Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it sets a really bad example for the country when the PMs family have tax dodged millions

458 replies

Chloefairydust · 25/10/2022 22:05

Just that really…

Im really surprised Sunak actually made it to be prime minister considering the recent stories that have been in the news regarding his family avoiding millions of ££ in tax . I actually thought Boris would have been more likely to have been PM. (Not that he’s any better🤔)

OP posts:
rosangelanne · 26/10/2022 10:02

@minou123 www.gov.uk/tax-foreign-income/non-domiciled-residents

Here.

"Non-domiciled' residents:
UK residentss_ who have their permanent home (‘domicile’) outside the UK may not have to pay UK tax on foreign income."

Thus, if your permanent home is in the UK, you have no business claiming to be non dom.

minou123 · 26/10/2022 09:59

rosangelanne · 26/10/2022 09:34

@minou123 that's not the same at all. That's a simple qualification based on facts.

The non dom stays depends on a stated intention to do something in the future (return to India). If she had no such intention of leaving her husband and kids here in the Uk then she should not have made that claim.

Could you point me in the direction of guidance/ legislation that non dom stays depend on stated intention?

I've read Chalter 5 section 21 of the Income Tax Act 2003, and I can't find it.

rosangelanne · 26/10/2022 09:56

Stationsofthecross · 26/10/2022 09:53

Ffs. Give it a rest. It’s legal. What else can we dig up on him to discredit him is it? He’s actually not done anything illegal. You don’t like him and his millions - fine. He hasnt done anything illegal! What on earth is ‘legal loophole?!’

In this case, it's because your future intentions are within your mind, and it's completely impossible to prove that you are lying. But we can all draw our own conclusions.

rosangelanne · 26/10/2022 09:54

Do you really honestly believe she had "no firm plans" about whether or not to stay in the UK with her husband and children?

Stationsofthecross · 26/10/2022 09:53

Ffs. Give it a rest. It’s legal. What else can we dig up on him to discredit him is it? He’s actually not done anything illegal. You don’t like him and his millions - fine. He hasnt done anything illegal! What on earth is ‘legal loophole?!’

Getoff · 26/10/2022 09:51

rosangelanne · 26/10/2022 09:31

Well, to claim non dom you have to have a genuine intention to return to your home country. So if she doesn't genuinely intend to do that then yes she absolutely has done something wrong.

According to a HMRC flow-chart I've just come across, it is not true that you have to have a definite intention to return, in order to be a non-dom. The first question is about future intentions, there are three options, stay in the UK, leave the UK, and "no firm plans". Following the "no firm plans" path and choosing the options I think she would, she still ends up as a non-dom.

Specifically, if you have "no firm plans" about where to live, you were born abroad, your father was born abroad, you have personal ties to your father's country, and you have personal ties to the country you were born in, you are a non-dom.

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/430830/hmrc6.pdf

Nanny0gg · 26/10/2022 09:51

NightfeedsandNetflix · 25/10/2022 22:19

They've just done smart business that's all not criminals. No different to what everyone else does. What I worry about is how can people so wealthy genuinely understand what families on low income have to go through.

Seriously, name me a poor Prime Minister

Monkeyrules · 26/10/2022 09:50

AloysiusBear · 26/10/2022 09:02

But you know, those of you who think its a "legal loophole", do you fancy having the same income taxed twice by two different countries? No?

Also seeing the bigger picture here, OECD agendas for the past few years are all about levelling the playing field on tax - such that countries like India are likely to get a better chunk of it and countries like UK and US may get less. So get used to it.

Yes they are taxed twice but under UK tax rules most individuals receive a deduction or credit against their tax liability for tax already paid in other countries. This applies to both UK domiciled or non UK domiciled individuals so I doubt anyone has an issue with this.

Where it gets to be unfair is when a non domiciled person is offered an election to disregard the normal UK tax rules and pay an amount which will often be a lot less than would have been otherwise due to HMRC instead.

This is not a loophole, it's written in the legislation but there must be a reason the UK government doesn't addrsss it. Personally I don't see how UK domiciled nationals can be asked to pay higher and higher levels of tax when people who live here for decades almost on a permanent basis but have non dom status can pay preferential rates of tax. It doesn't matter if they don't use the NHS or local schools. A lot of other taxpayers don't either, that's not how it works, the money is pooled to provide a variety of services to everyone.

With regards your point about the OECD, I assume other countries set their own tax rates and so get first dibs on the profits generated abroad by taxing them under their own tax regime so the UK doesn't need to divert money to them, other countries can get a higher proportion of this by increasing their own tax rates before its taxed in the UK.

Nanny0gg · 26/10/2022 09:49

Chloefairydust · 25/10/2022 22:08

They probably have some sort of legal loophole … but that doesn’t make it right

Evidence?

