Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

sick of ‘gentle parents’

329 replies

strawberrysugar23 · 24/10/2022 15:18

i’m so fed up of gentle parenting - just been to soft play and a boy probably about 4 years old was whacking my 18 month old, pushing her down, kicked her in the face. obviously i kept intervening and actually told him off myself but his parent was nowhere to be seen. once i’d told him off he moved onto a different toddler whose mum approached me and asked if i knew who his parent was. said parent eventually came over and said ‘aw is he being rough?’ i said yes he’s being very aggressive to multiple toddlers, has hit/kicked/pushed and keeps following them around even after other parents are intervening. and her response was ‘ohh (child’s name) you need to be more gentle!’ in a soft voice then walked off and he continued.

sorry but wtf. if your child is as feral as that surely you say right we’re leaving and actually tell them off instead of that response? seems to be a common occurrence too, always seems to be the most aggressive kids who are being gentle parented

OP posts:
quirkychick · 27/10/2022 20:20

I see plenty of 'gentle parenting' with lots of overtalking and ineffectual reactions here. I didn't see much when I taught early years in inner city London! We spent a lot of time helping the children process their emotions in acceptable ways. Small children can hit, bite, grab but need to be taught things like "I don't like that", "I feel sad", "stop", "can I have" etc. Although, it is a whole other thing when it's your own child.

BertieBotts · 27/10/2022 19:00

Math that is definitely why it appealed to me, although also why I don't use it any more.

Lola exactly 100% this. The emotion thing was a bit of a game changer for me actually, because I was aware that all the "stop crying, babies cry" wasn't what I wanted to do, and I had taken on from How To Talk that saying things like "Oh but you do love your sister really!" is dismissive, but I hadn't made the jump that actually even a lot of things that seemed gentle and supportive to me were my discomfort with my child having a negative experience or feeling upset and even though I thought I was dealing with it sensibly, I was trying to fix it, a lot of the time. And now I see it I can't unsee it. You see parents struggling with boundaries because they think from some gentle parenting resources that the child is supposed to be happy and willing at all times without any conflict or disagreement at all which just isn't realistic.

Noodles1234 · 27/10/2022 17:51

I have also seen this quite a few times, I think they’d rather not have to deal with it and hope another parent does, that or oblivious! I intervene as much as it feels uncomfortable as not my child, more the safety of my own. Seen parents leave birthday parties - always the ones you wish stayed to monitor their own kids.

I have been totally put off certain soft play places, also on another side saw two Dads get on toddler sit on ride toys and go down a big kids slide in a soft play arena (term time so advertised for all kids 4 or under), small kids in ball pool at end of slide and Dads crashing in at high speed. Staff looked on, carnage! Then you have to speak to parents. However on the whole most kids and parents are good x

CoveredInCobwebs · 27/10/2022 17:41

@LolaSmiles Great posts. I always liked Janet Lansbury for this - no guilt for the parent in imposing boundaries, no shame for the child in not liking them.

@mathanxiety Nobody is claiming that gently parented kids, or indeed any kids, or indeed any humans - are perfect - though the best behaved kids I know are the ones who are gently parented well - and by that I mean have parents who hold boundaries but do it respectfully. That is basically what it comes down to.

It’s not about there being a ‘pure form’ but about the fact that parents who allow their kids to carry on with the types of antisocial behaviour described here are basically falling into the permissive camp, whether they think it or not, and this is not something that gentle parenting advocates, if you actually read the books.

That said I absolutely agree that there are parents who see ‘not gentle’ parenting as abusive, and perhaps those are the ones who struggle with setting/holding boundaries. I was reflecting on the US thing earlier as I remember I used to be in a US centric FB group when my oldest was very small and I had to leave it because of the number of parents who were encouraging each other to basically ignore boundary setting in favour of not inhibiting their child’s spirit, or saying that it was developmentally appropriate for kindergarteners to still be hitting, and so on. I’d forgotten about that until this afternoon. Again, I really don’t witness this kind of parenting first hand where I live: the badly behaved kids here are always the ones who are being ignored by parents but get the promise of a good smack once the parents cotton on to what’s going on.

mathanxiety · 27/10/2022 17:04

@BertieBotts

Excellent post at 9:33.

Parents who are doggedly insisting they are doing 'gentle parenting' are essentially identifying very strongly with what they're 'not'..

They're not neglectful or abusive. The term gentle parenting appeals to something inside them.

