Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

sick of ‘gentle parents’

329 replies

strawberrysugar23 · 24/10/2022 15:18

i’m so fed up of gentle parenting - just been to soft play and a boy probably about 4 years old was whacking my 18 month old, pushing her down, kicked her in the face. obviously i kept intervening and actually told him off myself but his parent was nowhere to be seen. once i’d told him off he moved onto a different toddler whose mum approached me and asked if i knew who his parent was. said parent eventually came over and said ‘aw is he being rough?’ i said yes he’s being very aggressive to multiple toddlers, has hit/kicked/pushed and keeps following them around even after other parents are intervening. and her response was ‘ohh (child’s name) you need to be more gentle!’ in a soft voice then walked off and he continued.

sorry but wtf. if your child is as feral as that surely you say right we’re leaving and actually tell them off instead of that response? seems to be a common occurrence too, always seems to be the most aggressive kids who are being gentle parented

OP posts:
RoseslnTheHospital · 14/06/2023 15:36

This thread is like Groundhog Day. Ineffective parenting is not the same as gentle parenting.

In your example, you're judging the response of the children as insufficient when in reality in order to judge this woman as ineffective we'd need to know whether her children went on to comply with her instructions.

stunning71 · 14/06/2023 15:09

I was in a shop one day and a lady with 2 young boys (probably aged under 4). she proceeded to tell them that they should “look with their eyes and not touch with their hands” in the most ineffectual voice I’ve ever heard ! The 2 boys just stood staring at her with glazed expressions!
If that’s “gentle” parenting I’ll just stick with good old fashioned parenting! 🤣

Rycbar · 22/02/2023 15:14

That isn’t gentle parenting.

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/11/2022 21:22

Algor1thm · 24/10/2022 17:10

It's not necessarily about them fully understanding it and it's certainly not about controlling their behaviour in the moment or going forward. It's about accepting that developmentally a 4 year old has very little control over their behaviour and will act impulsively. It's our job to keep them and other people safe and to enforce respectful boundaries so that slowly, as they develop, they will copy the respect and kindness that has been modelled to them. It's about not shaming or punishing a 4 year old for acting like a 4 year old.

Being respectful will never get the same instant, reflexive obedience that fear-based parenting will. Yes, that parent who just gives their child a look and they stop immediately has more control over their child's actions in the moment. Respectful parenting is about the long game, and research shows the long term outcomes are very good.

I disagree that kicking a much younger child without severe provocation is normal behaviour for a 4 year old. I would think even most 2 year olds no longer do this unless they are fighting over a toy or something like that. If a 4 year old does it then either they are attention seeking or simply haven't been taught that its wrong. Normal lack of impulse control for a 4 year old in this scenario would be barging past the younger child - not attacking them.

Rhino94 · 30/11/2022 19:55

@Trez1510 then you’ve just proved you don’t actually know about gentle parenting and are thinking of permissive.
fyi this is about praise and gentle parenting sarahockwell-smith.com/2017/04/08/how-to-praise-your-children-in-a-gentle-and-effective-way/

Trez1510 · 25/11/2022 19:34

RoseslnTheHospital · 25/11/2022 18:39

How the blinking heck do you know that your useless young colleagues have anything to do with gentle parenting? Sounds more like permissive and boundary less parenting to me, given what you've described. Unless you carry out some kind of half decent research into their early life, you can't say either way!

From this thread alone, it's obvious consultation of feelings / (imo, empty) endless praise are key tenets of 'gentle parenting'. These tenets lead to the expectation others i.e. not their parents will continue to consult/praise endlessly/inappropriately in the workplace. When this is not forthcoming, for the simplest task, it's sulks/petulance galore.

The subjects of permissive/boundaryless parenting present in quite a different manner. They are aggressive, demanding, arrogant, rude and very often absent. They are also most likely to indulge in presenteeism i.e. colleagues should be grateful for their presence irrespective of how much (little) effort they make once there i.e. we are lucky they have deigned to rock-in at whatever time they felt like it.

I can only speak my (and my colleagues') experience in the workplace.