LimitIsUp · 26/10/2022 09:48

unici5 · 25/10/2022 23:43

As someone who has been a non-dom in the UK, I have some pretty mixed feelings about it.

Basically, the way it works is that you can claim non-dom status for a certain number of years (15, I think). You pay a flat fee for the first 12 years of around £30,000 and then £60,000 for the last three. You then pay whatever tax rate you fall into on any money you remit (bring into the UK). So most non-doms keep as much of their holdings as possible, either offshore (the Channel Islands basically exist to facilitate this) or in their native country, and bring in as little as possible. Although fun fact: money you bring onshore to pay tax is considered a remittance and will be taxed in the next year.

Our tax rate here is 45%, our tax rate in the US is (I believe) 37%, I do not know the rate in India, where I think Akshata Murthy is domiciled. Weirdly, we also have a substantial tax bill every year in California, despite not having set foot in the state for so much as a weekend in probably twenty years, as they take a portion of income generated from any business there. There are also some complicated deadlines where if you pay a certain amount by a certain date in one country or the other you get a small credit against your liability in the other.

Even in our case, and we're worth much less than she/they are, it requires a lot of hours by knowledgeable accountants. IMO, it really is not like getting tax relief on a pension or ISA, which is pretty straightforward.

I actually think it's a pretty crap policy, and it's not a great look for the family of the man in charge of monetary policy to be taking advantage of it, but it is legal. I find it particularly troubling as there is talk of abolishing it as a policy and he was hardly in an unconflicted position. We converted to domiciled earlier than we needed to as we had some moral queasiness about the bulk of our tax money not going to support the place in which we were living and raising our family, but I suppose, while not an insignificant amount, we had less to lose than they did.

Last thing - I've seen a lot about how it's her money and sexism etc. to expect her to accommodate his career. I don't know their setup, but my husband and I have both worked in an industry where there are certain investments we would not be allowed to make because it would raise a conflict of interest, so I'd be surprised if they'd never run across that issue.

This is well put. It may have been legal but it's not really ethical (unless you are genuinely in this country for only a couple of years). However, it has been addressed and isn't a reason for Sunak not to be PM

minou123 · 26/10/2022 09:41

Monkeyrules · 26/10/2022 09:12

Totally agree. Its a completely unfair system. I wonder if Rishi and his chancellor will do something about this in their future budgets. He's been saying we need to tackle the UK deficit and this would be an easy way to raise more tax

I'm surprised how many people on here are defending non domiciled tax rules for a wealthy few especially when so many threads are about cuts to services. There will be tax increases coming our way so I assume all the posters in favour will be happy for their burden of tax to go up so that wealthy non doms can keep their perks.

Nobody is defending non domiciled tax rules.
There is a huge difference between not liking tax rules, (thinking they are unfair) and understanding legitimate provisions which help people reduce thier tax.

Do you have an ISA?
If someone said to you that you are dodging tax, you are using a loophole and its tax avoidance, what would you think?
I could argue, that by not paying tax on interest, you are in favour of increasing the tax burden for everyone else, just so you can keep your "perk" of having an ISA.

If this thread was about the unfairness of Non-Dom Status and it needs an overhaul, then I'm in complete agreement.
But then again think a lot of tax reliefs schemes and allowances are unfair and need an overhaul, so we could be here fir a while. 😁

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 26/10/2022 09:36

Chloefairydust · 25/10/2022 22:08

They probably have some sort of legal loophole … but that doesn’t make it right

Well, it does actually.
If there is a means for you to not pay as much tax wouldn't you take it? Of course you would.

Whizzi24 · 26/10/2022 09:35

Good idea.

Let's apply the test "does it look good" to everyone's Tax.

Well you don't have to apply it to everyone but usually the Prime Minister of a country does want to look good to their voters!

rosangelanne · 26/10/2022 09:34

@minou123 that's not the same at all. That's a simple qualification based on facts.

The non dom stays depends on a stated intention to do something in the future (return to India). If she had no such intention of leaving her husband and kids here in the Uk then she should not have made that claim.

Getoff · 26/10/2022 09:32

KonTikki · 26/10/2022 08:40

The old test,
Is it a good look. No it isn't. Therefore
the criticism of her non - Dom status is
perfectly understandable.

Also, I believe, to apply for non-Dom status you have to declare a plan to return to your country of tax status, in
her case India, after the maximum 10
years is up.
She is married to a British citizen and I
doubt any such declaration on her part,
hence I feel that her claim to non-Dom
status to be disingenuous at best.

I've never heard of declaring or any sort of 10-year rule, can you clarify what you are talking about? I believe you do not apply for non-dom status, nor do you declare anything to anyone to get it. It's a legal fact about you that is either true or false.

