Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if people expect the government to solve all their problems?

161 replies

LadyHarmby · 25/10/2022 18:31

Just listening to the news, interviewing people in the street.

No government can change the fact that some people are rich and some are not. Or that wars in other countries and/or pandemics will affect the price of things.

Inappropriate content on social media. Unsafe cladding on blocks of flats put there by private developers. Being housed outside of your area by the council. Zero hours contracts. All issues that the government seem to be expected to sort out? Is it reasonable?

BTW I’m a Labour voter so this is not about the Tories, more government in general.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
voiceofmarion · 26/10/2022 21:59

the problem is that you are extrapolating your personal experience to the general population. Yes, there will always be people who do not plan and are not very responsible. But provision must be made for people who do everything right, plan ahead and save and then are felled by circumstances

ofcourse provision must be made for those felled by circumstances but I've known plenty of families who didn't do 'the right thing', had kids and then bitched that the governmemt didn't help them enough.

That's the point of the thread-people blaming the govt for situations they got themselves into. Many single mums and those on benefits with kids that I know are akin to the family of 5 I pointed out. They never did 3rd level, never had a big career or steady source of cash but still had multiple kids. They then struggle to feed the kids etc but if people have limited incomes and don't know that kids are expensive before having them then how can they blame the govt?

Icannoteven · 26/10/2022 20:04

Most of the things that you have mentioned are heavily affected by government/public policy. Who do you think is responsible for housing policy and regulation, public health/regulation of the media (i.e. dangerous messages on social media) and the passing and enforcing of laws relating to employment protection? Do you really think that the government shouldn't have a role in any of this? That it's something the free market should sort out or individuals should agree between themselves? Do you really think this would be a good way to run he country?

Do you think that the government are not/ shouldn't be responsible for regulating the economy to ensure that people have the resources they need? That economic interventions or lack thereof have no affect on how much money the rich have compared to the poor?

You say you aren't a Tory but from your question I would assume you were very much small state, minimal, minimal intervention - that's if I was being nice. If I wasn't being nice I would judge you as a conservative reactionary.

etopp · 26/10/2022 19:55

Worriedddd · 25/10/2022 19:00

Yep and it really ramped up during COVID. Money was printed , handed out left right and centre. People now seem to think the government is going to bail them out of energy rises and mortgages. Not going to happen they printed/borrowed half a trillion they don't have the money left to give out handouts, they can't use QE and the interest is rising on that debt the gov need to service. People were demanding more furlough and more lockdowns how did they think it was going to get paid?

The bills come in so buckle up, it's going to be very painful and no government Tory or labour will be able to fix it quickly.

Spot on.

Badbadbunny · 26/10/2022 19:48

pointythings · 26/10/2022 15:44

@Badbadbunny but that's an argument for doing nothing and allowing unfair treatment of workers to exist 'because the alternative would be worse'. That isn't good enough. If a piece of legislation causes employers to misbehave en masse, then further legislation is needed to ensure that they can't. Unforeseen consequences happen, but when they do they need to be dealt with and not ignored.

I agree, but for the last 20+ years, the fake self employment problem has been brushed aside, as has zero hour contracts. Whatever colour of government, these issues have been ignored, whilst new/improved employment rights have been introduced, which makes a mockery of it really.

onlythreenow · 26/10/2022 19:37

So when it comes to cladding or zero hours contracts or whatever, while these are big issues to the people they affect, shouldn’t there an understanding that the government simply can’t solve everything? It’s just not possible so they have to pick and choose.
How effectively they do that and whether you agree with they choose is a separate political issue.

This is exactly it! Everyone thinks their particular issue is the most important and that money should be thrown at the issue to fix it. However, there is not an unlimited amount of money available, it all has to be allocated - and unfortunately some issues are going to get less money than they need. I don't see people putting up their hands to pay double rates of tax to increase the pot of available money!

I'm not talking about the UK government btw - this applies to governments all around the world. Of course they get things wrong, sometimes very wrong, but I get tired of people thinking that their issue is more important than anyone else's and wanting "them" to do something about it. Especially when it is something which is partly an issue because of their lifestyle choice.

Gfplux · 26/10/2022 18:56

KimberleyClark · 26/10/2022 11:10

Where did people who voted Brexit think their employment rights came from? Not the Tory government that’s for bloody sure.

Agreed

Gfplux · 26/10/2022 18:54

Mindthegap725 · 26/10/2022 10:55

I think this is one of the fundamental questions we were asking ourselves when we were having the Brexit debate,

”how much state intervention do you want in your life?”

And people sadly voted to have less, whether they knew it or not.

