Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10% gratuity added to bill

739 replies

Byz · 24/10/2022 14:19

AIBU to be annoyed by a 10% gratuity charge being automatically added to my bill at a restaurant?

Seafood restaurant in the North East, a little town, not a city.

For four of us our bill came to about £230 and a £23 tip was automatically added to the bill. It did state at the bottom of the menu an optional charge would be added but they didn't ask me before actually adding it.
When the waitress brought the bill over she reminded us about the gratuity and said she would remove it if we prefer but I think I should have been asked if I wanted it adding in the first place. It was quite embarrassing to ask for it to be removed. She was polite about it but did seem a bit surprised.

Food was good, service was good and I would have left £10 but it soured the evening a bit so I left nothing. I don't think tips should be expected in this country.

OP posts:
Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 28/10/2022 08:54

Where are you all eating that tipping is normal? Think I've only been to half a dozen places in my life that add tip on.
Its not normal at all and more people need to stand up and call places out on it.

memorial · 28/10/2022 04:40

I have reached the point where I wish tipping would stop tbh because all the shit that goes with it just is not worth an extra £20/30 a week. It's really not. I'd settle for just being treated like a human being at this stage 🤣.

I dunno where you work but my daughter makes a couple hundred pounds a week in tips. She works exceptionally hard as well as going to uni and earns every penny.
She works for a big chain and gets to keep cash tips and 50% of card tips/service charges (the other 50% going to kitchen/bar/managers etc NOT the company). She doesn't mind this at all and prefers it because it's amazing how many stingy bustards there are out there.
This thread is quite sad in its gaslighting meanness and attempts to justify just being stingy and mean hearted.
It's not a race to the bottom and I'm pretty sure those on here trying to justify their self indulgence aren't on minimum wage. Stop being so ridiculous and don't pretend you don't tip out of misplaced loyalty to other low paid workers. Just own your mean selfish entitlement.

Squirelnutkins · 28/10/2022 02:46

theddorai · 28/10/2022 02:11

Then customary tip is 15%. You understand that those that work in the service industry rely on tips as this is their income. So, you couldn’t find it in your heart to even leave that? How cheap are you?

Customary for where exactly because from where I'm from that's just made up bollocks. If your pay is shit either take it up with your employer or find a better job. That's what 99% of all other employees do on other industries 🙄

theddorai · 28/10/2022 02:13

stingy.. huh?

theddorai · 28/10/2022 02:11

Then customary tip is 15%. You understand that those that work in the service industry rely on tips as this is their income. So, you couldn’t find it in your heart to even leave that? How cheap are you?

limitedperiodonly · 28/10/2022 00:00

A tip is an optional extra stated on the menu before ordering. If you don't want to give it then just say at the beginning that you don't. If the bill comes with the optional payment included then say it's a mistake and you don't want to pay it and settle your adjusted bill.

Charcy · 27/10/2022 23:55

pimlicoanna · 26/10/2022 09:03

I'm amazed at how many people think that tip goes to the waiting staff when it's added directly to the bill like this.

It does.
Unless you work somewhere dodgy.
It's paid through payroll and taxed accordingly at a reduced rate of 10%.

Brokendaughter · 27/10/2022 22:15

Seriously, if a waitress had saved someones life then got back to work & I'd seen it even on another table, I'd be leaving that woman an extra tip.

If that is not above & beyond I don't know what is!

Frankiez · 27/10/2022 21:53

Squirelnutkins · 27/10/2022 20:25

Yes a tip is expected and it should be. If this is something you don’t like then don’t go out to eat!

hahaha, since when did you decide what people should and should not do, I'd love to see how many restaurant owners would agree with you. Talk about pearl clutching 😂😂😂

There is nothing to 🤣🤣 about she said the food and service was good there was no reason to treat the server that way and is she doesn’t like to tip then stay home !

Maverickess · 27/10/2022 20:30

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 10:08

I was saying about adding hush hush charges to your bill in response to the comment about it being a normal thing to check your receipt - which seemed to me to be suggesting that might be the first you hear of such charges.

I suppose it's slightly less dishonest of the restaurant if they tell waiting staff to verbally advise you of it, but again, most people will assume that 'service charge = tip' - I think it's a terrible position to put your serving staff in if you're effectively making them tell people what tip they're going to take, unless the customer objects; so humiliating.

Also, yes it may well be written on the menu, but usually in tiny little print on the bottom of the page. If they're so proud of the service they offer and thus assume that people will consider it a pleasure to pay the charge, why don't they routinely mention it in normal-sized print at the top of the page and (at all) on the big blackboards outside?

I agree it's an awful position to put the staff in, but then it's not uncommon for companies to throw their employees under the bus with policies and stuff that they know fine well will piss off customers and they'll have a load of crap to deal with, or for customers to know fine well it's not the person in front of them who is responsible, but take it out on them personally anyway because they're frustrated and angry, I mean I guess some people labour under the impression that their 'feedback' will be well, fed back and something will change, but usually if it's putting money in the till then it's not going to happen, no matter how much shit the staff who deal with customers put up with because of it.

