Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Santa doesn’t exist.

133 replies

Elf25 · 25/10/2022 08:25

When did your DCs stop believing in Santa and whilst they did believe what was your rhetoric about how Santa works? E.g. Santa brings presents but parents give him money etc..

I saw another related post and it made me wonder what people do..

I have an under 1 year end of so will be there soon

OP posts:
FrankTheThunderbird · 25/10/2022 10:06

Father Christmas only brings stockings here with a handful of small things in. Always pants and socks for some reason.

DC are 18 and 16 and I've never explicitly told them he's not real. Mind you I'm 38 and my mum still says he's real :)
I think we talked about it once and I said if the magic of Christmas is alive then FC is real.

ahunf · 25/10/2022 10:06

inappropriateraspberry · 25/10/2022 09:49

For those who have all gifts from FC, how do you explain it when their friends have presents from parents, friends and family?

I think you're thinking too much. I never asked this and my kids 12 and 10 never did. They just assumed all from Santa.

Clymene · 25/10/2022 10:03

Stockings only here. Everyone gets them - adults and children so I guess they figured it out before secondary? I didn't do a big reveal.

It's definitely easier if you just say FC brings stockings because it helps when you can't afford whatever it is they ask for.

MRSE20 · 25/10/2022 10:02

I think I remember realising that santa didn’t exist around 9 years old… maybe 10. It was before secondary school for sure. I didn’t say anything because my sister was 6 and still very much believed. I had my feelings he didn’t exist when I noticed Santa had the same hand writing as my mum… I imagine something no child notices until they get a bit older 😂 and I heard my dad put my stocking on my door at midnight and pretended to be asleep…

I don’t want to get any hate for saying this but I think it’s best children know before secondary school. I do remember having a few kids in my class mortified when they felt like idiots that everyone else knew he wasn’t real

ahunf · 25/10/2022 10:02

I told my daughter when she was nearly 9 because her then 10 year old sister worked it out. She still tells me I shouldn't have told her the truth. I didn't want her going into y6 believing. I told her not to tell her friends.

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 25/10/2022 10:00

When the children were old enough we told them that the parents give santa money and that's why there sre differences between what children got in other families

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 25/10/2022 09:59

AnnapurnaSanctuary · 25/10/2022 08:45

My DC1 believed until he was 11. We told him the summer before he started secondary school, as we were worried he might get teased. People on MN seem to think it's impossible for an 11yo to believe, but he definitely did!

I'm not quite sure about DC2 and DC3. I think they worked it out a bit sooner.

Ds1 was still struggling at 16 😀

He said 'I know logically he can't exist but I don't know how else all the presents get in the house'

All mine believed into senior school but at some point they stopped

Although it's very much 'don't believe don't receive' in our house 😀

Elf25 · 25/10/2022 09:58

Abraxan · 25/10/2022 09:10

When dd was smaller (and now even though she's a young adult and doesn't actual believe but we play the Christmas game) Father Christmas only brought one gift. Not always the biggest or most expensive, but one she'd have been asking for, was best the top of her 'wish list' etc.

it arrived on Christmas morning all set up and ready to use or okay with, with evidence of some elf magic dust still there.

All other gifts came from me and Dh, and other family/friends.

The Christmas fairy delivered a Christmas Eve parcel each year (arranged by my mum) with new Pjs, a sweet treat and maybe a small other gift such as a film to watch, a book ti read or similar.

I never heard of Christmas Fairy. I love that idea - I’m from Europe the main day being Christmas Eve and DH is British so 25th. We will be doing 25th as Christmas but love the idea of also being able to do something on the 24th. Anyone else heard of Christmas Fairies? 😊

OP posts:
FabFitFifties · 25/10/2022 09:55

Posted too soon - admitted he doesn't believe, ans he still hammered the signs in and spread the reindeer food, on Xmas Eve. Santa brings everything, except one present from us, under tree. I stopped allowing relatives to say santa had left things at their house for him, as I wanted him to thank people personally. They were a bit miffed, but agreed.

SparkyBlue · 25/10/2022 09:53

feistymama75 · 25/10/2022 09:44

Father Christmas/Santa is a courier in my house. My kids are 24, 4 and due at end of next month. I've always just said we buy the presents, Santa collects them/are sent to Santa and then he delivers them.

