Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Santa doesn’t exist.

133 replies

Elf25 · 25/10/2022 08:25

When did your DCs stop believing in Santa and whilst they did believe what was your rhetoric about how Santa works? E.g. Santa brings presents but parents give him money etc..

I saw another related post and it made me wonder what people do..

I have an under 1 year end of so will be there soon

OP posts:
Pascha · 25/10/2022 09:07

Also Ds1 was always very pragmatic about him. His belief since toddlerhood really was that santa is just a job title and that during the rest of the year he's just some grandad living a normal life and maybe he even shaves the beard during the summer.

That the job gets passed on: when one santa retires another is recruited, a bit like MI5 I guess.

lavenderfine · 25/10/2022 09:05

My two are only little and only DS4 is old enough to understand so can't answer how long they believe for. But in our house Santa brings the stockings and one present. The rest is from us. They're wrapped in different paper and santa goes all out with big ribbons and bows 😂 when I was younger santa brought everything but mum and dad sent him the money for it all!

Retrievemysanity · 25/10/2022 09:05

Mine were about 9/10 when they stopped believing. I think there had been some discussion at school the year before but DD’s friends were all the oldest siblings in their families and their parents were keen to keep it up as long as possible so the friendship group still believed even if some of the other kids in the class didn’t.

We were lucky enough to go to Lapland the year before and get another year out of it too. One of the best experiences of all our lives! We used to do stockings and big present from Santa and then a few presents from us.

Discovereads · 25/10/2022 09:05

We never lied to our DC. We told them the truth which was the story of St Nicholas who gave gifts to the poor children at Christmas. So now at Christmas we honour him by giving gifts to our children (and each other). They’ve actually recently found St Nicholas tomb in Turkey so that is a nice add on these days.

But yes, we decided early on that having a massive lie isn’t the best way to keep your child’s trust as they are likely to realise you have made a mug of them exactly when they are being more independent and only a few years away from being a teen.

It never spoiled the “magic” of Christmas. In fact because they knew we bought the presents there were none of the difficult conversations my mum friends had in regards to their DC asking since they were super duper good all year did they think Santa would bring them the £400 Millenium Falcon Lego set like their (dripping in money) classmate Timmy got last year? And Little Timmy is a bully, so obviously if my DC doesn’t get this Lego set he’s going to think Santa thinks he’s naughty compared to Timmy!

HappyHappyHermit · 25/10/2022 09:04

Father Christmas brings any presents that we buy for our dd - usually a stocking and a main present. Everything else is from family. We don't really say anything else, just that FC is coming and then that he has been. I won't go out of my way to trick her into believing longer if she starts questioning it when she's older, but nothing will change as it will still be from him!

Pascha · 25/10/2022 09:03

Ds2 told me last year when he was nearly 9 that he knew the truth about santa so that was that.

Santa only ever brought stockings here and the stockings are only filled with small stuff. A book is probably the costliest thing in there.

All proper presents are always from proper people.

We still wait til they are asleep before hanging them on their doorknobs though.

FuzzyPuffling · 25/10/2022 09:02

Worldgonecrazy · 25/10/2022 08:34

I taught DD that Santa / Father Christmas was a representation of the spirit of Christmas, not a person.

it means that, even as an adult, I can state with hand on heart, Father Christmas is real.

We also did this. Father Christmas was never a real person, physically coming down the chimney, he is just the spirit of giving and kindness.

PeekAtYou · 25/10/2022 09:02

Santa brings a stocking and the other gifts are from the person who bought it.
The Santas at garden centres etc are actors who have been asked by him to spread Christmas cheer. This one is important as school often use staff that the kids know and recognise L.
My kids stopped believing around 6. They realised that if he were real poor children would be given loads and rich kids a token because they don't really need it.

megletthesecond · 25/10/2022 09:00

Mine knew by about age 8/9. They're teens and still get stockings.

megletthesecond · 25/10/2022 08:59

Santa only brings stockings with small items left in bedrooms in this house. Socks, pens, book, chocolate coins, puzzle etc.

Everything else under the tree and from family.

Soubriquet · 25/10/2022 08:58

Ds is 7 and didn’t believe last year but let me think he did. He has outright said that. He’s a practical boy though and doesn’t believe in what he can’t see

Dd is 9 and still believes.

ocadodeliveroo · 25/10/2022 08:57

Mine is 3 and he already knows there is no Santa. I won't even try to convince him otherwise.

BattleOfPastings · 25/10/2022 08:56

Our eldest stopped believing at 6. Youngest still believes (4)

They’re told he brings the stockings only too.

Id have personally told them myself if they got to 9 without cottoning on

SBAM · 25/10/2022 08:55

I’ve never admitted to my mum that I knew the truth about Father Christmas and I’m 34.

For my children we leave a snack and drink by the fire and hang stockings, which get filled and left with one present ‘from Father Christmas’ on the hearth. They write him a letter suggesting something they’d like, but do get warned that Father Christmas might bring something different. Everything else is under the tree and labelled with who it comes from.

SkankingWombat · 25/10/2022 08:53

DD1 asked the question last year aged 7. I channelled my inner politician, avoided giving a proper answer and replied with lots of questions eg "But then who fills the stockings? They were still empty when I went to bed... 🤔 Who ate the carrot? It had giant tooth marks on it! It could have been the cat I suppose, but we all know what a vegetable dodger she is!". She seemed satisfied. The questions have already started this year. I went with the same tactic, but she'd obviously been mulling over solutions from last year's bounced-back questions and I think she knows TBH. I will continue to fein ignorance and let it become one of those things that once you realise, you join the 'wink wink' fun of pretending. DD2 is 6yo and a strong defender of belief in FC - I can't see that changing any time soon. She actively wants to believe in magic even when she knows it isn't real, whereas DD1 prefers bluntness, facts and truth (DD1 is definitely my child 😂).

We do stockings only from FC. That way credit for tree gifts is given as it should be, and there is no confusion why their best friend got more/less. I always pop something into the stocking they know I disapprove of (for DCs their age) to throw them off the scent of who really fills it eg mini real perfume, nail vanish, or the Harry Potter jelly beans that I had been refusing for months and saying were an absolute rip off and waste of money for the palty amount you get (it's true!).

HowVeryBizarre · 25/10/2022 08:50

We also did “he exists as long as you believe” with my three so I am not sure when they actually stopped believing but with ten years top to bottom our eldest was happy to keep the magic going for his younger siblings. We still do stockings for the two living at home (19 and 24) and a very tongue in cheek (large) glass of baileys and mince pie is left by the fireplace for Santa/mum. There was always a decent “ Santa present” as well as stockings when they were younger but it was clear that the main present/s came from mum and dad. I think we said Santa knows what you like so will bring you a surprise but your “Christmas list” is for us. It worked well tbh as there were never any unmet expectations. If we couldn’t find/couldn’t afford what they asked for we could say so.

AnnapurnaSanctuary · 25/10/2022 08:45

My DC1 believed until he was 11. We told him the summer before he started secondary school, as we were worried he might get teased. People on MN seem to think it's impossible for an 11yo to believe, but he definitely did!

I'm not quite sure about DC2 and DC3. I think they worked it out a bit sooner.

ChocolateCakeYum · 25/10/2022 08:41

My son has never believed. He’s 8.

We never really pushed the “Santa brings the presents” stuff tho. In our house Santa is only responsible for spreading Christmas cheer.

In general I think kids figure it out on they’re own and if they don’t so what. Personally I don’t understand the need to spoil it.

PAFMO · 25/10/2022 08:38

It just happened naturally. Never told her he existed, never told her he didn't. I think she was quite late (about 8) when she said "mum, I know all these presents are from you"

Burnt0utMum · 25/10/2022 08:38

I never said he was real or not, just let them make their own minds up. We've always liked the idea of Santa around Christmas but I think they've always known it was just for fun.

Benjaminsniddlegrass · 25/10/2022 08:37

DD6 still very much believes. In our house Father Christmas brings a stocking of small presents, the big presents under the tree come from us.

onmywayamarillo · 25/10/2022 08:37

My son who is 9 just worked out the tooth fairy is not real.. because I still have his older brothers first tooth.

Before he could think about Father Christmas I changed the subject and ran off 🤣

ParentallyUnprepared · 25/10/2022 08:37

Father Christmas brings the stocking.

The downstairs presents are from us (unless they're from friends or family). They usually get a "big" present then I wrap two or three others in white paper and make them look like a snowman.

No idea why I do that.

Divebar2021 · 25/10/2022 08:37

FC only brings stockings in our house which goes some way to explain why different children might receive very different quantities of presents.

Subnauctic · 25/10/2022 08:35

My eldest is 9YO and I'm not giving him the truth about Santa. He's a smart lad. He goes to school with a lot of non-Christians. I'm sure he's worked it out by now. But I'll be dammed if I tell him!