he could consider doing a one year Masters there afterwards.)

FYI re money some barristers earn millions of pounds a year, others struggle to make minimum wage. Be careful what to specialise in! I’d aim for commercial litigation personally.

I do wonder why people persist in spreading this “it’s all who you know” myth. I think it must be to justify their own failures to themselves 🤷‍♀️

Labradooor · 26/10/2022 19:02

solicitor here. No need for making decisions on solicitor or barrister for a while. It’s not true you need to have gone to Oxbridge to secure a pupilage and tenancy but doubtless money and connections still help some out. The legal profession is trying to be more inclusive and look outside the higher prestige universities. That said, I’d go for a law degree from the best institution possible. Plenty of time to decide on bar school or legal practice course. No doubt about it getting a pupilage is tough as is seeing through the year earning next to nothing. The solicitor route is more secure from this point of view and I know people who switched after pupilage after not getting a secure tenancy. The stuff in the media about how difficult life is for junior criminal barristers is not made up. Read the Secret Barrister.

ElspethTascioni · 26/10/2022 18:58

I need to correct @Waveacrossabay ’s false information - ALL of the pupillage year is paid. Normally minimum earnings of £40k even in provincial sets. Very outdated information. Must have been 20 years now. (Not necessarily at £40k!)

crosstalk · 26/10/2022 18:56

@LaurieFairyCake Unfortunately you clearly know nothing about law, so not helpful. A barrister may be self employed (but contributing to all chambers' expenses) but they can't just call themselves barristers even with a law degree and specialist training.

Swipe left for the next trending thread