Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect to keep my full holiday entitlement?

380 replies

namechange0998776554432 · 26/10/2022 14:53

I've just applied to change my hours at work so I finish at 3pm every day, meaning I now work 80% of my full time hours. I was previously entitled to 25 days holiday but they're saying that will reduce to 20
(I.e. 20% less). I understand the logic, but I'm still working every day and losing a whole week's holiday is going to be pretty significant for me. The reason I'm cutting my hours is because I have no childcare outside of school! My pay is already reducing by 20% so taking a weeks leave from me on top seems unfair.

Surely, since in each day I work 20% less hours, when I am on leave I am also taking 20% less leave. So, I should still get 25 days (but am taking 20% less hours each day). I already argued this to HR but they refused, and sent me a policy which very clearly states the calculation and says if you're part time on e.g. 80% hours, you get 80% leave even if you work 5 days a week. This seems wrong to me but they refuse to give in.

Has anyone else been in a similar situation and managed to argue successfully? Am I being unreasonable to expect a bit more from a company who claims to support women who need flexible working arrangements?

OP posts:
Getoff · 28/10/2022 14:13

There are two ways hours can be reduced by 20%. If OP went from 5 to 4 days a week, and holiday entitlement went from 25 to 20 days, she'd still be able to take five weeks holiday, because she would only have to book 4 days off for each week of holiday. It would be illogical if reducing each day by 20% did not give the same result as leaving the day length unchanged and reducing the number of days by 20%.

The contract is probably correct in saying she should have 20 days, the problem is the holiday booking system that does not allow her to book 0.8 day units of holiday for each calendar day she intends to be away.

Faultymain5 · 28/10/2022 13:00

namechange0998776554432 · 28/10/2022 08:53

Sorry! HR haven't replied yet and I'm not technically working this week. I'll let you know what the outcome is as soon as I know though!

Not to worry this is your life. Not entertainment.

Princessglittery · 28/10/2022 12:45

@Utilityroomenvy 3 months with ACAS involvement, that is appalling.

What I don’t understand is the Working Time Regs came in to effect in October 1998 and the The Part-time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations came into effect in July 2000. The original right to request flexible working came into effect in 1996 (I think as part of Employment Rights Act). So why are so many employers and HR people getting it wrong over 20 years from when the legislation was implemented.

I joined HR in 1992 and we had a long standing methodology which, used hours to be absolutely fair and, is still legally compliant 30 years later. Whilst HR systems I use are now configured with this methodology there are still published worked examples so employees can work it out themselves.

Utilityroomenvy · 28/10/2022 11:59

OP I really hope you aren’t being put off getting this sorted because of some of the nonsense comments and frankly shitty maths skills of some people on here.

I have dug out the email conversations I had with my HR team back in 2015. It’s been covered several times but almost definitely worth reiterating the point.

My working hours changed from 35 hours per week (Monday to Friday 9-5 with an hour for lunch) to 32.5 hours per week (Monday to Friday 9-4 with a half hour for lunch).

Annual leave entitlement for all employees is 30 days or pro rata’d based on hours worked per week. That remains the same as I am still working 5 days a week.

FT entitlement is 210 hours (30 days multiplied by 7 hours worked per day).

6.5 hours worked per day is 195 hours entitlement. Therefore when you book a “day” leave it should reduce your entitlement by 6.25 hours each time. This will ONLY apply if an employee works 5 days a week.

It took three months and a conversation with ACAS to confirm all this with HR but got it sorted in the end. Do persevere with this because you are right!!!!!

almondflake · 28/10/2022 11:56

Ours is calculated by days to so when I was full time I got 25 days which equated to 5 weeks now I'm part time and work 3 days a week I get 15 days which still equals 5 weeks . If you still work the same number of days just reduced hours you should still get the same number of days holiday just reduced pay as your day is shorter .

BinBandit · 28/10/2022 11:48

Glitterlikeawinner · 28/10/2022 09:02

@namechange0998776554432 Really hoping you got this one sorted!

So many different approaches on here which reflects the various ways business' calculate leave.

Having worked in HR for 17+ years I've seen them all!

Essentially though if they are giving you a 'days entitlement' they should be working out by how many days you work per week for their calculation. In this case 5 days so yes your entitlement should remain as 25 days, however when you book a day off, of course your days pay is less than normal. 25days @ 5.6hrs per day = 140hrs.

This way is perfectly reasonable way to calculate part time annual leave, on the basis that if payroll are processing said leave, they are doing so at the employees normal working day hours not FTE.

The alternative to this is to calculate in hours, so calculate what a colleague works per week so for consistency as above, they work 5.6hrs per day, 28 hours per week their years entitlement will be 140hrs, which does scale back up to 20 days but because they've calculated in hours, they need you to book in hours from this entitlement. I suspect they have confirmed this 20 days from your hours entitlement but you shouldn't then be booking 'days' from this.

Essentially, you either calculate in days and OP books in days, or you calculate in hours and OP books in hours. You can't switch between the two if that makes sense!

Hope this is helpful!!

exactly.

