Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it sets a really bad example for the country when the PMs family have tax dodged millions

458 replies

Chloefairydust · 25/10/2022 22:05

Just that really…

Im really surprised Sunak actually made it to be prime minister considering the recent stories that have been in the news regarding his family avoiding millions of ££ in tax . I actually thought Boris would have been more likely to have been PM. (Not that he’s any better🤔)

OP posts:
DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 07:23

Either way she’s paying the tax because of pressure not because she thought it the right thing to do.

Binkybix · 29/10/2022 01:20

She isn’t claiming non dom status now but was until it all blow up earlier this year

Actually, as I understand it she is, but opting to pay the tax that would have been die had she not been non-Dom. Presumably to keep the IHT benefits.

DonnaDonna0 · 28/10/2022 20:31

She isn’t claiming non dom status now but was until it all blow up earlier this year. It was ok to do that when no one spoke about it but when it came under public scrutiny she decided the right thing to do was not claim.
Draw your own conclusions.

Chessie678 · 28/10/2022 20:06

@feelthebeatfromthetangerine
I haven’t thought about the IHT in any detail but I’d assume that the vast majority of assets are shares in an Indian company which would qualify for business property relief. And I would also think that if she lives until she’s 85 and dies in the UK never having left claiming non- dom status at that point is more contentious.

Hellsmovie · 28/10/2022 18:06

Why is it implied theres rAcISt undertones when some who's non-white is criticised.

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 28/10/2022 17:57

minou123 · 28/10/2022 17:17

You could be right @feelthebeatfromthetangerine .

Inheritance Tax isn't an area I have specialist knowledge on.

But I will say this about Inheritance Tax: it is a tax that is quite easy to get out of.
You don't need to go through the rigmarole of getting Non Dom Status.

Well, it's not really a rigmarole if you were born abroad to foreign parents and lived abroad! But I do get your point about there being various reliefs that apply to inheritance tax anyway.

I assume Rishi Sunak knew about this quirk all along - or if he didn't, he should have known about it - and it seems in poor taste that to my knowledge, he's never tried to legislate against it.

I can't get excited about a non-dom potentially claiming the remittance basis though. It's about as interesting as a company claiming capital allowances.

I just feel this is one of those many, many times where the media have whipped up a frenzy about the wrong thing, and it means no one is paying attention to the thing that's actually interesting.

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 28/10/2022 17:51

toomuchlaundry · 28/10/2022 17:18

But is she claiming non dom status now?

If she's a non-dom, that is a matter of fact. (She's probably a non-dom.)

The question is whether she is claiming the remittance basis (something only non-doms can do). Maybe she is, maybe she isn't. That's between her and her tax advisor, and I take no issue with it.

All non-doms benefit from the ability to keep her income and gains outside the UK for the first 15 years if they pay for it. I'm not sure if that point has been understood by everyone - it's not a free pass to keep everything out of the UK. It starts off as £30k, then when you've been here 12 years, it becomes £60k. If they don't bring everything onshore to the UK, they have to pay this instead.

I know plenty of wealthy people who came to the UK to do business because of the attractiveness of the regime, and who have massively contributed to the economy. I'm not that fussed about keeping income and gains outside of the UK and having them taxed elsewhere (the point is that someone is taxing them).

toomuchlaundry · 28/10/2022 17:18

But is she claiming non dom status now?

minou123 · 28/10/2022 17:17

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 28/10/2022 16:26

PS I should really clarify that Rishi Sunak would be likely to benefit from death taxes from the POV of his children not suffering tax on assets they inherit from their mother. Have just realised I didn't make that particularly obvious.

You could be right @feelthebeatfromthetangerine .

Inheritance Tax isn't an area I have specialist knowledge on.

But I will say this about Inheritance Tax: it is a tax that is quite easy to get out of.
You don't need to go through the rigmarole of getting Non Dom Status.

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 28/10/2022 16:26

PS I should really clarify that Rishi Sunak would be likely to benefit from death taxes from the POV of his children not suffering tax on assets they inherit from their mother. Have just realised I didn't make that particularly obvious.

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 28/10/2022 16:19

toomuchlaundry · 28/10/2022 15:50

Is the fact that there is no inheritance tax in India the reason she says she might move back to India?

There's no inheritance tax in India. If she lived in India, there wouldn't be an inequity between her and the people living in the same country, as they wouldn't be paying inheritance tax either.