There are strands of emotion rather than the one pure, scientific dogma to it that some are claiming here. The parents who are seen comforting a child who has destroyed everyone else's sand castles and is upset that he has been rebuked by the other children are apparently doing it all wrong, and there really exists some pure form of gentle parenting where the result is perfectly adjusted children who somehow manage to feel empathy, restrain their impulses, and behave like considerate little ladies and gentlemen, despite never being told that they are annoying the pants off everyone, or experiencing a top down reprimand or consequence. It's a fairy tale really.

It comes straight out of Positive Psychology, where you smile your way through adversity (in fact, as critic Barbara Ehrenreich points out, the logic of positive psychology means if you dont stay positive you risk doom) and just firm belief in your children's innate goodness will succeed in bringing that out and shutting away the rest of their nature. It has nothing to do with Authoritative parenting, which tends not to leave moral development to chance.

Untitledsquatboulder · 27/10/2022 15:50

Badnewsoracle · 27/10/2022 12:52

To echo others - that's not gentle parenting. That's permissive and ineffective parenting.

I practice gentle parenting and in that situation, I'd have removed my 4 year old, sat in the cafe area with him and had a conversation about hurting others, the feelings of the child being hurt and the reasons why DS felt the need to do what he was doing. Recognizing and identifying my son's reasons for his behaviour and helping him find other ways to manage those emotions. If he did it again, either to your child or another, we'd leave immediately.

So basically you give your ds 1 free hit per play session?

LolaSmiles · 27/10/2022 15:17

Mylittlesandwich
Completely agree with you.

It's fine to feel angry. It's not ok to hit.
It's fine to feel frustrated when you'd like a turn. It's not ok to push/shove/snatch the toy.

The thing I've taken from some of the gentle/respectfully authoritative groups and reading is how important it is for adults to examine why childhood behaviours can be a trigger for them. It seems like an awful lot of adults are very uncomfortable with children expressing a range of feelings so feel the need to either shut it down by being authoritarian/sanctioning any expression of certain feelings or shut it down by being permissive/pandering to whatever the child demands in order to make the feelings go away.

A lot of people seem to hold children to a much higher standard than adults. Adults expect other adults to be respectful to them and not to shout or be an arsehole when something is upsetting them, whilst plenty of them think nothing of shouting at a young child who is upset or frustrated because if you don't be firm with them they'll end up ruling the roost.

Mylittlesandwich · 27/10/2022 14:56

LolaSmiles · 27/10/2022 14:45

BertieBotts
That podcasts sounds like one of the groups I've been in.

It's about parents confidently embracing their authority as parents, choosing boundaries, and holding them in a calm and respectful way. The group also covers how it's entirely reasonable to acknowledge a child's feelings, whilst still holding boundaries.

Eg. I understand you'd like to play longer. It's home time. We can come back another day. The child is allowed to feel disappointed or upset. It's fine for the adult to acknowledge the feelings. It's not bad for the child to experience those feelings and the adult can confidently make the decision that it's time to go.

I've always taken the view that if a child isn't capable of of understanding reason, they won't understand being smacked, and if a child isn't capable of understanding reason then they're not going to understand why their caregiver is shouting at them/isolating them/implementing an entirely unrelated punishment.

Like most people on this thread, I also can't stand permissive parenting, but I also won't get drawn into adapting how I correct my DC behaviour to appease strangers who seem to think that being rude, belittling, authoritarian and unpleasant to children is acceptable.

This is exactly my take on it too. It's ok to be disappointed about x y or z but we're still going. Also feel those feelings, be upset but don't lash out (e.g. hit) because of those feelings

LolaSmiles · 27/10/2022 14:45

BertieBotts
That podcasts sounds like one of the groups I've been in.

It's about parents confidently embracing their authority as parents, choosing boundaries, and holding them in a calm and respectful way. The group also covers how it's entirely reasonable to acknowledge a child's feelings, whilst still holding boundaries.

Eg. I understand you'd like to play longer. It's home time. We can come back another day. The child is allowed to feel disappointed or upset. It's fine for the adult to acknowledge the feelings. It's not bad for the child to experience those feelings and the adult can confidently make the decision that it's time to go.

I've always taken the view that if a child isn't capable of of understanding reason, they won't understand being smacked, and if a child isn't capable of understanding reason then they're not going to understand why their caregiver is shouting at them/isolating them/implementing an entirely unrelated punishment.

