Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if people expect the government to solve all their problems?

161 replies

LadyHarmby · 25/10/2022 18:31

Just listening to the news, interviewing people in the street.

No government can change the fact that some people are rich and some are not. Or that wars in other countries and/or pandemics will affect the price of things.

Inappropriate content on social media. Unsafe cladding on blocks of flats put there by private developers. Being housed outside of your area by the council. Zero hours contracts. All issues that the government seem to be expected to sort out? Is it reasonable?

BTW I’m a Labour voter so this is not about the Tories, more government in general.

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 26/10/2022 11:10

Where did people who voted Brexit think their employment rights came from? Not the Tory government that’s for bloody sure.

Mindthegap725 · 26/10/2022 10:55

I think this is one of the fundamental questions we were asking ourselves when we were having the Brexit debate,

”how much state intervention do you want in your life?”

And people sadly voted to have less, whether they knew it or not.

I absolutely believe that people should look after themselves when they are physically and mentally able, and I believe most people want to do that too. More than that, where able, I think they should try and contribute to others in society too. But I also want to live in a country that has good state welfare for those who are desperately ill, frail or elderly, disabled or impoverished. And if that means higher (means tested) taxes then so be it.

I want to live in a country where capitalism is regulated sensibly and fair work standards prevail. Also where products like toys and food are safe. And where it is against the law to use dodgy flammable tiles to clad a residential building. Where the environment is protected. Where public transport is efficient, accessible and affordable. Where national manufacturing industries are supported.

Unfortunately, when the 52% voted for Brexit, they voted for the opposite of all of these things.

If you move away from the broadly Christian-democrat centrist values of the EU, it’s pretty obvious where you are heading, and that’s towards a free market low regulation economy. It’s a scary time for the uk and I am far from convinced that those in charge are there for wholly altruistic reasons.

KimberleyClark · 26/10/2022 10:43

I expect the government to provide

Healthcare free at point of access and save, clean efficient hospitals
Good state schools everywhere not just in leafy suburbs
Efficient and affordable public transport

If those things are not the responsibility of the government, whose responsibility are they?

Miajk · 26/10/2022 10:35

Middledazedted · 25/10/2022 18:38

You think political decisions don’t impact on wealth inequality? That legislature has no impact on safe building practice? That the law has no influence on contracts of any sort?

if you think that then there might not be much point belonging to any party.

This.

People are allowed to expect the government to fix problems that are a result of poor policy and governing.

Wealth inequality is a result of poor policy and legislation. Employment contracts are exactly something the government should sort, same for building regulations.

We pay taxes and risk going to prison if we don't respect legislation. The government owns us this way. Our freedom and finances.

Therefore it's their responsibility to make sure the world they make for us is good and they fix shitty problems that shouldn't exist in the first place.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 26/10/2022 10:24

Well the government are the only ones who can make laws, set taxes and decide how taxes should be spent. So they are the ones we rely upon to make changes to legislation and to fund public services.

Not sure who else you think is going to sort all this out?

mewkins · 26/10/2022 10:04

luxxlisbon · 25/10/2022 18:46

@PeekabooAtTheZoo Yes I think people think the government are a replacement for their parents and that citizens are entitled to act like angry teens rebelling, arguing and complaining nonstop instead of solving their own problems.

What do you think the purpose of a government is?

To be fair it has mainly been the government themselves acting like angry teens, rebelling, arguing and complaining non stop.

itispersonal · 26/10/2022 10:03

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 26/10/2022 08:09

Has anyone noticed that when it comes to austerity savings, the Government take the funding from excellent initiatives like Sure Start, or Social care across all sectors, but never tighten the belts of anything they can personally gain a benefit from (the Kwasi budget being a prime example of feeding the poor to the rich by tanking the £)?

I don’t expect the Government to solve my problems, but I do expect them to stop passing legislation that benefits themselves & their donors first & pulls those who really need extra help & support further into the shit.

Like the billions spunked to their friends for PPE at the start of the pandemic which was either substandard or never appeared.

But they’re Tories, so I don’t expect bloody miracles. Greed is king.

