Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect to keep my full holiday entitlement?

380 replies

namechange0998776554432 · 26/10/2022 14:53

I've just applied to change my hours at work so I finish at 3pm every day, meaning I now work 80% of my full time hours. I was previously entitled to 25 days holiday but they're saying that will reduce to 20
(I.e. 20% less). I understand the logic, but I'm still working every day and losing a whole week's holiday is going to be pretty significant for me. The reason I'm cutting my hours is because I have no childcare outside of school! My pay is already reducing by 20% so taking a weeks leave from me on top seems unfair.

Surely, since in each day I work 20% less hours, when I am on leave I am also taking 20% less leave. So, I should still get 25 days (but am taking 20% less hours each day). I already argued this to HR but they refused, and sent me a policy which very clearly states the calculation and says if you're part time on e.g. 80% hours, you get 80% leave even if you work 5 days a week. This seems wrong to me but they refuse to give in.

Has anyone else been in a similar situation and managed to argue successfully? Am I being unreasonable to expect a bit more from a company who claims to support women who need flexible working arrangements?

OP posts:
namechange0998776554432 · 26/10/2022 15:57

IceandIndigo · 26/10/2022 15:54

It sounds like whoever has written the policy was only thinking about the scenario of a part-timer working fewer days, rather than reduced hours over the same number of days.

If their policy explicitly says that you are only entitled to 20 calendar days' leave, despite you working less than full-time hours on those days, then your employer is breaking the law because they are expecting you to accept less favourable terms and conditions than your full-time colleagues.

As others have explained, the correct thing for them to do is would be to calculate your leave in hours. If the normal leave entitlement is 25 days and you're 0.8 it's correct that your number of hours leave will be equivalent to 20 full-time days. But each calendar day you take should only 'cost' you 0.8 of the full-time equivalent, meaning that you can stretch your leave over 25 calendar days.

Thank you for the link, again I'm grateful to everyone for giving me the confidence to fight this. I can't help but wonder how many others have just accepted it?

OP posts:
IceandIndigo · 26/10/2022 15:56

When you were full-time, what happened if you wanted to take a half-day off, did that count as a full day's leave? It's the same principle.

IceandIndigo · 26/10/2022 15:54

It sounds like whoever has written the policy was only thinking about the scenario of a part-timer working fewer days, rather than reduced hours over the same number of days.

If their policy explicitly says that you are only entitled to 20 calendar days' leave, despite you working less than full-time hours on those days, then your employer is breaking the law because they are expecting you to accept less favourable terms and conditions than your full-time colleagues.

As others have explained, the correct thing for them to do is would be to calculate your leave in hours. If the normal leave entitlement is 25 days and you're 0.8 it's correct that your number of hours leave will be equivalent to 20 full-time days. But each calendar day you take should only 'cost' you 0.8 of the full-time equivalent, meaning that you can stretch your leave over 25 calendar days.

namechange0998776554432 · 26/10/2022 15:51

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 26/10/2022 15:28

I wouldn't go in full guns blazing. I'd say they have it right but are communicating it poorly. I used to cry every year working out the Christmas rota and one fifth payment and public holidays for bank holidays because we'd argue until we were ready to collapse and then I'd present my rota and they'd say that's grand despite telling me I was wrong the whole time. We'd be saying the same thing in different words. It's like how doctors are taught to make their writing indecipherable in college.

My issue is that the poor communication will be enshrined in my contract if I sign it, since it states 20 days. So I need to get it corrected in writing!

OP posts:
WireSkills · 26/10/2022 15:51

Grandstan · 26/10/2022 15:45

You work 80% compared to your previous 100% but expect the same holiday. Would you expect a colleague who only worked 60% to get the same as you? If not, why would you think you retain your holiday? It's usually worked out in hours, some employers' convert that to days for ease. YABU.

You're missing the point though. She's not expecting the same holiday, but the same proportion of holiday.

OP used to get 187.5 hours annual leave per year.

Yes, losing 20% of her work should mean losing 20% of her holiday, so 150 hours, but when a working day is now only 6 hours instead of 7.5, 150 /6 = 25 days!

Her work are saying that she actually should get 120 hours of leave, which is 64% of what she had, or a 36% drop - that's not right.

OP was working 5 days a week and is still working 5 days a week, but somehow it's "right" that she loses a whole week's annual leave?! No chance!

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 26/10/2022 15:48

I'd ask them to clarify :-

  1. How many hours the new leave entitlement is
  2. How many hours of that leave do they then apply to you when you take a day off
thenightsky · 26/10/2022 15:46

Y7drama · 26/10/2022 14:57

They’ve got it wrong, they need to calculate your holiday entitlement in hours, so for example you’d still get 25 days but 25 days at 6 hours a day so 150 hours rather than 25 days at 8 hours a day (200 hours). I think that makes sense

That's how it worked for me when I cut my days shorter to finish at 2.30pm for school pick up. It was all worked in hours, so yes, I got less hours leave, but I only needed 5.5 hours leave to get a whole day off (NHS)

Ataliecalm · 26/10/2022 15:46

I did something similar last year and asked how It would be worked out. I now work Monday to Friday 9-3 instead of 9-5.30. I get exactly the same amount of days as previously, its just based on the new hours.

WireSkills · 26/10/2022 15:46

PP's way of explaining it is excellent where they equate that you're losing 36% of your holiday for a 20% reduction in your working hours.

