Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Old as time question

60 replies

Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 22:07

WWYD…
a relationship years long, I want to get married (happy to do it just us) I want us us to be family, he doesn’t see the point so says no. Everything else is great and he wants us to keep doing what we are doing forever (neither have DC or have been previously married)

YABU - everything else is ideal suck it up
YANBU - everything else is ideal, he should suck it up and give you what you want

OP posts:
OnTheBrinkOfChange · 25/10/2022 23:27

I think you need to say to him look, we need and want different things. You are confusing our relationship with your parents' relationship and yet the fact we can sit and talk in a civilised manner about difficult things shows we are nothing like them.

Say, I want to form a family of whatever kind with someone. I thought that person was you but I can see now that we want different things. So what I'm going to do now is to leave so that I can find that with somebody else.

Then I think you should leave.

Stay civil, stay polite, but do exactly what you said you would do. Then wait. He will be shocked, I think he thinks you're all talk at the moment about this. Give him time to really think about what he has lost. In the meantime have a bloody good time!

StoneofDestiny · 25/10/2022 23:16

can't imagine why he worries about a 'messy divorce' (that might never happen) and doesn't care enough you just walking away from a long relationship now.
Sounds his feelings might be shallower than yours.

Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 23:11

Summerfun54321 · 25/10/2022 23:05

Sorry to say it but he’s just not that into you. This isn’t a man who’s madly head over heals in love with you. This is a guy who’s prepared to loose you because he won’t budge on a stupid principle. He’s a gutless time waster and exactly the kind of guy who will be engaged and expecting a baby with someone else 6 months after you split. Get out now and find your sole mate because this guy isn’t it.

I genuinely don’t think he would

however, from a point of view of only caring about myself if this is it and it doesn’t work am I f&£k ever doing this to myself again.. I will just get myself 29384 dogs and 29394 cats thank you very much x

OP posts:
TheCurseOfBoris · 25/10/2022 23:11

Dont fall foul of the 'sunken cost fallacy'. Just because you've been together years, don't expect him to suddenly change, why would he? If it's that important to you, get out now.

Summerfun54321 · 25/10/2022 23:05

Sorry to say it but he’s just not that into you. This isn’t a man who’s madly head over heals in love with you. This is a guy who’s prepared to loose you because he won’t budge on a stupid principle. He’s a gutless time waster and exactly the kind of guy who will be engaged and expecting a baby with someone else 6 months after you split. Get out now and find your sole mate because this guy isn’t it.

Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 23:05

Sapphire387 · 25/10/2022 22:59

I'm calling BS, on him.

He 'doesn't see the point'? The point is that it matters, to you.

If he really wasn't fussed either way then surely he'd do it, because it matters, to you.

He doesn't want to marry you. I am so sorry if that sounds harsh. Believe me, I have been there, in past relationships. There was a marked difference between that and DH... when I said I wanted to get married, he said 'ok, shall we say March?'. That was four months away. We did it, no fuss.

Call me cynical but so many men do this, the relationship ends and then they quickly marry their next partner.

This is what deep down I’m scared might be happening (I’m a very defensive person so I never know if I’m just being wild) x

OP posts:
Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 23:03

NannyGythaOgg · 25/10/2022 22:56

So what if/when one of you is seriously ill. The partner has no legal right to have any involvement in making any decisions either financial, emotional or care.

When the first one dies (and it will probably be a long time off) then the other has no rights financially or any other way.

If you BOTH do decide to not marry then at least all potential legal positions should be looked at. EG A distant relative that the dying partner has never met has more rights over the funeral, any financial aspects, and any care aspects should one be left incapacitated.

There are no definitive right or wrong choices here - it's far more about what is right for both of you (definitely not just one of you)

Another thing that makes it even harder both sides look at us like a “married couple” so take what the other says as “this person knows them best”…which has happened e.g. she/he would want this and family accepts (probably the only MN question where the family has each other’s back and there’s a lot of respects from both sides 😑) x

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 25/10/2022 22:59

I'm calling BS, on him.

He 'doesn't see the point'? The point is that it matters, to you.

If he really wasn't fussed either way then surely he'd do it, because it matters, to you.

He doesn't want to marry you. I am so sorry if that sounds harsh. Believe me, I have been there, in past relationships. There was a marked difference between that and DH... when I said I wanted to get married, he said 'ok, shall we say March?'. That was four months away. We did it, no fuss.

Call me cynical but so many men do this, the relationship ends and then they quickly marry their next partner.