Like most people on this thread, I also can't stand permissive parenting, but I also won't get drawn into adapting how I correct my DC behaviour to appease strangers who seem to think that being rude, belittling, authoritarian and unpleasant to children is acceptable.

quirkychick · 27/10/2022 14:28

@CoveredInCobwebs I certainly have come across lots of parents who launch into a long-winded explanation of their child's emotions when the child is too small and has just behaved dangerously/aggressively. "Don't hit" would be perfect, I agree. I have certainly heard a lot of discussions of feelings/choices that are not appropriate to a small child or toddler, especially in that moment. These are parents that call themselves 'gentle parents'.

lannistunut · 27/10/2022 14:08

piesforever · 27/10/2022 13:36

Wtf is gentle parenting?! What a load of rubbish, kids aren't gentle, neither are adults!

It is usually sensible to learn about something before dismissing it out of hand.

Gentle parenting is an evidence-based approach to raising happy, confident children. This parenting style is composed of four main elements—empathy, respect, understanding, and boundaries—and focuses on fostering the qualities you want in your child by being compassionate and enforcing consistent boundaries. Unlike some more lenient parenting methods, gentle parenting encourages age-appropriate discipline that teaches valuable life lessons.

www.verywellfamily.com/what-is-gentle-parenting-5189566

piesforever · 27/10/2022 13:36

Wtf is gentle parenting?! What a load of rubbish, kids aren't gentle, neither are adults!

Badnewsoracle · 27/10/2022 12:52

To echo others - that's not gentle parenting. That's permissive and ineffective parenting.

I practice gentle parenting and in that situation, I'd have removed my 4 year old, sat in the cafe area with him and had a conversation about hurting others, the feelings of the child being hurt and the reasons why DS felt the need to do what he was doing. Recognizing and identifying my son's reasons for his behaviour and helping him find other ways to manage those emotions. If he did it again, either to your child or another, we'd leave immediately.

CoveredInCobwebs · 27/10/2022 11:35

peaceandove · 27/10/2022 10:54

Well, quite. I studied language acquisition at post-grad level. It's utterly pointless parents going into gentle, detailed explanations of 'why you shouldn't repeatedly kick Toby in the head' with their 3 year old. The child literally understands maybe one word in ten and and their logical reasoning ability is barely functioning.

You get far better results with a very stern tone of voice and a sharp look.

But you don’t launch into a detailed explanation. You say ‘we don’t hit. Hitting hurts’ or similar. Also, very young children do have empathy; it’s a misconception that this doesn’t develop until much later. I always found ‘how would you feel if x did that to you?’ was very effective, even when mine were toddlers. Obviously if they’re dysregulated and not capable of any sort of conversation then you remove from the situation.

Plopplopplopplopplopploppy · 27/10/2022 11:18

That’s I can’t be arsed parenting, not gentle parenting.

Penguin92 · 27/10/2022 11:14

Urm… that’s not gentle parenting. That’s called negligence.

peaceandove · 27/10/2022 10:54

quirkychick · 24/10/2022 15:25

I used to teach small children, what annoys me is that a lot of the talking and explaining is completely developmentally inappropriate, which is why it doesn't work. Also, at what point are you going to intervene with your child?

Well, quite. I studied language acquisition at post-grad level. It's utterly pointless parents going into gentle, detailed explanations of 'why you shouldn't repeatedly kick Toby in the head' with their 3 year old. The child literally understands maybe one word in ten and and their logical reasoning ability is barely functioning.

You get far better results with a very stern tone of voice and a sharp look.

BertieBotts · 27/10/2022 10:48

Those four labels are the ones which are used in research and psychology. They aren't parenting styles that you would recommend - they are ways to categorise the different ways that parents respond to children, and yes, that includes abuse and neglect, because abuse and neglect are ways that parents respond to children.

IIRC it's like a box chart like this:

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Fewer rules / More rules
Less empathy / uninvolved / authoritarian
More empathy / permissive / authoritative

The one that produces good results is authoritative, which encompasses many actual parenting styles within it.

Uninvolved is basically neglect and authoritarian can encompass both very strict high expectations parenting and also abuse. Permissive isn't neglectful as such because the parents do care about the children but it doesn't produce very good results in terms of behaviour and achievement.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 27/10/2022 10:39

I’m not sure I give much credence to any of these labels, given that one is “neglectful parenting” - oh, sorry, “uninvolved parenting”. I had that one as a child and I think it’s properly known as abuse, not a valid parenting style!