The only issue is how she is taxed, given that she is a non-dom. Being a non-dom is odd, because it gives you the option to calculate tax owed on foreign income in two different ways, and you are explicitly allowed on the self-assessment form to choose whichever way you prefer.

rosangelanne · 26/10/2022 09:31

Well, to claim non dom you have to have a genuine intention to return to your home country. So if she doesn't genuinely intend to do that then yes she absolutely has done something wrong.

BMW6 · 26/10/2022 09:23

Oh FFS.

Look, I worked for HMRC for over 30 years, the last 10 in Compliance (investigation).

SHE HAS NOT DONE ANYTHING WRONG. NOT EVASION. NOT AVOIDANCE. NOT IMMORAL.

Educate yourself before you post absolute BOLLOCKS.

minou123 · 26/10/2022 09:20

KonTikki · 26/10/2022 08:40

The old test,
Is it a good look. No it isn't. Therefore
the criticism of her non - Dom status is
perfectly understandable.

Also, I believe, to apply for non-Dom status you have to declare a plan to return to your country of tax status, in
her case India, after the maximum 10
years is up.
She is married to a British citizen and I
doubt any such declaration on her part,
hence I feel that her claim to non-Dom
status to be disingenuous at best.

Good idea.

Let's apply the test "does it look good" to everyone's Tax.

Oh hang on, I don't think it looks good that anyone who earns over £30,000 should get tax relief for pension contributions.
I think its disingenuous and those who earn over £30k can afford to pay the tax. I'll criticise anyone whose pension contribution are taken out of thier pay before paying tax.

Tax dodging arseholes.

gogohmm · 26/10/2022 09:19

She's not British, she's used a legitimate mechanism to avoid tax. Do I think these mechanisms should exist to avoid tax - no, did she do anything illegal - also no

rosangelanne · 26/10/2022 09:19

I agree. It is surprising this is brushed over.

Non dom status is for people whose permanent home is outside the UK. She is married to a British man and her children are in school here. In what sense is this not her permanent home?

She obviously is able to technically claim that she intends to move back and that this is just a temporary sojourn in the UK. But we can all see that this is bloody dodgy and only done to avoid paying tax.

That's why they have stopped doing it. Only once they were found out.

fruitbrewhaha · 26/10/2022 09:16

Getoff · 25/10/2022 22:49

Yes, but to be clear, what she did was not even tax avoidance.

Eh? Of course it is. Not paying tax on earnings legally is tax avoidance.

However what people with their repetition of the definition of tax avoidance vs evasion seem to be not getting their head around is that, as a member of the government, he is the one writing the rules. You could argue that we could
all set up a shell company in The Cayman Islands or Panama but it’s very expensive so only
works if you are super rich. He is not the only
pm to use tax avoidance loopholes and while
we vote in conservatives, he won’t be the last. Even Blair used a shell company in a tax haven to buy his house to avoid cgt. Cameron’s father was a name in the Panama papers.

Whilst us regular Joes keep paying PAYE and tax on our dividends and banging on about it all being legal, they will still takes us for the mugs we are. If we closed these loop holes for the super rich, we might not die waiting for an ambulance.

Monkeyrules · 26/10/2022 09:12

Oblomov22 · 26/10/2022 08:47

I don't know enough about her particular case. But, Actually I think the ' non dom status' rule is questionable. In certain cases. Or any rule. If many people are using any tax rule to their Advantedge / legally 'circumnavigating it', then it needs to be reviewed. Regularly. That should be standard. Cases should be reviewed, on a case by case basis.

Totally agree. Its a completely unfair system. I wonder if Rishi and his chancellor will do something about this in their future budgets. He's been saying we need to tackle the UK deficit and this would be an easy way to raise more tax

I'm surprised how many people on here are defending non domiciled tax rules for a wealthy few especially when so many threads are about cuts to services. There will be tax increases coming our way so I assume all the posters in favour will be happy for their burden of tax to go up so that wealthy non doms can keep their perks.

OperationRinka · 26/10/2022 09:10

AloysiusBear · 26/10/2022 08:59

Also note the absence of any comment in the media articles about the indian tax she will pay. The Indian tax system is way more aggressive than ours so its unlikely she's significantly at an advantage paying tax there vs here

She was very carefully non-specific about which taxes she was paying where. I'd eat my hat if she was holding all her assets in India and paying CGT/dividend tax/IHT there. If she was, then surely she'd have said so,

Oblomov22 · 26/10/2022 09:10

But this shouldn't be allowed to happen. Ideally. Nothing wrong with non-Dom rules, they are there to serve a purpose. But she?

Stay in any country for 10+ years, raising your kids. But claiming non-Dom? Nah. I don't think so.

And like I said I'm not talking about her case specifically. I'm talking about general cases. you have to admit that this doesn't sit right with many of us.

Granddadwentdownthepit · 26/10/2022 09:09

How dare an Indian pay Indian tax on Indian dividends.

Not quite the same as say Tony Blair or the Guardian's owners using loopholes to reduce their tax exposure.