RoseslnTheHospital · 25/11/2022 18:39

How the blinking heck do you know that your useless young colleagues have anything to do with gentle parenting? Sounds more like permissive and boundary less parenting to me, given what you've described. Unless you carry out some kind of half decent research into their early life, you can't say either way!

Trez1510 · 25/11/2022 18:08

I've read this entire thread.

All I have to add is the effects of 'gentle parenting' is already manifesting in the workplace, and it's one of the reasons I'm so glad to be retired.

Young adults taking affront when asked to do what they're actually contracted to do, when they're actually contracted to do it without consulting their feelings about doing it at that moment. Expecting unremitting praise for achieving the simplest of tasks (often to a not very good standard) and becoming petulant/sulky if asked to re-do something that is not acceptable.

It's bonkers.

Newmumatlast · 25/11/2022 02:35

strawberrysugar23 · 24/10/2022 15:18

i’m so fed up of gentle parenting - just been to soft play and a boy probably about 4 years old was whacking my 18 month old, pushing her down, kicked her in the face. obviously i kept intervening and actually told him off myself but his parent was nowhere to be seen. once i’d told him off he moved onto a different toddler whose mum approached me and asked if i knew who his parent was. said parent eventually came over and said ‘aw is he being rough?’ i said yes he’s being very aggressive to multiple toddlers, has hit/kicked/pushed and keeps following them around even after other parents are intervening. and her response was ‘ohh (child’s name) you need to be more gentle!’ in a soft voice then walked off and he continued.

sorry but wtf. if your child is as feral as that surely you say right we’re leaving and actually tell them off instead of that response? seems to be a common occurrence too, always seems to be the most aggressive kids who are being gentle parented

I gentle parent. What you've described isn't gentle parenting.

Changechangychange · 24/11/2022 23:32

MrsTerryPratchett · 24/10/2022 15:25

Don't blame gentle parenting. A gentle parent would have sympathetically removed the child from soft play as a natural consequence for face kicking!

FWIW my child was very big for her age and parent would think she was 4 when she was two. So bear that in mind. However, she would have been supervised.

i was wondering if the kid was actually even four as well.

Took DS to a birthday party when he was 4, and there was another boy who towered above him, but seemed to have some sort of developmental delay because he was behaving like a toddler (snatching toys, hitting, delayed speech).

I was chatting to his mum later, and yep it turned out he was actually just a very tall two year old, behaving completely developmentally appropriately.

I do agree that this particular parent wasn’t supervising him well enough regardless of age, but lots of parents do that at soft play 🤷‍♀️

niugboo · 28/10/2022 18:27

YABU. That’s not gentle parenting.

LolaSmiles · 28/10/2022 11:24

It’s not working though is it? Because her thug child threw a rock at my child, and she praised him for how strong he was. Fuck that for a bunch of crunchy nonsense.

That's not gentle parenting. That's just shitty parenting. Then those parents wonder why their child ends up being disliked in the playground.

I really wish lazy parents owned their own laziness instead of hijacking a phrase that those working in the field openly say involves consequences and boundaries.

I think they cling to the phrase gentle parenting because they think giving it a name can justify their own laziness and permissiveness.

Herejustforthisone · 28/10/2022 11:03

mathanxiety · 28/10/2022 03:18

@Herejustforthisone
The concept of energy is a part of gentle / positive parenting. The terminology is supposed to be non-judgemental.

It’s not working though is it? Because her thug child threw a rock at my child, and she praised him for how strong he was. Fuck that for a bunch of crunchy nonsense.

Untitledsquatboulder · 28/10/2022 10:40

@WimpoleHat it happens even within families. Child with the stronger personality dictates what happens for everyone, whilst other, less vocal kids miss out. Common denominator is always some wringing- wet parent patting themselves on the back for allowing Fenella to express herself and move at her own pace.