I absolutely believe that people should look after themselves when they are physically and mentally able, and I believe most people want to do that too. More than that, where able, I think they should try and contribute to others in society too. But I also want to live in a country that has good state welfare for those who are desperately ill, frail or elderly, disabled or impoverished. And if that means higher (means tested) taxes then so be it.

I want to live in a country where capitalism is regulated sensibly and fair work standards prevail. Also where products like toys and food are safe. And where it is against the law to use dodgy flammable tiles to clad a residential building. Where the environment is protected. Where public transport is efficient, accessible and affordable. Where national manufacturing industries are supported.

Unfortunately, when the 52% voted for Brexit, they voted for the opposite of all of these things.

If you move away from the broadly Christian-democrat centrist values of the EU, it’s pretty obvious where you are heading, and that’s towards a free market low regulation economy. It’s a scary time for the uk and I am far from convinced that those in charge are there for wholly altruistic reasons.

I couldn’t say it better

pointythings · 26/10/2022 18:24

@voiceofmarion the problem is that you are extrapolating your personal experience to the general population. Yes, there will always be people who do not plan and are not very responsible. But provision must be made for people who do everything right, plan ahead and save and then are felled by circumstances. I would rather that 100 feckless families got money than that one family who fell into hardship through no fault of their own should go without - especially since the sums involved are so small as to be dwarfed by the amount of cash this government has thrown away through its own incompetence.

voiceofmarion · 26/10/2022 18:05

but the whole 'don't have kids if you can't afford them' doesn't take into account the fact that we are in a low pay, high cost (housing) economy, therefore it is very difficult for many people to save. It's extremely easy to fall into a situation where you need benefits when previously you haven't - all it takes is one accident, one cancer diagnosis and you're there

We are in a world where it was always expensive to have kids though. I know a couple living in London who had no health problems and had 5 kids in the last 18 years-the house prices were already mad then and neither parent had great jobs and had no property when they conceived the 1st kid.

They constantly sponge off family and they moan to me about the cost of everything etc yet I think why did you have 5 kids when you knew you couldn't afford them? Many cases of this there was no health problem with either parent.

If they'd had 1 or 2 kids I'd maybe be more empathy- but 5? Their own fault.

pointythings · 26/10/2022 15:44

@Badbadbunny but that's an argument for doing nothing and allowing unfair treatment of workers to exist 'because the alternative would be worse'. That isn't good enough. If a piece of legislation causes employers to misbehave en masse, then further legislation is needed to ensure that they can't. Unforeseen consequences happen, but when they do they need to be dealt with and not ignored.

Leypt1 · 26/10/2022 15:35

What most people in this thread don't seem to realise is that everything in our social and economic context is shaped by government in some way, either through active intervention or a choice not to intervene - this in itself is an intervention.

If people are poorer it's because the government made an active choice to make them poorer over years of austerity. Now they ask that the government chooses to reverse that and, what, suddenly it's not the government's business any more?

People are happy to pay taxes if those taxes are actually going towards improving society. The magic money tree seems to function perfectly well when it comes to government corruption and fraud - why not improving society?

ginghamstarfish · 26/10/2022 15:33

In some ways yes, but there needs to be more emphasis on people having more responsibility for their own health etc, and it should be that the harder you work the better off you are, but it isn't.

RagingWoke · 26/10/2022 15:30

Orangestrap · 26/10/2022 15:07

Not at all but I’d expect them not to add to them.

☝️☝️ a government can't solve everything but they can not make things worse. Like not prioritising corporate profits and allowing energy prices to rise, with the knock on effect that everything else increases.

Badbadbunny · 26/10/2022 15:23

pointythings · 26/10/2022 15:19

@Badbadbunny onerous' employment rights = employment rights that stop me from squeezing every drop of profit from my workforce. I have zero sympathy for these employers. If they can't run their business without exploiting their staff, they do not deserve to be in business at all.

My point was that increased employment rights had the adverse effect in some cases, with the result that the workers end up worse off, rather than better off, which was the purpose of the changes.

OnlyTheBravest · 26/10/2022 15:19

@TooBigForMyBoots Totally agree. I think it is unrealistic to expect a government to solve every problem but every government since Tony Blair took the UK into a war we had no business being involved with has created further divisions/problems for UK citizens.

We really need to start with the basics. Make sure they are working well before commencing with anymore vanity projects.

