Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10% gratuity added to bill

739 replies

Byz · 24/10/2022 14:19

AIBU to be annoyed by a 10% gratuity charge being automatically added to my bill at a restaurant?

Seafood restaurant in the North East, a little town, not a city.

For four of us our bill came to about £230 and a £23 tip was automatically added to the bill. It did state at the bottom of the menu an optional charge would be added but they didn't ask me before actually adding it.
When the waitress brought the bill over she reminded us about the gratuity and said she would remove it if we prefer but I think I should have been asked if I wanted it adding in the first place. It was quite embarrassing to ask for it to be removed. She was polite about it but did seem a bit surprised.

Food was good, service was good and I would have left £10 but it soured the evening a bit so I left nothing. I don't think tips should be expected in this country.

OP posts:
RiverSkater · 27/10/2022 11:15

If you can afford that on a meal, pay the tip. Between four of you it's hardly much extra.

I would rather the bill was just the bill and serving staff paid better but that won't be happening anytime soon.

Pay in cash though as I've heard some waiting staff don't get the card tips. 😯

Vickstory79 · 27/10/2022 11:12

Would you ask your builder to only pay for the materials after they have carried out the work satisfactorily or do you pay the labour without thinking? Service is paying for labour, it pays part of the staff's wages. It's not difficult to understand. It's optional in case the service was bad not because you don't agree with paying for labour.

So you left £2.50 each as a tip?

You know that the £2.50 you left will be shared amongst other people, like the pot washers, table clearers etc.....don't you?

You know that your food bill covers the food, the chefs who made it, the cleaners, the electricity, the building rates, the menu prints etc.....and probably a small profit although not guaranteed with the cost of food currently.

You know that most of the staff get paid minimum wage and rely on the service element to live?

Just because you would prefer a system where the labour/service is included in the food price doesn't mean that you should refuse to pay it.

OneTC · 27/10/2022 11:10

And I wouldn't call my earnings lucrative by any stretch but they made the job appealing. I could have been a cashier or something on the same basic with a load of drudge and no extra reward, but in a till it would have been acceptable to sit there and do nothing more than run it up and say the price. No one would care because no one is looking for a maximum experience in the supermarket

OneTC · 27/10/2022 11:07

There are many different experiences and also I think much of the market and consequently service levels have already changed. I don't even know if places like that really exist or are in fashion now but I certainly have friends who chase around more lucrative jobs (both in basic but also in massive tip potential) in higher end restaurants for the same reason.

Yeah working in a Yates is shit, no doubt Grin

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 11:02

It's small print of course.

Yep, as I suspected. I highly doubt they have any promotions or invitations to spend extra on sauces/side orders/puddings in the same small print.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 11:00

Because it caps it. I've said that again and again.

So are you saying that serving staff want the best of both worlds - a socially-enforced minimum tip (with people accusing you of tightness and shaming you if you don't) but also the opportunity to earn more than that? On top of the NMW?

If your opinion is that waiting staff are in a lucrative job - guaranteed NMW, customary minimum 10% tips AND more on top of that if they 'perform' - and are in an empowered position where they can really cash in if they use their skill and charm, then fine; but the clear vibe I've been getting throughout this thread (and every other thread on tipping) is that waiting staff are poorly paid and are left desperately holding their hands out for more money in order to be able to make ends meet.

OneTC · 27/10/2022 10:54

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 10:42

In happy it's on the front page of the menu

That's a start, at least. The same-size print as all the stated prices of the meals?

No.

It's small print of course. I prefer it on the bottom of each menu page, or first page with food on. Cos people don't really check covers or blurb pages very often if they are there

OneTC · 27/10/2022 10:47

How can it be less appealing to restructure your pricing in a more honest way that guarantees your staff a certain (higher) wage?

Because it caps it. I've said that again and again. The places I worked and wanted to work were places that you could do very well from tips if you put the effort in. But I'm talking full clowning type establishments where you're meant to perform. This is how I selected places to work. Not on the hourly rate (about £3 at the time iirc).

I understand that nmw changes things a little but presumably there were customers in there who were also on £3 in a different job

Badgirlriri · 27/10/2022 10:45

IndysMamaRex · 27/10/2022 00:43

it is disgrace to spend £230 on a meal & either not tip or leave a pathetic tip. It’s good manners to tip if your happy with service. Waiters etc are typically on crap wage, part time unsociable long shifts. They have to deal with the “joy” of the general public who can after a few drinks etc can be rude A-holes. The tips help make up for that in my opinion. And before you say they can get another job. It’s isn’t always that simple. Some restaurants oat huge wages, yeah “some” do most don’t & they staff are expendable. So tip your waiters guys don’t be a cheapskate

As are many other employees!
I used to be a waitress, I know how hard it is. I now work for the NHS, which is more physically tough and soul destroying. I know which job I feel I deserve tips in!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 10:42

In happy it's on the front page of the menu

That's a start, at least. The same-size print as all the stated prices of the meals?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 10:40

Yeah let's make hospitality sector work even less appealing.

