Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to respond to menopausal nanny?

91 replies

HeatingCheating · 25/10/2022 10:01

We have a part-time nanny for our two DC (1 and 4). She is amazing, brilliant woman - and we often have a natter over a cup of tea when I'm working from home. We've been out for a few wines too. I realise this might make it trickier now to handle this.

Anyway - she's been chatting about being menopausal or pre-menopausal - I'm not sure which - but she has been on HRT off and on for the last 6 months. She has talked about not feeling herself, feeling very strange, and told me about getting v. angry about things.

The GP can't find any HRT for her at the moment. And she is turning for work with a face like thunder. Getting frustrated at the kids whereas before she would have been so kind. She just generally doesn't really want to be here anymore. But she is trying really hard to be loving but I see the anger across her face over stuff all the time. She mutters stuff under her breath.

I know this isn't her. But also I leave my two kids with her 3 days a week and it's not fair on them.

How would you respond? The last thing she needs is me telling her to "look happier" but I don't feel I can just leave it like it is.

OP posts:
WahineToa · 25/10/2022 14:11

@Wisenotboring what would be your suggestion though if it was their mother taking care of them and experiencing the same things? The OP won’t be fair away herself. Are you suggesting women should hide menopause symptoms or just dismissed as horrible bitches during menopause? Or should families discuss it and make everyone aware of how to support their mother and what they should expect?

over50andfab · 25/10/2022 14:03

Paris2023 · 25/10/2022 13:18

Isn’t the menopause a protected characteristic? Please take advice

The menopause itself is not a protected characteristic, however it could be covered under other protected characteristics like sex and age www.acas.org.uk/menopause-at-work/menopause-and-the-law

To Justasking muttering to yourself can also be a symptom of menopause to try to cope with the others eg irritability or concentration issues.

We don't know what the actual issue is with the nanny whether it's the shortages (these are improving and there are other options and ways to access it) or getting the right type and dose. There is support for this though and it can be a massive relief to someone knowing there are others feeling the same way. Menopause symptoms can be scary for many women and being able to talk about it can help.

Smineusername · 25/10/2022 14:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wisenotboring · 25/10/2022 14:00

Smineusername · 25/10/2022 13:54

Yes you are being very unreasonable to want to discriminate against your 'amazing, brilliant' employee because she is going through the menopause. Perhaps talk to your children and educate them about the menopause and how it makes people feel.

Are you serious?! No, small children should not need to be educated about the menopause so that they can more easily cope with an angry adult in sole charge of them. I'm sure there is some middle ground here as op seems caring but there is also an obligation to do the job one is actually employed for.

MzHz · 25/10/2022 14:00

CruelworldKindwords · 25/10/2022 12:41

It's just that if I saw a post on here where someone I knew was talking about my personal struggles with menopause, I would feel absolutely mortified, hurt and upset.

No identifying information for one.

if I saw someone talking about my (or anyone else’s) menopause symptoms as a mental health condition I’d be pissed off.

educate yourself love, menopause hits women differently, and often rage is a common symptom. Getting the right HRT can fix that in a very short space of time. MH doesn’t work like that.

Smineusername · 25/10/2022 13:54

Yes you are being very unreasonable to want to discriminate against your 'amazing, brilliant' employee because she is going through the menopause. Perhaps talk to your children and educate them about the menopause and how it makes people feel.

ilovemydogandmrobama2 · 25/10/2022 13:47

There is a bit of blurring of boundaries, but you can't just treat her as, 'just an employee,' as you know things as her friend.

Could you possibly say, 'I am concerned as a mother and as a friend,' and ask her if there is anything that has affected her ability to do her job?

If she mentions the issue of inability to get HRT, then maybe address this, but I have not had any issues in getting supplies. I did have to switch to sachets rather than the pump, but it worked out better.

Moominfanjo · 25/10/2022 13:37

I knew a very angry non-menopausal nanny looking after children that my children were friends with, omg ehat a b*tch she was. i gave the mother a heads up and she installed cctv and promptlu sacked the nanny!
It doesn't matter the reason for the anger or grumpiness, if it's chronic or acutely bad, it has an impact on the children amd they won't thank you for leaving them with a potential monster.

justasking111 · 25/10/2022 13:36

blackberrybat · 25/10/2022 13:23

Peri menopausal here and anger / irritability is a massive issue for me. I've tried HRT and it made it worse rather than better so for now I'm off it again until I can get another elusive GP appt to try something different. Its horrible, there are times where I feel I could easily murder someone (I was so angry on Sunday I was actually biting my own hand really bloody hard rather than scream at DH because he was annoying me). It's definitely meno related, for the doubters! Its like the worst PMT but all the time / at unpredictable times.

So tricky because it's not her fault but equally not at all fair on your children (and likely quite scary and upsetting if she can't keep a lid on it).

It does help to talk in my experience. Can you try and get some time with her to say you've noticed she seems unhappy and frustrated and ask if there is anything you can do to support her? Appreciate its a 121 employment situation but I'd say that's the first step any employer should take IMO.

It's one thing if your DH is getting on your nerves but innocent children really?

Endofmytether2020 · 25/10/2022 13:35

To all the people saying "get her a private prescription" - I think the issue for the nanny is that there is a shortage of oestrogel and possibly patches in pharmacies. This is due in part to the massive boom in awareness about HRT. Some people, like me, can't take traditional oral HRT treatments for medical but lots of people are demanding gel or patches as "better" and the manufacturers can't meet the demand.