Absolutely the same here. That's what my mum did. I'm in Ireland so when I was a child certain toys were often difficult to get. We'd see things on tv but they might have been easily got in the UK but often scarce here especially certain Barbie stuff (it's actually so strange thinking about it now) so my mum was always pragmatic in her approach to Santa and I've copied it. I absolutely love Christmas but I think the past few years the Santa thing seems to be getting bigger and some parents are almost hysterical about the need for "magic" and the obsession for children to believe in Santa even when they are past the age of believing. My eldest daughter is nine almost ten and she doesn't believe but of course she will still have lots of presents it won't change anything for her at all. It's still exciting finding gifts under the tree on Christmas morning regardless of who brought them no matter what age you are.

Tallulasdancingshoes · 25/10/2022 09:52

Ds is 10 and hasn’t said anything. I think he probably secretly knows. Dd is 7 and still fully believes. Father Christmas brings stockings and a few other presents. The rest of the presents they know come from family. I really hate it when all presents from supposed to be from Father Christmas, even ones from grandparents etc.

EstellaHanclay · 25/10/2022 09:52

We live in a small flat so there's no hanging stockings by the fireplace downstairs. Because there is no fireplace, or downstairs lol

Instead, Father Christmas leaves them a present each outside the front door (how would he get inside unnoticed in our creaky flat?)

Also, his mince pie, brandy, carrot and water station is outside so it makes sense.

FabFitFifties · 25/10/2022 09:51

DC and his friends still believed in year 5. If they didn't, they were doing a fabulous job of pulling the wool over their parents eyes. Year 6, mine started to say "yeah, yeah" and roll his eyes, when I spoke about Santa, but has never ad

inappropriateraspberry · 25/10/2022 09:49

For those who have all gifts from FC, how do you explain it when their friends have presents from parents, friends and family?

LT2 · 25/10/2022 09:48

I think i stopped believing at about 12. It helped that I had elder siblings who kept it going for me. We got most presents from him, some from mum and dad. Made it believable. I plan to do the same for my baby.

inappropriateraspberry · 25/10/2022 09:48

feistymama75 · 25/10/2022 09:44

Father Christmas/Santa is a courier in my house. My kids are 24, 4 and due at end of next month. I've always just said we buy the presents, Santa collects them/are sent to Santa and then he delivers them.

Isn't that a bit odd, and a lot of extra steps when you could just buy them and give them?
I've always thought it a strange explanation, and defeats the point of having Father Christmas in the first place.

Grumpybutfunny · 25/10/2022 09:44

DS is 8 and told us this year that Santa is us, don't think he really believed last year. All presents in this house came from Santa, the birthday fairy or the Easter bunny. This year is going to be strange we are still doing the elves tho find it so funny

feistymama75 · 25/10/2022 09:44

Father Christmas/Santa is a courier in my house. My kids are 24, 4 and due at end of next month. I've always just said we buy the presents, Santa collects them/are sent to Santa and then he delivers them.

SleeplessInEngland · 25/10/2022 09:43

Santa mysteriously being much more generous to rich kids is probably a hard but worthwhile life lesson. Society really does prefer rich people.

inappropriateraspberry · 25/10/2022 09:42

And to explain all the FCs you see in shops, school etc, he's very busy and needs people to help him. They all report back to him what the children have said, what they want and if they've been good!

Itisbetter · 25/10/2022 09:41

People who don’t believe don’t get stockings on the end of their beds … none of my children are fools.

inappropriateraspberry · 25/10/2022 09:41

Also, I never turned round and told my parents I didn't believe anymore. I think I was afraid I wouldn't get a stocking otherwise! It was just a given that as I got older, we were given our full stockings to take up to bed with us on Christmas Eve!

tingalayo · 25/10/2022 09:40

My DD is 4 and we do santa but we're never going to maintain any sort of pretence that he's real. We also say that her toy sea creatures go out for a swim when we're not in the house. But have told her that this is just a fun pretend game that we play. It'll be the same with santa.

inappropriateraspberry · 25/10/2022 09:39

Father Christmas brings stockings which are left on the end of the bed. These are smaller things, usually picked up cheap through the year.
All other gifts are from parents, friends and family.
No mention of money given to FC. They write a list, send a letter etc. We make it clear that they won't get everything on the list, and it won't all be from FC. It is also a list to help family and friends know what they would like.

I try to make sure there are one or two small things in the stockings that they have specifically asked for. FC and the elves make toys in the North Pole, and do copies of things they see in the shops.
We explain that FC has a lot of children to give presents to, so can't get all that they want every year, it has to spread across the whole world and FC chooses different children each year to sometimes get a bit more.
Mostly though, I just explain awkward questions away with 'Christmas magic!' 😆

Laiste · 25/10/2022 09:37

Oh, and we have the stocking presents which appear xmas eve, and are close as poss to what is on the list left out, and then family presents which are stored under the tree.

Santa uses different wrapping paper to us, obvs, and tends not to do labels Wink