The point is, she lives here, the bulk of people who also live here will pay inheritance tax, and the inequity is she won't pay inheritance tax here because it was originally negotiated Indian citizens would pay inheritance tax in India... but inheritance tax in India was scrapped ages ago.

I don't begrudge the assertion she might move back to India one day. If I were to move abroad and integrate there and live there for some time - it's likely I would still always want to be buried in the UK. I'd still always keep my UK passport. I'd still complain about the weather but shout at any non-Brit also doing the same.

Shaking your domicile status is actually pretty hard. As much as a lot of us are pissed off at many things about the UK right now, it's still 'home' in our hearts. You can't determine domicile based purely on facts - part of it is based on feelings.

The injustice is specifically around that tax treaty. As there is no concept of inheritance in the UK, Indians who have lost their non-domicile status should instead pay inheritance in the UK like the rest of us.

It's not great to ignore this when you're the Chancellor and personally benefiting from an estimated £200m tax saving... it's even worse when you're the PM. Just looks like a clear conflict.

I think given how divisive an issue this is, if he really wanted to reunite his Party and the country more generally, he'd try to legislate against it. You should be squeaky clean as the PM. (And yes, I know Boris Johnson made a horrible job of adhering to that, but trying to be better than him is a very low bar. Rishi Sunak should aim higher. It's a really tough gig, but he's not stupid, and he could potentially do well in this role if he listened to all the criticism and got above it by seeking to amend the laws that personally benefit him and not the person in the street.)

toomuchlaundry · 28/10/2022 15:50

Is the fact that there is no inheritance tax in India the reason she says she might move back to India?

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 28/10/2022 15:35

I've been through 16+ pages and I don't think anyone has really got to the main issue yet.

Akshata Murthy is quite plausibly non-domiciled, and non-doms are able to plan to keep their wealth outside of the UK for a fixed period of time. There's not really anything controversial about this - the argument is that non-doms will be paying tax overseas on what they don't bring into the UK.

However, and this is where it gets interesting...

If she's a non-dom, she's probably an Indian non-dom. Due to the tax treaty between the UK and India, she'll never pay inheritance tax on her assets in the UK. And as there's no inheritance tax in India, she's winning!

I'm loathe to use the word loophole, but that's the discrepancy that people should be cross no one is trying to legislate against. Off the top of my head, the only other people I can think of who get to preserve their tremendous wealth without being taxed anywhere are the monarchy. They choose to pay tax on their income, but they are keeping their right to not pay death taxes.

There's an argument that the Royal Family shouldn't pay death taxes as if they had to every time someone died, they might have to, say, sell off Balmoral, and a private owner might refuse access to the grounds to the public, which would be a shame. There's some logic that they should get to preserve their assets.

Not really sure what argument you can have against not legislating to make Indian non-doms pay tax in the UK once they've stayed here 15 years and therefore put down roots... What's the public interest in not bringing their estates within the tax net?

And to the people who brought up Meghan Markle, give your heads a wobble. Racism would be never challenging people based on the colour of their skin. Rishi Sunak is the PM; he's a public interest figure. The racist thing to do would be to give him a free pass - I'll treat him like any other politician, thank you.

As someone who isn't white, I roll my eyes every time someone invents a story of racism. Fair play to his spokeswoman for shooting down the current claims by going on the record to state Rishi Sunak doesn't believe the UK is a racist country either. Let the man be judged on his own actions and policies.

Oh, and why bring his wife into it? Well, if she dies, as her husband, he's probably going to benefit hugely from the lack of death estates. There's that conflict of interest.

Binkybix · 28/10/2022 15:01

Thanks @Chessie678

Chessie678 · 28/10/2022 14:58

@Binkybix
Being UK tax resident doesn’t prevent you also being tax resident elsewhere like in your country of domicile (that depends on the laws of the other country as to what constitutes tax residence there). However double tax treaties tend to include a tie breaker to deem one of the countries your tax residence for the purposes of the treaty. This isn’t related to whether you pay the non dom charge but if you spend the majority of your time in the UK you’re probably going to be tax resident here.

But also you can be liable for tax in a country even if you’re not tax resident there. So let’s say you are Indian resident for tax purposes but have a UK branch of your business e.g you run a hotel in the UK.

You might not be UK tax resident but would likely be liable for UK tax on profits from the hotel (but not on the hotel business so far as it is outside the UK).