WimpoleHat · 28/10/2022 09:59

What you get after 8 years or so of that is kids who really haven't learned that other people are real, three dimensional beings

This is what’s always struck me about this approach; it’s fine if you and your kid live in a vacuum, but we all have to live in a society with others and their feelings and the overriding social norms that come with that. And - as I said upthread - because we tend not to be direct with others, I think it’s really important as a parent to teach your kids about that, because other people won’t. And that involves them learning when they’re pissing other people off! (Someone’s going to come along and say there’s a perfect gentle parenting way to do this - but I struggle to see what can be an effective substitute for a child seeing that their behaviour is irritating from your own reactions. Or being told that something that they have done is outwith the boundary of good manners and that other people will think that they are rude if they do it. Because, of course, the natural consequence of rude behaviour would be that someone tells you that you’ve been rude. Or is rude back to you. But that isn’t how our society works. Most likely, they’ll smile to your face and bitch about you behind your back, so that all sorts of other people also think you’re rude. And that may be an issue for you, but you may well never know about it. So not the best outcome.) As a parent, you’re uniquely placed to have these frank conversations with kids which can help their social and emotional development enormously - precisely because they know you love them and so you don’t need to sugarcoat everything. It puts far too much responsibility for critical thinking on children if we expect them to infer these social norms for themselves from a wider discussion about their own feelings and choices.

LolaSmiles · 28/10/2022 07:34

I'm not talking about screeching or sarcasm or insults leveled at a child here. I'm not talking about humiliation - I'm talking about any invitation to a child to 'Treat others as you would like to be treated,' however it's expressed - 'Look at Daisy, she's crying because you bit her and her arm hurts
You can use a a gentle parenting approach to do that.

In gentle parenting, which is under the umbrella of authoritative parenting, children's feelings and opinions are validated, heard, and the parent is responsive to these.

And when the parent has set firm boundaries and guidelines for the child, the parent validates the child's emotions while also maintaining the boundaries.

The tools of gentle parenting are connection, communication, and consistency

Limit setting not as a necessary evil, but as an act of love and respect.

Robin Einsig did a good blog on limit setting and dropping the rope, and she explains how some parents hear one thing and turn it into something else.
E.g. she says sometimes we have to 'drop the rope'. What she means and explains is a nuanced reflection on the limits we've chosen as parents, whether they're appropriate, and how best to respond in a situation. What some parents hear (especially if they're relying on sound bite parenting advice or snippets on social media) is 'if your child is having a tantrum because you've turned the telly off/said to put toys away then dropping the rope means giving in because it doesn't matter'. That's just permissive though.

I've heard people say they're using A,B, C method for sleep training or for weaning but it doesn't mean they're actually doing it. Sometimes it's that they've picked and chosen which parts work for them (fine), and others say they're doing it but all evidence says otherwise (thinking about the trend for everyone saying they do baby led weaning, but actually are doing the good old fashioned mix of finger food and purees from an adult). Same with gentle parenting/positive parenting/respectful parenting/any other name people give for parenting with calmly and respectful boundaries and without irrelevant, punitive sanctions.

mathanxiety · 28/10/2022 03:18

@Herejustforthisone
The concept of energy is a part of gentle / positive parenting. The terminology is supposed to be non-judgemental.

Herejustforthisone · 27/10/2022 23:02

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 27/10/2022 21:17

@Herejustforthisone Everyone will jump on you and tell you that isn’t gentle parenting because gently parented children are kind, quiet, loving etc. but the description of the child is also my experience with the children of self-proclaimed gentle parents.

The mother is very vocal about her desire to ‘gentle parent’. I’ve heard her quite vehemently reinforcing her ideals into the nursery staff. She wants them to mirror her style too. That’s the only way I know. Otherwise I’d have just thought she was a useless parent.

She won’t say no, raise her voice, scold or admonish. Apparently she ‘redirects’ energies into something more positive. Didn’t fucking happen with the rock today though, did it? Honestly, it would have been awful if it had hit my kid. I’d have probably thrown it at her.

She’s very posh, her children probably want for nothing, but they’re turning into nasty little shits.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 27/10/2022 21:17

@Herejustforthisone Everyone will jump on you and tell you that isn’t gentle parenting because gently parented children are kind, quiet, loving etc. but the description of the child is also my experience with the children of self-proclaimed gentle parents.

mathanxiety · 27/10/2022 21:16

Nobody is claiming that gently parented kids, or indeed any kids, or indeed any humans - are perfect - though the best behaved kids I know are the ones who are gently parented well - and by that I mean have parents who hold boundaries but do it respectfully. That is basically what it comes down to.

What you are talking about there is authoritative parenting, which is consistent, attentive, and not harsh.

