Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why it's bad to 'beg for sweets' but not bad to drag around a burning effigy of a Catholic while begging for money?

170 replies

TheWindBeneathMyFlaps · 25/10/2022 08:33

Is it because one is perceived as American by people who are a little bit thick

DH is 50. He went trick or treating and carved vegetables. He's from Essex.
We have photos of him and all his little friends dressed up.

Where did this idea that it's American come from? And even if it was American would that be enough to not celebrate something that kids enjoy? When the UK was off spreading its culture forcibly all over the world that was fine, but when one of its former colonies spread a little back, it's offensive.

OP posts:
ElspethTascioni · 25/10/2022 23:46

Brought up Catholic, so we never did either. Fireworks and bonfire sure, but certainly no guy!

Notjustanymum · 25/10/2022 23:43

I’m (nominally) a Roman Catholic… not sure if you can really ever “leave”!
Halloween is celebrated enthusiastically in my house - not because we believe in ghosts, God or Satan, but because it’s great fun to decorate the house like it’s Christmas, and allows the DC to mug willing participants (those displaying a Jack O’Lantern on their doorsteps) for unreasonable hauls of confectionery.
Anyone who assumes that we are nefarious Satan-Worshippers are immediately written off as completely Batshit and avoided at all costs from there on in.
Bonfire night however, unless you’re in Lewis (Sussex) is unlikely to sport a burning Catholic (they normally burn the Pope, I think) - so you are conflating two different events here, I believe…

etulosba · 25/10/2022 21:32

Ancestor’s

etulosba · 25/10/2022 21:32

Let's bring torture and capital punishment back then, after all if they know the consequences it's OK isn't it.

Society has moved on.

We shouldn’t judge our ancestors actions by today’s moral standards.

Brefugee · 25/10/2022 21:18

Don't be daft. I didn't say i agreed with it, i didn't say it was right. But he knew what he was facing. And he tried to blow them up, which is a painful awful, possibly slow and lingering, death.

I'm not ashamed of pointing that out.

ancientgran · 25/10/2022 20:57

Brefugee · 25/10/2022 09:38

I don't like the burning of the guy, the man was tortured and murdered why do we want to commemorate that? It is something to be ashamed of.

meh. He knew the consequences if he was caught trying to blow up the king and parliament. Gruesome to celebrate it, but if it hadn't been him in effergy on the bonfires it would have been the pope or someone else.

Let's bring torture and capital punishment back then, after all if they know the consequences it's OK isn't it.

He was a human being just like you and they tortured him and we should be ashamed not celebrating it. I don't think burning effigies of the pope is appropriate but it isn't the same thing as celebrating torture and murder.

Devoutspoken · 25/10/2022 20:53

Plenty of catholics hate guy fawkes night

Blueeyedgirl21 · 25/10/2022 20:49

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER but for a lot of younger posters with kids we’ve only known what you describe as the ‘tat from China’ version of Halloween. So we’ve not been witness to the decline or whatever. I was born in the 90s. There’s always been plastic tat present in my childhood!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/10/2022 20:44

Yes, @FarmerRefuted , but I was referring to an earlier era, when old fartettes like me were kids. My dds were kids in the 80s.

FarmerRefuted · 25/10/2022 19:22

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/10/2022 17:47

IMO Halloween has only become so huge in the U.K. since the advent of so much black and orange plastic tat in the shops. It’s been commercialised in a way Bonfire Night never has, because (except for fireworks) it doesn’t lend itself to a lot of cheap, made in China tat.

Back in my 80s childhood we had hat, masks, fangs, fingers, etc that you could buy in shops. Also facepaints, decorations, lanterns, themed sweets/cakes/biscuits, toys, etc.

etulosba · 25/10/2022 18:57

The stricter Catholics I know absolutely do not celebrate Bonfire Night!

I went to a convent school. We had a school bonfire night event every year. A big bonfire with burning guy, fireworks, baked potatoes, apple dipping etc.

The nuns who organised it (many of them Irish) seemed to enjoy it just as much as we did.

RedHelenB · 25/10/2022 17:53

Mumsnet is full.of killjoys over Halloween. There was trick or treating 50 years ago in Derbyshire too, at school we carved turnips and were read ghost stories. I think over time the pumpkin thing has got bigger, with pick your own farms and carving etc but the treats have remained the same.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/10/2022 17:47

IMO Halloween has only become so huge in the U.K. since the advent of so much black and orange plastic tat in the shops. It’s been commercialised in a way Bonfire Night never has, because (except for fireworks) it doesn’t lend itself to a lot of cheap, made in China tat.

