Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Been waiting 12hrs for an ambulance

332 replies

Riggsisadino · 25/10/2022 03:55

I know it's all in the news but ambulance wait times are ridiculous and I know it's mainly due to people in a&e not being moved onto a ward and ambulances not being able to move into a&e.
I am currently with someone with a dislocated hip and shoulder and we gave been waiting 12hrs. The pain is getting unbearable and I am struggling to reassure and calm and know what to do. They are saying that they have people in same catogory waiting longer to.
I feel bad for the person I'm with but can't help to think people who aren't sat inside or are on there own. I don't know what the answer is but something neeeds to change

OP posts:
Wombat100 · 25/10/2022 09:49

One factor is definitely that people with non major issues use ambulances as a taxi service.

I’m no medic but it seems clear that if you have a dislocated shoulder and hip then you need an ambulance. However, a lot of people could (and should) be put in the back of a car and taken to a&e instead.

HotCoffee22 · 25/10/2022 09:49

Hoowhoowho · 25/10/2022 09:08

People who think it’s about organisation not funding forget that shortly after the Tories came in, the NHS was rated the best health system in the world for efficiency, ie number of deaths for money spent.

12 years on what’s happened?

minimal pay rises for staff, so staff are leaving the professions in droves. Many newly qualified professionals who now pay thousands to train just never even start the job. They realise they’d earn more elsewhere. 12 years ago the gap between my husband’s pay (non NHS) and mine (NHS) was less than £10000. He’s had inflation linked pay rises. He now earns £35000 more than me.

Brexit- Brexit is probably an even bigger factor than above. EU citizens not only staffed the health service but perhaps more importantly they staffed social care services. Without this workforce, the NHS and social care are both fucked. Frankly if you voted for Brexit you chose this.

The Baby boom generation have all hit retirement thus tax income has reduced and the need for health and social care is every rising. This was never well planned for and it combined with Brexit is resulting in a perfect storm

The answer is
either free migration and that is free migration of ‘unskilled’ workers who staff social care as well as health care professionals

or an extreme rise in wages for health and social care professionals so these jobs (which are after all messy, sometimes dangerous and involve anti social hours) are attractive to our own workers. Effectively starve the private sector of a workforce. We already subsidise vast numbers of these low wage workers with in work benefits so the actual cost of a wage rise would likely be evened out as benefits are a costly way to support people.

Personally I think migration is the answer although it suppresses wages because this is a short term problem, over the next 20 years, the bulge generation will die off releasing vast amounts of money and property into the economy and there will be a natural rebalancing. Off all the times for Brexit, we chose the worst.

This is really insightful, thank you.

My only query would be in respect of your last paragraph? Won’t there always be a supply of old folk?

walkinginsunshinekat · 25/10/2022 09:48

BigWoollyJumpers · 25/10/2022 09:15

Domiciliary care ( the majority of which is private ) is in crisis , not enough staff, so very difficult to provide appropriate or safe care packages, and too few beds, especially the short term rehab/step down type

I'm old enough to remember cottage hospitals.
I can't remember who or when, but the decision was taken to close them all down as it was more cost efficient/better medical care to have them all relocated to central hospitals.
That has backfired as most of these elderly don't need continuing medical care, they need rehabilitation and support.
There is one left locally, classified as a community frailty unit, it's excellent because they have all the specialists for elderly care in one spot, have some in-patient beds, and also all the support for dementia, falls, etc etc

The smaller community hospitals down here have been closed/reduced hours, not due to lack of money but lack of staff, inc the one my mum was in for many weeks in 2016, shut as a hospital, open between 0800 and 1800 now, no beds.

Whether people who voted for Brexit like it or not, the fact is many EU HCP left the UK & that is why we are now seeing the crisis in health.

So now we have Care workers/ nurses leaving the sector to work in higher paid non health roles.

We do not have enough people coming into the labour market to fill these jobs now - hence all the rush to get HCP's from SE Asia and adding care workers to the essential visa list.

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 25/10/2022 09:42

TheSilentPicnic · 25/10/2022 09:32

Can someone please explain to me what has caused this situation?

Chronic underinvestment in health and social care causing a structural issue in getting people the care that they need in the appropriate environment.