I would like to see more affordable housing made available for rent, reduction of NHS waiting times for priority services e.g. A & E, ensure utility costs are not pushing average earners into poverty, limit zero hour contracts and remove average earners dependence on UC by increasing wages, so company profits not tax payers fund their staff and an education system, which is fit for 21st century.

pointythings · 26/10/2022 15:19

@Badbadbunny onerous' employment rights = employment rights that stop me from squeezing every drop of profit from my workforce. I have zero sympathy for these employers. If they can't run their business without exploiting their staff, they do not deserve to be in business at all.

Orangestrap · 26/10/2022 15:07

Not at all but I’d expect them not to add to them.

Badbadbunny · 26/10/2022 15:06

KimberleyClark · 26/10/2022 11:10

Where did people who voted Brexit think their employment rights came from? Not the Tory government that’s for bloody sure.

But it's the arguably the employment rights that have led to zero hours contracts, freelancers, casual workers, fake self employment etc., as employers have defaulted away from "normal" contracts to avoid what many perceive to be onerous employment rights!

Badbadbunny · 26/10/2022 15:04

mewkins · 26/10/2022 09:38

Actually I think that zero hrs and cladding are things that can be sorted with legislation and least damage to public funds. It is private companies and their profits that will be impacted and that is problematic for a Tory government- especially one that is losing public confidence fast. They are reluctant to make decisions which will hit the only supporters they have left.

From what I heard during the enquiry, the cladding wasn't legal, so there was already laws/regulations in place to stop that type being used on tall buildings. Trouble was that no one enforced the laws/regulations in place, so it's building control/building inspection where the fault seems to lie. Yes, of course, the contractors shouldn't have installed it, the architects shouldn't have specified it, but ultimately, building control/inspection is there to police the laws/regulations and they havn't, and not just one group either, as we've since found that same cladding was put on numerous high rise buildings, so there was an endemic lack of oversight of the laws/regulations in place.

pointythings · 26/10/2022 14:35

@voiceofmarion but the whole 'don't have kids if you can't afford them' doesn't take into account the fact that we are in a low pay, high cost (housing) economy, therefore it is very difficult for many people to save. It's extremely easy to fall into a situation where you need benefits when previously you haven't - all it takes is one accident, one cancer diagnosis and you're there. It's perfectly possible to do everything right and still get bitten on the arse by fate.

voiceofmarion · 26/10/2022 13:41

Unsafe cladding on blocks of flats put there by private developers. Being housed outside of your area by the council. Zero hours contracts. All issues that the government seem to be expected to sort out

in the case of unsafe cladding the govt are at fault here as they should have tight enforced legislation in place. In Ireland the houses are falling down because of mica and the govt are responsible as they didn't have enforced legislation in.

Zero hour contracts are also the fault of the govt because they control the legislation. I think with the ''being housed outside of your area by the council'', it's a mixed one because they shouldn't have sold off all the council houses. But at the same time when I hear people moaning about they can't feed their kids on benefits I wonder then why did you have them if you can't afford them-it's their own fault.

MinervaVeta · 26/10/2022 13:34

I blame the media for asking the silly, and always leading questions, in the first place.

CaronPoivre · 26/10/2022 13:26

LadyHarmby · 25/10/2022 18:31

Just listening to the news, interviewing people in the street.

No government can change the fact that some people are rich and some are not. Or that wars in other countries and/or pandemics will affect the price of things.

Inappropriate content on social media. Unsafe cladding on blocks of flats put there by private developers. Being housed outside of your area by the council. Zero hours contracts. All issues that the government seem to be expected to sort out? Is it reasonable?

BTW I’m a Labour voter so this is not about the Tories, more government in general.

I thinkuchnof that is government responsibility Governments are eletrd to serve their citizens, to keep them safe (in the widest sense) and to support them throughout life. They are not there to line their own pockets and do dodgy deals.

They can't change the fact wealth isn't fairly distributed but they can ensure the cost of public services isn't unfairly burdensome on the poorest and those in the middle. They can stop profiteering from basic utilities and hold companies accountable for ensuring safe services before shareholder profits.
The current price increases in UK are shocking in that they affect the poorest most and are not entirely down to extraneous factors. Look to profits on utility companies. Other governments have capped fuel prices.

mewkins · 26/10/2022 13:18

caroleanboneparte · 26/10/2022 12:53

Poverty is a choice governments make.

I agree. It's unfortunate that people buy into this narrative that nothing can be done and there is a finite amount of money. Today Barclays announced a huge profit surpassing all expectations. Windfall taxes properly distributed can help prevent more and more millions of people slipping into poverty. It is a choice that a Government makes.

caroleanboneparte · 26/10/2022 12:53

Poverty is a choice governments make.

Swipe left for the next trending thread