Anonymous177 · 25/10/2022 17:38

Carving the turnip (swede) was definitely man’s work in our house. My father did it for me to take to the Brownies’ party. I’m slightly older than your husband @TheWindBeneathMyFlaps and you had to be enormously cheeky/hard to attempt trick or treating when I was a child.
I’ve never thought of Halloween as American, but trick or treating obviously is and it took off in England in my lifetime. Why should anyone on the receiving end like it. I believe it wasn’t even popular in America when it took off there either.
We don’t burn an effigy of Guy Fawkes because he’s Catholic but because he was a dangerous terrorist.
Asking for money in the street isn’t as annoying as asking threateningly at the door.
In the early eighties unsupervised trick or treaters (they always were unsupervised) did things like smash milk bottles on your doorstep if you didn’t give them anything. Of course people hated it.

Dahlietta · 25/10/2022 17:30

The religion of Guy Fawkes wasn't the point - his failure was the whole point and this is celebrated by Catholics as well.

The religion of Guy Fawkes was very much the point. He was part of a Catholic plot to overthrow the Protestant king and instate a Catholic monarch. The stricter Catholics I know absolutely do not celebrate Bonfire Night!

Abhannmor · 25/10/2022 17:12

Lots of people actually carried out mass murder. But they were the winners.

Now I don't mean to derail - but I always thought the Burning Effigies would be a great name for a punk or metal band.

etulosba · 25/10/2022 16:15

For us there was no thought of his religion or really of him as an actual person.

Regardless of his religion, the bloke got caught while attempting mass murder.

Burning his effigy on top of a bonfire seems entirely appropriate to me.

hatsofftoyouall · 25/10/2022 14:24

It's a bit weird in this leafy middle class neighbourhood

To wonder why it's bad to 'beg for sweets' but not bad to drag around a burning effigy of a Catholic while begging for money?
Lilyhatesjaz · 25/10/2022 14:23

I'm in my 50s and grew up in the south. Halloween passed unnoticed for us.
But bonfire night was a big thing, the village had a big bonfire and there were lots of fireworks.
One year some of us kids went around with a guy in a pushchair and collected money which we gave to charity. For us there was no thought of his religion or really of him as an actual person.

Fairislefandango · 25/10/2022 14:18

As with most traditions, it's just what you are used to and were raised with.

Yes, and as with most traditions, it should be perfectly possible for grown adults to accept that other people do things differently, without sneering or being overly dramatic about it. And the constant snobbery about anything that might possibly have come from or have been influenced by America is incredibly pathetic and tedious.

I turn 51 on the 31st and went trick or treating as a child, as did my children (they're a bit old for it now). We put pumpkins out. We don't fill our house with 'plastic tat' and I don't know anyone who does. YANBU, OP.

Abhannmor · 25/10/2022 14:08

Assuming Nos is Night , what does Calan Gaef mean?

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 25/10/2022 14:04

@mynameisnotkate In Wales it was Nos Calan Gaeaf

MysteryCallWTF · 25/10/2022 12:53

FarmerRefuted · 25/10/2022 10:30

I can confirm that Benwell, Elswick, Scotswood, etc are still rough as fuck. Even Fenham, which used to be considered a 'nice' area isn't what it used to be. Obviously there are reasons why deprivation has grown and its not all bad, I could go into depth but not the time or place. Yes though, Halloween and Bonfire Night are both awful in these areas. The fireworks will have already started I'll bet, those big booming ones that sound like an actual war is going on outside. I remember it from my childhood, especially my mam taping the letterbox shut at night because putting them through people's doors was a thing.

We moved away too, before we hit our teens my parents decided they didn't want us being teenagers in Benwell. It was a bit of a theme, lots of my friends parents moved out of the area at that time too.

I'm in Kenton and can confirm that the big booming fireworks have been back for weeks (not to be confused with the Diwali ones, which all seem to be organised displays rather than huge explosions in the middle of the street when it's not even dark yet).

Kenton is fairly deprived (the estate where I live anyway) and has a similar demographic to Benwell, Elswick etc. Yes, it's pretty threatening here around this time of year, although it has got better since I moved here 20 years ago. Then, we woke up on 1 Nov every year to find out windows egged, and one year, broken. We live in a second floor flat so switch the intercom off on Halloween and I think that was taken as 'trick' by the local kids. Hasn't happened for a few years thankfully.

etulosba · 25/10/2022 12:45

It’s not really true to say it’s been celebrated in Britain since the Middle Ages. It’s a Celtic festival and has been celebrated in Scotland and Ireland far longer than that - it’s pre-Christian. I don’t know much about its history of being celebrated in England but I think that is fairly recent

Until the Romans turned up, all of the Britain Isles were Celtic. Including what is now England.

OoooohMatron · 25/10/2022 12:41

HailAdrian · 25/10/2022 12:20

OK OK 'asking' for sweets then. You do you, it's not how I choose to do it. That's ok, except on mumsnet, where people can't tolerate ideas that are different to theirs.

I have absolutely no issue with people choosing not to participate, I couldn't give a monkeys. It just really annoys me when people say that it's 'begging'. Adults who want to give sweets buy them in specifically for trick or treaters and are expecting them to knock, it's not a surprise or unexpected in any way and there is no pressure to join in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread