Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if people expect the government to solve all their problems?

161 replies

LadyHarmby · 25/10/2022 18:31

Just listening to the news, interviewing people in the street.

No government can change the fact that some people are rich and some are not. Or that wars in other countries and/or pandemics will affect the price of things.

Inappropriate content on social media. Unsafe cladding on blocks of flats put there by private developers. Being housed outside of your area by the council. Zero hours contracts. All issues that the government seem to be expected to sort out? Is it reasonable?

BTW I’m a Labour voter so this is not about the Tories, more government in general.

OP posts:
Ylvamoon · 26/10/2022 08:04

Inappropriate content on social media
UT government can pass laws and police this area better.

Unsafe cladding on blocks of flats put there by private developers
A change in building regs should catch some of the issues.

Being housed outside of your area by the council
This is a compex issue and we can't please everyone.

Zero hours contracts
Change the employment law.

All issues that the government seem to be expected to sort out? Is it reasonable

So some of it would be reasonable for the government to change.

But yes, I agree, the government can't change everyone's life for the better.

luckylavender · 26/10/2022 07:57

Obviously no government can solve everything but the purpose of government is to serve the country. So I would expect legislation on social media content, on cladding and on zero hours contracts. I would also expect them to be proficient enough not to spook the markets and make people's lives worse. I would also have expected that we had energy storage capacity.

Unseelie · 26/10/2022 07:50

lion71 · 25/10/2022 18:43

Well it would be nice if they could stop creating problems. Perhaps when they stop being the root of most of the catastrophe in this country people will stop looking to them to solve it.

👏

A huge amount of our current problems were caused by government incompetence. It isn’t unreasonable to expect them to sort that out, and especially to regulate social media. It isn’t right that most children have seen violent misogynistic porn hundreds of the time by age 14 yet the online harms hill isnparked unable to provress while the tory party lurches from one internal power struggle to another.

onlythreenow · 26/10/2022 07:47

A government obviously has certain responsibilities to make life as good as it can be for the citizens of the country, and of course those citizens should expect them to perform accordingly.

However, many people these days seem to believe they don't need to take any responsiblity for their own lives. They make poor decisions and then expect to be bailed out, and everything which is wrong in their life is down to "the government".

The OP didn't use particularly good examples, but I get what they are saying, and I agree.

MarshaBradyo · 26/10/2022 07:23

Hbh17 · 25/10/2022 22:26

Some people do seem to think that if they are short of money, the Government should just keep giving them handouts - I wonder whether this is a legacy of furlough?
Any Government should be creating a general environment where people are able to help themselves and (hopefully) need less and less input from the state.
People who say that "they" should do whatever seem to forget that "they" don't actually have any funds - it is either money that comes from us (taxpayers) or from borrowing...... so be careful what you wish for!

Yes there’s a lot of ‘they’ when it comes to funds. And idea of that probably went up during pandemic.

It’s taxes or borrowing.

Ith examples in op aren’t great but generally more recognition of tax receipts and where it comes from.

balalake · 26/10/2022 07:21

I think there are people who expect others to solve problems and never contribute to reducing them themselves. Complaining about traffic levels when you drive less than a mile and could walk to and from school, for example.

However, a competent government could at the very least not make things worse, and some of the things the OP mention are the responsibility of government.

malificent7 · 26/10/2022 07:12

Would not*

malificent7 · 26/10/2022 07:11

I spoke to one of my Indian colleagues and he told me that unlike in the UK, in India , you would bout have to wait 6 hours for a chest xray once admitted to A and E or 3 weeks/ months for a gp. India has a bigger population and probably less resources than the uk...so what are we doing wrong? I DO blame the government for these problems.

Bramblejoos · 26/10/2022 07:10

I wish they would fund Surestart type of arrangement - to catch disadvantaged families at the beginning. And sport for children - athletics, footie, darts, anything - all children have an opportunity to do out of schools sport. Instead our sportspeople largely come from private schools (not footie).

KTheGrey · 26/10/2022 07:08

Well if the government want a third of our earnings, yes they should make laws that a) make it possible for people to live their lives without unscrupulous landlords burning them to death in their beds without consequence and b) ensure people can live off their incomes if they work 35-40 hours a week.

That's their job. It comes from the word "govern" meaning to steer or to rule. They should make laws that steer behaviour and they should maintain the rule of law. This government has run the rule of law ragged in more than one way.

ohfook · 26/10/2022 07:08

My expectation is that I give my money to the government via my taxes and they use that money to create a society that benefits everyone as best they can.

So yes I would except them to make unsafe cladding illegal for private developers to use because I don't want people living in fear of another Grenfell. I would like them to search for a suitable alternative to zero hours contracts because they keep many people trapped in a cycle of poverty and only benefit the employer. I expect schools and hospitals to be well funded before millions of pounds are given to someone else to help prolong the government's power.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 26/10/2022 07:07

Choppies · 26/10/2022 06:56

The government can legislate to make developers who ignored building regs pay to replace the dodgy cladding. The bill doesn’t have to go to taxpayers - it’s 100% an issue the government should sort imo

This 100% also to ensure building regulations are adhered to in the first place with proper scrutiny.

malificent7 · 26/10/2022 07:05

If we voted in a party that weren't such capitalists and in bed with big business we might see some wealth distribution which would be better than this trickle down nonsense. I don't see any wealth trickling down.

malificent7 · 26/10/2022 07:02

3 years for the job* that should read.

malificent7 · 26/10/2022 07:00

I expect them to provide the conditions where hard work pays off. I work nhs. I studied 2 years for the job when the bursary was cut off by the tories, got a 1st as worked my arse off. Currently on band 5 pay. Not enough to cover cost of living. I am thinking of leaving to work in the private sector or, as many on here would suggest, become a rich investment banker or business person. But everyone is leaving the nhs....

Aarohi · 26/10/2022 07:00

No government can change the fact that some people are rich and some are not. Any government can (for example) make economic and budgetary decisions that keep costs down and wages up, that increase available housing stocks, that offer an emergency safety net but mitigate against its being abused. Or that wars in other countries and/or pandemics will affect the price of things. They can refrain from leaving a trading block of 40+ years' duration with their 31 closest neighbours with no concrete plans and no apparent desire to mitigate the negative impact, and they can avoid doing things that are predictably likely to cause the national currency to drop when the country is reliant on imports.

Inappropriate content on social media. Not sure of the context, but if platforms are violating the law the government/Parliament can act. Unsafe cladding on blocks of flats put there by private developers. Yes, the government can legislate to prevent this, and impose meaningful penalties if it does happen. Other countries do. Being housed outside of your area by the council. Can't prevent this on an individual basis, but can influence the factors that cause it to be widespread. Zero hours contracts. They are useful and desirable in some cases (from a worker's perspective) but when they become all that's available for a segment of the population nationwide then yes, that's an issue for the government. Companies can be required by law to observe reasonable workers' rights.

Choppies · 26/10/2022 06:56

The government can legislate to make developers who ignored building regs pay to replace the dodgy cladding. The bill doesn’t have to go to taxpayers - it’s 100% an issue the government should sort imo

MrsJThornton · 26/10/2022 06:40

Believeitornot · 25/10/2022 18:42

YABU FFS. What do you expect in return for your vote and paying taxes?

governments can sort out regulation and prevent wealth from being drained from the country.

They could protect our natural resources and ensure that it benefits citizens, not corporates.

They could pay their own staff a decent living wage.

Seriously.

Perfect response.

Itstarts · 25/10/2022 22:29

If there's a minister for that area(e.g. education/health) then yes I expect them to solve that problem. That is literally their job.

GrumpyPanda · 25/10/2022 22:27

YABVVU, and illogical to boot. Wars and pandemics are one thing. But everything you list in your second paragraph isn't a natural occurrence but the direct result of previous government intervention. Zero hours contracts were a deliberate choice by previous administrations - well turns out they have consequences. Ditto for buildings regs. Ditto for intergovernmental fiscal relations and the resulting strain on council finances. Getting to that point resulted from political decisions. People are now expecting political decisions to deal with the fallout. Deal with it.

Worriedddd · 25/10/2022 22:27

VestaTilley · 25/10/2022 22:00

No. But we do expect the Govt of the day not to crash the economy to the extent it puts our mortgage interest rates up by 5% and counting.

And poverty isn’t an inevitability - that’s a policy decision. Of course there would always be people with less money than others, but the grinding poverty of hunger, cold and genuine want? No. That’s a choice - a choice the rich impose on the poor, by their constant re-election of Conservative governments.

Again what do people expect , people wanted lock down ,they had to print money to pay for it causing inflation. It will have to be paid for

Hbh17 · 25/10/2022 22:26

Some people do seem to think that if they are short of money, the Government should just keep giving them handouts - I wonder whether this is a legacy of furlough?
Any Government should be creating a general environment where people are able to help themselves and (hopefully) need less and less input from the state.
People who say that "they" should do whatever seem to forget that "they" don't actually have any funds - it is either money that comes from us (taxpayers) or from borrowing...... so be careful what you wish for!

CapMarvel · 25/10/2022 22:21

LadyHarmby · 25/10/2022 22:09

Your examples are very much things that government is in control of

I never said they weren’t in control of them. I said are these the sort of problems they should reasonably be expected to ‘fix’, when there are so many demands on government time and money. I just think people aren’t realistic about how much they can do.

The civil service employes thousands of people who are supposed to fix problems like the ones you listed.

So yes, it is realistic they do their fucking jobs.

fruitbrewhaha · 25/10/2022 22:18

LadyHarmby · 25/10/2022 22:09

Your examples are very much things that government is in control of

I never said they weren’t in control of them. I said are these the sort of problems they should reasonably be expected to ‘fix’, when there are so many demands on government time and money. I just think people aren’t realistic about how much they can do.

No, they can bloody well do it all. They can fix it.

Doubledenimrocks · 25/10/2022 22:17

Quitelikeit · 25/10/2022 18:49

im sometimes astonished at the things the government is expected to solve

oh I’m in poverty, oh I can’t pay my rent, oh I can’t afford childcare, oh I’m cold…………….

well not everyone is in that position so do self reflect and also those issues I mentioned are subsidised by millions and millions of pounds by the government each year.

Obviously they cannot cover every single life scenario in their proposals and funding so I sympathise in some circumstances

No but they can provide decent public services that help people make their situation better - education, healthcare, access to housing etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread