Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Been waiting 12hrs for an ambulance

332 replies

Riggsisadino · 25/10/2022 03:55

I know it's all in the news but ambulance wait times are ridiculous and I know it's mainly due to people in a&e not being moved onto a ward and ambulances not being able to move into a&e.
I am currently with someone with a dislocated hip and shoulder and we gave been waiting 12hrs. The pain is getting unbearable and I am struggling to reassure and calm and know what to do. They are saying that they have people in same catogory waiting longer to.
I feel bad for the person I'm with but can't help to think people who aren't sat inside or are on there own. I don't know what the answer is but something neeeds to change

OP posts:
Insertcreativenamehere · 26/10/2022 19:11

And because of dickheads who lie saying symptoms are worse (they know the key words to say to get the ambulance on a cat1) just so they get seen quickly!! Makes me f’ing mad. That’s one of the reasons why people who need one can’t get one….

DumpedByText · 26/10/2022 19:04

It's just shocking how bad things are, my mum waited 7 hours for an ambulance with oxygen levels of 65. She died 3 days later, the hospital were amazing but our NHS needs some serious help.

Mary54 · 26/10/2022 18:59

YANBU.
absolutely not a medical professional but from general knowledge I would be extremely concerned about patient losing feeling in their hand with a dislocated shoulder. Could indicate damage to nerves

Diamondsareforever123 · 26/10/2022 18:58

So sorry to hear about this. Blame the Tories! They have been underfunding the NHS since they got in 12 years ago. They don't care if people die waiting for ambulances. Give your friend painkillers. I'd call 111 too. I hope that all is OK.

Hurdling · 26/10/2022 18:32

It is the NHS, but the real problem is chronically underfunded social care, there is nowhere to discharge patients too if they can’t go home.

wooo69 · 26/10/2022 18:25

thebellagio · 25/10/2022 07:52

I completely agree. I live in an aging village. The big houses are filled with 90+ people living on their own who need carers 3 x a day. Like you, we have ambulances constantly to our next door neighbour. We have three developments taking place right now but none of them have any bungalows where these people could downsize and live independently at home in the village that they are used to and want to remain in

I’ve long said if the provision for downsizing/last home owners was given the same priority as FTB/affordable housing people would be able to live at home independent much longer, less risk of falls, if they end up in hospital for various reasons they can go back to their home rather than being stuck in hospital bed blocking because their home is unsuitable. It would free up a LOT of pressure on social services and the NHS but no one wants to admit it.

Where I live everything being built is targeted at the elderly population. Two large pubs and a car dealership site in about 5 or 6 miles all demolished and elderly housing being built.

each time planning is granted for a site you hear people saying “why more elderly accommodation, what about the youngsters”

AnnaMagnani · 26/10/2022 17:16

Loads of EU nationals. When my DM was in hospital pre Brexit almost all the staff were Spanish.

If even a few went home the hospital would have been struggling.

RosesAndHellebores · 26/10/2022 16:29

I'm listening @Alexandra2001. I've issued countless certificates of sponsorship since Brexit.

The last 12 months have coincided with labour shortages across the developed world. It won't be long before tens of people are chasing every vacancy again. People will follow the money. They always do.

I don't recall meeting many: French, Dutch, Swiss, German, Italian, Austrian, Belgian, Icelandic, Spanish, Greek, Polish, Hungarian, Bulgarian, etc., nationals working as nurses in the NHS during my 62 years. I wonder how many EEU Nationals were working as nurses in the UK pre Brexit. I know 20% of my institution's 1500 employees were EU nationals pre Brexit. 20% now have pre-settled or settled status. We supported them to get it.

Alexandra2001 · 26/10/2022 15:14

RosesAndHellebores · 26/10/2022 14:47

European nurses did not have to return to Europe because of Brexit. It was very easy to apply for pre-settled status. Post brexit it is much easier for employers to apply for a skilled worker visa wherever in the world they are from, including Europe.

EU nurses left the UK and applications completely dried up, it wasn't easy at all, my friend returned to Portugal because it was an awful process, then having her car vandalised was the final straw.

Brexit created an environment where EU workers felt unwelcome here, what was it T. May called them..... "Citizens of Nowhere" Farages..... "We are full" posters.

Leave campaign/DMail constantly saying.... "They are stealing our jobs.

Skilled Labour Visa's have min wages associated with them, plus restrictions on close family coming here, very expensive health insurances & the visa's aren't cheap either.

why would an Italian nurse come to the UK when he/she can go to Sweden of Germany and avoid all of the above, in a less stressful environment?