Failure to ensure safe working environments and appropriate levels of pay.

The goodwill has run out. They’re chronically understaffed and the staff they have are burning out.

NCnurse · 25/10/2022 09:41

@Hoowhoowho couldnt agree more. I’m an overseas nurse and completely gobsmacked by what I’ve seen and experienced here in the NHS. Pitiable pay and a workforce heavily dependent on foreigners. I worked ICU during Covid and saw nearly no British nurses. Irish, Australian, Spanish, Portugese, Kenyan, Nigerian, Philipino, US, Canadian, Kiwis, Indian, and a very small handful of UK born nurses. (I’m in central London, perhaps more diverse here than elsewhere?)

And so in response to Brexit, there is now massive drive to bring nurses from the Philippines and India as EU nurses have left in droves. Many of the Uk staff I have met who continue to work in the NHS are somehow subsidised: they have lived in council housing for years and so have lower monthly outgoings, live with family, or themselves have inherited wealth. For many others it’s utterly impossible to get by on the wages offered. It’s shameful that the system depends so heavily on the goodwill of its staff. What I’ve seen recently (post covid) me nervous about having access to safe care, there are just too many gaps these days. It’s beyond unfortunate.

RosaGallica · 25/10/2022 09:32

7Worfs · 25/10/2022 07:21

Unpopular opinion but what needs to be looked at first is living arrangements and support for the elderly.

I live in a street with many people in their 70s, 80s and 90s. Honestly there is an ambulance here at least once a week, often more. One house had an ambulance attend twice in the same day.

I’m not suggesting to rob the elderly of their independence, but we’ve got to be realistic that we live much longer now and it’s no longer the norm to live with/nearby family. They need some level of support that can’t be outsourced to the NHS.

My gran spent the last years of her life living on a supported estate. It was all bungalows, all with emergency help cords throughout, that went through to an employed team of wardens who did regular patrols too. That’s what’s needed. No idea about costs.

TheSilentPicnic · 25/10/2022 09:32

Can someone please explain to me what has caused this situation?

pumpkinelvis · 25/10/2022 09:31

I hope your friend has been sorted. Just wondered if you could've phoned the OOH doctor in this case to get some stronger pain relief?

Mistletoewench · 25/10/2022 09:30

mrshoho · 25/10/2022 09:14

In our area there was a decision going back many years whereby one major hospital became a super a&e. It is huge and covers a large area. All other local a&e units were then closed one by one. These would previously have been used for injuries such as in the OP. Many people at the time said having only one a&e would not work and it doesn't. We now have this 'Super' a&e that cannot cope with the numbers needing treatment. People with initially non lifethreatening injuries are being harmed because of the delay in getting treatment.

Same ! Our local A&E was closed down about 10 years ago. We now have a larger A&E in another town, which is always packed.
my husband had the situation recently that he had to go behind the scenes at this A&E, he said it was like a war zone, corridors just full of old people on trolleys waiting for beds, he was really shocked.

Steve Baker MP I will never forgive you for closing our local A&E and you will never get my vote.

BigWoollyJumpers · 25/10/2022 09:27

MissyB1 · 25/10/2022 09:17

Oh yes they did this in our County too. It’s a cost cutting thing, their budgets are so squeezed you can see how the idea was attractive. It also often happens because of lack of staff, easier to staff one hospital. Understandable from that point of view but doesn’t actually work for the patients!

To be fair, the additional rational is that these larger hospitals have concentrated care and expertise that the smaller a&e's could never achieve. It makes sense to have and a&e excellent in stroke care or stab wounds, if they see hundreds a year rather than only one or two. Extreme scenario for effect, but you know what I mean. Again locally, if you have a heart attack you are sent to hospital x, if you have a stroke, you are sent to hospital y. Although this is, of course, not generally available in more rural/isolate communities.

allflownthenest · 25/10/2022 09:25

My DB waited 9 hours for an ambulance to take him to A&E, shocking wait times all round

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 25/10/2022 09:23

ChagSameachDoreen · 25/10/2022 08:05

Get the poor sod into a car or taxi, FFS! Momentary pain is better than languishing for hours and hours.

It's just not like that with dislocated joints.

