Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Santa doesn’t exist.

133 replies

Elf25 · 25/10/2022 08:25

When did your DCs stop believing in Santa and whilst they did believe what was your rhetoric about how Santa works? E.g. Santa brings presents but parents give him money etc..

I saw another related post and it made me wonder what people do..

I have an under 1 year end of so will be there soon

OP posts:
Laiste · 25/10/2022 09:34

4 DCs.

Our rule of thumb is that he stops coming once you get to secondary school age weather you still believe or not, because there just isn't room in his sack for toys for EVERYONE who believes in him.

My kids get skeptical at about 9ish, but the older ones have always kept the secret beautifully for the little ones Smile

FarmerRefuted · 25/10/2022 09:33

In our family, Santa doesn't buy or make the presents. The person buying the presents sends them away to Santa for safekeeping then Santa brings them back on Christmas Eve, sort of like a celestial Yodel driver. This stops the DC asking for anything ridiculous like a flying pony, helps to explain why some people get piles of presents and other people don't, and makes sure they thank the appropriate person rather than Santa.

We don't do stockings but Santa does leave them one gift, it's always something to share such as some board games or art supplies or cinema vouchers.

Eldest two DC know Santa isn't real. They asked if he was real and I asked "what do you think?", they said they thought he was real so I agreed and left it there. They each asked again, separately, and again I asked "what do you think?". They said they didn't think he was real so I confirmed it. I said that obviously we buy their presents, which they already knew, but we don't send then to Santa and that this is just a game to make Christmas seem magical for smaller children. I let them help put the presents out after the younger DC were asleep so that they could be involved in that side of it.

9yr old DC is questioning it this year, if they haven't worked it out before Christmas then I'm certain they'll work it out afterwards.

Unseelie · 25/10/2022 09:31

Age 1-3 you don’t really need to say anything apart from ‘it’s Christmas!’ And give a pile of toys 😂

Age 3+ I explained the Santa legend and that its a fun game the whole world plays but some people tell their kid its real so don’t tell them it isn’t as theirnparnts will be mad, just say nothing if the subject comes up.

Has avoided a lotta drama!

Rewis · 25/10/2022 09:26

@BattleOfPastings
😅 I fixed the auto correct 5 times on that message and still left it! Weirdly, I don't even have an account with them and yet they have invaded my phone. Might have to leave NatWest if they give me santa 🤶 🧑‍🎄

LillyBugg · 25/10/2022 09:25

Santa only fills stockings in our house so any requested gift needs to fit in there. Only one gift request.

My children know that we like to buy them their most sought after presents (if we can afford to) because we work hard to earn money to buy the present. I want them to know that their gifts come from people who love them very much. Santa doesn't get all the credit in our house, but brings just enough to keep the magic alive.

Although my eldest DS is 8, and I think this might be our last year.

Livetoplay · 25/10/2022 09:25

We never did the elaborate ploys of footsteps, or sleigh bell sounds, never did the ‘santa’s watching ‘ etc kept it pretty simple so they wouldn’t feel like twits when they found out!

Livetoplay · 25/10/2022 09:24

10 year old still 100% Santa, not a doubt! Told 12 year old at 11, they suspected but we confirmed so now older D.C. is in on it and still gets ‘Santa’ gifts or will until the little one stops believing.
So this is our last ‘proper’ Santa year as we’ll make sure the little one doesn’t go to high school believing in Santa!

Cryingbutstilltrying · 25/10/2022 09:23

We’ve never made a big deal out of Santa because my sil, who had kids first, insisted on doing the whole ‘Santa brings all the presents’ line to the point that even family gifts from grandparents were from Santa. No thank you, no appreciation for the time and effort we all went to. I found it rude. It was a while later thanks to mn that I realised how bad it would seem for those kids who had less at Xmas. So with my kids it was never mentioned. The surprise of what was in the stocking was enough, they knew it was me that did it, they knew who other gifts were from and thanked them. I think youngest ds said something about a friend believing in Santa when he was about 6, I said well people have different beliefs and traditions, that’s his, so let it be. It’s never been an issue for us.

edwinbear · 25/10/2022 09:23

Mine are 13 & 10, they're not stupid, of course they've worked it out. But when asked directly, I simply smile, and ask them if it's worth taking the risk of not believing. I've never been sat down by my parents and told 'the truth' and I'm 47!

AloysiusBear · 25/10/2022 09:22

Also i don't really like the kids asking for big specific stuff as it just leads to unrealistic expectations or disappointment. In our house, in your letter to FC you write that you've been good/kind, and ask him to fill your stocking. You don't demand bikes/nintendos/expensive crap.

MyneighbourisTotoro · 25/10/2022 09:21

Santa fills the stockings and brings one main gift.

L1ttledrummergirl · 25/10/2022 09:21

We always used generic wrapping paper for all of our gifts which were labelled from us and one that would be beautifully wrapped in father Christmas paper. It would have ribbons and bows so it stood out and the label would have a picture of Santa.
We would use swirling/ calligraphy writing that just said to first name,surname and leave the rest to their imagination.

Oysterbabe · 25/10/2022 09:20

Mine are 4 and 6 and believers.
In this house Father Christmas brings all the presents that we give them.
The presents from friends and family are from friends and family.
It's how mine and also DH's family did it.

40andfit · 25/10/2022 09:19

In our house he brings the stockings.

AloysiusBear · 25/10/2022 09:18

Father christmas fills stockings in our house, and it's not high value items, its more traditional - consumables.theres always raisins, an orange/satsuma, nuts, chocolate money, sugar mice, candy cane. Then its things like a card game, a book, some sort of craft item like glitter glue sticks or metallic pens, something noisy/musical (harmonic, duck whistle)a
then little funny bits like lego or playmobil figurines, some socks. One year i put inflatable globe balls in. Another year little torches.

Twizbe · 25/10/2022 09:17

My brother disproved him at the age of 3. His teacher had told his that Father Christmas flew through the air on his sleigh. My brother told my mum that it couldn't be true because there's no friction in the air for the reindeer to push against!

My 3 year old announced at dinner the other night that Father Christmas was just a story!

BattleOfPastings · 25/10/2022 09:16

Rewis · 25/10/2022 09:14

Well, where I'm from the santander actually comes over and distributes the presents (as in a neighbour or a hired dude comes over in a santa costume). I stopped believing around 6/7. My nephew1 at 7 and nephew2 at 11. But we stopped with the santander visits when nephew2 was around 7 and from then on santa left presents outside. The narrative has always kinda been ever since the kid is old enough to have any suspicion that parents buy the gifts and santa brings them.

What can that bank not do!

Rewis · 25/10/2022 09:14

Well, where I'm from the santander actually comes over and distributes the presents (as in a neighbour or a hired dude comes over in a santa costume). I stopped believing around 6/7. My nephew1 at 7 and nephew2 at 11. But we stopped with the santander visits when nephew2 was around 7 and from then on santa left presents outside. The narrative has always kinda been ever since the kid is old enough to have any suspicion that parents buy the gifts and santa brings them.

RoseBucket · 25/10/2022 09:13

I just told my daughter the story of St Nick, we had a lovely book written about him, so he is always still referred to, she is 18 😁 she knew I dropped the presents overnight in her room from about 9.

Mummysgonetobed · 25/10/2022 09:12

Three dc and for us Father Christmas brings the stocking and one thing they’ve asked for. Everything else from the people who actually bought it. I believe children need to say thank you for their presents - my friends dc think Santa brings everything and they never say thank you to anyone - really winds me up!

TeenDivided · 25/10/2022 09:12

DD1 was 8 with her first Christmas with us (adopted).
She came with a convoluted story as to how they moved a lot so Santa didn't used to find them Sad . Then 2 Christmases in foster care where they got masses of Santa presents.

So we rewrote the story - presents in foster care were to make up for the missed ones. Now stocking would be filled overnight and all big presents were from family. Keep it simple.

With DD1 & DD2 we never actually said stockings were from Santa we just talked about them being fllled. Culture filled in the rest. We told both towards the Easter of their y5 (starting with Easter Bunny that we had never done, and the very forgetful tooth fairy) so they were well prepared for Xmas in y6.

pumpkinelvis · 25/10/2022 09:10

My dc is 11 and hasn't said that she doesn't believe. I've said some things to her and her friends about 'Santa' to see their reaction but they acted as if they still believed!

Candyflosscrochet · 25/10/2022 09:10

In our house, santa/father Christmas looks after all the presents and can then decide if the kids have been good enough! This is of course backed up by the amount of presents that suddenly appear under the tree yet (because of mummies expert hiding skills) have never been found before then!!
You can keep the magic going longer that way as when they can read the labels, there is no suspicion raised!
I think it's unfair of parents who say the 'big' present is from santa....what if I can't afford the latest games console or ipad or fancy bike? Does my child then feel they haven't been good enough to deserve something like that?
My eldest was 9 when she found out from a friend amd was mortified and so upset....luckily she has younger siblings so can keep the magic going for them.

Abraxan · 25/10/2022 09:10

When dd was smaller (and now even though she's a young adult and doesn't actual believe but we play the Christmas game) Father Christmas only brought one gift. Not always the biggest or most expensive, but one she'd have been asking for, was best the top of her 'wish list' etc.

it arrived on Christmas morning all set up and ready to use or okay with, with evidence of some elf magic dust still there.

All other gifts came from me and Dh, and other family/friends.

The Christmas fairy delivered a Christmas Eve parcel each year (arranged by my mum) with new Pjs, a sweet treat and maybe a small other gift such as a film to watch, a book ti read or similar.

AlternativelyWired · 25/10/2022 09:08

He's real! Of course he's real, how dare you suggest otherwise. In our house he brings a gift that is asked for (ds7) and something he knows would be liked (everyone else). He brings us me big Lego sets if we've been especially good 😃 This year I'm hoping for the Home Alone Lego set. The adults buy the rest of the presents and he puts all the presents together on Christmas Eve and puts a small gift in stockings. The big (in size) presents from him go under the tree and are always wrapped in different paper.