CoveredInCobwebs · 27/10/2022 10:16

Untitledsquatboulder · 27/10/2022 09:47

Maybe from bitter experience? The bit where you comfort your battered child whilst gentle parent gives little brute a good cuddle and a lots of empathy to help him deal with his anger issues "he can't apologise because he doesn't feel sorry"(like we care). And then 20 minutes later it happens again.

What's weird is that gentle parents get really upset when their kid thumps the wrong kid and gets thumped back. Now that's a natural consequence.

But that’s just ineffectual parenting. Ineffectual parenting can also be authoritarian - in fact statistically it is more likely to be authoritarian, or neglectful, or permissive - the three other categories of which authoritative is the fourth; these are the four types defined and studied in developmental psychology. Authoritarian is the one which centres punishment.

Untitledsquatboulder · 27/10/2022 09:47

CoveredInCobwebs · 26/10/2022 23:05

The gentle parenting approach centers the emotions of the offender, even at the expense of ignoring a crying victim.

So you keep saying, and so a couple of us have asked where you get this idea from, and you won’t reply… Not from any gentle parenting books I’ve read.

Maybe from bitter experience? The bit where you comfort your battered child whilst gentle parent gives little brute a good cuddle and a lots of empathy to help him deal with his anger issues "he can't apologise because he doesn't feel sorry"(like we care). And then 20 minutes later it happens again.

What's weird is that gentle parents get really upset when their kid thumps the wrong kid and gets thumped back. Now that's a natural consequence.

BertieBotts · 27/10/2022 09:33

Isn't this the problem though, Math, that you're agreeing with what I've said that there are hundreds of strands of gentle parenting, but then you also say all gentle parenting centres the child's emotions. That to me is contradictory. And plenty of gentle parents don't agree that they centre emotion.

I don't like the term gentle parenting any more TBH, because it's too confusing. It's used for this emotion-centred parenting, and also for "natural consequences" (usually meaning logical consequences) which, I agree, don't work for aggression, which is somewhere I got completely stuck with when DS1 was about 4 or 5 - I mean, actually, logically, the logical consequence for violence is return violence, in the form of bite them back or similar, which isn't very gentle nor considered good parenting by most people. It's also used for sensible authoritative parenting, it's used for positive parenting (focus on good, ignore bad) and it's used for root-cause behaviour-as-a-symptom type parenting, and actual natural consequences parenting (which is a bit confusing) and no-boundaries permissive parenting and I don't even know, probably dozens more that I've never come across before.

I used to think that there was a concrete singular definition of it but I don't any more. I think it was MN, actually, that made me understand that what I do isn't special or unusual, it's just normal parenting that happens to have some things that I disagree with some other parents about. The only common strand I can come across in ALL gentle parenting resources is that it is opposed to authoritarianism, and that's a really unhelpful vague common strand. If I said "I will dispense parenting advice: Don't be abusive. Abuse is bad. It causes XYZ." That's undoubtedly true and correct and good advice, but it's not in the slightest bit helpful because it doesn't tell you anything about what to do instead, and that's why gentle parenting is such a soup of contradictory advice and people vary enormously in how they interpret and approach it.

Interestingly, I'm seeing a really exciting change now in some of the discourse that is less about moving away from authoritarianism, because I think a lot of people are pretty saturated in that idea now, and more about how to move away from permissiveness or the kind of codependence to children's emotions that is often present when people want to do gentle parenting. For example, I was listening to a podcast the other day which had an aside about "confident no and enthusiastic yes" - where the guest gave the example of a parent who doesn't want to play with their child but feels guilty, like they should, so they say "Oh no, honey, I'm sorry, I really can't right now" in a really wheedling and conciliatory voice because they feel like they are doing something awful. Children can hear that hesitation and it makes them feel insecure. And when the parent says yes reluctantly, it creates resentment on the parent's side and can then lead to them being snappy and irritable, which isn't really that positive an interaction for the child anyway. So she points out that if you say no with confidence, "No honey, not today." Then you can reserve your yes for when you actually have the energy to spare in enjoying play (or whatever shared activity).

Probably that sounds obvious to a lot of people. But this kind of thing was not obvious to me and I had to figure it out in the face of all the gentle parenting stuff (which I generally admire and think sounds great and want to emulate) that is telling you - connection is key, make memories, be with your kids, don't say no to them unless you have to.

CoveredInCobwebs · 27/10/2022 07:29

Well, it sounds like it’s being done very differently in the US then. Because I know a lot of kids who have been parented gently and they are as far from tyrants as can be.