MissyB1 · 25/10/2022 09:17

mrshoho · 25/10/2022 09:14

In our area there was a decision going back many years whereby one major hospital became a super a&e. It is huge and covers a large area. All other local a&e units were then closed one by one. These would previously have been used for injuries such as in the OP. Many people at the time said having only one a&e would not work and it doesn't. We now have this 'Super' a&e that cannot cope with the numbers needing treatment. People with initially non lifethreatening injuries are being harmed because of the delay in getting treatment.

Oh yes they did this in our County too. It’s a cost cutting thing, their budgets are so squeezed you can see how the idea was attractive. It also often happens because of lack of staff, easier to staff one hospital. Understandable from that point of view but doesn’t actually work for the patients!

Laiste · 25/10/2022 09:16

A friend of my DHs (early 40s) took an overdose at the weekend. He then panicked and rang for an ambulance.

The ambulance took 4.5 hours to arrive. They were too late.
Sad

RosesAndHellebores · 25/10/2022 09:16

@Ekaterina my post came across as entitled. But the present NHS situation cannot continue to prevail. Healthcare in France, Germany, Austria, Ireland, Channel Islands, etc. All works much better. We need a system of social I durance as much of the Continent has. There seems to have arisen a culture of downright rudeness and jobsworthness in our NHS clinical/medical provision. I only use the bits that my insurance doesn't cover; sometimes my GP persuades me to use the NHS for things that are covered. It's always disorganised and sloppy.

My local NHS MH Trust was given 2.3m (CAMHS). They spent it on a tier of additional bureaucracy that sunk the system further. It really isn't all about monet- it's about money and resources being used in a sensible way.

BigWoollyJumpers · 25/10/2022 09:15

Domiciliary care ( the majority of which is private ) is in crisis , not enough staff, so very difficult to provide appropriate or safe care packages, and too few beds, especially the short term rehab/step down type

I'm old enough to remember cottage hospitals.
I can't remember who or when, but the decision was taken to close them all down as it was more cost efficient/better medical care to have them all relocated to central hospitals.
That has backfired as most of these elderly don't need continuing medical care, they need rehabilitation and support.
There is one left locally, classified as a community frailty unit, it's excellent because they have all the specialists for elderly care in one spot, have some in-patient beds, and also all the support for dementia, falls, etc etc

mrshoho · 25/10/2022 09:14

In our area there was a decision going back many years whereby one major hospital became a super a&e. It is huge and covers a large area. All other local a&e units were then closed one by one. These would previously have been used for injuries such as in the OP. Many people at the time said having only one a&e would not work and it doesn't. We now have this 'Super' a&e that cannot cope with the numbers needing treatment. People with initially non lifethreatening injuries are being harmed because of the delay in getting treatment.

MissyB1 · 25/10/2022 09:14

Hoowhoowho · 25/10/2022 09:08

People who think it’s about organisation not funding forget that shortly after the Tories came in, the NHS was rated the best health system in the world for efficiency, ie number of deaths for money spent.

12 years on what’s happened?

minimal pay rises for staff, so staff are leaving the professions in droves. Many newly qualified professionals who now pay thousands to train just never even start the job. They realise they’d earn more elsewhere. 12 years ago the gap between my husband’s pay (non NHS) and mine (NHS) was less than £10000. He’s had inflation linked pay rises. He now earns £35000 more than me.

Brexit- Brexit is probably an even bigger factor than above. EU citizens not only staffed the health service but perhaps more importantly they staffed social care services. Without this workforce, the NHS and social care are both fucked. Frankly if you voted for Brexit you chose this.

The Baby boom generation have all hit retirement thus tax income has reduced and the need for health and social care is every rising. This was never well planned for and it combined with Brexit is resulting in a perfect storm

The answer is
either free migration and that is free migration of ‘unskilled’ workers who staff social care as well as health care professionals

or an extreme rise in wages for health and social care professionals so these jobs (which are after all messy, sometimes dangerous and involve anti social hours) are attractive to our own workers. Effectively starve the private sector of a workforce. We already subsidise vast numbers of these low wage workers with in work benefits so the actual cost of a wage rise would likely be evened out as benefits are a costly way to support people.

Personally I think migration is the answer although it suppresses wages because this is a short term problem, over the next 20 years, the bulge generation will die off releasing vast amounts of money and property into the economy and there will be a natural rebalancing. Off all the times for Brexit, we chose the worst.

Amen to all of this! 👆

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 25/10/2022 09:13

ChagSameachDoreen · 25/10/2022 08:05

Get the poor sod into a car or taxi, FFS! Momentary pain is better than languishing for hours and hours.

I take it you've never dislocated a hip and a shoulder?

Mischance · 25/10/2022 09:13

Now that social care has been privatised, people get stuck in hospital beds more. Care agencies and homes need to make a profit under this system, so they establish their protocols, staff pay and fees to reflect this.

This has a knock-on effect on the NHS as people with nowhere to go stay in hospital at massive expense to the service.

Sadly the privatisation of care services also results in poorer care, as staff do not get the support and training they require, and as used to happen when local authorities ran these services.

When you have governments wedded to narrow political dogmas this is what you get. And not just NHS - transport and education too.

Wiluli · 25/10/2022 09:10

Dislocated bones than press on blood supply and lead to amputation . This should be considered an emergency . Make sure if they suffer long term damage they look into their legal rights . This so clinical neglect at its best .

Hoowhoowho · 25/10/2022 09:08

People who think it’s about organisation not funding forget that shortly after the Tories came in, the NHS was rated the best health system in the world for efficiency, ie number of deaths for money spent.

12 years on what’s happened?

minimal pay rises for staff, so staff are leaving the professions in droves. Many newly qualified professionals who now pay thousands to train just never even start the job. They realise they’d earn more elsewhere. 12 years ago the gap between my husband’s pay (non NHS) and mine (NHS) was less than £10000. He’s had inflation linked pay rises. He now earns £35000 more than me.

Brexit- Brexit is probably an even bigger factor than above. EU citizens not only staffed the health service but perhaps more importantly they staffed social care services. Without this workforce, the NHS and social care are both fucked. Frankly if you voted for Brexit you chose this.

The Baby boom generation have all hit retirement thus tax income has reduced and the need for health and social care is every rising. This was never well planned for and it combined with Brexit is resulting in a perfect storm

The answer is
either free migration and that is free migration of ‘unskilled’ workers who staff social care as well as health care professionals

or an extreme rise in wages for health and social care professionals so these jobs (which are after all messy, sometimes dangerous and involve anti social hours) are attractive to our own workers. Effectively starve the private sector of a workforce. We already subsidise vast numbers of these low wage workers with in work benefits so the actual cost of a wage rise would likely be evened out as benefits are a costly way to support people.

Personally I think migration is the answer although it suppresses wages because this is a short term problem, over the next 20 years, the bulge generation will die off releasing vast amounts of money and property into the economy and there will be a natural rebalancing. Off all the times for Brexit, we chose the worst.

HotCoffee22 · 25/10/2022 09:04

40andfit · 25/10/2022 09:03

I recently rang for an ambulance with a 2 year old with breathing difficulties. I was told she needed an ambulance immediately but they didn’t have one and to drive to hospital by myself with her while simultaneously keeping her awake and monitoring her breathing. I had to stop several times to wake her up. It was terrifying.

That’s sound absolutely awful. It’s terrifying when you think the emergency services aren’t actually there anymore. You have this notion that you dial 999 and help with arrive. More and more I’m realising it won’t and I fear the cost is human life. It’s a terrifying time to have young, vulnerable children.

donttellmehesalive · 25/10/2022 09:04

40andfit · 25/10/2022 09:03

I recently rang for an ambulance with a 2 year old with breathing difficulties. I was told she needed an ambulance immediately but they didn’t have one and to drive to hospital by myself with her while simultaneously keeping her awake and monitoring her breathing. I had to stop several times to wake her up. It was terrifying.

What was the outcome?

donttellmehesalive · 25/10/2022 09:03

Social care is the biggest issue as many pp have said. A family member works in a private care home. They cannot recruit or retain staff for the wages they pay and are operating at increasingly dangerous ratios or paying agency staff much higher hourly rates. Families want staff to be paid more but do not want to pay more.