I don't for a minute think that these service charges are being added by companies for the benefit of their employees, maybe they like to pretend they are so they look like good employers? Without actually having to pay more or raise prices which could result in a loss of business.
Someone upthread made a point about it being easier to track 'extra' money that is given in tips and therefore for it to be declared and then tax paid on it - maybe that's part of the reason (as well as taking a cut for 'admin') many have started doing this, because it's less of a faff?

As I've said, it's a practice I don't believe in anyway and it'd be one of the things that would put me off working somewhere, because of the potential for hassle with customers over it.

Squirelnutkins · 27/10/2022 20:25

Yes a tip is expected and it should be. If this is something you don’t like then don’t go out to eat!

hahaha, since when did you decide what people should and should not do, I'd love to see how many restaurant owners would agree with you. Talk about pearl clutching 😂😂😂

Maverickess · 27/10/2022 20:15

Can someone explain what is restaurant service "above and beyond" that would earn a tip?

For some, nothing would ever be enough, tip or no tip, I know that for sure!

Though I would be interested to know too.

I have reached the point where I wish tipping would stop tbh because all the shit that goes with it just is not worth an extra £20/30 a week. It's really not. I'd settle for just being treated like a human being at this stage 🤣.

Frankiez · 27/10/2022 19:42

Yes you are ridiculous to act that way. So you were annoyed and didn’t leave the server any tip? This isn’t their doing it’s the restaurant. So you punish her for their policy ! Yes a tip is expected and it should be. If this is something you don’t like then don’t go out to eat! In the USA servers don’t even make minimum wage their entire income depends on tips! She Removed it with no issue so what did she do so wrong that you had the nerve to leave her $0?

limitedperiodonly · 27/10/2022 18:55

Can someone explain what is restaurant service "above and beyond" that would earn a tip?

@lillila this is slightly unfair because you're not the only one to say it but you are the most recent so I've alighted on you. Them's the breaks. So what would make you give an extra reward? I really want to know.

I'll give my own example of exceptional service to start you off.

We were having a family outing and my SIL started to cough. Discreetly at first and then more. She went red in the face and looked terrified and we realised she was choking. My brother slapped her on the back but it didn't work. She was dying in front of us.

A waitress, not ours, came over grabbed her from behind and shouted: "Come on!" She did the Heimlich manoeuvre and after a few thrusts it actually worked and Maureen coughed out the bit of dinner that was killing her. We were so grateful and the waitress said: "I learned it at first aid but I've never done it before." She looked as shocked as us but weirdly hardly anyone else in the restaurant noticed because it happened so fast. She went back to her job.

We left a tip. But just the one we were planning to. We were glad the waitress saved my SIL's life but anyone with that rare skill would have done it so that wasn't our reason for leaving the standard 12.5 per cent tip. We left one because apart from the exceptional life-saving bit the service was good and call me a conventional fool but it's the custom.

So given that what is everyone else's idea of service "above and beyond"?

lillila · 27/10/2022 14:01

HenryHenrietta · 27/10/2022 08:25

@lillila

This hasn't been responded to maybe because it is quite irrelevant.

If you want to tip your mechanic have at it!

There are social conventions which mean that most reasonable people expect to tip in restaurants. Some people also tip in cabs or hairdressers. Most people tip delivery drivers too.

Saying but "what about...? Why don't they get any tips?" is literally whataboutery. Like saying why don't we take our shoes off and fart loudly in nice restaurants or pick apart a steak with our bare hands in nice restaurants? Why don't we bring out our ipad and stick the footie on while we're eating our Michelin star dinner? You just don't.

If you feel that strongly about giving tips to other workers, you go for it. But don't use "well I don't tip the lady in tesco so I won't be tipping you either harrumph" as an excuse not to tip as it would make you sound awful. Not saying you would do this btw, but just in case!

I do give tips, usually because I feel I have to. if someone has gine above and beyond i am happy to do so.

I can't see how it is irrelevant when compared to other minimum wage jobs, including those who provide a service..I probably am being a bit dense, but really can't see the difference (apart from it bring difficult and not 'the norm' to tip in most cases)

WilsonMilson · 27/10/2022 13:48

You spent £230 and left no tip at all?

I’m cringing for you. I’d be too embarrassed to ever go back.

MercedesD · 27/10/2022 13:11

If it’s charged as a service charge and payed through a tronc system they are taxed. In fact a waiter who accepts cash tips, technically should declare these as income and pay tax on them, charging tips as service charge makes this easier.