I’d assume that India has similar rules. So a UK tax resident running a business in India is still likely to be liable for Indian tax on profits of that business.

International tax quickly becomes really complex because you are looking at an interaction between the laws of each state plus the double tax treaties they have in place which allocate taxing rights between them.

Binkybix · 28/10/2022 12:23

What do you mean when you say ‘invest’? Spend money on consumption, shares, VC, start a company etc? You don’t need to live in a country to be able to do most of that. Attracting ‘talent’, maybe.

To me the morals of this look very different depending on whether taxes are paid in the original country, or a tax haven.

Does anyone know: because you are UK tax resident and agree to pay a flat fee for non-dom, does that mean that you can therefore NOT be tax resident in the country of domicile?

toomuchlaundry · 28/10/2022 11:19

Would be interesting to see the amount of money invested in this country by non-dom individuals and the amount of tax they would have paid if not non-dom. one argument on having non-dom rules is to encourage wealthy foreigners to invest in this country. If we taxed them from the start would they move here?

MarshaMelrose · 28/10/2022 11:13

Should the UK government allow very rich people (originally from abroad) but now living here to not pay tax on their overseas income.

You can bet the Tories won’t be changing this. Maybe start lobbying Labour to change it when they are next in power.

George Osbourne did tighten the rules but didn't do away with it. Neither has any Labour govt. Many countries have a form of the non dom status with the very purpose of attracting wealthy people, who tend to contribute financially by the very dint of the fact that they have a lot of money to spend. It's a difficult juggling act.

MeridaBrave · 28/10/2022 05:57

Re the non dom rules. For the first 15 years after moving to the UK, a uk tax resident (who is likely not a UK citizen) don’t have to pay UK tax on overseas income provided they pay a £30k tax charge.

Maybe it should be reduced to 5 years? Or 10? Maybe should be tied to citizenship (but it it was no one one apply).

MeridaBrave · 28/10/2022 05:54

OP, you need to consider the language “avoided”. We all avoid tax when we pay money into a pension or take an ISA. Tax avoidance is totally legal.

The issue is whether he (or his wife) evaded tax, which would be a criminal offence.

There is a grey area when people find crafty loopholes and use the law for a purpose for which is was not designed. Think Starbucks stripping profit out of high tax jurisdictions into lower ones.

But I don’t think that’s what his wife did. She just used the normal rules in the way they were intended.

So the question is a wider one.

Should the UK government allow very rich people (originally from abroad) but now living here to not pay tax on their overseas income.

You can bet the Tories won’t be changing this. Maybe start lobbying Labour to change it when they are next in power.

Wallaw · 27/10/2022 17:56

BabyGrooverBug · 27/10/2022 09:32

Can you give me a single example of a foreign national and resident who pays UK tax on money they earn abroad? Seems a bit unlikely to me.

@BabyGrooverBug

For starters, every foreign national who has been in the UK for over 15 years.

minou123 · 27/10/2022 14:48

BabyGrooverBug · 27/10/2022 14:37

You're right and I was wrong. Thanks for the correction.

The rules are here:

www.gov.uk/tax-foreign-income/non-domiciled-residents

Rightly or wrongly it looks reasonable to me, I'd love to see the specific change proposed.

No worries. 😁

Most countries have rules for tax residency and Domicile.
But, off the back of this thread, I thought I'd do some research into why the UK has the Non Dom rules.
Turns out, it all stems from when we had the British Empire. That's how old it is!

Its been tinkered with over the years, but I can't find the curent proposed changes.

walkinginsunshinekat · 27/10/2022 14:44

toomuchlaundry · 27/10/2022 09:47

But @walkinginsunshinekat you could say that about any tax paying Chancellor. Any change in tax rate could be seen as a conflict of interest

Yes you could make that argument but its an open and transparent decision - had certain journalists dug this up, we'd all be none the wiser.
plus it wouldn't normally involve 10s of millions in tax.

When a recent chancellor tried reducing tax rates for the very wealthy, we all heard the out cry!

At the end of the day, the Sunaks realised this wasn't a good look didn't they.

BabyGrooverBug · 27/10/2022 14:39

BabyGrooverBug · 27/10/2022 14:38

MN garbles the link. Last try.

www.gov.uk/tax-foreign-income/non-domiciled-residents

BabyGrooverBug · 27/10/2022 14:38

www.gov.uk/tax-foreign-income/non-domiciled-residents

Swipe left for the next trending thread