Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it sets a really bad example for the country when the PMs family have tax dodged millions

458 replies

Chloefairydust · 25/10/2022 22:05

Just that really…

Im really surprised Sunak actually made it to be prime minister considering the recent stories that have been in the news regarding his family avoiding millions of ££ in tax . I actually thought Boris would have been more likely to have been PM. (Not that he’s any better🤔)

OP posts:
RosaGallica · 26/10/2022 19:07

MariEllie · 26/10/2022 16:39

Interesting a prime minister is being criticised for being an offspring of an immigrant family, whose parents came with nothing, worked hard as business people and sacrificed so they could send him to a leading school. He himself then did well in finance and became very wealthy himself and married an heiress. I would’ve thought that’s a story that could inspire other kids to do well. But no, to some people apparently it would be better if he’d been a downright failure and ended up on social security as a drain on the system.

From nothing? From parents who had nothing?

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

minou123 · 26/10/2022 19:00

MariEllie · 26/10/2022 18:33

So the leader of the Opposition is worth between £5-7 million. Where did his wealth come from? And the trade union leaders get vast salaries too. For goodness sake, some of these Libby left BBC personalities are worth millions!

So the leader of the Opposition is worth between £5-7 million. Where did his wealth come from?

He was a professional fluffer.
Its a sad story really, due to medical advancements, the market dried up. So he became a politician instead.

🙄

Chippy1234 · 26/10/2022 19:00

Give it a rest. You are clearly a Labour leftie.

Hawkins001 · 26/10/2022 18:56

mynamesnotMa · 26/10/2022 12:49

It might be ethically wrong but being so wealthy it's no different than billionaires all over the world using legal schemes to minimise their tax liability.
The shit will hit the fan if he doesn't sort the countries finances and trillions of debt. He's on borrowed time

Debt, always needs to exist to enable the creation of cash, via fiat currency

LadyWithLapdog · 26/10/2022 18:48

Where do you get the info about KS’s wealth? I can only find some dubious sources quoting each other. At any rate, it would be about 200 times less than Sunak’s who has £730 million which is a pointless, staggering sum of greed.

crosstalk · 26/10/2022 18:47

@VickyEadieofThigh And it would be interesting to look at all politicians who have made money out of buy to let. There was at least one Labour MP and one time cabinet minister who had more BTL than anyone else. I'll google him to check.

MariEllie · 26/10/2022 18:33

VickyEadieofThigh · 26/10/2022 17:30

Tory (and other) politicians have been avoiding tax and using a wide range of loopholes to enhance their incomes for decades now.

Sunak is just one of them. Johnson was shameless in his money-making on the back of being a politician, for example.

Quiite why anyone expects the Tory PM to be 'not rich' is beyond me - it's not as if the Tory benches are filled with horny-handed sons of toil.

So the leader of the Opposition is worth between £5-7 million. Where did his wealth come from? And the trade union leaders get vast salaries too. For goodness sake, some of these Libby left BBC personalities are worth millions!

crosstalk · 26/10/2022 18:22

All the media quoting Winchester College school fees at £42000 and above are ignoring a couple of facts (a) Sunak went there over 20 years ago when the fees were much less and less proportionate to income and (b) these are boarding school fees and he remained a dayboy. How his parents managed three children at private school - I'm not sure, but there are day schools in Southampton with good reps which were around £7000 a year in the nineties.

His wife is no longer non dom but Sunak would be well advised to reduce this route and also overseas purchases of properties for investment some of which lie empty - a tricky one since it would mean a collapse in property prices which while initially great for the average person could also mean a collapse of high street banks who are once again over leveraged in the housing market.

goldfinchonthelawn · 26/10/2022 18:12

Fushiadreams · 26/10/2022 17:42

And for the record, Boris Is worth two million versus Keira 8. And Jeremy Corbyn on e milliom

i honestly am agog at the multi millionaires running labour and their supporters calling out the likes of Boris lol.

How is Jeremy Corbyn worth one million? Unless you include his house. Even the tiniest terraced house in zone 2 is worth around a million. But that's not ready cash.

MintyFreshOne · 26/10/2022 17:55

Fushiadreams · 26/10/2022 17:45

It’s normal to get taxed on your overseas income. If you had shares in a company abroad, you’d be expected to pay UK taxes on that as a resident. Why should she be any different? Besides, you usually get tax credits on the difference

😂

Don’t know why you think it’s so funny as she is definitely having to pay US taxes too due to her green card. If she doesn’t like paying her taxes she can give up her green card and her UK residency if she doesn’t like it.

Fushiadreams · 26/10/2022 17:45

It’s normal to get taxed on your overseas income. If you had shares in a company abroad, you’d be expected to pay UK taxes on that as a resident. Why should she be any different? Besides, you usually get tax credits on the difference

😂

MintyFreshOne · 26/10/2022 17:43

Fushiadreams · 26/10/2022 17:31

And honestlu if you’ve a clue anout what this is about then you’d feel it grossly unfair the uk is taking a tax on over seas income earned in that country and held in that country, it’s crazy, my view is she’s crazy to agree this. No fucking way I would. And I suspect neither would most on here. She must really love her husband and he must Really love his job.

this isn’t avoiding taxes on uk income. It’s not some big company moving their cash overseas. This is a woman who owns shares in companies over seas and earns income on those shares and is taxed in that country snd taxed in the uk on it also. It’s batshit

It’s normal to get taxed on your overseas income. If you had shares in a company abroad, you’d be expected to pay UK taxes on that as a resident. Why should she be any different? Besides, you usually get tax credits on the difference

Fushiadreams · 26/10/2022 17:42

And for the record, Boris Is worth two million versus Keira 8. And Jeremy Corbyn on e milliom

i honestly am agog at the multi millionaires running labour and their supporters calling out the likes of Boris lol.

Fushiadreams · 26/10/2022 17:40

Tory (and other) politicians have been avoiding tax and using a wide range of loopholes to enhance their incomes for decades now

It’s not a party thing, it’s a wealth thing, Keir starmer is worth eight million, he is a multi multi millionaire. Do you think for one moment he doesn’t optimise his tax?

minou123 · 26/10/2022 17:39

Whizzi24 · 26/10/2022 17:21

I'm surprised people aren't taking into account that this is the PM's wife. OK, so it may not be illegal to minimise your tax payments but if you are the leading public figure in the country who is responsible for taxation legislation and how tax income is spent, your actions (and by reflection, your spouse with whom your finances are closely intertwined), are going to be subject to greater scrutiny on these matters. Your public perception will be affected by how you handle them.

I don't think anyone is suggesting a PM or a PM wife tax affairs shouldn't be scrutinised.

Of course they should.

If a PM or spouse is using a Tax Avoidance Scheme, then I'd be with shouting this shit from the rooftops.

But this isn't the situation. This is a situation is which the PMs wife is entitled to claim Non-Dom Status.

If public perception is Non Dom Status is unfair or should be overhauled or even removed - I agree

But if public perception is the PM wife "dodged" tax, or used a legal loophole or she lied to claim Non Dom Status, - this is wrong.
If you meet the criteria for a Status or Relief or an Allowance and you claim it this is not tax avoidance or morally wrong.

toomuchlaundry · 26/10/2022 17:31

Have labour got plans to close all these loopholes? Do wealthy Labour MPs make use of these loopholes?

Fushiadreams · 26/10/2022 17:31

Whizzi24 · 26/10/2022 17:21

I'm surprised people aren't taking into account that this is the PM's wife. OK, so it may not be illegal to minimise your tax payments but if you are the leading public figure in the country who is responsible for taxation legislation and how tax income is spent, your actions (and by reflection, your spouse with whom your finances are closely intertwined), are going to be subject to greater scrutiny on these matters. Your public perception will be affected by how you handle them.

And honestlu if you’ve a clue anout what this is about then you’d feel it grossly unfair the uk is taking a tax on over seas income earned in that country and held in that country, it’s crazy, my view is she’s crazy to agree this. No fucking way I would. And I suspect neither would most on here. She must really love her husband and he must Really love his job.

this isn’t avoiding taxes on uk income. It’s not some big company moving their cash overseas. This is a woman who owns shares in companies over seas and earns income on those shares and is taxed in that country snd taxed in the uk on it also. It’s batshit

VickyEadieofThigh · 26/10/2022 17:30

Chloefairydust · 25/10/2022 22:34

This is exactly what I mean. I know technically there is a legal loophole but it still seems corrupt to me…

Tory (and other) politicians have been avoiding tax and using a wide range of loopholes to enhance their incomes for decades now.

Sunak is just one of them. Johnson was shameless in his money-making on the back of being a politician, for example.

Quiite why anyone expects the Tory PM to be 'not rich' is beyond me - it's not as if the Tory benches are filled with horny-handed sons of toil.

