Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it sets a really bad example for the country when the PMs family have tax dodged millions

458 replies

Chloefairydust · 25/10/2022 22:05

Just that really…

Im really surprised Sunak actually made it to be prime minister considering the recent stories that have been in the news regarding his family avoiding millions of ££ in tax . I actually thought Boris would have been more likely to have been PM. (Not that he’s any better🤔)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
minou123 · 30/10/2022 08:01

Sorry my post cut off, not sure what happened

What do you expect from the Tories. They whole purpose is to give tax breaks to the wealthy. They tell you that's what they will do.

I just find it odd that people question thier morals, when they specifically tell everyone that is exactly what they are planning on doing.

It's strange to vote for a party knowing who they are and what they will do, but then complain that's its "unfair" when they do exactly what they said they will do.

(NB, I don't mean you specifically, i mean "you" as in the general public)

minou123 · 30/10/2022 07:51

rainingsnoring · 29/10/2022 22:57

Give it a rest @BMW6 .
@DonnaDonna0 disagrees with you as she is perfectly entitled to do. You need to move on and accept that people's opinions vary.

The laws, after all are set by the very same Rishi Sunak and his colleagues. There is just a tiny bit of self interest going on when they are made. It would be utterly naive to suggest that this isn't the case. They are not moral rights or wrongs necessarily, just what a very powerful group of individuals has decided should be the rule at any given point. See, for example, how quickly Truss's new laws were overturned. A lot of people question these rules. if you don't want to, that is up to you.

But, that's the whole point of having a Government.

We, the public, specifically vote, to give a group of individuals power, to decide what should be the rules, at any given point.

Of course there is self interest when new laws are made, especially with the Tories.
The political parties write huge manifestos explaining what laws they are planning to introduce or change. They wouldn't write anything that doesn't benefit them aswell. That's the whole point.

What do yiu expect

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 23:55

@rainingsnoring sorry misread the first part. I realise now what you were saying.

rainingsnoring · 29/10/2022 23:46

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 23:12

@rainingsnoring I don’t disagree with you, I have just questioned some of her actions.

I was saying that you are entitled to disagree with the other poster who keeps going back and forth trying to convince you that you are wrong.

Personally, I think her actions are morally questionable but that wasn't the point I was trying to make.

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 23:12

@rainingsnoring I don’t disagree with you, I have just questioned some of her actions.

rainingsnoring · 29/10/2022 22:57

BMW6 · 29/10/2022 18:16

Yes, its your Personal Opinion that is Unjust.

I applied UK tax law to hundreds of thousands of individuals over 30 years. The same to Everyone, whoever they were, rich or poor, whatever their Ethnicity.

I personally disagreed with many of the laws, but applied them without bias. That is Just.

You are not. Your bias is not founded on Law. You are Unjust.

Give it a rest @BMW6 .
@DonnaDonna0 disagrees with you as she is perfectly entitled to do. You need to move on and accept that people's opinions vary.

The laws, after all are set by the very same Rishi Sunak and his colleagues. There is just a tiny bit of self interest going on when they are made. It would be utterly naive to suggest that this isn't the case. They are not moral rights or wrongs necessarily, just what a very powerful group of individuals has decided should be the rule at any given point. See, for example, how quickly Truss's new laws were overturned. A lot of people question these rules. if you don't want to, that is up to you.

Intru · 29/10/2022 22:51

@feelthebeatfromthetangerine
”The point is, she lives here, the bulk of people who also live here will pay inheritance tax”

That’s not true, and you know that it’s not true, so why post it?

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 22:45

@BMW6
Where have I said she committed an offence, don’t quote me on things I haven’t said?
Your clutching at straws now but I do take offence to being misquoted especially when suggesting it could be libellous.
I suggest you get your facts right before misquoting people on social media.

BMW6 · 29/10/2022 22:37

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 18:40

@BMW6
Have I every said she has done anything illegal?
Have I lied about what has happened over the last few months with her non don status - no
I have seen and heard what has happened and had an opinion on it. - yes
I haven’t lied, haven’t said she’s done something she hasn’t, I’ve been honest.
Unjust - hardly but some people can’t stand someone to have a different opinion than theirs.

So you agree she did nothing illegal you just "don't like it"?

You can have an opinion on many things, but not to claim someone has committed an offence when they haven't . That would be Unjust (possibly libellous?)

Good job you're not in a position of authority.

LCopp89 · 29/10/2022 22:20

Beneficialchampion2 · 29/10/2022 18:04

Nobody has broken the law, YABU OP.

Bored of hearing this anti Rishi narrative now, clearly he knows how to handle finances, he doesn't need the money from the job of being PM, why would anyone take that role unless they were passionate about doing so? Give it 12 months, I'm certain he will do a good job. It's a shame he wasn't PM from the start of Boris resigning, the UK would be in a great position otherwise.

Now can all you socialist benefit scrounging anti Rishi folk crawl back under your rocks?

Yes very good at handling finances is our Rishi - wonder what he was doing back in 2008? Or in 2016, out campaigning for the very financially successful Brexit I think

And sure everyone becomes PM because they are passionate about doing a good job...nothing to do with power and influence, or ego, or anything like that. Not at all.

And of course all of us anti-Rishi folk are all socialist benefit scroungers, what else could we be? I mean, he gets a lot of credit for furlough but let's face it, he was left with no choice but to follow in other countries footsteps and still managed to lose billions of pounds through fraudulent payments. I personally worked throughout lockdown so have no experience of that anyway - never claimed any benefits my entire life either so that's me out of your sweeping generalisation.

What else has he done? Apart from state the bleeding obvious v. the idiot Truss during the summer.

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 18:40

@BMW6
Have I every said she has done anything illegal?
Have I lied about what has happened over the last few months with her non don status - no
I have seen and heard what has happened and had an opinion on it. - yes
I haven’t lied, haven’t said she’s done something she hasn’t, I’ve been honest.
Unjust - hardly but some people can’t stand someone to have a different opinion than theirs.

MarshaBradyo · 29/10/2022 18:37

It was probably to make it go away. Let’s face it we are not electing Rishi Sunak’s wife. It was a damaging campaign to try and lower his chances.

I doubt she wanted her personal life in the spotlight, and why should she be scrutinised if legal.

minou123 · 29/10/2022 18:34

Now can all you socialist benefit scrounging anti Rishi folk crawl back under your rocks?

This is out of line.
This debate has got heated at times, but there is no need for this.

Like BMW6 says UK Tax Law is based on fact, not on what on what I feel about an individual or political party.

In fact, I am very much anti-Rishi.
You could probably call me a "socialist"
And i never think anyone on benefits is a "scrounger". I think the benefits system is restrictive and it should be open to more people - but thats another thread.

I may not personally like Mrs Sunak ir Rishi Sunak, but that doesn't matter.
The fact is she claimed Non Dom Status correctly, legally and full within UK Tax Law. If I was her advisor, I would have told her not to give in to public pressure.

BMW6 · 29/10/2022 18:16

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 16:51

@BMW6 it’s not unjust , it’s my personal opinion which I am entitled to. Just like you.

Yes, its your Personal Opinion that is Unjust.

I applied UK tax law to hundreds of thousands of individuals over 30 years. The same to Everyone, whoever they were, rich or poor, whatever their Ethnicity.

I personally disagreed with many of the laws, but applied them without bias. That is Just.

You are not. Your bias is not founded on Law. You are Unjust.

Beneficialchampion2 · 29/10/2022 18:04

Nobody has broken the law, YABU OP.

Bored of hearing this anti Rishi narrative now, clearly he knows how to handle finances, he doesn't need the money from the job of being PM, why would anyone take that role unless they were passionate about doing so? Give it 12 months, I'm certain he will do a good job. It's a shame he wasn't PM from the start of Boris resigning, the UK would be in a great position otherwise.

Now can all you socialist benefit scrounging anti Rishi folk crawl back under your rocks?

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 17:04

Plus “reading the room” and “magnanimous of her”
She was the wife of the chancellor, if it’s totally legal and she’s confident and happy in taking this option why not defend it regardless of public opinion? That’s why we are in some of the mess we’re in now, taking the wrong option to gather favour.
It’s not about being a Tory either, I just want what’s best for the country and the people to make that happen. I hope it is Rishi Sunak but this along with some other business issues with Mrs Sunak do have me concerned.

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 16:51

@BMW6 it’s not unjust , it’s my personal opinion which I am entitled to. Just like you.

BMW6 · 29/10/2022 15:49

DonnaDonna0

There are options to choose for UK taxation under Non Domicile legislation. Both options are entirely legal, because the options are drawn up by HMRC.

She changed from one option to the other (again, perfectly legal) because the Court of Public Opinion was decrying her perfectly legal tax status and option. What with her DH being Chancellor and all, I dare say she was trying to read the room.

I'd say that was pretty magnanimous of her, considering she wasn't doing anything wrong, illegal or immoral in the first place.

It's all very "Caesars wife" - except no matter what she did she will be pilloried because she's married to a Tory.

It is unjust. You are being unjust as are all the others here claiming tax avoidance, dodging etc etc.

LadyWithLapdog · 29/10/2022 15:26

nypost.com/2022/10/27/german-heir-annoyed-by-multibillion-dollar-inheritance-wants-it-taxed-away/amp/ Some rich people do want to pay more tax.

MarshaMelrose · 29/10/2022 14:32

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 07:23

Either way she’s paying the tax because of pressure not because she thought it the right thing to do.

To be fair, that's the same reason my DH is still alive.

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 14:30

@pigsDOfly so now your saying Mrs Sunak was not doing anything illegal and was confident of her non dom status but due to public opinion she’s changed to doing the wrong thing? Doesn’t bode well if that’s how the PM is going to operate does it; well I known it’s not the right option but if it makes the public happy we’ll do it anyway?
I suspect people aren’t “bothered” as you put it about the American coffee company because the owner isn’t married to the PM who needs to lead getting this country out of the mess it’s in.
I don’t drink coffee so can sleep well tonight.

pigsDOfly · 29/10/2022 14:07

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 13:44

@pigsDOfly my point is her actions, she thought it was ok not to pay when it wasn't in the public eye, when it came under public scrutiny she decided the right thing to do was pay the tax.
It’s not what I’m saying, it’s what her actions are saying.
You say why would you pay more if you don’t need to, maybe ask Mrs Sunak?

I imagine she's paying more because of the impact on public opinion in this country, as witnessed on this thread.

However, she wasn't doing anything illegal or wrong.

She was paying the tax she was legally obliged to pay, people in this country weren't happy about that and now she's changed how she pays her taxes.

I hope you never buy your takeaway from a certain American Coffee chain, I'm not going to name them but they're huge all over the UK.

The minimal amount of uk tax they pay is appalling. Nobody seems to be bothered by that and seem more than happy to add to their non tax paying profits.

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 13:44

@pigsDOfly my point is her actions, she thought it was ok not to pay when it wasn't in the public eye, when it came under public scrutiny she decided the right thing to do was pay the tax.
It’s not what I’m saying, it’s what her actions are saying.
You say why would you pay more if you don’t need to, maybe ask Mrs Sunak?

pigsDOfly · 29/10/2022 13:28

DonnaDonna0 · 29/10/2022 07:23

Either way she’s paying the tax because of pressure not because she thought it the right thing to do.

Do you pay an extra amount of tax that you're not legally obliged to pay because you think it the 'right thing to do'?

I can't imagine anyone paying more tax than they have to. I certainly don't.

Every extremely rich person on the planet, and everyone else come to that, pays exactly the amount of tax they are legally obliged to pay and no more.

She's doing nothing different from anyone else.

OperationRinka · 29/10/2022 08:57

Binkybix · 29/10/2022 01:20

She isn’t claiming non dom status now but was until it all blow up earlier this year

Actually, as I understand it she is, but opting to pay the tax that would have been die had she not been non-Dom. Presumably to keep the IHT benefits.

Yes, that's how I understand it, she's still a non-dom but paying taxes as if she weren't for now: hedging her bets in case the IHT element becomes important. If her father died while Sunak was still PM then she'd have some difficult choices to make.