OneTC · 27/10/2022 12:56

There's acute shortages in most lower paid sectors at the moment and there's a big difference between 25-30 years ago and now in terms of what your money gets you. NMW staff are worse paid than I was on when on £3 an hour

Vickstory79 · 27/10/2022 12:37

If it's so easy and lucrative please explain why there's an acute shortage of hospitality workers.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 11:47

Would you ask your builder to only pay for the materials after they have carried out the work satisfactorily or do you pay the labour without thinking? Service is paying for labour, it pays part of the staff's wages. It's not difficult to understand. It's optional in case the service was bad not because you don't agree with paying for labour.

I've never had a builder, other tradesman, car mechanic or whatever quote me the price of materials and leave it up to me to decide if I want to give them any extra so that they can actually earn a living. Just like they don't ask me to contribute to diesel for their van or their phone contract - they run a business and factor their prices in when quoting them.

They may break it down separately - partly to avoid complaints about ripping people off, if they're charging you £1,000 for a job but having to hand £900 of that straight over to the supplier for parts/materials; or to ask for some money upfront for cashflow reasons - but they never leave me in any doubt that "If you want me to fully supply and complete this job for you, you will need to pay me £XXX."

Also, as we've already touched on about the issue of a quiet, undemanding couple who order lobster and champagne vs a big, loud, messy family group all have pasta and coke, the percentage basis is just silly and bears no relation at all to the value of the service offered. Why would you pay a tradesman far more money for his effort for ordering a 24-carat-gold-plated mirror and screwing it to the wall than you would for him to replumb half of your bathroom and identify and replace leaky old pipes to fit a brand new budget shower that only cost £100 from the supplier?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 11:32

Fair enough, then, OneTC - at least you're owning it Grin

Thanks for your insights - interesting Smile

neighboursmustliveon · 27/10/2022 11:31

@Vickstory79

We DO live in a country where the FULL cost of goods and services, including labour, are included in the price we pay. There is no obligation to tip anyone. If companies think that their staff deserve to be laid higher, then increase your costs and pay your staff more. That way it's all above board, everyone is taxed corrected and if benefits are claimed, they are claimed on actual earnings, not the lower earnings paid by the employer and ignoring all tips that so many people think these staff are owed!

We do it as a social convention and yes have done for years, it started long before we had a NMW.

I always used to tip waiting staff and did think poorly of friends and family who didn't. Since the introduction of a NMW, I personally have phased out doing this.

I only ever really tip wait staff now if I am part of a large group as I do recognise that's its harder work to ensure 10 drinks/meals are ready at the same time than 4. However, I would tip based on the number of people served, not on the bill.

I all these posters calling non tippers rude, tightwads, telling us we shouldn't go out to eat are the ignorant ones. Just because you choose to do something, doesn't make it the only way to do something.

I guess this is one of the reasons I don't go to 'restaurants' and prefer the more relaxed pub style. I don't want to be waited on so much or have that personal service so many people seem to feel waiting staff give.

OneTC · 27/10/2022 11:21

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 11:00

Because it caps it. I've said that again and again.

So are you saying that serving staff want the best of both worlds - a socially-enforced minimum tip (with people accusing you of tightness and shaming you if you don't) but also the opportunity to earn more than that? On top of the NMW?

If your opinion is that waiting staff are in a lucrative job - guaranteed NMW, customary minimum 10% tips AND more on top of that if they 'perform' - and are in an empowered position where they can really cash in if they use their skill and charm, then fine; but the clear vibe I've been getting throughout this thread (and every other thread on tipping) is that waiting staff are poorly paid and are left desperately holding their hands out for more money in order to be able to make ends meet.

Further to this I was young. I did have rent and stuff to pay but it was cheap I just wanted money for partying and getting shitfaced. I do think that much of the quality is already gone from very much of the hospitality sector already as there's no career considered for most people in the industry. It used to be made up of students and older people who had been doing it for years and helped underpin a good level of service that people genuinely didn't resent tipping for.

I think it's rare that you actually encounter fully professional service anymore outside of very high end restaurants and even then they can be a bit hit and miss but I also think that despite the nmw that rents and stuff are not so comparatively cheap now. Living close enough to a central London restaurant that you can rent there viably is unlikely so high transport costs

Conkersareback · 27/10/2022 11:15

Vickstory79 · 27/10/2022 11:12

Would you ask your builder to only pay for the materials after they have carried out the work satisfactorily or do you pay the labour without thinking? Service is paying for labour, it pays part of the staff's wages. It's not difficult to understand. It's optional in case the service was bad not because you don't agree with paying for labour.

So you left £2.50 each as a tip?

You know that the £2.50 you left will be shared amongst other people, like the pot washers, table clearers etc.....don't you?

You know that your food bill covers the food, the chefs who made it, the cleaners, the electricity, the building rates, the menu prints etc.....and probably a small profit although not guaranteed with the cost of food currently.

You know that most of the staff get paid minimum wage and rely on the service element to live?

Just because you would prefer a system where the labour/service is included in the food price doesn't mean that you should refuse to pay it.

They didn't leave a tip at all!

OneTC · 27/10/2022 11:15

So you left £2.50 each as a tip?

No they didn't Grin