Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you respond to MIL about this?

115 replies

DamnedIfDoOrDont · 25/10/2022 14:16

I think my MIL is going to confront me about her and FIL not being "treated equally" with my parent.

My parent lives 5 hours away and comes to stay with me a couple of times a year. Whilst here, they are really helpful with the DC and make my life a lot easier as my DH works very long hours and I work too. A couple of years ago I was really sick and my parent came and looked after me and ferried my DC to school. PIL have never helped me out, and once they agreed to babysit whilst I went to a wedding and they spitefully backed out at the last minute and my parent drove 5 hours to look after my DC so I could go. PIL live 45 mins away and have never helped us.

So, MIL has said to DH that she is not treated equally with my parent. I suppose she doesn't like the fact that my DC get to spend more time with their other GP and go out for meals etc. Basically my PIL want to stay here for nights on end thinking they are on holiday with me hosting them. I don't want to do this because this is just more work for me and they only live down the road. If my parent lived 45 mins away, they wouldn't be staying over, or not that often.

It's not just this either. If I invite my parent for Christmas, they refuse to come and childishly say things like "well, you won't want us there then". I used to include them a lot, but it is petty things like this that has made me say sod it, DH can deal with them.

PIL are very welcome to come here whenever they want, but they don't. It is not like I am massively favouring my parent over them. I am not. Mine is helping me out, whereas they don't want to.

I think MIL is going to have a word with me, and I am not sure what to say if she does. Who IBU here?

OP posts:
EL8888 · 25/10/2022 17:21

user1471538283 · 25/10/2022 16:54

I would tell them they can babysit or take the children to school or cook you dinner or clean any time they like. Just like your DM does.

My DM was like your MIL. On the few occasions she came I had double the work. She wanted her food when she wanted it, to be entertained by me, to do the stuff she wanted to do. I still took my DS to school, picked him up, cooked, washed up. She didn't even try to play with my DS. She sat there and talked about how great she was. So I stopped it. And she hated it that my DF really helped and had a fantastic relationship with my DS.

In recent years my mum seems to have developed bumstucktoseatitis in my house. She just sits there expecting to be waited on 🙄. Low point was when l did a 3 course Christmas dinner with all the trimmings and no assistance. She wouldn’t wash up and neither would my brother. Her demands are endless and annoying. So yeah l can see how someone’s prescience can increase the workload rather then reduce it

In OP shoes then l would be blunt and say when your parents come then they actually contribute. Her and her husband are busy people and under pressure so don’t have the time or resources to host people all the time. Plus it’s not the IL’s place to comment on her relationship, with her parents

IncompleteSenten · 25/10/2022 17:20

Tell them all the things your mum does when she visits you.

Tootyfilou · 25/10/2022 17:19

You didn't marry your MIL you married her son. For you to favour your own parents and enjoy spending time with them is nothing you have you need to apologise for. Your parents are more involved and therefor there will be a different dynamic. Not your problem, not even a problem at all. DH should speak to his parents and ask what exactly they want. You can just tell MIL that you love your parents more and love spending time with them 😁

GabriellaMontez · 25/10/2022 17:11

"No you're not equal! You're unreliable and don't help out. And why would you want to stay over, you only live down the road"

Tbh it is for your dh to head this off if it's been mentioned to him.

Wetblanket78 · 25/10/2022 17:08

They are being rather childish by saying it's either them or us. We aren't coming if they are there YANBU.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 25/10/2022 17:05

girlmom21 · 25/10/2022 14:21

I'd be very clear. The relationship is entirely different because the dynamic is different. Your parent mucks in, wants to help and is reliable. You can count on your parent to be a part of the household when they're there and not a guest.

When you've asked the IL's for help, they've let you down. When they have been to your home, they act like guests and expect to be waited on - which is fine but then they need to understand they'll also be treated as such as will outstay their welcome if they expect it regularly or for prolonged periods of time.

Just be honest about the differences. Although DH should have already done that rather than you being put in this position.

I would say exactly this in a calm and matter of fact way.
The are close enough to pop in regularly and see their grandchildren and should arrange this with DH as you can't say when would be convenient for him and you both have FT jobs.

If she gets cross simply tell her that you are sorry she feels that way. (You're not sorry obvs)
I would also point out to your DH that if he invites them he is obliged to host them so if she goes off on one he is quite clear of your expectations.

picklemewalnuts · 25/10/2022 16:58

Just reply with specific situations your parents are involved in, that MiL doesn't want to be.