This the sure start centres would have saved money in the long term. Families and children who needed support were highlighted earlier. Closure of the sure start centres have had an added impact onto schools who are now doing the early diagnosis of children.
This seems very much like robbing Peter to pay Paul, but shafting everyone in return.

Government make a massive deal out of benefit fraud which is minute to tax avoidance and tax evasion. But the latter two are used and done by the rich!

MrsSkylerWhite · 26/10/2022 09:57

No. I do expect the Government not to directly cause me additional problems, though.

itispersonal · 26/10/2022 09:56

Government role should be to look after the poorest and give everyone a decent standard of living. An education and job opportunities.

However I do think people think that the government should dole out money to sort all their problems or that they shouldn't have any problems and no one should have to cut their cloths accordingly.

Giving money at some people doesn't help them - I know many people who have spent the £400 energy help on trivial things and so when the bill comes they won't be able to pay it but will also moan and know they won't cut us off as we have children! Worked in debt management and friends in charity who give debt advice - many of the people didn't want to know how to save money/ or spend appropriately they just wanted extra or a food bank referral.

I think a good example of this, though not government related, is Bristol uni saying student who may be struggling with fuel poverty they can have the library, common rooms and the student Union as a place to keep warm with free tea and coffee and the student have mocked this as not doing enough!

sashh · 26/10/2022 09:47

Expecting there to be laws that make you landlord keep a building safe and not putting cladding that can turn a fire into an inferno is NOT asking the government to do everything.

It should be a human right in this country that your home is safe.

Damnautocorrect · 26/10/2022 09:46

No government can change the fact that some people are rich and some are not.
Or that wars in other countries and/
or pandemics will affect the price of thing
yes but if people are starving. That’s a government issue. It’s not that people can’t rent the latest Range Rover.

Inappropriate content on social media.
should have been legislated as it developed to ensure it’s a safe place

Unsafe cladding on blocks of flats put there by private developers.
building regs should have prevented it. Developers are there to make profit not to make sure it’s a happy healthy place to live. That’s councils and government to push for decent homes.

Being housed outside of your area by the council.
not enough council homes affects communities, it affects the entire housing market from the bottom to the top. Moving people to another area just pushes the problem elsewhere until the entire country is unaffordable. It’s a massive government issue

Zero hours contracts.
no workers rights, how can you get a mortgage or pass affordability on a rental contract if you don’t have set hours? Of course it’s a government issue that employers are using tax and employment loop holes.

mewkins · 26/10/2022 09:44

LadyHarmby · 25/10/2022 22:09

Your examples are very much things that government is in control of

I never said they weren’t in control of them. I said are these the sort of problems they should reasonably be expected to ‘fix’, when there are so many demands on government time and money. I just think people aren’t realistic about how much they can do.

You do realise that there are over 500,000 civil servants working behind the government?

mewkins · 26/10/2022 09:38

LadyHarmby · 25/10/2022 20:24

The reality is that the Government's main priority of "The Top 5 Things" vary depending on who you ask

Maybe this is the crux of it.

There’s a limited pot of money, right?

We want a functioning NHS where you can get a GP appointment. With short waiting lists for operations. And decent mental health provision. And properly funded care homes. And have nurses’ paid properly. And more NHS dentists. And….and…

Then there’s education. Decent state schools for ALL children. Better salaries for teachers. More TAs and SENCOs. And…and…

The list is endless.

So when it comes to cladding or zero hours contracts or whatever, while these are big issues to the people they affect, shouldn’t there an understanding that the government simply can’t solve everything? It’s just not possible so they have to pick and choose.

How effectively they do that and whether you agree with they choose is a separate political issue.

(Actually, I’ve just remembered I voted Lib Dem once or twice. But I’ve never voted Tory, promise.)

Actually I think that zero hrs and cladding are things that can be sorted with legislation and least damage to public funds. It is private companies and their profits that will be impacted and that is problematic for a Tory government- especially one that is losing public confidence fast. They are reluctant to make decisions which will hit the only supporters they have left.

GuyFawkesDay · 26/10/2022 08:57

Payouts, not parents #fatfingers

GuyFawkesDay · 26/10/2022 08:56

On the basis the current government has

1.wasted billions on useless track & trace system for covid. In doing so , given Tory donors and supporters. huge parents as they won the contracts.

  1. Stripped public services to bare bones. Outsourced some of it to private health companies (see above)
  2. Made a right hash of the economy. From austerity to the recent mini budget onmishambles, it's a mess.

I could go on and on with how useless they have been. And they've had 12 years to sort something and in that time we have had precisely no real terms in teases in pay or living standards for anyone except those who are in the top 10% of earners.

I am not precisely sure what government is for
if it is not for providing decent public services, responding intelligently to threats and problems and putting the needs of its citizens first.

I'd like a government to do that please. Put the needs of the people it serves first. That's it.

luxxlisbon · 26/10/2022 08:51

Worriedddd · 25/10/2022 21:36

How could they not have crashed the economy? The masses were calling for lockdowns , money had to be printed and borrowed to pay for it.

You are being completely obtuse. Available interest rates rose by around 5% overnight due to the Trussenomics of the mini budget, how are you possibly blaming that on covid lockdowns?

Yes the lockdowns would have resulted in repayments from the public finances over a period of decades, it was not responsible for an almost overnight crash along with a crippling rise in energy.

Whereisthehugeteddybear · 26/10/2022 08:34

They think someone should pay them to sit at home and normal, fit, healthy people go to food banks instead of working.

I'm not convinced that there are a lot of people that fall in to this category....Hmm

in reality an awful lot of benefits are in work benefits because people's wages are not sufficient to buy luxuries like food...🙄

DontdoitDoris · 26/10/2022 08:25

Believeitornot · 25/10/2022 18:43

How absurd.

It's not absurd, you see it everywhere.
There is plenty of work but people don't want to do it.
They think someone should pay them to sit at home and normal, fit, healthy people go to food banks instead of working.
Before anyone starts I'm not rich but I've never expected handouts like people do these days.
All while moaning that others who have studied and worked hard have more than them and its not fair.

Bizarre

Mumoblue · 26/10/2022 08:17

Are we so used to the government being incompetent that we’ve reached the point of ‘expecting the government to function is unreasonable’?

Lunar270 · 26/10/2022 08:16

In fairness OP, politics isn't something most people understand (including myself) or where the lines are drawn. So it's not unreasonable to ask what the role of our government is.

But pretty much all of what you've posted falls under their remit 🤣

Obviously the government aren't entirely responsible if someone becomes rich (to some extent) but they are definitely responsible for how wealth is redistributed, opportunity to become wealthy etc etc.

midgetastic · 26/10/2022 08:14

being housed outside of area

Need enough council houses / the profit from the sell off should have been reinvested

This will alos reign in property prices

It's much more expensive to achieve now but that was a Tory choice

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 26/10/2022 08:13

GreyElephantsWearingYellowPyjamas · 25/10/2022 18:34

Yes a lot of people do. You hear a lot of moans of ‘They’ should do this and ‘They’ should do that without actually being proactive and doing anything themselves.

And often without having actually voted!

sst1234 · 26/10/2022 08:12

Expectations from the government should be commensurate with the tax you pay. Some people are paying more now than they have ever paid before, since we have the highest tax burden is the highest since WW2.

Some, on the other hand, graced this planet to only take from the taxpayer. Their sense of entitlement doesn’t match their sense of responsibility to do anything for themselves.

midgetastic · 26/10/2022 08:12

some people are rich and some are not

But they can change the difference between rich and poor - I think for example one country has a 10 to 1 rule in company salaries, working poverty should be a thing of the past whereas it's growing

They can make rich more closely related to merit by reducing the impact of inherited wealth - better state schools paid for through higher inheritance taxes as an example

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 26/10/2022 08:09

Has anyone noticed that when it comes to austerity savings, the Government take the funding from excellent initiatives like Sure Start, or Social care across all sectors, but never tighten the belts of anything they can personally gain a benefit from (the Kwasi budget being a prime example of feeding the poor to the rich by tanking the £)?

I don’t expect the Government to solve my problems, but I do expect them to stop passing legislation that benefits themselves & their donors first & pulls those who really need extra help & support further into the shit.

Like the billions spunked to their friends for PPE at the start of the pandemic which was either substandard or never appeared.

But they’re Tories, so I don’t expect bloody miracles. Greed is king.