NannyGythaOgg · 25/10/2022 22:56

So what if/when one of you is seriously ill. The partner has no legal right to have any involvement in making any decisions either financial, emotional or care.

When the first one dies (and it will probably be a long time off) then the other has no rights financially or any other way.

If you BOTH do decide to not marry then at least all potential legal positions should be looked at. EG A distant relative that the dying partner has never met has more rights over the funeral, any financial aspects, and any care aspects should one be left incapacitated.

There are no definitive right or wrong choices here - it's far more about what is right for both of you (definitely not just one of you)

Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 22:56

Pixiecushion · 25/10/2022 22:21

This is me. 30 years together. Jointly own our house. Mortgage paid off. But not married and he’s never going to ask me. Why not?

Sorry the above was meant to ask you x

OP posts:
Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 22:55

Are you happy/have you been able to accept it? X

OP posts:
Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 22:52

TheCurseOfBoris · 25/10/2022 22:49

Also he is fully aware I might walk away over this I’ve told him, we have had very open conversations over it..he says I don’t want to hold you back by saying I will want it when I don’t know (both late 30’s) and it’s down to me if I can accept it or not
He's telling you. Listen.

Maybe, it’s just so difficult to know with no other issues (I know you will think I’m clutching but it’s really not the case)

OP posts:
Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 22:51

not to make excuses-he doesn’t know it but I do he doesn’t want to get married because of his mum and dads v messy divorce

OP posts:
TheCurseOfBoris · 25/10/2022 22:49

Also he is fully aware I might walk away over this I’ve told him, we have had very open conversations over it..he says I don’t want to hold you back by saying I will want it when I don’t know (both late 30’s) and it’s down to me if I can accept it or not
He's telling you. Listen.

AnneLovesGilbert · 25/10/2022 22:43

Plenty enough reason to walk away. While you’re being upset by this you’re not meeting the man who’ll share your hopes and dreams and enthusiastically want the commitment you do.

Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 22:41

TheCurseOfBoris · 25/10/2022 22:38

I don't know how old you are but it sounds like having children might be difficult? Sorry if I'm wrong. Maybe your OH is happy with the way things are and your dreams of being married won't actually happen, if you stay with him.
Do feel like he's not fully committed to you?

This 100% he is committed but I have a lot of feelings over him not taking the last step I want…is that enough to walk away

OP posts:
TheCurseOfBoris · 25/10/2022 22:40

He's telling you to go but he hasn't got the guts to actually say it.

Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 22:39

Also he is fully aware I might walk away over this I’ve told him, we have had very open conversations over it..he says I don’t want to hold you back by saying I will want it when I don’t know (both late 30’s) and it’s down to me if I can accept it or not

OP posts:
TheCurseOfBoris · 25/10/2022 22:38

I don't know how old you are but it sounds like having children might be difficult? Sorry if I'm wrong. Maybe your OH is happy with the way things are and your dreams of being married won't actually happen, if you stay with him.
Do feel like he's not fully committed to you?

Helpplz23563 · 25/10/2022 22:30

I completely understand the “third option” which is fully in my head but it’s so difficult because it would be the only reason I walked away…we have been living together for years (property/money would not be an issue for either party if we spilt up) and the kids thing is quite complex so I don’t know if health wise is on the cards for me or the child I may have (again something we went the tough together that he was so supportive with). X

OP posts:
Crucible · 25/10/2022 22:27

I don't see the point in doing many things but I do them anyway. I add syrup to coffee. It makes no great difference. But I do it sometimes. So, ask him to do it anyway and carry on as before. If it means nothing to him, what difference does it make - apart from doing it for you (which should count).
What I'm saying is that he won't do it because it does mean something.
And he knows that.

Don't know how many reluctant partners I've seen get pulled up real quick by this argument..

Merryoldgoat · 25/10/2022 22:24

Why is marriage important to you?

It was a deal breaker for me and I told my (now) husband that on I think date 3/4 - certainly in the first two months.

I was totally prepared to walk away.

If you know it’s what you want move on.

steff13 · 25/10/2022 22:23

Neither of you is wrong. You want different things, if you can't accept that he won't marry you, you should leave.

minticecreamisjustok · 25/10/2022 22:22

Do you live together? I'd leave, he doesn't want the same commitment as you, waiting isn't going to make him any keener.

toastofthetown · 25/10/2022 22:22

You need to decide whether or not being with him is more important than being married. He's clear that it's something he doesn't want to do, and that's ok. But it's an issue that there's no compromise on. Either it's a dealbreaker and you move on or it's not so you accept that you won't be married.

Swipe left for the next trending thread