Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That Santa doesn’t exist.

133 replies

Elf25 · 25/10/2022 08:25

When did your DCs stop believing in Santa and whilst they did believe what was your rhetoric about how Santa works? E.g. Santa brings presents but parents give him money etc..

I saw another related post and it made me wonder what people do..

I have an under 1 year end of so will be there soon

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CombatBarbie · 25/10/2022 18:39

My kids have always been told to believe in the magic of Xmas not Santa per se. But we still done the whole santa thing.

BetsyBigNose · 25/10/2022 18:28

In our house stockings are laid out on the ends of beds on Christmas Eve, and FC comes and fills them with little gifts in the middle of the night. All other gifts are under the tree and are labelled from the sender.

Our DDs were around 8 or 9 before they stopped believing, although the elder was happy to keep pretending to believe until the youngest worked it out for themselves.

DDs are both teens now, but still lay out stockings for FC, however I no longer need to stay up ridiculously late to wait for them to fall asleep before filling them, as I'll just tap on their doors and say "Close your eyes and pretend to be asleep for a couple of minutes while FC makes his delivery!"

I'd keep the magic alive as long as your DC enjoy it, and as long as they know before starting senior school, as it seems to be a bit of a "thing" if a child still believes in FC when they start year 7 and can make them a bit of a target for teasing.

XmasElf10 · 25/10/2022 18:02

I never added a script. I just sometimes said “No Santa is not bringing you a battery powered ride on car and I’m not buying one either!” We also had a 3 gifts to put on your Santa list rule. Made it easier for me to get it right. Mini kid worked out he didn’t exist around aged 6 and I just agreed however we still fill stockings now she’s 11 - she just doesn’t write letters or leave out carrots anymore. We still talk about asking Santa for stuff, she just knows it’s me!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/10/2022 18:01

Santa/Father Christmas only brings little things in stockings, so you can’t ask him for anything big or expensive. (He doesn’t like greedy children.) Also he’s not strictly not allowed to bring puppies, kittens, any other animals, or real babies (a Gdd did once ask!) in case people don’t know how to look after them properly. Plus it’s much too cold for them on the sleigh.

Those are the rules that should be dinged in ASAP.

FilthyforFirth · 25/10/2022 17:58

FC brings the stockings and one present from their list. I make the eldest, youngest 2 in a few weeks) write a list to santa and tell him santa will bring him one thing and he wont know which one.

Everything else is under the tree from relatives. We get him a separate present from us.

LBFseBrom · 25/10/2022 17:53

I never taught mine about Santa though I said it was fun to pretend.

ghostyslovesheets · 25/10/2022 17:48

Father Christmas brings one big present and stocking fillers (IF you are good) mum buys all the rest

mine are 14/18/20 and still swear they believe! (for the stocking)

BettyOBarley · 25/10/2022 17:46

DD is almost 9 and I'm pretty sure she didn't believe by last Christmas but she still plays along and hasn't asked me outright.
Santa brings everything here. I don't like the idea of him only bringing stockings personally, but I really wish we had gone with us sending him the money or something as it's very hard to explain why they can't have that super expensive gift otherwise!

Fallstar · 25/10/2022 17:40

We never said that Father Christmas was real or that he wasn't when my now-adult DC were growing up.

The advantage to never confirming or denying was that it remained magical without them ever feeling lied to. They didn't ask whether it was the truth or not any more than they asked whether Thomas the Tank Engine was real. They just enjoyed it.

They always had a stocking 'from FC' but everything else was from us or whoever gave them gifts.

We all love Christmas and this worked for us. It never seemed to be an issue that their friends' families did it differently - I think children are keen to 'believe' in their own way, even after they suspect it's just a story.

Kimya · 25/10/2022 17:39

We have a mixture. Some are presents bought by us and sent to Santa to "check" and bring on Christmas Eve along with the presents from him.

She's only 5 and has never asked for anything particularly big. The most expensive present she's ever had was her bike and she knows that was from Gramps. She's not having a "main" present this year, there's nothing big she wants so we'll just go 50-50ish.

oakleaffy · 25/10/2022 17:35

The poor kids of substance abusers years ago who got nothing..
Even if a charity gave them presents, they would be sold by the parent/s

Extreme, but do these kids believe in Father Christmas?
Heartbreaking for them.

It was sad to witness.

inappropriateraspberry · 25/10/2022 17:26

Although a few years ago, I remember my mum giving my child a sack of gifts, saying the FC had left them at her house! I soon corrected it, and told my child they were from Grandma. It's something we've never done and not sure why she said it.
Both sets of grandparents give a sack of smaller gifts, which is fine. The sacks are homemade by the grandmothers and reused each year. Easy to put under the tree, but definitely from them not FC!

Darbs76 · 25/10/2022 17:26

Santa was merely the delivery guy in my house. He didn’t pay, that helped with expensive requests. Mine had all stopped believing before secondary, no 2 probably the earliest. I had to tell them before secondary as no way I’d have sent mine to secondary believing. Must admit since the last stopped believing 3-4yrs ago my life’s been easier. And no I don’t miss playing Santa!! Will have a break now before grandkids

inappropriateraspberry · 25/10/2022 17:23

@TeenDivided Agree completely, surely these children must wonder why others get gifts from family and friends and they don't. It doesn't encourage much goodwill if they're not expecting to give gifts to people they care about. Are the parents gifts all from FC as well then? Do the children not think about giving their own parents a gift?
What if they get presents from friends or family early or late? How are these explained? I'd hate to not have the credit for a gift I've given to a nephew. I probably wouldn't bother giving them anything.
A few small things in a stocking from FC, fine, but everything else is from the person who bought/made it.

Plexie · 25/10/2022 17:22

Learn from the recent thread by the parent of a 4 year old who is having to reset the child's expectations that Father Christmas will provide whatever the child asks for (in that case, something the parent can't afford).

Set the narrative early: either Father Christmas does the stocking presents, or you send him the money and therefore there's a limit as to the gift he will bring.

FuzzyPuffling · 25/10/2022 17:15

If Santa brings ALL the presents, to whom do your children write thank you notes/texts etc?

FuzzyPuffling · 25/10/2022 17:13

AuntieDickhead · 25/10/2022 16:25

Relatives generally the nicer ones put from Santa and the dickheads put from themselves.

Can't wait to label my niblings presents "From Auntie Dickhead" at Christmas. FFS. The presents I buy are from me, so they have my name on.

OTOH I needed a new name. So thanks for the inspiration.

Brilliant!

Blanketpolicy · 25/10/2022 17:00

ds is 18 now and I have never told him Santa is not real 🎅 (because he is!)

My biggest advice to anyone is to keep it simple and not stress over it. Anything you do you will need to remember to keep doing for years. Forget tying yourself in knots with lots of unnecessary details or addons such as the Elf, special wrapping paper, Santa delivering presents via granny etc, especially avoid anything that needs unnecessary collaboration from others.

Deny all knowledge of how the magic happens and let them make it up and work it out in their own amazing minds.

Second advice is never equate being naught or nice with Santa, if your child asks, again deny all knowledge and change the subject - "yes, I heard someone say that, but I've no idea, he came every year for me!"

IME keeping it simple does not distract from the magic in any way, if anything it lets it develop gradually as the child does.

gogohmm · 25/10/2022 17:00

Santa brings modest stockings (think socks, chocolate money, small toy) parents buy the big gifts under the tree.

Dd2 was 8 when she figured it out dd1 was 10 when dd2 told her in an argument

WellDunHun · 25/10/2022 16:55

Father Christmas brings everything that we buy, presents from family and friends are from them and go under the tree for Boxing Day or are exchanged whenever we see them over the festive period.
This is exactly what mine and DH's parents did. I hadn't realised anyone did anything different until DC1 started school, although I remember my best friend in primary got a stocking and I did not.
I can't ever remember believing in Father Christmas myself though, I saw the pillowcase being filled when I was just turned 5. My parents still don't know I did!

So I actually find doing the whole thing with my DC really odd.
I think this is our first year where everyone knows. I've been talking about buying the gifts and the cost etc and it hasn't been questioned so I presume they know.

ReneBumsWombats · 25/10/2022 16:48

Eldest is 7 and I think she knew last year although she didn't spoil it for us.

TeenDivided · 25/10/2022 16:46

it isn't the value of the present, it is that Auntie Bella cared in the gift giving season to want to choose something special. The child sees other gift giving going on in the family (and on TV) and yet doesn't get any from their own family? Do the DC not give gifts either? It also means the DC don't thank for their gifts which isn't good manners.

Each to their own, I think it's weird. But I know it is what some families do.

purser25 · 25/10/2022 16:42

Think it is best that stockings are from Santa and the rest actually from the people who send them why are you a dickhead for putting your name on a gift. It is also good that children appreciate that relatives and friends buy for them and they say thank you. Can never understand how a child still actually believes past the age of 10. Surely the logistics don’t make sense. As a child from quite a young age I gave people presents. Not sure what i actually gave and if they are wanted. I do remember making a shoe polishing pad for my Dad.

Sunnyqueen · 25/10/2022 16:40

TeenDivided · 25/10/2022 16:31

But WHY ??

Why would you want to deprive your DC from understanding that their relatives love them and want to give them presents?

It doesn't make Christmas any less 'magical' to have loving relatives give them presents? Why would you get in the way of relatives building bonds with your DC?

How is it getting in the way of building bonds?? Building bonds is not based on gift giving in my family, they build bonds through spending time together all year round. And they will realise when they are older where all their gifts came from. Just an observation on my life the kinder adults are willing to forsake the credit to max out the magic on christmas and santa. Its only a few years, they can get the credit when they are older and on birthdays. Doesnt bother me one bit to give Sants the credit and know they are experiencing the same level of joy I did when I was a child.

UWhatNow · 25/10/2022 16:40

Santa still comes to us and my DC are all fully functioning professional adults with partners.

Swipe left for the next trending thread