Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brexit legislation that could result in 2,400 laws disappearing overnight – including a ban on animal testing for cosmetics, workers’ rights and environmental protections.

160 replies

Kendodd · 25/10/2022 16:17

Does anyone know about this? The government seem really keen to rip up everything. AIBU to be worried or is it not going to happen?

www.gov.uk/government/news/the-retained-eu-law-revocation-and-reform-bill-2022

www.theguardian.com/law/2022/oct/24/post-brexit-proposals-mean-2400-laws-could-disappear-lawyers-warn

OP posts:
Foronenightonly01 · 25/10/2022 22:38

Sadly, odds are on that this will pass. It’s a travesty.

JocelynBurnell · 25/10/2022 22:34

Blossomtoes · 25/10/2022 16:53

Thankfully he’s now on the back benches again. And hopefully Sunak will ditch this along with the rest of Truss’ lunatic ideas.

Wishful thinking.

I think these laws with go. So too will the NHS. The UK has to grow its economy and the only way it can do it is by removing regulation and privatising healthcare.

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/10/2022 22:31

Of course Labour could easily add replacement laws in their manifesto.

If they get in. What if they don't? What if a different party get in? One, even more intent on ideology than the Conservatives?

By the end of this parliamentary term, the Tories will be unelectable. The UK has massively shifted to the right, so those votes aren't necessarily going to Labour.

I despair of this Tory government that has already stripped me of so many rights but isn't finished. And I worry about whatever government English people will elect in 2 years time. For once in my life, living NI seems a privilege.🤯 I'd be shitting myself if I was English.

Kendodd · 25/10/2022 22:29

If this/when happens how will it affect NI?

And what about Scotland? I assume this will also cover Scotland, and that Scotland won't like that as it will create more hurdles to EU membership for them if they become independent? Plus Scotland wouldn't want diminished rights and protections for people, animals and environment.

What a shitshow!

OP posts:
PrincessofWellies · 25/10/2022 22:08

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 21:54

I am still yet to see anyone name a single law which they would like to see repealed.

I don’t know them all! Do you? They may even all be retained, maybe most of us here don’t want any repealed? But we have to incorporate them into our own laws in that case, you can’t keep it as it is. I’d like to know what this government plans to repeal, surely they’d be able to tell us something. Maybe they have? I’m just not aware of which ones they have on a list to get rid off, if any.

They are already incorporated into English law. What do you think happened before? Because what actually happened was that the EU Parliament passed legislation that the UK countries then put into UK law. Some were incorporated as passed, some were altered slightly or we derogated from in accordance with EU law.

You seem to have a misunderstanding about the legal position.

Applesandcarrots · 25/10/2022 22:01

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 21:54

I am still yet to see anyone name a single law which they would like to see repealed.

I don’t know them all! Do you? They may even all be retained, maybe most of us here don’t want any repealed? But we have to incorporate them into our own laws in that case, you can’t keep it as it is. I’d like to know what this government plans to repeal, surely they’d be able to tell us something. Maybe they have? I’m just not aware of which ones they have on a list to get rid off, if any.

There is a link to dashboard I posted earlier with retained EU law.

People don't need to know them all, no one does, but those saying it's needed should be able to say why and give examples.
Otherwise they are just making it up

User135644 · 25/10/2022 21:55

People voted for it so we'll have to get on with it.

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 21:54

I am still yet to see anyone name a single law which they would like to see repealed.

I don’t know them all! Do you? They may even all be retained, maybe most of us here don’t want any repealed? But we have to incorporate them into our own laws in that case, you can’t keep it as it is. I’d like to know what this government plans to repeal, surely they’d be able to tell us something. Maybe they have? I’m just not aware of which ones they have on a list to get rid off, if any.

MadameMaxGoesler · 25/10/2022 21:48

@jcyclops explains it perfectly. I wonder if she works with my husband? In the Goesler household we talk of little else.

Wheretheskyisblue · 25/10/2022 21:47

I don't think people realise just how complex the process is and how much is at risk e.g
in relation to food safety laws. blogs.sussex.ac.uk/uktpo/2022/03/10/finding-the-benefits-of-brexit-food-law-and-the-uks-emerging-regulatory-identity/

The benefit of this process is very dubious and I am still yet to see anyone name a single law which they would like to see repealed.

MadameMaxGoesler · 25/10/2022 21:46

@midgetastic
They can very easily say all Laws will roll over into uk law as they are
No need to scrap them
That is precisely what was done. Hence 'Retained EU Law'.

Mindthegap725 · 25/10/2022 21:44

And thank heavens for uk civil servants who have kept government departments running while the politicians went through recent successive meltdowns!

Mindthegap725 · 25/10/2022 21:42

notmyrealmoniker · 25/10/2022 20:39

Hold on, wasn't it part of the EU problem that there were just too many thousands of laws which were tying the country up in red tape? Not only that many of these regulations were ignored by much of europe but adhered to by the rule loving Brits.

Yes that is the myth that Boris Johnson and his cohorts was promoting for years in the right wing British press.

Wheretheskyisblue · 25/10/2022 21:41

Let's hope they are still not planning to cut 91000 civil service jobs then.

Applesandcarrots · 25/10/2022 21:36

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 21:34

I believe we have to trust the professionalism of the civil service and the scrutiny of select committees and the House of Lords - just as have to with any new legislation.

Yes, me too. It’s just the timeframe I don’t think makes it possible.

Tbh it's not like they are not busy with other important things.
Don't forget the "we will get rid of xxx civil servants" while giving them extra job...