If you look at in terms of actual hours worked, it goes as follows:

  • Let's assume that a working year is exactly 52 weeks x 37.5 hours this is 1,950 hours. You take 25 x 7.5 days holiday, leaving 1,762.50 hours actually worked per year.
  • Reducing to 6 hours a day is 1,560 hours of available working hours per year. If they're now only saying you get 20 x 6 hour days this means you'll be working 1,440 hours, so as a percentage of your original working hours it's 81.7%

I'd be going back to them if they insist and saying in that case you want 81.7% of your original pay, not 80%!

I reckon the intern has either used poor maths, got totally muddled, or has used the Government's calculator.

The problem with the government calculator is that it only works out the statutory minimum entitlement. You already had more than the statutory minimum in the first place.

Grandstan · 26/10/2022 15:45

You work 80% compared to your previous 100% but expect the same holiday. Would you expect a colleague who only worked 60% to get the same as you? If not, why would you think you retain your holiday? It's usually worked out in hours, some employers' convert that to days for ease. YABU.

SomeUnspokenThing · 26/10/2022 15:40

Dguu6u · 26/10/2022 15:28

OP - repeating in case you miss this message in the thread. This spells it out cleanly and factually.

I work part-time at 0.8 FTE and have no issues with leave. It can be managed very effectively when calculated in hours.

Sager · 26/10/2022 15:39

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 26/10/2022 14:56

You should still get the same number of days. The total hours will be different 5hough. So if you were previously entitled to 100 hrs, you would now be entitled to 80hrs which would equate to the same number of days because each day now takes up less hours.

This. I've just changed my hours from full time to 9-3. I get less AL hours but I still get the same number of days.

Dixiechickonhols · 26/10/2022 15:35

Ours is expressed as 25 days but actually booked by hour so 7.4 hours for a day off whereas you would only need 5.5 etc for a day off.

Ellie1015 · 26/10/2022 15:34

Your AL should drop by the same % as the work you have dropped. So you should still get the same amount of days AL.

For example worked 40 hours per week, 30 days AL (240 hours). Dropped to 80% ie 32 hours per week means AL drops by 20% too so 24 days AL (192 hours). 192 hours AL divided by 32 hours per wk = 6 weeks off each year for 32 hours per week. 240/40 = 6 weeks AL.

The person should have said your AL entitlement drops by 20%, not the number of days off. Worth querying, but unless a very small business the payroll system will calculate the hours.

Notadramallama · 26/10/2022 15:33

I've done the same. I still work 5 days a week but only 5 hours per day instead of 7. My holiday allowance, in days, has remained the same, but has reduced in hours.

Sistanotcista · 26/10/2022 15:32

OP - if you are going to check this with HR, then also ask whether your entitled to paid sick leave changes. You might as well have all the facts before committing to the new contract!

RagzRebooted · 26/10/2022 15:32

SardineJam · 26/10/2022 14:55

Genuine question, why do you believe you're eligible for 100% holiday when only working 80%? What made you think it wouldn't change?

Surely it would now just be paid at 25 6 hour days rather than 25 8 hour days (or however many hours your days are now). Leave is actually accurately calculated using hours and then you divide that by days, but still you will get 80% of what you got before. Same number 9f days but less pay.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 26/10/2022 15:28

I wouldn't go in full guns blazing. I'd say they have it right but are communicating it poorly. I used to cry every year working out the Christmas rota and one fifth payment and public holidays for bank holidays because we'd argue until we were ready to collapse and then I'd present my rota and they'd say that's grand despite telling me I was wrong the whole time. We'd be saying the same thing in different words. It's like how doctors are taught to make their writing indecipherable in college.

Dguu6u · 26/10/2022 15:28

Show your employer this: www.acas.org.uk/checking-holiday-entitlement

TheGoodEnoughWife · 26/10/2022 15:27

Also this regarding you now getting 20 days. They are 8 hour days. When you take a day off you will using 0.8 of a holiday day so it would work out but they may not see that!

To have a five day week off you will need to use four holiday days iyswim.

blobby10 · 26/10/2022 15:25

It depends on your Terms of Employment - in our organisation if you work 5 days a week you get the same number of holidays whether working 4 hours a day or 8. If you only work 4 days a week then you get 80% of FTE.

Dguu6u · 26/10/2022 15:25

But they are right... you drop down to 20 FTE days. So 20 fulltime days, but as you only work 0.8 days, you only need to take 0.8 days for every day off. So it works out the same. It's easier if you just calculate your leave in hours.

namechange0998776554432 · 26/10/2022 15:21

Haven't dropped a day!! Gosh this interface is rubbish and I have a squirming child jumping on me

OP posts:
namechange0998776554432 · 26/10/2022 15:20

Dinoswearunderpants · 26/10/2022 15:17

That's pretty standard practice. I've also just reduced my hours from 37 to 28. My annual leave went from 30 to 24 days.

How do bank holidays work? you might need to calculate them as I get an allowance for my bank holidays and those that don't fall on my non-working day, I need to book off out of this bank holiday allowance.

I can understand your frustration but you have to be fair and realistic. You're calculating this is days when you need to calculate it on hours.

I think the difference is I have dropped a day, I just work less hours each day. I agree it would be different if I was working fewer days

OP posts:
namechange0998776554432 · 26/10/2022 15:19

20 days, not 3

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread