Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Santa doesn’t exist.

133 replies

Elf25 · 25/10/2022 08:25

When did your DCs stop believing in Santa and whilst they did believe what was your rhetoric about how Santa works? E.g. Santa brings presents but parents give him money etc..

I saw another related post and it made me wonder what people do..

I have an under 1 year end of so will be there soon

OP posts:
emmsyg · 25/10/2022 16:37

Santa brings one requested gift here, and I add things in the stocking that are also 'from Santa'. My son is five now and he knows he gets to ask for one thing, and hasn't ever requested anything expensive (yet!). If he does, and we can afford to buy it, then I'll say that's from us, not from Santa - I always think it must be really unfair for kids whose parents don't have much money to think that Santa likes other kids more than them. If my son tells me that a kid in his class got an expensive gift from Santa, then I just say that their parents bought that because Santa doesn't do big gifts, working so far 😂

TeenDivided · 25/10/2022 16:31

Sunnyqueen · 25/10/2022 16:14

Older ones have stopped believing about 9/10.
Santa gets full credit, all the toys and stockings are from santa. Older ones go along with that for little one.
Relatives generally the nicer ones put from Santa and the dickheads put from themselves.

But WHY ??

Why would you want to deprive your DC from understanding that their relatives love them and want to give them presents?

It doesn't make Christmas any less 'magical' to have loving relatives give them presents? Why would you get in the way of relatives building bonds with your DC?

AuntieDickhead · 25/10/2022 16:25

Relatives generally the nicer ones put from Santa and the dickheads put from themselves.

Can't wait to label my niblings presents "From Auntie Dickhead" at Christmas. FFS. The presents I buy are from me, so they have my name on.

OTOH I needed a new name. So thanks for the inspiration.

PortalooSunset · 25/10/2022 16:25

Santa brings stocking presents only here, I'm not having the big guy getting credit for what I've spent my hard earned cash on! Though when I was growing up he was purely the delivery service iirc.
Dc are both old enough to know the truth, although there were a few years where they were suspicious but unwilling to admit in case they missed out 😂
Dh at the appropriate time told them something along the lines of this story: www.washingtonpost.com/news/inspired-life/wp/2016/12/19/the-story-behind-the-beautiful-way-this-mom-told-her-sons-the-truth-about-santa/
They were both happy with that, and with keeping the magic alive for younger ones.

Sunnyqueen · 25/10/2022 16:14

Older ones have stopped believing about 9/10.
Santa gets full credit, all the toys and stockings are from santa. Older ones go along with that for little one.
Relatives generally the nicer ones put from Santa and the dickheads put from themselves.

DontSpeakLatinInFrontOfTheBooks · 25/10/2022 16:07

Santa has never brought all the presents in our house- he brings the stockings and one not-massive present. He doesn’t bring the “big” present (game console/bike/dolls house).

Mine don’t believe anymore but play along which is very sweet of them as I like doing stockings for them and they like taking the piss out of how badly I wrap presents. I still wrap Santa presents in separate paper always with pictures of Santa on it as the big man is a massive narcissist.

mandi73 · 25/10/2022 15:59

Santa brings the presents but we send him money, sometimes Santa hasn't enough time to make ALL the toys so has to buy them so we help out by sending money. So the kids are aware that they can't have everything in the toy catalogue.

HollyPupp · 25/10/2022 15:56

FuzzyPuffling · 25/10/2022 15:30

Those people who do all their presents from Santa, do your children not ask "Why have Granny and Aunty Buggins and Mrs Neighbour and my friend Bert all given me a present and you haven't mummy?"

I just said Santa brings yours as you are such a good girl and I have to buy for nanny and grandad etc etc as they are adults now and santa doesn’t bring presents for adults.

FuzzyPuffling · 25/10/2022 15:30

Those people who do all their presents from Santa, do your children not ask "Why have Granny and Aunty Buggins and Mrs Neighbour and my friend Bert all given me a present and you haven't mummy?"

Snugglemonkey · 25/10/2022 15:19

inappropriateraspberry · 25/10/2022 09:49

For those who have all gifts from FC, how do you explain it when their friends have presents from parents, friends and family?

Very easily, all the gifts from friends family etc are still from those people in our house. I buy the Santa stuff.

Snugglemonkey · 25/10/2022 13:41

DS6 still believes, which I very much hope to keep going. Santa brings most gifts, the stocking and a toy sack. The tree presents are from family and friends. There is a present from mummy and daddy under the tree too, because he asked at 2 what we were buying him for Christmas and we thought he had a point. Last year he got his first nerf gun from Santa. He knows I hate guns and weapon toys, so there is no way he thinks that I buy everything!

Mommabear20 · 25/10/2022 12:36

We're teaching our DC that Santa fills our stockings with all the little bits and then we and other people buy them their big presents.

lanthanum · 25/10/2022 12:26

Livpool · 25/10/2022 11:56

That is an extreme reaction from your DH

Possibly. However there is a lot to be said for valuing truth over anything else.

reigatecastle · 25/10/2022 11:57

He definitely exists. I met him in Lapland when I was 18!

Livpool · 25/10/2022 11:56

lanthanum · 25/10/2022 11:02

DH was absolutely furious when he discovered that his parents had been lying to him, and vowed never to do that to his kids. So DD has never believed, but was happy to play along with the story at school. As far as I know, the only time she let slip was to a friend when they were about 9, but his mum reckoned he'd probably just about worked it out himself anyway, and wasn't bothered.

That is an extreme reaction from your DH

CaronPoivre · 25/10/2022 11:35

Santa has never existed in our House. He's father Christmas. He still comes to fill stocking in the early hours of Christmas morning. We can see when he's due to arrive on NORAD site, which is helpful.
It's a different magic as families grow and change, but magic nevertheless.

AddieLoggins2 · 25/10/2022 11:32

I think a lot can depend on how and when you find out about Santa. I remember believing in him, I knew he was real. It didn't cause me any long term trust issues finding out he wasn't! I would never want to deprive my children of that magic. The world is harsh and cruel and they'll find that out soon enough.

I found out when I was quite old, so I was already questioning it. I just needed someone to definitely confirm my thoughts. And it happened by accident - an older boy I knew said something, assuming I already knew. I remember being shocked, not that Santa wasn't real but that my friend had just said it so bluntly and matter-of-fact. I did feel nostalgic about the Christmases where I'd believed, but I was grateful I'd had them and had the memories of believing.

Even once I knew, I liked that the traditions of stocking/mince pie etc continued - the age I found out was a time that I was already finding to be a difficult transition period, I was always 'young' for my age if that makes sense and I was trying to balance still being a kid and wanting to do childish things with growing up and wanting to be accepted by peers. I felt that those traditions harked back to that more magical time when I did believe, and for one night I could still feel like a little kid again.

Even now I think if I could live one day of my life again I'd like to little on Christmas Eve again!

I have always tried to make Christmas and especially Christmas Eve feel as special for my children as it was for me, and Santa and his magic is a big part of that for us. Once they stop believing I will keep up our traditions and definitely be explaining that Santa represents the spirit of Christmas.

lanthanum · 25/10/2022 11:02

DH was absolutely furious when he discovered that his parents had been lying to him, and vowed never to do that to his kids. So DD has never believed, but was happy to play along with the story at school. As far as I know, the only time she let slip was to a friend when they were about 9, but his mum reckoned he'd probably just about worked it out himself anyway, and wasn't bothered.

Ponoka7 · 25/10/2022 10:41

Worldgonecrazy · 25/10/2022 08:34

I taught DD that Santa / Father Christmas was a representation of the spirit of Christmas, not a person.

it means that, even as an adult, I can state with hand on heart, Father Christmas is real.

That what I did with my children and it's sort of happened with my GC. The eldest is 7 and a thinker, she never really believed. Now we treat Santa as fun like Halloween/scary stories/fairytales. Her school is quite diverse and once other children put different points of view and life experiences to each other and questions start, I don't think that you should lie to them. We've had to share the experiences of the refugee children to stop racism. That does change outlooks. While we can create magic, the world isn't as magical for all.

MsJuniper · 25/10/2022 10:40

We have always done small/medium presents from FC (socks, annual, chocolate, Lego, game and at least one item I have vocally disapproved of from TV adverts). They leave out a drawstring bag and it is full in the morning to be opened when everyone is awake. Main present from us and relatives/friends presents from them under the tree (to be opened after lunch).

DS is 9 and he has had a couple of times of wavering in his belief due to school chat but has since doubled down and insists he has heard sleigh bells and that presents have appeared within a few seconds... so I don't know if we will end up having to tell him or it will just evolve. His little sister is at the perfect age to believe and enjoy it all so I am definitely happy for it all to continue for now.

notanotheroneagain · 25/10/2022 10:30

Don't know what you're on about OP.

Santa comes to our house every year. Takes a bite out of the mince pie, and sip from the sherry. Rudolph also takes a bite out of the carrots. We leave this out every year. Then he stuffs the DC named bags full of presents.

Duh...........🙄

Elf25 · 25/10/2022 10:20

Thanks MN. These are great. Some of them made me laugh, the Santander being definitely one.

And sorry, of course he exists 😁.

I do like the idea of stockings from FC and the other gifts under the tree from parents / family.

As some mentioned, I think it’s good to have a story line that keeps the magic going but also sets expectations (such as very expensive gifts will not always be delivered). Well, I do think that after it was pointed out. Never thought about that and probably would’ve gone all presents are from FC as that’s how it was when I grew up.

Thanks MN for the wisdom 🙂

OP posts:
Inasec24 · 25/10/2022 10:17

Well he does exist, I've met him several times.

We buy our kids presents for under the tree and a stocking but Father Christmas also brings them a gift each which he leaves in their room at the end of the bed when they go to sleep. That's the first thing they see and open.

Todaynotalways · 25/10/2022 10:15

DD figured it out at 5. Just as I did.

We were very keen to keep the magic alive, but DD is uncommonly logical (as I was).

Some kids are just more skeptical than others.

BeanCounterBabe · 25/10/2022 10:10

We always bought main presents. Santa brings smaller gifts, something on wish list about £20, selection pack, novelty socks, toiletries, stationery. Lots of items to unwrap for about £40. They never asked why Santa brought some friends a bike or laptop. I never confirmed or denied but we always left a cookie, mince pie and a glass of port just in case.