All of the literature and articles I have read on 'gentle parenting' conflate gentle parenting with authoritative Authoritative parenting is an extremely broad strokes description. It includes within in it many subtypes of parenting. Gentle is one such subtype when done right. When done wrong, which according to MN happens a lot outside of the place where I live, it falls into the permissive subtype.

By the way, I never said I was keen on Sarah OS. I think she’s incredibly smug and a bit of a mother shamer.

mathanxiety · 27/10/2022 01:36

What you are calling 'gentle parenting' is authoritative parenting. Authoritative isn't really that wide an umbrella. Gentle parenting is part of what is termed Positive Parenting. There are differences between authoritative parenting and 'gentle parenting'/ Positive Parenting that are important. The centering of the child's emotions is key in gentle/positive parenting.

I posted a New Yorker magazine article upthread which is a very well thought out critique of gentle parenting. There are huge tensions inherent in the approach, huge risks, and consequences for children (and pets) who share space and resources with positively/gently parented children that are not always pretty.

People here who are dismissing parenting styles that they call 'permissive' are saying that there is some pure form of gentle/ positive parenting that the true disciples have taken on board and understand and practice flawlessly, and the rest are bogus. But the truth is that there are as many 'gentle parenting' methods as there are parents. Nevertheless, there are clear strands to it, and they are problematic.

The key tenets of Gentle / Positive parenting are -
Respect, understanding, empathy, and boundaries, meeting the child where he is. All nice and woolly and aspirational so far....

It emphasises natural consequences - an easy get out of jail card for parents who for whatever reason do not want to confront a child who is misbehaving, and absolutely absurd when a child is being aggressive, because there is no natural consequence for aggression or adversarial conduct that will make an impression on a child who tends to be antagonistic.

All of the literature and articles I have read on 'gentle parenting' conflate gentle parenting with authoritative, then veer away to provide woolly instructions that are actually appeals to the parent's feelings about himself or herself, and provide convenient straw men to demolish. Examples of straw men - children's behaviour that might elicit punishment in some other parenting style include - child crying because he doesn't want to go to school, child fussing about getting dressed, child spilling a drink.

There's no reference to a child willfully lamping his sister, calling his siblings rude names despite being asked by them to stop, coming up with multiple justifications for biting a sibling, or being deliberately destructive in the home.

The guru being trotted out here is not a neuroscientist or a psychologist. One of my DDs has an honours degree in psychology from a university with a far better reputation that Ockwell-Smith's alma mater (which is the former Woolwich Polytechnic). She's a mother of four who used to work as a homeopath. This should give you an idea of the shallowness of her commitment to science.

Any claims she makes about producing healthy, well balanced adults are spurious. Nobody knows how the centering of the child's emotions, which is what her views boil down to, will turn out.

She appeals to parents who want to think well of themselves, parents who are sure they are going to do a better job than their own parents did, parents who like to think of themselves as cutting edge.

Here's some food for thought (though Gentle/ Positive parenting is shaping up as something of a cult so maybe I'm being over optimistic)
www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20200703-the-challenges-of-positive-parenting

One possible risk of this parenting approach is that children won’t learn how to interpret and react to negative emotions if parents don’t let them see any. “Because sometimes we’re upset, it’s important for kids to see their parents express their own concerns,” says Coifman. “Openly talking about that fear and their anxiety – that validates the kids’ experience.”

This is, of course, more difficult when children are small, but “as children get older there is a place for them to understand that if they don’t listen, they are in fact inducing irritation in you. And that’s a normative experience. You need to know that if someone is asking you to do something and if you don’t do it consistently, there are potentially negative consequences.”

I see a lot of parents who have done gentle parenting from the earliest years - the empathy, the respect, the understanding, patience, and attempts to meet the child where he is, attending to emotions, biting their tongues, counting to ten, and screaming into pillows - and find themselves dealing with petty tyrants at age 7/8 or so, resulting in a change of approach where distinctly undemocratic consequences are dished out in a top down way because the 'gentle' approach has created a child whose only motivation is the satisfaction he gets from behaving in a way that he is happy with.

CoveredInCobwebs · 26/10/2022 23:05

The gentle parenting approach centers the emotions of the offender, even at the expense of ignoring a crying victim.

So you keep saying, and so a couple of us have asked where you get this idea from, and you won’t reply… Not from any gentle parenting books I’ve read.

Swipe left for the next trending thread