Maybe you should listen to industry bosses on labour shortages in the UK post Brexit? or better still, realise Bojo played you.

RosesAndHellebores · 26/10/2022 14:47

European nurses did not have to return to Europe because of Brexit. It was very easy to apply for pre-settled status. Post brexit it is much easier for employers to apply for a skilled worker visa wherever in the world they are from, including Europe.

FallSpringing · 26/10/2022 14:12

@Alexandra2001 Most of the countries outlined in that post would not be considered as 'developing'. I work in public health and academia, the simple truth is that many of them do. We've only recently moved towards all graduate entry for nurses here, and the entry requirements are frankly low. Of course there are some amazing nurses in this country, but I have sadly encountered many whom I wouldn't trust to nurse a budgie, let alone a relative.

Razu45 · 26/10/2022 12:46

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Yes yes and yes.

money is an issue undoubtedly
but with
a healthy dollop of people using a&e for very far from close to an emergency

ozloz · 26/10/2022 12:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Labraradabrador · 26/10/2022 12:42

@scaredoff you ignore my point that money is only part of the issue, which could be partially addressed by charging nominal fees at point of service.

and as to the assertion that 12 years ago everything worked just fine I call bs. I moved here in 08 from another EU country and soon thereafter faced a health emergency. Treatment was absolutely shambolic - I spent over a week in hospital too sick to be discharged but not sick enough to ever see the cardiologist or have basic tests arranged. Eventually I self discharged without ever seeing the cardiologist and arranged for some intermediary treatment privately while waiting 8 months to finally see that nhs cardiologist. It was terrifying and traumatic- I despair to think what it would be like now if that was the golden age.

PeachyIsThinking · 26/10/2022 12:26

I know oysters often unavoidable at present but be wary of advising people to take someone themselves, we took our son in (has an atypical
lain response) without knowing he had a leg fracture and had a lecture about the risks- quite correctly had we realised the severity!

The answers involve investing up the chain; make it so that people who choose to be family carers can be without facing the penury of a £69pw income; make paid carers a job that pays enough to survive and covers time travelling (as it used to be years ago when I did that job); give disabled kids edcafional
options that reduce their chances of needing social care… only focussing on the nd results brings constant chaos

ChuffKnows · 26/10/2022 11:23

Our local fire station used to have an emergency first responder car which the on-call firefighters manned. They went through all the training and were incredibly busy but then it just stopped after a year or so. Would be a good idea to bring it back with how things are currently.

Prokupatuscrakedatus · 26/10/2022 11:16

@BertieBotts
I would gladly pay more of my income towards healthcare, because carers and nurses definitely need and deserve more money.

There is a % of my income that goes into the 'elderly care coffer' (Pflegeversicherung). My late MIL's pension and the 'Pflegestufe' she was in payed for her place in a decent care home and the care needed.
We has a family only payed for her hairdresser and having her nails done.

In a previous post I explained my current costs of being treated for cancer.
After 6 weeks my employer no longer pays for me and instead health insurance steps in for the next 78 weeks with about 70% of my income (which counts as income towards my pension).

Rachie1973 · 26/10/2022 11:09

7Worfs · 25/10/2022 07:21

Unpopular opinion but what needs to be looked at first is living arrangements and support for the elderly.

I live in a street with many people in their 70s, 80s and 90s. Honestly there is an ambulance here at least once a week, often more. One house had an ambulance attend twice in the same day.

I’m not suggesting to rob the elderly of their independence, but we’ve got to be realistic that we live much longer now and it’s no longer the norm to live with/nearby family. They need some level of support that can’t be outsourced to the NHS.

In theory yes, in reality it won’t work.

I work in assisted living. We’re not allowed to help people up from the floor, we have to call an ambulance. So the same resources are still being used.

BertieBotts · 26/10/2022 11:00

I live in Germany, and if you have state health insurance, which is basically everyone earning under 100k, you do not pay at the point of service. Nothing at all. The only thing I've ever paid for is prescription medicines, which are often discounted but not free, and you can claim this back in a tax return if you can be bothered to keep the receipts. Also some extra tests in pregnancy, these were optional. (Similar happens in the UK). And there is a €10 fee for an ambulance but you get it in the post several weeks later, they don't turn up with a chip and pin machine Grin

If you have private health insurance then you do pay at the point of care but it gets fully reimbursed. Which if you're on a high income is no issue at all I imagine.