They can be professional and great, bit if it has to be rushed, things will get missed

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 21:34

I believe we have to trust the professionalism of the civil service and the scrutiny of select committees and the House of Lords - just as have to with any new legislation.

Yes, me too. It’s just the timeframe I don’t think makes it possible.

TakeMe2Insanity · 25/10/2022 21:32

DesMoulinsRouge · 25/10/2022 16:22

This is exactly what people were warned about during the referendum campaign.

This

DesMoulinsRouge · 25/10/2022 21:28

Yes I understand that, I'm merely stating their ideology in the context of the 2400 laws.

Personally I don't agree with it. I think most ordinary people wouldn't if they realised what the consequences might be.
I don't think a cliff edge for that much legislation is a good idea but for a section of the Tory party it was the whole point imo.

1dayatatime · 25/10/2022 21:17

@DesMoulinsRouge

"The ERG people are Libertarians who want a "small state" like the US model. Lower standards across the board to save companies money.
Let the market decide.
That's not a good thing."

+++

Whether a "small state" and lower regulation is a good thing or not is of course a matter of political opinion.

However to make this theory work you also need lower Government spending and cutting Government spending is never a vote winner. So we had the car crash economics of Liz Truss promising to cut taxes at the same time as not cutting spending for example stating the pension triple lock would stand.

A lower tax and higher spending model simply doesn't add up or work as Liz Truss found out. So we are now moving to a higher tax and trying to keep spending on services stable whilst covering new spends such a the energy support scheme. In this model there is no need to junk standards.

jcyclops · 25/10/2022 21:15

midgetastic · 25/10/2022 20:23

They can very easily say all Laws will roll over into uk law as they are

No need to scrap them

This happened a couple of years ago before we left the EU.
In effect we passed an overarching law that said these 2400 laws/rules/regs are retained and incorporated into UK law. Now we have the next stage which is reviewing all these laws/rules/regs and by the end of 2023 either
a) incorporating them "as is" as amendments to existing UK laws
b) incorporating them "as is" as new individual UK laws
c) amending them and doing a) or b)
d) scrapping them as unnecessary.
e) Making a positive decision on the most difficult/contentious pieces for later discussion before the second deadline in 2026.

There is no doubt that this needs doing, and it was always known that this would be required. If it is not done, in some cases we will have the stupid situation where we have an EU law/rule as it was before 2020 frozen in UK law where the EU no longer follow it because they have since scrapped/amended/replaced it.

I share other posters' apprehension about the timescales and the inevitable Tory bias that could be incorporated in the exercise, but there could well be a Labour government in power for half the exercise who would incorporate their own bias. I believe we have to trust the professionalism of the civil service and the scrutiny of select committees and the House of Lords - just as have to with any new legislation.

Cavviesarethebest · 25/10/2022 21:15

I think many people think “but they won’t actually let that happen”.

but the conservatives have proved that they will.

they genuinely don’t care about any not wealthy or the environment or Britain’s international reputation

1dayatatime · 25/10/2022 21:05

notmyrealmoniker · 25/10/2022 20:40

2,400. And every one vital to the smooth running of the country? Not buying it.

Maybe you are right or maybe you are wrong.

But out of those 2,400 EU laws could you please give just one example of an unnecessary EU law tying the UK up in red tape.

DesMoulinsRouge · 25/10/2022 21:04

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 20:57

Although concerned about the timeframe and process, I don’t think it’s fair to assume the intention is just to get rid of the whole lot and take away rights they all enjoy too. Let’s be reasonable.

The ERG people are Libertarians who want a "small state" like the US model. Lower standards across the board to save companies money.
Let the market decide.
That's not a good thing.

Applesandcarrots · 25/10/2022 20:59

cakeorwine · 25/10/2022 20:56

Of course, Labour could easily add replacement laws in their manifesto.

e.g. We will ensure that consumers are protected.
We will ensure you have the right to holidays, maternity pay
We will ensure that you can claim compensation from airlines.

All things that people want. I would love to see Conservatives arguing about that when they were the ones who MAY be getting rid of regulations like this or reforming them

Passing replacements will take ages

Wheretheskyisblue · 25/10/2022 20:58

'Of course, Labour could easily add replacement laws in their manifesto'

It is not that simple though. Here is labour's take on it
labourlist.org/2022/10/labour-must-take-back-control-of-brexit-for-the-benefit-of-britain/
What looks like a dry list of legislative instructions deletes overnight 2,500 pieces of law on which our way of life has depended for decades. Not only does it abolish all these laws which rested on European statutes on the 31st December 2023 in one go, it offers no clue or certainty as to what will replace them. Furthermore, it demands any replacement be of a lower standard – thus enshrining deregulation as the outcome of Brexit in law. Whether you voted Leave or Remain, no one voted to require a race to the bottom on environmental, consumer or employment protections. Because of the way legislation interacts, any future Labour government will spend years revising the laws this bill rips up in a stroke as it could not simply be repealed. The harm would be done and last a generation.

Having left the EU it is inevitable we need to review our laws to ensure they sit on robust statutes. But this is not just minor or technical changes. The government’s dashboard – setting out every piece of legislation they say is affected – covers anything from the requirements that ensure the Olympics is free to air and no country act to undermine that, protection that if your employer goes bust you are entitled to at least 50% of your pension pot, requirements to stop cancer causing chemicals in cosmetics, airline safety standards, vital environmental protections that cover sites of special interest and even insider trading. The list covers over 300 different policy areas, with many not having any clear ministerial lead to take responsibility for what happens when they are deleted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread