Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to respond to menopausal nanny?

91 replies

HeatingCheating · 25/10/2022 10:01

We have a part-time nanny for our two DC (1 and 4). She is amazing, brilliant woman - and we often have a natter over a cup of tea when I'm working from home. We've been out for a few wines too. I realise this might make it trickier now to handle this.

Anyway - she's been chatting about being menopausal or pre-menopausal - I'm not sure which - but she has been on HRT off and on for the last 6 months. She has talked about not feeling herself, feeling very strange, and told me about getting v. angry about things.

The GP can't find any HRT for her at the moment. And she is turning for work with a face like thunder. Getting frustrated at the kids whereas before she would have been so kind. She just generally doesn't really want to be here anymore. But she is trying really hard to be loving but I see the anger across her face over stuff all the time. She mutters stuff under her breath.

I know this isn't her. But also I leave my two kids with her 3 days a week and it's not fair on them.

How would you respond? The last thing she needs is me telling her to "look happier" but I don't feel I can just leave it like it is.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Beautiful3 · 27/10/2022 08:43

You really shouldn't leave someone angry with such small children. Your children should be your main priority, not the nanny's feelings. You know you need to get rid of her. Your children can sense her anger you know.

Kanaloa · 26/10/2022 13:28

WahineToa · 26/10/2022 07:01

Based on the OPs own description of what is happening here:
But every week her mood is worse. She tries to hide it, but i see the eye rolls, the almost growls under her breath if she gets a text that annoys her, or if gets stuck in traffic - she looks livid really quickly. There is sarcasm when dealing with the kids which i don't know if they pick up on = but i certainly do.

I actually think perhaps everyone is overreacting. If you all think the children are so at risk because she eye rolls and is sarcastic, then what do you think about all the kids being looked after by menopausal Mums? ‘Almost growls’ aren’t really grounds for dismissal or anything a child would notice. Is it the children the OP is worried about? Or does she just not like hanging out with her friend as much?

Being sarcastic and having a bad/angry attitude is grounds for dismissal. When you’re paying for professional childcare your child deserves to have good quality care, not an annoyed and sarcastic carer. I don’t know why people are acting like this is totally normal and acceptable from paid childcare - it isn’t. And even if the issue is that she doesn’t like the nanny anymore that’s also relevant. You need to like and trust somebody to leave your child with them.

WahineToa · 26/10/2022 07:01

Based on the OPs own description of what is happening here:
But every week her mood is worse. She tries to hide it, but i see the eye rolls, the almost growls under her breath if she gets a text that annoys her, or if gets stuck in traffic - she looks livid really quickly. There is sarcasm when dealing with the kids which i don't know if they pick up on = but i certainly do.

I actually think perhaps everyone is overreacting. If you all think the children are so at risk because she eye rolls and is sarcastic, then what do you think about all the kids being looked after by menopausal Mums? ‘Almost growls’ aren’t really grounds for dismissal or anything a child would notice. Is it the children the OP is worried about? Or does she just not like hanging out with her friend as much?

Goldbar · 26/10/2022 06:26

Smineusername · 25/10/2022 13:54

Yes you are being very unreasonable to want to discriminate against your 'amazing, brilliant' employee because she is going through the menopause. Perhaps talk to your children and educate them about the menopause and how it makes people feel.

The children are 1 and 4! How is the OP supposed to do this? Such young children need responsive, loving care to develop and thrive.

OP, this sounds very difficult. Little children can push a lot of buttons and I would feel very uneasy leaving an angry person in charge of two tiny children. I'd have a chat with her to see if there's anything you can do, but ultimately you need to feel safe leaving your children with their caregiver.

Ticksallboxes · 26/10/2022 01:17

@TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet seems to be the only one making sense on here!

Milly2022 · 25/10/2022 19:28

I'm menopausal and on HRT. Can go from 0 to homicidal in 60 seconds for no apparent reason! I wouldn't let anyone leave their children with me if they want them back in one piece 😂
Her issues are just that, hers. Your children have to come first.

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 18:52

But I'm going to push back against this stereotype that all menopausal women

Well you’re pushing back at something that hasn’t been said by anyone on this thread or anywhere else. Being aware and having options for good care and workplace policy for those it does affect, isn’t creating a stereotype or negative connotation. It’s making a reasonable request to society to accept and be flexible when it comes to menopause, just like we do with pregnancy, some work all the way almost to full term, some don’t, and for maternity leave. Some women are never going to need maternity leave, some are. It is a very positive thing to normalise menopause and the common symptoms that affect many women. I think you trivialise when you imply women want the free pass to go round losing their temper. It’s the stereotypical response. There are a lot more serious symptoms than that for one thing. Awareness that gets us better access to good treatment will also eliminate the occurrence of temper tantrums from us pesky old bags.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 25/10/2022 17:57

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 16:07

Middle aged women are going to be seen as unemployable at this rate.