How can it be less appealing to restructure your pricing in a more honest way that guarantees your staff a certain (higher) wage?

How does having to rely on goodwill and hoping that people will be kind enough to hand over a large part of the income that you're anticipating encourage people into the job?!

That said, I think that, whilst plenty of people do like the whole experience of a waitress/waiter actively serving them, answering questions, recommending dishes or wines and being at their beck and call, plenty of other people don't want all the fuss and would rather just place their order and have it brought out to them - like going to Argos vs having a personal shopper. Some people find it helpful and considerate when the waitress asks several times if everything is OK, whilst others see it as an intrusion whilst they just want to talk with their friends.

People are saying how essential it is to tip the serving staff because of how very involved they are and all the little touches they provide, even though some customers really don't actually want all that in the first place. That's why using self-service checkouts and one-click ordering on Amazon are so popular - which is not to say that there aren't also plenty of people who like the experience of being made to feel special and actively 'served' at all stages.

Dippydinosaurus · 27/10/2022 10:36

It's one thing tipping when it's optional and leaving cash on the table for great service. It's another for an 'optional' 15% tip added to the electronic device automatically when asked to pay where the only way to remove it is to ask the server to remove it. Especially if the service was slow and awful. It's not optional if it's already added

musttryharder84 · 27/10/2022 10:29

£10 on a £230 bill isn’t even 5%. Between waiting staff, bar staff and kitchen staff, that’s maybe £2 each if that. How stingy.

But lets say that they went to a much cheaper restaurant and only spent £50 total. £10 tip on that is 20% - really generous I think. But that's still only £2 each once it's split between waiting staff, bar staff, and kitchen staff.

Last time I went out for dinner our waitress was serving at least 6 tables during the time we were there. Even if each staff member only gets £2 from each table, that's an extra £12 in less than 2 hours (which won't be subject to tax/NI etc). So effectively it's over £6 an hour extra on each staff members hourly wage. That's more than a lot of very skilled people earn at my work.

OneTC · 27/10/2022 10:28

In happy it's on the front page of the menu

neighboursmustliveon · 27/10/2022 10:22

These 'hush hush' charges reminded me of something that happened this summer. We went to London for the day. My dd and I stopped at Happy for lunch. We got 3 starters/small plates (hummus, mozzarella sticks, fries) and two drinks. So very little interaction with staff. Took our order, brought our drinks, brought food.

My DD and I were having a competition on how much we thought the bill was, she said £32 and I said £33. It came and was about £37. I looked to make sure only the 5 items we ordered was on it and paid by contactless. It was only as the payment was going through that I saw there was a service charge on! I hadn't seen this on the menu at all - and we read it a couple of times while we decided what we wanted.

I really don't think this service warranted a £3/4 tip which is what they charged us. The waiter did nothing more than he was paid for as part of his job. If I had spotted it before we paid I would have asked for it to be removed.

OneTC · 27/10/2022 10:19

Yeah let's make hospitality sector work even less appealing. The end result will truly be a benefit to us all. Apps for ordering, apps for paying, "runners" for the food. Card only. We'll be able to streamline the process for any type of food, it'll be like spoons for one and all

NightmareSituation · 27/10/2022 10:12

It’s about time tipping was done away with and restaurants paid their staff a reasonable wage instead. When pricing up a menu service should be factored in for everyone. Whether ordering a £10 burger or a £25 steak, the staff that look after you still have to do the same amount of work so a percentage of the bill doesn’t always seem fair either.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 10:08

I was saying about adding hush hush charges to your bill in response to the comment about it being a normal thing to check your receipt - which seemed to me to be suggesting that might be the first you hear of such charges.

I suppose it's slightly less dishonest of the restaurant if they tell waiting staff to verbally advise you of it, but again, most people will assume that 'service charge = tip' - I think it's a terrible position to put your serving staff in if you're effectively making them tell people what tip they're going to take, unless the customer objects; so humiliating.

Also, yes it may well be written on the menu, but usually in tiny little print on the bottom of the page. If they're so proud of the service they offer and thus assume that people will consider it a pleasure to pay the charge, why don't they routinely mention it in normal-sized print at the top of the page and (at all) on the big blackboards outside?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 10:03

These people handle your food you know

So does the bakery shop, and the butcher's, and the fruit and veg shop - and I don't tip them. That's all loose food that they handle and serve me with too; but as I'm paying the price they've requested in exchange for the food, they're actually grateful for my business and not liable to gob in it first, if that's what you're driving at.

Maverickess · 27/10/2022 10:03

XelaM · 27/10/2022 09:12

@nogginatemycat * These people handle your food you know

So what has that to do with any thing, please explain?*

I wouldn't advise to mess with people who handle your food 🤢if you intend to eat there again

Wouldn't be putting my job and possibly liberty at risk by doing this over anything, never mind a tip, and anyone I caught would be getting sent home straight away and reported to my manager straight away and they'd be sacked for gross misconduct and it's pretty hard to do something like that without someone noticing because of the nature of a kitchen having people in and around all the time, waiting staff in and out etc.

Most chefs I've worked with would have you in the oven should you mess with their food instead of just serving it as it's plated, there's a lot of professional pride involved in most kitchens, especially ones like the OP describes (that aren't ping it meals from the freezer for example)
I'm not saying it doesn't happen because there's some strange people out there, but it's not the common practice (at least in places I've worked) people seem to assume it is. Although I realise working in a restaurant in just about any capacity isn't rated or respected (and not just by reading this thread) so people don't tend to understand why you'd have a bit of pride in a job like that, while demanding outstanding service at the same time.

It doesn't particularly instil confidence, though, does it - if they stick it on and leave you to find it before deciding whether or not to object?

Doesn't OP say it was on the menu and the waitress also pointed it out and asked OP if she wanted it removed? Doesn't sound so sneaky to me tbh, sounds more like the waitress has had these issues before and was trying to head any issues off at the pass with OP, but is still being slated, and publicly too with OP's review, as well as on here.

There is a growing attitude towards people who provide a service towards others that there is some kind of conspiracy against customers by 'the staff' who's main aim in life is to mislead and piss off customers rather than just do the job they're employed to do and as they're told by their employer (you know, the ones who call the shots and decide to give you the job, what you need to do to keep it and what you get paid). It makes it really hard to actually give good service when someone has already decided that you're not going to.

bellabasset · 27/10/2022 09:27

Staff should be paid properly by the restaurant. If they're putting a 10% gratuity on the bill then it's likely that it's being shown through the business records as income so credit card charges, VAT and income tax is being paid on it. Tronc, service charge, gratuities should be stopped.

If I leave a tip it's in cash for the hairdresser or restaurant.

nogginatemycat · 27/10/2022 09:25

XelaM · 27/10/2022 09:12

@nogginatemycat * These people handle your food you know

So what has that to do with any thing, please explain?*

I wouldn't advise to mess with people who handle your food 🤢if you intend to eat there again

Well if that's the case they should be shut down/reported and don't deserve to work in the industry and especially not be tipped.

May be I should not go back into hospital as I didn't tip for my meals there and did not tip the surgeon 😯

XelaM · 27/10/2022 09:12

@nogginatemycat * These people handle your food you know

So what has that to do with any thing, please explain?*

I wouldn't advise to mess with people who handle your food 🤢if you intend to eat there again

nogginatemycat · 27/10/2022 08:53

These people handle your food you know

So what has that to do with any thing, please explain? If restaurants don't want custom from people who don't want tip or pay an extra fee for service then they should just put a sign outside and say soo. But they don't, because they rely on the gullible and pearl clutchers pay up.

Its not up to me to make up wages and shitty conditions for others, that is their employer so take it up with them not me and if the restaurant owner no longer wants my business on that basis there more than welcome to inform me, but no never happened. 😂

HenryHenrietta · 27/10/2022 08:25

lillila · 27/10/2022 06:58

Apologies if I have missed anything (I may well have!) but I don't think I can see an argument against others on miminum wage, who work just as, or harder than waiting staff.
For example, care staff work extremely hard and often subjected to abuse, and are unable to accept tips, and types of cleaning jobs where the conditions are awful. Shop assistant serve many people compared to waiting staff, but may work just as hard. I do leave a tip, due to the attitudes as seen on this thread, but I don't agree with the principal as the minimum wage is in place.

@lillila

This hasn't been responded to maybe because it is quite irrelevant.

If you want to tip your mechanic have at it!

There are social conventions which mean that most reasonable people expect to tip in restaurants. Some people also tip in cabs or hairdressers. Most people tip delivery drivers too.

Saying but "what about...? Why don't they get any tips?" is literally whataboutery. Like saying why don't we take our shoes off and fart loudly in nice restaurants or pick apart a steak with our bare hands in nice restaurants? Why don't we bring out our ipad and stick the footie on while we're eating our Michelin star dinner? You just don't.

If you feel that strongly about giving tips to other workers, you go for it. But don't use "well I don't tip the lady in tesco so I won't be tipping you either harrumph" as an excuse not to tip as it would make you sound awful. Not saying you would do this btw, but just in case!