I have worked reduced hours (93%) evenly over 5 days, I've worked same % on a nine date fortnight and now work 80% over 4 days. I've been tupe'd twice so transferred between different employer systems and yet, I've never had an issue.

hours/days didn't matter when I worked 5 days of the same length. After that, I got allocation in hours but the system was clever enough to allow me to book in days/half days and deduct the correct number of hours from my balance even when my hours were not exactly the same everyday.

It even works out my pro rated Bank Holidays and sorts out deducting hours or not depending on whether I'm normally due to work that day. I don't work on a Monday and a lot of BH fall on that day.

Hope you get this sorted OP

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 28/10/2022 10:55

JOFFCV · 28/10/2022 10:43

I understand it.

I'm glad someone does.

I'm trying to say if you buy something worth 80p with a pound coin, and don't get any change, you're being ripped off.

JOFFCV · 28/10/2022 10:43

Razu45 · 28/10/2022 10:36

Well I don’t think the OP is unreasonable (not based on her Op which was quite unclear, but subsequent posts)

however I couldn’t make head nor tail of your post!

I understand it.

Razu45 · 28/10/2022 10:36

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 28/10/2022 10:28

I live in hope.

Maybe I should add on the end that if OPs employer want to charge her a whole coin per day off, then need to give her 25 x 80p coins.

Or they give her 20p change. But that sounds like it would require re writing the leave system, so 25 x 80p coins is much simpler.

Well I don’t think the OP is unreasonable (not based on her Op which was quite unclear, but subsequent posts)

however I couldn’t make head nor tail of your post!

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 28/10/2022 10:28

Razu45 · 28/10/2022 10:22

Doubt it

I live in hope.

Maybe I should add on the end that if OPs employer want to charge her a whole coin per day off, then need to give her 25 x 80p coins.

Or they give her 20p change. But that sounds like it would require re writing the leave system, so 25 x 80p coins is much simpler.

Razu45 · 28/10/2022 10:22

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 28/10/2022 10:22

Maybe this will make sense to those not agreeing OP is right:

Assume OP gets paid £1 a day. And at the beginning of the year, she is given 25 £1 coins to 'buy' her holiday with when she wants a day off.

She's now reduced her hours by 20% so her employer is giving her 20% less coins to buy her holiday. So she gets 20 coins.

Now OPs days are shorter, she only gets paid 80p a day.

OP wants a day off, so she hands over one of her £1 coins. 'can I have 20p back please' she says, 'my days cost 80p'

'NO' says her employer. (because ops holiday system only allows leave to be booked in 1 day blocks, and OP only has 20 blocks to use) 'we don't give any change. A day is £1.'

'But' says OP 'my days are 80p! You've already taken some coins away for my shorter days, now you want to keep my change too by charging me £1 for one day!'

Doubt it

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 28/10/2022 10:22

Maybe this will make sense to those not agreeing OP is right:

Assume OP gets paid £1 a day. And at the beginning of the year, she is given 25 £1 coins to 'buy' her holiday with when she wants a day off.

She's now reduced her hours by 20% so her employer is giving her 20% less coins to buy her holiday. So she gets 20 coins.

Now OPs days are shorter, she only gets paid 80p a day.

OP wants a day off, so she hands over one of her £1 coins. 'can I have 20p back please' she says, 'my days cost 80p'

'NO' says her employer. (because ops holiday system only allows leave to be booked in 1 day blocks, and OP only has 20 blocks to use) 'we don't give any change. A day is £1.'

'But' says OP 'my days are 80p! You've already taken some coins away for my shorter days, now you want to keep my change too by charging me £1 for one day!'

burnoutbabe · 28/10/2022 09:53

SMrs · 28/10/2022 08:07

Your annual leave is worked out in hours. So when they say 20 days that usually means 8/8.5 hours so if you only work 6 hours, you will essentially only use 0.8 of your annual leave for a full day off.

So you will still get the exact same annual leave allocation in terms of your shorter working days

Correct but the op says she can't book 0.8 days off on the holiday system.
If she could it would be okay -20 days meaning 20 7.5 hour days. Booking 25 0.8 days holiday would use it up. All would be fine.

But the system only allows a unit of 1 to be booked. That's the main issue (and weird,no one ever allowed a half day when they have say hospital appointment)

jsof595 · 28/10/2022 09:41

What do you do if you do not mind me asking? I would argue if you are getting all of/the same amount of work done in less hours worked you could make a fair argument to your employer not to cut pay or holiday.

VerbenaGirl · 28/10/2022 09:27

For part-timers, our holiday entitlement is done pro rata in hours - so to book one day off, they use less than full-time hours. This makes it fair and comparable.

Glitterlikeawinner · 28/10/2022 09:05

Glitterlikeawinner · 28/10/2022 09:02

@namechange0998776554432 Really hoping you got this one sorted!

So many different approaches on here which reflects the various ways business' calculate leave.

Having worked in HR for 17+ years I've seen them all!