Yes, it’s true but it already happens. It also happens to women of child bearing age. Do you think we should not talk about women’s health and the very real impacts in all areas of life including work? We make allowances for pregnancy, childcare, lots of medical things. We can do the same for menopause. Women try to get treatment but it’s been withheld by GPs, against guidelines, for two decades. Where have you been? Everyone is talking about it! Keep up with the times!

Of course access to proper health care is important and should be talked about!

But I'm going to push back against this stereotype that all menopausal women are sweaty, raging monsters who can't control themselves at work and need tiptoeing around. That's damaging to women.

I lost my patience with someone at work the other day. Very out of character. Did I tell them all about the menopause and how it makes me feel? No, I apologised. And told my boss I'd stepped out of line, and reflected on how to manage my temper better in future. Because I'm a capable, professional woman who owns her shit and doesn't make it everyone else's problem.

A woman who has very severe menopause symptoms and has completely lost the ability to regulate her emotions has my absolute sympathy. But if we normalise that as part and parcel of what every woman goes through, there'll be no impetus to treat it as what it is, an illness/disability, and prioritise treatment.

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 16:51

Good advice @2bazookas

2bazookas · 25/10/2022 16:44

She's been up front with you. Do the same

"Susan, you've mentioned feeling very menopausal and tbh, I have noticed you're feeling the strain with the children. I'm quite anxious about that"

stop there; see what she says.

Then you can try " I'm worried you might reach a crisis point and lose the plot while you're with the children".

If she's worth her salt she will recognise this is a valid concern for her as well as you.

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 16:21

I think we all understand age appropriate conversations. In general, what do you suggest though? You said they shouldn’t be educated about menopause before OP stated age. If she were pregnant, would she get fired? Or would the OP work out how to help them figure it out, including letting the children know what’s changed and why? Menopause isn’t just emotions, there’s lots to consider. People need to talk about it as normally as you would pregnancy or anything else.

Wisenotboring · 25/10/2022 16:18

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 14:36

@Wisenotboring nobody said the children had to ‘deal with it’ but you didn’t actually answer my question. This happens to half the population, some of them suffer so badly in this country due to poor care that their moods and behaviour is like this for some time. If it was their mother, what would your suggestion be then? Not ever discuss menopause with the kids? That’s so old fashioned

Of course age appropriate conversations about emotions are important but I don't think that is the answer here. The op said one of her children was one!

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 16:07

Middle aged women are going to be seen as unemployable at this rate.

Yes, it’s true but it already happens. It also happens to women of child bearing age. Do you think we should not talk about women’s health and the very real impacts in all areas of life including work? We make allowances for pregnancy, childcare, lots of medical things. We can do the same for menopause. Women try to get treatment but it’s been withheld by GPs, against guidelines, for two decades. Where have you been? Everyone is talking about it! Keep up with the times!

CruelworldKindwords · 25/10/2022 16:04

MzHz · 25/10/2022 14:00

No identifying information for one.

if I saw someone talking about my (or anyone else’s) menopause symptoms as a mental health condition I’d be pissed off.

educate yourself love, menopause hits women differently, and often rage is a common symptom. Getting the right HRT can fix that in a very short space of time. MH doesn’t work like that.

Sorry I realise that.
Mine makes me feel genuinely suicidal.

Fraaahnces · 25/10/2022 16:00

WTAF? Sit down and educate the kids about menopause??? Really? She was hired with one personality… either smiley or cool, calm and collected, and now she’s eye-rolling, muttering under her breath, impatient and growly. These are all extremely undesirable characteristics in a nanny and I am absolutely certain that the nanny is fully aware of this. It’s not feasible for her or the kids to continue if she can’t get on top of things ASAP.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 25/10/2022 15:25

Smineusername · 25/10/2022 13:54

Yes you are being very unreasonable to want to discriminate against your 'amazing, brilliant' employee because she is going through the menopause. Perhaps talk to your children and educate them about the menopause and how it makes people feel.

I am completely blown away by this and similar comments on here.

Middle aged women are going to be seen as unemployable at this rate.

Menopause affects SOME women's moods however it remains the woman's responsibility to behave professionally while at work, especially if caring for vulnerable people. If that's not possible, seek treatment, while taking leave if necessary.

It's absolutely not an employer's obligation to dish out medical advice or ignore bad behaviour for fear of being discriminatory.

Beautiful3 · 25/10/2022 14:59

I know a few women going through the menopause. One had to leave her job due to feeling rage, it made her look unprofessional. My neighbour who is also going through it, has started screaming and hitting her husband. It's like they've both had personality transplants. I would get rid of the nanny. Explain that she looks angry and the children don't feel comfortable anymore.

emptythelitterbox · 25/10/2022 14:52

SaintVitasShagulaitas · 25/10/2022 12:16

Why does she have to be happy? Very few of us are happy all the time, particularly at work. And if a grumpy expression were a bar to looking after children, most parents would have to disqualify themselves at some point.