EndlessMagpies · 26/10/2022 17:27

Getoff · 26/10/2022 08:40

The terminology I use is from the language used publicly by a civil servant towards the end of the last Labour government. (I was somewhat outraged at the time because they spoke of "tax avoidance" being wrong, and I thought a civil servant had no right to make a politically contentious judgement about a legal activity.) However, they did go on to make a distinction I had never heard before, between "tax avoidance" and (if I remember rightly) "acceptable tax mitigation". "Tax avoidance" was where you use the law in ways parliament did not intend in order to legally pay less tax. "Acceptable tax mitigation" is where you pay less tax by using schemes that parliament specifically intended to be used for this purpose. Such as making pension contributions, or (as Sunak's wife did) claiming non-dom status.

Having worked in finance since 1979 and seen decades of complex tax law changes (yawn), it is not up to a civil servant to interpret HMRC regulations in such a way as to make their own distinction between what they believe to be 'acceptable tax mitigation' and what is merely 'tax avoidance' by using the rules in a way that parliament did not intend (or in other words, loopholes). In the meantime, like it or not, those loopholes are entirely legal and above board.

It is up to HMRC and the incumbent Government to change the law to close any such loopholes. Not that I am suggesting that a Tory government would leave them open because it suits them and their rich corporate friends, or anything like that.

Confused

Whizzi24 · 26/10/2022 17:21

I'm surprised people aren't taking into account that this is the PM's wife. OK, so it may not be illegal to minimise your tax payments but if you are the leading public figure in the country who is responsible for taxation legislation and how tax income is spent, your actions (and by reflection, your spouse with whom your finances are closely intertwined), are going to be subject to greater scrutiny on these matters. Your public perception will be affected by how you handle them.

LCopp89 · 26/10/2022 16:59

toomuchlaundry · 26/10/2022 16:48

@Capri3 or the colour of their skin

This is really a case that has zero to do with the colour of someone's skin. If Ms Murthy was a blonde, Caucasian North American there would still be a distaste for her former non-dom status. From me, at least.

unici5 · 26/10/2022 16:57

Fushiadreams · 26/10/2022 14:13

I'm sorry, but we are dual US / UK citizens who moved from non-dom status to settled status. We're not in their league, but our tax payments are seven figures in both countries. Yes, the amount owed went up when we changed. There is more of the pot on which we pay the higher rate but there is very little on which we are double taxed. I'm sure her financial affair are more complicated than ours, so there might be a small portion on which she is indeed double taxed, but I'm positive she will have had people ensuring that's it's a small percentage of her holdings.

sure, but it’s very different right? It is factual she is doing double taxation. And it’s on overseas earnings, I don’t know your financial circumstance but to compare apples with apples you need to be talking about overseas income held in the us and taxed there and here, this is what the conversation is about. If you are saying you don’t get taxed in both countries on overseas income then you habe exemptions or something in place.

again you’re getting into a level of complexity that is not required for a high level discussion on mumsnet.

@Fushiadreams

No, it's apples to apples. Nutshell version, all our earnings are of overseas origin (USD), distributed half US, half UK. (As US citizens and settled status UK payers) total income and timing of payments matters, where an asset is held made no difference as soon as we went from non-dom to settled.

Exemptions are pretty simple as they're contained in the US/UK tax treaty. Granted, I don't know if this is differently applied to non-US citizens (and where/how green card holders fit in). I also don't know where Ms Murthy was paying tax on her holdings previously (they weren't particularly transparent on that), so don't know what kind of treaties are or are not at play there.

Double taxation would be an issue if she's at the top of a C Corporation, I believe (which is why most people in her position would structure as an S Corporation) and while it's not total double taxation but some aspect of that for capital gains (for which the UK reaches into worldwide holdings).

Either way, my heart's not bleeding for them, and I think considering the amount of money they have, and the position he's in, it's not a good look.

I also, as I said before, don't buy the totally separate finances thing. We have certain investments neither of us can make due to the creation of a conflict or interest for the other. There's no way they haven't been in this position.

toomuchlaundry · 26/10/2022 16:48

@Capri3 or the colour of their skin

Capri3 · 26/10/2022 16:39

rosangelanne · 26/10/2022 12:25

So did she still have "no firm plans" to stay in the UK in 2015 when her husband was elected to the British parliament and she had 2 small kids here?

Very possible. Nick Clegg moved to California with his wife and kids after being an MP here. Also, David Milliband moved to NYC with his wife and kids.

Is it only OK when Labour MPs do this?

MariEllie · 26/10/2022 16:39

Interesting a prime minister is being criticised for being an offspring of an immigrant family, whose parents came with nothing, worked hard as business people and sacrificed so they could send him to a leading school. He himself then did well in finance and became very wealthy himself and married an heiress. I would’ve thought that’s a story that could inspire other kids to do well. But no, to some people apparently it would be better if he’d been a downright failure and ended up on social security as a drain on the system.

Swipe left for the next trending thread