Oh yes, like when they baby sat so we could go to the wedding? It was such a shame you couldn't.

Oh yes, come and stay when I'm ill, to do the school runs? Oh that would be wonderful.

Did you want to have the DC for a few days in the holidays, so DH and I can work? Great! That will make things much easier.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 25/10/2022 16:56

Pumpkindoodles · 25/10/2022 14:26

You’re in the right
I think you can just deny,
‘no I don’t think we treat them different’ and change the conversation
minimise ‘yes of course, they live further away, this makes sense’ and change the conversation
or tell her the truth.

in my experience no reasoning, or confrontation helps because they do not wish to change, and the reality of the situation is irrelevant, they only want what they want. The conversation isn’t going to change until you give them what they want or they pick something new to want.
Obviously I don’t know if your MIL is the same as mine. But I typically choose simple truths - ‘well yes, because they actually help’ with no emotion, just fact and refuse to engage further, or I play dumb and don’t engage.

alternatively, if you think it’s something to rebuild, you could try to have a conversation and explain you’re really busy and your parent comes to help you, it’s not that they are getting more time, it’s that they are coming to do things for you. PIL are always welcome to visit, but you can’t always be a good host, like they may wish.
depends if you think they are whining because it’s ‘unfair’ or genuinely hurt and would like a better relationship with you and GC. It does sound more like the former since they turn down invitations to be included.

This. Its the diplomatic way, if as suggested you think there is something to rebuild.
but
ultimately the relationship you have with your parent is absolutely none of MIL's business and she doesn't get to dictate how often you see your DM, whether she stays over at YOUR house after driving for 5 hour and how much your DM sees your children.

Fraaahnces · 25/10/2022 16:54

I think you’ll find that my parents have been a lot more reliable than you have…

user1471538283 · 25/10/2022 16:54

I would tell them they can babysit or take the children to school or cook you dinner or clean any time they like. Just like your DM does.

My DM was like your MIL. On the few occasions she came I had double the work. She wanted her food when she wanted it, to be entertained by me, to do the stuff she wanted to do. I still took my DS to school, picked him up, cooked, washed up. She didn't even try to play with my DS. She sat there and talked about how great she was. So I stopped it. And she hated it that my DF really helped and had a fantastic relationship with my DS.

CuteCillian · 25/10/2022 16:54

Please don't beat around the bush, that just builds more obstacles. "Yes, my Mum stays because she leaves further away. Yes, my Mum helps us out whereas you have only let us down."
In the normal world it should be DH's conversation to have, but on MN it often seems as if Mothers are the ones who do the hosting/make all the social arrangements.
As Moveoverdarlin says, at the end of the conversation explain you would love to have a closer relationship with them and ask if they can babysit/go to the nativity play etc. whatever suits you...then make it clear how you feel should they let you down again.

ShineOnYouLikeMorningStar · 25/10/2022 16:54

I'd be tempted to call their bluff, make sure they know what your parent does while they're staying with you. Say you think it's lovely that your PILs want to be more involved & you'll let the school know they will be dropping the kids off & picking them up sometimes, the kids eat at X time, they have clubs on certain nights, etc. And of course you'll be very grateful for the break & will do your best to accommodate them, given that you'll still be working full time but it will be such a rest for you not to have to worry about the school run etc sometimes. Maybe you can even have the occasional date night with your DH, how kind your PILs are for offering to babysit.

Cantstandbullshit · 25/10/2022 16:52

Fraaahnces · 25/10/2022 14:25

I would simply say “Why the fuck do you think it’s a democracy? You get what you put in. Stop being a manipulative dick.”

You sound like one of those idiots who are so anonymously brave on the internet but stupid cowards in real life.

You sound so immature, really that’s what you will say if you were in her shoes?

I’m sure the OP is mature and sensible enough to ignore ridiculous advice like this, she should stand her ground but do it politely and let her husband deal with most of it.

Bordesleyhills · 25/10/2022 16:49

In-laws - 3 weeks post c section with sepsis. Mine been brilliant and step in to help.. in-laws offered help… by phone… yet to do anything useful

DowntonCrabby · 25/10/2022 16:49

Echoing all those saying push this back to your DH, her son. So many DGP have poorer relationships with their DGC due to misogyny and ineffectual men.