Essentially though if they are giving you a 'days entitlement' they should be working out by how many days you work per week for their calculation. In this case 5 days so yes your entitlement should remain as 25 days, however when you book a day off, of course your days pay is less than normal. 25days @ 5.6hrs per day = 140hrs.

This way is perfectly reasonable way to calculate part time annual leave, on the basis that if payroll are processing said leave, they are doing so at the employees normal working day hours not FTE.

The alternative to this is to calculate in hours, so calculate what a colleague works per week so for consistency as above, they work 5.6hrs per day, 28 hours per week their years entitlement will be 140hrs, which does scale back up to 20 days but because they've calculated in hours, they need you to book in hours from this entitlement. I suspect they have confirmed this 20 days from your hours entitlement but you shouldn't then be booking 'days' from this.

Essentially, you either calculate in days and OP books in days, or you calculate in hours and OP books in hours. You can't switch between the two if that makes sense!

Hope this is helpful!!

Just to add for clarity, the scaling back up to 20 days is based on a FT day but as OP works 5.6hrs if you cake back up correctly I does come to 25 days which is correct!

JOFFCV · 28/10/2022 09:04

Glitterlikeawinner · 28/10/2022 09:02

@namechange0998776554432 Really hoping you got this one sorted!

So many different approaches on here which reflects the various ways business' calculate leave.

Having worked in HR for 17+ years I've seen them all!

Essentially though if they are giving you a 'days entitlement' they should be working out by how many days you work per week for their calculation. In this case 5 days so yes your entitlement should remain as 25 days, however when you book a day off, of course your days pay is less than normal. 25days @ 5.6hrs per day = 140hrs.

This way is perfectly reasonable way to calculate part time annual leave, on the basis that if payroll are processing said leave, they are doing so at the employees normal working day hours not FTE.

The alternative to this is to calculate in hours, so calculate what a colleague works per week so for consistency as above, they work 5.6hrs per day, 28 hours per week their years entitlement will be 140hrs, which does scale back up to 20 days but because they've calculated in hours, they need you to book in hours from this entitlement. I suspect they have confirmed this 20 days from your hours entitlement but you shouldn't then be booking 'days' from this.

Essentially, you either calculate in days and OP books in days, or you calculate in hours and OP books in hours. You can't switch between the two if that makes sense!

Hope this is helpful!!

Very helpful.

Glitterlikeawinner · 28/10/2022 09:02

@namechange0998776554432 Really hoping you got this one sorted!

So many different approaches on here which reflects the various ways business' calculate leave.

Having worked in HR for 17+ years I've seen them all!

Essentially though if they are giving you a 'days entitlement' they should be working out by how many days you work per week for their calculation. In this case 5 days so yes your entitlement should remain as 25 days, however when you book a day off, of course your days pay is less than normal. 25days @ 5.6hrs per day = 140hrs.

This way is perfectly reasonable way to calculate part time annual leave, on the basis that if payroll are processing said leave, they are doing so at the employees normal working day hours not FTE.

The alternative to this is to calculate in hours, so calculate what a colleague works per week so for consistency as above, they work 5.6hrs per day, 28 hours per week their years entitlement will be 140hrs, which does scale back up to 20 days but because they've calculated in hours, they need you to book in hours from this entitlement. I suspect they have confirmed this 20 days from your hours entitlement but you shouldn't then be booking 'days' from this.

Essentially, you either calculate in days and OP books in days, or you calculate in hours and OP books in hours. You can't switch between the two if that makes sense!

Hope this is helpful!!

namechange0998776554432 · 28/10/2022 08:53

Faultymain5 · 28/10/2022 07:39

Op please come back and put us out of our misery. This thread needs a Trigger warning.

Sorry! HR haven't replied yet and I'm not technically working this week. I'll let you know what the outcome is as soon as I know though!

OP posts:
JOFFCV · 28/10/2022 08:50

Everyone at my employment work 5 days. So a part time person who did 6 hours instead of 8 would still get the same amount of days holiday. Why are people arguing this and saying it has to be in hours?

Yes, if people did different hours all the time it would be worked out on hours.

SMrs · 28/10/2022 08:07

Your annual leave is worked out in hours. So when they say 20 days that usually means 8/8.5 hours so if you only work 6 hours, you will essentially only use 0.8 of your annual leave for a full day off.

So you will still get the exact same annual leave allocation in terms of your shorter working days

Faultymain5 · 28/10/2022 07:39

Op please come back and put us out of our misery. This thread needs a Trigger warning.

Faultymain5 · 28/10/2022 07:28

dementedpixie · 27/10/2022 19:22

FFS read the thread properly!

Yes by this time in the thread. I agree with this response.

csigeek · 28/10/2022 07:26

This is precisely why holiday should never be in days. Weeks or hours is the only logical way this works.
if you got 25 days previously plus bank hols you would have 6.6 weeks and you should still have 6.6 weeks regardless of your hours or days per week.

Blocklynn · 28/10/2022 07:05

I dropped my working hours but carried on working each day, they initially tried to pro rata the amount of days holiday that I got but I argued that it didn’t make sense.
I now have the same amount of days holiday as full time people but just less hours entitlement.