Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you respond to MIL about this?

115 replies

DamnedIfDoOrDont · 25/10/2022 14:16

I think my MIL is going to confront me about her and FIL not being "treated equally" with my parent.

My parent lives 5 hours away and comes to stay with me a couple of times a year. Whilst here, they are really helpful with the DC and make my life a lot easier as my DH works very long hours and I work too. A couple of years ago I was really sick and my parent came and looked after me and ferried my DC to school. PIL have never helped me out, and once they agreed to babysit whilst I went to a wedding and they spitefully backed out at the last minute and my parent drove 5 hours to look after my DC so I could go. PIL live 45 mins away and have never helped us.

So, MIL has said to DH that she is not treated equally with my parent. I suppose she doesn't like the fact that my DC get to spend more time with their other GP and go out for meals etc. Basically my PIL want to stay here for nights on end thinking they are on holiday with me hosting them. I don't want to do this because this is just more work for me and they only live down the road. If my parent lived 45 mins away, they wouldn't be staying over, or not that often.

It's not just this either. If I invite my parent for Christmas, they refuse to come and childishly say things like "well, you won't want us there then". I used to include them a lot, but it is petty things like this that has made me say sod it, DH can deal with them.

PIL are very welcome to come here whenever they want, but they don't. It is not like I am massively favouring my parent over them. I am not. Mine is helping me out, whereas they don't want to.

I think MIL is going to have a word with me, and I am not sure what to say if she does. Who IBU here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FurAndFeathers · 08/05/2023 07:29

Hotfootgoose · 08/05/2023 07:15

i think I would head anything off with “ well they are my parents so they are my responsibility, you are DH parents and he is responsible for arranging to see you” end of . Because at the end of the day, that is exactly true!

Well, thank goodness you delivered that advice 5 months after the OP posted.!

Hotfootgoose · 08/05/2023 07:15

i think I would head anything off with “ well they are my parents so they are my responsibility, you are DH parents and he is responsible for arranging to see you” end of . Because at the end of the day, that is exactly true!

Blablablaaaaa · 30/10/2022 06:35

Just reply that you’re exhausted what with DH working such long hours and your mother helps you a lot when she’s here. Washes pots, changes the kids, nursery drop offs. If they want to help out too, that’s great and would be appreciated. When are they available to help and how would they like to help out?

VinnyDaPooh · 30/10/2022 06:27

Sounds like PIL have an entitled mindset. They want all the rewards with none of the effort. While others say DH needs to take care of this, either he isn't going to OR he has tried and they won't listen to him. Either way it really boils down to you needing to fix it or deal with it for years to come. However you can use this to your advantage.

When they bring up that you don't treat them equally, lay a trap for them to walk through. Hopefully they do this in front of the whole family as that will help you. In the most loving tone you can muster say "I'm so sorry I made you feel this way. It wasn't intentional and I never realized it was happening". At this point they have just dropped their guard and can clearly see they are getting what they want. Or so they think.
"We need to fix this immediately. Since I didn't notice this to begin with, help me out here...please tell me every way I have been treating you unfairly." Grab pen and paper to take notes. Let them drone on and on about how awful you've been and every way you treated them differently. Nod your head in agreement. When they are done listing the ways, you now switch gears and spring the trap they so graciously built for you. "This is going to be lots of help. I know what we need to do now." Go to the list and go line by line... (obviously using your real history and not what I'm making up as examples)
"You were upset that my parent spent a whole week here last year and you didn't. That was the week I had the flu so they came down to watch the kids and take care of the house. Next time I get sick I'll just call you instead and since you're so close it won't be a problem for you to take care of me, the house and the kids".
"It bothered you that my parent gets to spend entire weekends with their grandchildren and you don't. DH and I have been talking about taking more romantic weekend trips just the two of us. He'll be so excited to hear you're going to spend time with your grandchildren and watch the kids for us when we go away."
Do not get defensive with any of this. Don't point out how helpful and great your parent is. But think.fast on your feet here. Repeat every thing that upset them, and for each one, tie in an action (or behavior) they they need to do (or have) in order to get their desired result. Like I said earlier this works better if it's in front of their side of the family because they can't paint you as the bad guy. It shows everyone that they arent getting what they wanted because they haven't been putting any effort into being grandparents.

The most likely outcomes I see are...