Parents who cling doggedly to the label 'gentle parenting' are doing so for reasons within themselves, maybe trying to differentiate themselves from their own parents, or the parenting of the culture they were exposed to as children. Or maybe they confuse the terms authoritarian and authoritative.

Gentle parenting springs from positive psychology. The parenting form, positive parenting, advocates ignoring the bad out of faith that despite all indications to the contrary, the child will one day turn his behaviour around himself, thanks to modeling of dealing with emotions and interpersonal interactions, hugs and assurances of unconditional love while the child is emotionally disregulated, and comments on the child's emotional state instead of reprimands or firm requests to stop unacceptable behaviour or speech, and avoidance of introducing any sense of shame into the child's life, which is what is said to happen when you issue a rebuke, a firm, "Stop that!" or any comment directing the child to take note of the effect their behaviour has had on someone else. Any intervention prompted by behaviour is supposed to make the child aware of his emotions and ultimately to learn to regulate them himself. Shame is old school, and bad.

(I'm not talking about screeching or sarcasm or insults leveled at a child here. I'm not talking about humiliation - I'm talking about any invitation to a child to 'Treat others as you would like to be treated,' however it's expressed - 'Look at Daisy, she's crying because you bit her and her arm hurts.')

What you get after 8 years or so of that is kids who really haven't learned that other people are real, three dimensional beings who are emotionally and physically hurt by being bitten, and are really surprised - actually outraged - when they get bitten back.

mfasr · 27/10/2022 20:50

Herejustforthisone · 27/10/2022 20:48

This is probably a bit outing if his mother is on here. 😬

hopefully his mother does see this and realises she needs to reign her kid in then

mathanxiety · 27/10/2022 20:50

You see parents struggling with boundaries because they think from some gentle parenting resources that the child is supposed to be happy and willing at all times without any conflict or disagreement at all which just isn't realistic.

Yes, this.

And actually, when you look closely at it, it's very, very controlling if that is the reason for a parent to adopt this approach. They're saying something along the lines of, "There's no such thing as a wrong feeling" but they're still trying to steer the feelings into something more aligned with everyone else's feelings and affect.

Herejustforthisone · 27/10/2022 20:48

Herejustforthisone · 27/10/2022 20:46

There’s a vocally gentle parent at my kid’s nursery. Her son is a thug. He hits, he grabs kids’ hair and wrenches them to the ground by it, he pushed over a little girl and booted her in the face in front of me at collection one day. She was crying her eyes out. The nursery staff were absolutely beside themselves trying to get this kid to stop. He is a devious, violent little arsehole. His little brother is the same. He’s moved up a room now thank fuck and so my kid is safe again, Christ knows how the next lot are getting on. I happened upon them all today at collection and he picked up a massive flinty rock and tried to throw it at my kid as we walked to the car. The mum said “darling, put the rock down, it’s very heavy! tinkly laugh You’re a big strong boy, I know.”

I stared at her agog. What she should have said is “PUT THAT ROCK DOWN! We do NOT throw rocks at people. We do not throw anything at people.”

It landed about a foot away from us but still. What the fuck.

This is probably a bit outing if his mother is on here. 😬

Herejustforthisone · 27/10/2022 20:46

There’s a vocally gentle parent at my kid’s nursery. Her son is a thug. He hits, he grabs kids’ hair and wrenches them to the ground by it, he pushed over a little girl and booted her in the face in front of me at collection one day. She was crying her eyes out. The nursery staff were absolutely beside themselves trying to get this kid to stop. He is a devious, violent little arsehole. His little brother is the same. He’s moved up a room now thank fuck and so my kid is safe again, Christ knows how the next lot are getting on. I happened upon them all today at collection and he picked up a massive flinty rock and tried to throw it at my kid as we walked to the car. The mum said “darling, put the rock down, it’s very heavy! tinkly laugh You’re a big strong boy, I know.”

I stared at her agog. What she should have said is “PUT THAT ROCK DOWN! We do NOT throw rocks at people. We do not throw anything at people.”

It landed about a foot away from us but still. What the fuck.

Meatshake · 27/10/2022 20:40

You're confusing gentle parenting with shit parenting.