ItsaMetalBand · 25/10/2022 16:47

I wouldn't respond. That's DH's job - it's his parents not yours.

JuneOsborne · 25/10/2022 16:46

I'd just tell her to speak to DH.

Fuck getting into it all! She's your mum and you can do what you like. Mil is DHS mum and he can do what he likes. You are not responsible for her or her feelings.

The minute she starts, just say, oh you need to talk to Mike about this, not me.

Moveoverdarlin · 25/10/2022 16:42

The situation with my parents and in-laws is EXACTLY the same. I could have written this myself. If she approaches you about this, it’s probably best to be honest and say ‘it’s great that you want to be more involved, the kids will be delighted. Ooh now you’ve mentioned it, my Mum was due to come down (which takes her 5 hours) on xxth December because me and DH have got a do, but it would be great if you could come here and babysit?’ Try your luck and test her. See what she says, she’ll probably make some lame excuse and not want to do it if she’s anything like my MIL. If she says no she hasn’t got a leg to stand on.

Gloryofthe80s · 25/10/2022 16:38

Why does she want a word with you? It sounds like you should be having a word with her. I’d get in first and mention to her all the things you’ve said. It’s time for her to step and and be the solution not the problem.

LondonGirl83 · 25/10/2022 16:35

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 25/10/2022 14:55

If you want to stay and babysit we'd love that, there's a restaurant I want to try out. Or do you want to do the school runs? That would be lovely. Would it not be easier if the kids came to you for a night? I feel we'd be putting you out coming here when you're only 45 mins away.

If she says you treat us different, I'd say "in terms of help? That's fair I do generally ask mum and dad first, but I'll get dh to ring you the next time one of us is sick, thanks so much. I really appreciate it"

This is exactly what to say. Also, emphasise the staying over is because of the distance but they are welcome to babysit and help out just like your mum does and you really appreciate the offer.

stuntbubbles · 25/10/2022 16:35

AryaStarkWolf · 25/10/2022 14:32

Why are you gender neutralising whether it's your mother or father, it's not like it's really going to change the advise given!?

Maybe the parent is gender neutral. Maybe OP feels specifying her parent’s gender outs her when combined with the other details – I often do this. If it doesn’t matter to the advice given, it doesn’t matter.

OP, if MIL does confront you: over the phone, you can say, “Oh, you want to talk to DP” and hand the phone over. Via text/WhatsApp, a straightforward ignore and a handy mute (though I’d be tempted to reply “?” and escalate to “??” and “???” the more she pushes). In person, a confused frown and again, hand her over to DP. Don’t engage with her making it in issue: you treating her different isn’t an issue for you! It’s fine!

Loics · 25/10/2022 16:28

My in laws are similar, but luckily don't care enough to say anything. They live less than half an hour away and we see them maybe 4 times a year (that's usually if we really push and try our hardest to coax a time we can see them out of them). However MIL will throw a tantrum (and has done previously) if she thinks she has been left out of something. I'm talking crying, screaming, calling me all the names of the day, running around the house slamming doors... DP more or less has to tell her she can air any issues she has when she's able to do it in an adult manner, and leaves her to it. I literally take nothing to do with it. I would say your DP should do the same - partly why mine deals with his is because he tells them it isn't just "her/that woman/whatever I am that day" that feels a certain way, he does too.

Untitledsquatboulder · 25/10/2022 16:28

Of course you shouldn't have to treat your inlaws the same but do you ever invite them round? You don't really have a "popping in" relationship. Also, do they ever invite you to theirs?

2bazookas · 25/10/2022 16:26

I think MIL is going to have a word with me, and I am not sure what to say if she does.

You immediately put her on the back foot by saying " You're quite right, my mum does a lot more. The thing is, Mum is my mother so it's really easy to ask her when I need help because I know she won't mind; she loves babysitting and helping round the house. She just makes straight for the to-do list.

What's the to-do list? Heavens, did DH never show you? It's here, on the back of this cupboard door. DH and I keep a list of little jobs that need doing, shopping lists etc, and tick off the ones we've done. Don't be shy, just dive right in. Now, when would you like to babysit? "

Bonniegirlie · 25/10/2022 16:23

I would just say basically what you have put in your post. If she doesn't like hearing the truth then it's her problem not yours. She sounds like she wants her cake and eat it. How does she expect to be treated the same as your parent when they don't remotely help you out in any way.