With regard to the issues with the nanny, may be give it a week or two to try to observe her as if you didn't know about the menopause issues. Is she objectively acting in a way that you feel means she can't perform in her role? If you still feel you need to talk to her, maybe get some professional advice first (not on Mumsnet) to help you frame the conversation in a way that is constructive and not counter to employment law.

justasking111 · 25/10/2022 13:34

Paris2023 · 25/10/2022 13:18

Isn’t the menopause a protected characteristic? Please take advice

Muttering to yourself isn't though

NKffff · 25/10/2022 13:30

www.prescriptiondoctor.com/
This is where I got my hrt when it wasn't available locally. She should give this a try, I think I paid about £30.

blackberrybat · 25/10/2022 13:23

Peri menopausal here and anger / irritability is a massive issue for me. I've tried HRT and it made it worse rather than better so for now I'm off it again until I can get another elusive GP appt to try something different. Its horrible, there are times where I feel I could easily murder someone (I was so angry on Sunday I was actually biting my own hand really bloody hard rather than scream at DH because he was annoying me). It's definitely meno related, for the doubters! Its like the worst PMT but all the time / at unpredictable times.

So tricky because it's not her fault but equally not at all fair on your children (and likely quite scary and upsetting if she can't keep a lid on it).

It does help to talk in my experience. Can you try and get some time with her to say you've noticed she seems unhappy and frustrated and ask if there is anything you can do to support her? Appreciate its a 121 employment situation but I'd say that's the first step any employer should take IMO.

Paris2023 · 25/10/2022 13:18

Isn’t the menopause a protected characteristic? Please take advice

BreatheAndFocus · 25/10/2022 13:16

Don’t assume it’s all to do with the menopause. It might be that but made worse by personal problems. Ask her and see how you can help. That will give her a chance to explain. Or, perhaps it’s something like menopausal-induced insomnia? That can make people uncharacteristically grumpy. Finally, perhaps she has an additional health problem, is worried about that and that worry is making her irritable.

Whatever the answer, you need to talk to her, say you s noticed she’s not been herself, and ask what you can do to support her. If it is ‘just’ HRT, then if you could afford a private consultation/prescription that might be worth it if she’s usually “wonderful”.

over50andfab · 25/10/2022 13:10

LesLavandes · 25/10/2022 12:51

Most women in the workplace, manage 'it' in their professional life. This doesn't seem right or she is taking your kindness as a note to do as she feels and not behave professionally

It is called menopause and there shouldn't be any stigma mentioning it. Women can struggle massively and many leave their work. Some don't get good support from their GPs. A lot of awareness has been raised in recent years with many companies now having or in the process of putting together a menopause policy where reasonable adjustments can be made.

adriftabroad · 25/10/2022 13:07

You have blurred the borders, she has confided in you, you are now seeing problems and using her confidences to come to your own conclusions.

In the nicest possible way, you have put yourself in a stupid position.

It really is funny to me that 30/40 year olds do not realise they are only a decade away from perimenopause theselves. If not sooner.

justasking111 · 25/10/2022 13:05

Sorry my kids come first her health issues are hers. I wouldn't let my mum or MIL look after mine if they were this out of control.

Find someone else

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 13:00

Most women in the workplace, manage 'it' in their professional life.

You must have missed the current conversations on menopause and the concern over the numbers of women giving up work due to poorly treated menopause. It’s a financial concern for women and the country.

Kanaloa · 25/10/2022 12:55

jeffbezoz · 25/10/2022 12:50

Just to add to this reasonable adjustments must be made

Yes of course - just hard to see what reasonable adjustments could be made here. Talking to her kindly but honestly to her may be the first step.

LesLavandes · 25/10/2022 12:51

Most women in the workplace, manage 'it' in their professional life. This doesn't seem right or she is taking your kindness as a note to do as she feels and not behave professionally

jeffbezoz · 25/10/2022 12:50

Kanaloa · 25/10/2022 11:00

You aren’t asking her to ‘look happier’ you’re asking her not to violate the terms of her employment. It’s not acceptable to come to work angry and muttering under your breath when you’re in sole charge of small children. It wouldn’t be acceptable from a shop worker or a lawyer or a waiter or a teacher and it’s not acceptable from a nanny. If her medical issues make it so that she isn’t able to work then she needs to take time away from her job.

Just to add to this reasonable adjustments must be made

Laiste · 25/10/2022 12:49

It can feel tricky, when you've strayed into friend territory with someone who works for you/with you, to then have a convo. about their work quality.

For this reason i'd do as a couple of pps have advised and have the convo. in a friendly manner, but without mentioning anything which was bought up by her in social outings together.

If she wants to respond to your feedback with a reference to her menopause then you can take it from there in a professional and understanding manner - with a view to what happens in the now and the near future if the symptoms can't be bought under control.

As you would any other medical condition which affected her work.

oakleaffy · 25/10/2022 12:48

No way would I pay for an angry woman ( or man) to look after children.
It’s not fair on them.
Son ‘s class had a terribly angry teacher who was notorious for her shouting- so much so that she was called Shouty - (Surname)
She lost her cool over the simplest thing.

Similar age (50’s) but so say she’d always been shouty.
Not hormones, just her.

over50andfab · 25/10/2022 12:45

The HRT issue - I'm not sure - so it worked for a bit but then wasn't working so well. Then she went back to a GP who fobbed her off. Then back again and this time they prescribed patches but she can't get hold of them at any of the pharmacies near here apparently. She's sat on the phone to the GP right now.

I hadn't thought about offering to pay for her to go private. I could do that. But I can't afford lots and lots but could I pay for her to have an initial consultation - yeah, I could if that meant helping her and things improving.

It's possible she needed a higher dose. It's been quite tough for many women to get what they need over that past year or 2. HRT prescribing has risen a third of what it was last year. what patches is she using? If eg Evorel Sequi/Conti she could get Evorel estrogen only at a higher dose and oral Utrogestan as the progestogen component.

The support group mentioned above has low cost consultations with one of 2 nurse trained women who can then write to her GP with suggestions.