  1. They don't like being called on the carpet for this, miraculously grow a heart and actually put forth effort.
  2. They get upset with you, storm off and go low/no contact. I'm sure you won't cry too much over that.
  3. They realize that you outsmarted them and boxed them into a corner. Though they still won't put in the effort, they realize they can't complain about being treated differently unless they put forth the effort. They are still cranky curmudgeons but they get off your back... about this anyway.

Hope everything works out for you in the end

Murdoch1949 · 29/10/2022 20:28

MIL is jealous. Her baby boy is no longer completely under her control and she doesn't like it. You are being much nicer than I would be with her, probably because you love your husband and want to be nice to her because he loves her. Continue as you are. Ask your parents every Christmas and if MIL chooses to stay away so be it.

pantsville · 29/10/2022 12:48

We don’t even know what the MIL has said yet, or is planning to say, if anything. It doesn’t seem right to just guess that she’s going to be wrong about everything and be ready to tell her to fuck off the minute she opens her mouth. This is only one side of the story.

Her perception of the dynamic might be very different from yours. Some people don’t expect to need to be “helpful” when they visit people. Maybe she finds your parent irritating, or gets pissed off by him/her involving themselves in everything “helpfully” whenever they’re both there. In her mind it may look like your parent is taking over or being overbearing. Most of us wouldn’t turn down an invite because certain people are there - unless we have a previous bad experience and don’t like/get along with them.

I think all you can do is redirect complaints to DH and make a conscious effort not to be obstructive to any reasonable plans they make. I’m only assuming there’s more to their side of the story here as otherwise it just looks like them moaning for absolutely no reason when they live fairly nearby and have every opportunity to spend quality time with you all. I think listening to what MIL has to say and having an open mind would be better than planning arsey replies in advance.

(not the MIL I swear, just looking for an alternative perspective here!)

justdontkno1 · 29/10/2022 12:06

@MarieIVanArkleStinks that’s fair enough, well said. My own mil expects to be waited on hand and foot and having small dcs it is ridiculous but I don’t expect her to help with them or mind them.
I think I thought the op said that she expected them to help practically and mind dcs in exchange for more time with them.
But mil is that demanding then fair enjoy she wants to reduce visits etc.

Whatsleftnow · 26/10/2022 09:02

JenniferBarkley · 25/10/2022 20:29

I think this approach (similar in lots of other posts) would be a real mistake. Family relationships aren't transactional, they shouldn't only get to see the DC if they do some babysitting or housework. They were out of line with the wedding, but other than that it's ok. If you take this approach you'll look like a complete bitch to anyone they tell the story too - my DIL will only let me see the DGC if there's something in it for her.

Keep it light and breezy like I posted above. If that doesn't work, say you're not going to get between her and DH and she needs to be speak to him.

On reflection I agree with @JenniferBarkley. it’s very easy to post a pithy response online but real life is more nuanced and protecting good relationships between your dh and his dps, and your dc and their gps is the important thing.

Naunet · 26/10/2022 08:53

This crap is ALWAYS put on women. In the history of the world, have pils ever pulled their SIL aside to complain he’s not treating them the same as his own parents???

Grumpusaurus · 26/10/2022 05:36

Of course, it is normal for you to favour them! They are your parents! Secondly, it is cause and effect. They do sod all to help, so why should you put yourself out. If Mil has the nerve to raise the subject, tell her exactly that.

HannaHanna · 26/10/2022 03:35

It does not matter what you say. She’s an unreasonable person and you can’t make her be different.

I would perhaps try listening and just saying “I will think about this”. But it’s doubtful she’s going to suddenly recognize her own bad behavior.

allboysherebutme · 25/10/2022 22:29

Tell her the truth, you are not interested in the children, you are only interested in staying here when you could quite easily drive home, because you want a mini break and me to run around after you.

My parent help me, you do not, you want me to look after you, rather than you look after the children, quite frankly I have enough to do, I don't need anymore children to look after. X

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 25/10/2022 21:13

Laiste · 25/10/2022 18:38

I would guess the reason OP is saying 'parent' is to avoid the usual knee jerk reactions from some posters who see 'my mother' vs 'his mother' and immediately jump to 'poor paternal MILs always get the shit end of the stick' and ''Wait till your son grows up ect ect ect'' rhetoric 🙄

And with good reason.

Houseplantmad · 25/10/2022 20:47

Why wait for her to bring it up with you, why not take the initiative and tell her you’ve heard via DH she is complaining about being treated unfairly. That will catch her off guard so you can deliver you’re pre-prepared speech about why she and FIL can’t possibly expect to be treated the same as a grandparent who gets involved willingly, unselfishly etc.