In fact in Germany I am more encouraged to visit my doctor with a cold as it is expected in order to get a sick note so that you are paid for your time off work. The sick note is required from the fourth consecutive day of illness, or the second day in some industries (including where I worked) if it is hard to get cover at short notice. The first time the secretary at work explained to me that I should visit my GP I was completely confused and disbelieving (Really?? You want me to go to the GP with a cold??) and she got a bit exasperated with me but it is absolutely expected here. The employer is also strictly forbidden from phoning you and asking you to come back before the date that the doctor states, and if you want/need more time you simply go back to the doctor and if they agree they will extend the sick note.

I really like the way the German health system works but it is more expensive per head than the NHS. And I have absolutely no clue how social care works, but that must be different as well because we don't seem to have these backlogs caused by insufficient elderly care places, even though Germany also has an ageing population.

scaredoff · 26/10/2022 10:44

SnackSizeRaisin · 25/10/2022 20:03

Completely disagree with this. Things were hugely better under the last labour government. I don't know why so many people believe this myth that the NHS has to be crap and the problems are not solvable. It's not a coincidence that the NHS has declined in line with years of austerity and cuts!

I don't know if anyone does really believe it, to be honest. It's so completely counter-factual. I think Tories just say it anyway to avoid admitting the obvious connection between government policy and the state of the health system.

scaredoff · 26/10/2022 10:42

germany and the us (not sure about France) require some payment at point of care. This serves dual function of generating revenue, but also more importantly decreasing demand. Even a nominal sum would encourage the ‘my cold hasn’t cleared in 5 days’ crowd to think twice before seeking care.

Which completely ignores my point that those countries ALSO simply spend more on healthcare (in the case of the US, a LOT more). So what makes you think it's the blocking out of this troublesome "crowd" you assert exists that is responsible for the better outcomes (for the wealthiest only, in the case of the US), and not simply the additional money?

I am American, and I know the US system gets vilified here, but ironically stories from the UK are a big part of why your average American wants nothing to do with socialised healthcare. I am terrified of getting sick here. In the US a health emergency might cost me more personally, but I would get an ambulance in less than 15 mins, emergency treatment within the hour, and cancer screening within a week.

You would have had all those things in the NHS between 2000 - 2010 too. The difference is that everyone else would have had them as well.

Nurselle30 · 26/10/2022 10:41

Our government have broken and fragmented the NHS into the shambolic service we see today.
They got rid of bursaries for NHS students, charge thousands for training, don't put money where it is needed and pay low wages.
The result is no staff due to problems with recruitment & retention, no resources and additional pressures such as fewer ambulances on the road.
Furthermore the amount of management and unecessary job roles there are within the NHS swallows money that could be used for front line services.
Our NHS could be wonderful, indeed the concept is wonderful it's just it's been creamed off, ripped off and sold off by the Government, who are the same people that like to flag it's failings up.
It's really simple - if you can afford private healthcare go pay for it, leave it for those who can't.
The general public also need to realise that whilst it is 'free' to use if you don't use the right service at the right time then we aren't going to have a NHS for very much longer!

#sadNHSnurse😔

Runningwithoutstopping · 26/10/2022 08:22

I know that there huge gaps in the NHS system I'm well aware that there is a postcode lottery and people have had awful experiences accessing care.
When people speak about the excellent American system for acute care they never mention the people who are suffering because they have no access to management for a chronic condition .
I read yesterday about a young woman being denied acute rehab after a stroke because insurance deemed it unnecessary. I've heard about children who are denied drugs to manage seizure conditions because treatment would be long term and expensive.
I have a long term condition (IBD) which is a miserable and painful, when it flares I'm severely affected by it and unable to manage my life. Under the NHS I have been able to have medication and treatment that has been life changing for me. All that has been free my life would of been very different if I had to pay

NancyBellaDonna · 26/10/2022 08:06

The NHS and Social care are in this mess because they have deliberately been underfunded by this vile Tory government so that the system breaks down and fails. Thus enabling them to privatise it. US care here we come!
I am so sorry for all those people suffering and the staff too.

General election now!

Alexandra2001 · 26/10/2022 08:02

That wouldn't be a bad thing. I think the standard of training for nurses in this country is very poor compared to other countries

UK nurses are not badly trained at all, 3 years of education plus 1000's of hours of placements mean they get some of the best training in the world.

...that is why UK nurses can walk out of the NHS and with no additional training earn far more in pretty much any English speaking country in the world.... my DD was offered work in Australia whilst still at Uni.

The challenges of using overseas nurses with poor understanding/use of drugs and language are huge & take up a heck of a lot of time to fix.

Rather shameful you think its ok for a developed country to take healthcare workers from developing countries that need them for themselves