It's acceptable in men but not so much women.
Men can stomp, sulk, be short and snippy, grump all they want.
Women do it and there is something terribly wrong with them.

The reason I got treated is because I didn't like feeling rageful inside.

SpeckledlyHen · 25/10/2022 14:43

HeatingCheating · 25/10/2022 12:37

Thanks for your advice. I think my natural instinct is to try and help - but I realise that I need to think of myself as an employer first.

She has been with us for 1.5 years and has always been absolutely WONDERFUL with them and honestly, the biggest help in so many ways. She is never late, always flexible, and so so kind to the kids.

But every week her mood is worse. She tries to hide it, but i see the eye rolls, the almost growls under her breath if she gets a text that annoys her, or if gets stuck in traffic - she looks livid really quickly. There is sarcasm when dealing with the kids which i don't know if they pick up on = but i certainly do.

She talks openly with me about feeling angry.

The HRT issue - I'm not sure - so it worked for a bit but then wasn't working so well. Then she went back to a GP who fobbed her off. Then back again and this time they prescribed patches but she can't get hold of them at any of the pharmacies near here apparently. She's sat on the phone to the GP right now.

I hadn't thought about offering to pay for her to go private. I could do that. But I can't afford lots and lots but could I pay for her to have an initial consultation - yeah, I could if that meant helping her and things improving.

The anger is what jumps out at me. I was sooooo angry all the time I was menopausal without medication. Literally starting arguments (mostly in my head) with randoms walking along the road, in the shops etc. When I went to the GP eventually I said you need to help me before I kill someone, I am just soo angry all the time. I was prescribed fluoxetine initially (which resolved the anger) and then HRT which resolved the anxiety. I now take both and life is much more balanced and normal.

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 14:36

@Wisenotboring nobody said the children had to ‘deal with it’ but you didn’t actually answer my question. This happens to half the population, some of them suffer so badly in this country due to poor care that their moods and behaviour is like this for some time. If it was their mother, what would your suggestion be then? Not ever discuss menopause with the kids? That’s so old fashioned

Wisenotboring · 25/10/2022 14:33

WahineToa · 25/10/2022 14:11

@Wisenotboring what would be your suggestion though if it was their mother taking care of them and experiencing the same things? The OP won’t be fair away herself. Are you suggesting women should hide menopause symptoms or just dismissed as horrible bitches during menopause? Or should families discuss it and make everyone aware of how to support their mother and what they should expect?

There are lots of reasons an adult may be cross or angry around a child. Generally, I just dont think it is the child's responsibility to deal with it. Even 'low level' emotionally unavailable or negative behaviour from carers can be damaging on an ongoing basis and it is important to be honest with ourselves about that instead of passing the buck to children.

blackberrybat · 25/10/2022 14:30

@justasking111 luckily there are no innocent children in my care but I'm pretty sure children can be just as annoying as a DH who isn't really doing much wrong, and almost definitely more demanding!

The issue / point I'm trying to make is that it isn't always rational / controllable. I didn't shout or scream or do anything to DH at all, but I knew he could read my mood and feel my annoyance. Sounds like the nanny is having similar issues, and the children will potentially pick up on it if she's not able to get the help she needs to manage it better.

HeatingCheating · 25/10/2022 14:23

@Smineusername I tried to explain to the one year old about menopause. He mainly threw weetabix in my face in response but fingers crossed we can expect him to be far more empathetic in the future.

And it's not that I can't be bothered to look after my own children. I'm a single mum and I go to work. It's a thing now - mums who work.

OP posts:
Fraaahnces · 25/10/2022 14:16

I am going to come at this from both a medical-ish (student nurse) and menopausal point of view here. I would suggest that she head back to the GP and request some kind of supportive medication to assist with the symptoms while there is a shortage of HRT meds.(ie Venlafaxine - an SSRI that helps stabilize moods and can also help calm hot flushes for some women. I am in Aus and am using an oestrogen supplement and Venlafaxine and can assure you that the world is much better off as a result! Of course there are many other supportive meds and this would best be discussed with her GP and the decision would be based on any medical conditions and medications she takes, etc.) I would also suggest that she inquires about another varieties of HRT medications too. Personally I am concerned about what you said about her going on and off them for a few months. I am sure that alone would mess with her mood. Whether that is due to availability, or due to her choice or her doctor’s, she needs to be on HRT medications for several months to give them a chance to settle in and work. I would stress that while she has been a valuable employee, you are extremely concerned about leaving your kids in her care while she is clearly not herself and you are worried she isn’t coping as a result.

PantyMcPantFace · 25/10/2022 14:16

@HeatingCheating There are supply issues - but she should be able to get something if she phones around. She needs to call pharmacies, find one with stock and then get the prescription issued sent "back to the spine". They willl giver her a barcode/number to then quote to the pharmacy who can then dispense it.