JenniferBarkley · 25/10/2022 20:29

Whatsleftnow · 25/10/2022 19:03

“Oh I’m so glad you’ve brought this up. My dos have been such a support to us. It’s wonderful that you feel you can take more on now. Which days would you like to mind dc? “

I think this approach (similar in lots of other posts) would be a real mistake. Family relationships aren't transactional, they shouldn't only get to see the DC if they do some babysitting or housework. They were out of line with the wedding, but other than that it's ok. If you take this approach you'll look like a complete bitch to anyone they tell the story too - my DIL will only let me see the DGC if there's something in it for her.

Keep it light and breezy like I posted above. If that doesn't work, say you're not going to get between her and DH and she needs to be speak to him.

Hoppinggreen · 25/10/2022 19:41

“Oh dear, it’s a shame you feel like that”
change subject and let your H deal with it

beakyboo10 · 25/10/2022 19:39

Let your husband deal with her, chances are she will bring it up with your husband and not mention it to you directly.

My MIL complained that I didn't make her welcome when her grandson was born, apparently me trying to breastfeed and having a very painful episiotomy meant that I didn't offer her a cup of tea.

Goosygandy · 25/10/2022 19:07

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 25/10/2022 17:50

Your DH is being unreasonable in not being honest with his parents about them taking the piss, being rude and not supporting you all as a family.

Exactly this! Why is he passing this down to you to deal with? Why has he not been standing up for you and allowing his mother to bad mouth you? Why didn't he go mad at them for letting you down over the wedding.

Your PiL are behaving appallingly because your DH is allowing them to get away with it.

StripeyDeckchair · 25/10/2022 19:05

My response would be

  • my parents are reliable, if I ask them to do something and they agree then I can rely on them. In the past you've agreed to do something for us and then dropped out at the last minute.
They help us out when they're here and don't sit around waiting to be entertained, feed and served drinks, unlike you. They support us and don't judge us or offer unwanted advice. And yes, my parents stay when they visit. They live too far away not to. Aren't you lucky to be able to go home & sleep in your own bed? And not be woken by the kids at 6am?
Whatsleftnow · 25/10/2022 19:03

“Oh I’m so glad you’ve brought this up. My dos have been such a support to us. It’s wonderful that you feel you can take more on now. Which days would you like to mind dc? “

saraclara · 25/10/2022 18:56

"You know you're welcome here any time you want MIL. You can just pop round. The distance with my parents makes things awkward, so they need to stay and then we don't see them for ages. Don't worry, the DC know you're both equally granny."

Words to that effect. Focus on the practical element that she can't argue with. And how lucky MIL is that she doesn't have to go six months without seeing her son and grandkids.

And yes, then leave it to your DH.

GinIronic · 25/10/2022 18:56

Fraaahnces · 25/10/2022 14:25

I would simply say “Why the fuck do you think it’s a democracy? You get what you put in. Stop being a manipulative dick.”

Agreed.

billy1966 · 25/10/2022 18:54

Pirrin · 25/10/2022 17:55

If she does approach I would guess it's more about her saying her piece than anything else. Hard to reason with that as its not from a place of live and understanding.

"That's a shame that you feel like that. However, my relationship with my mum is entirely about the two of us. I don't compare the time I spend with her to the time I spend with anyone else - she's my mum. If this is about your time with the grandchildren then please tell DH how you feel as time spent with his family is mainly based on him. I would appreciate you not bringing my mum into this again."

Nip it in the bud (if it happens). Polite but clear that this is a boundary for you.

Good post.

XanaduKira · 25/10/2022 18:49

Snoken · 25/10/2022 16:08

It's not up to you to maintain a relationship between your DC and PIL's, that's your DH's job. You are doing what you can to make sure your parents have a relationsip with the DC, that's all you need to do. If she starts talking to you about that, just tell her to speak to her son instead.

This absolutely!

I'd also be tempted to point out how much your parents helps out and can be relied upon and they can't, however it's probably best not saying anything like this. If she's spoiling for a fight, don't give her one, point her in DHs direction.

GoldenCupidon · 25/10/2022 18:45

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/10/2022 14:46

Tell her you’re sorry she feels that way but that you aren’t going to stop accepting offers of help when you get them, and if she’d like to make similar offers of help then she’d see her gc more too.

Yes - this one