Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10% gratuity added to bill

739 replies

Byz · 24/10/2022 14:19

AIBU to be annoyed by a 10% gratuity charge being automatically added to my bill at a restaurant?

Seafood restaurant in the North East, a little town, not a city.

For four of us our bill came to about £230 and a £23 tip was automatically added to the bill. It did state at the bottom of the menu an optional charge would be added but they didn't ask me before actually adding it.
When the waitress brought the bill over she reminded us about the gratuity and said she would remove it if we prefer but I think I should have been asked if I wanted it adding in the first place. It was quite embarrassing to ask for it to be removed. She was polite about it but did seem a bit surprised.

Food was good, service was good and I would have left £10 but it soured the evening a bit so I left nothing. I don't think tips should be expected in this country.

OP posts:
juliaxxl80 · 28/10/2022 19:35

Exactly!

ForeverbyJudyBlume · 28/10/2022 18:21

As has been pointed out often on this thread, she didn’t leave. £10 – in the end she left a big fat zero!

Blanketpolicy · 28/10/2022 17:08

You don't think twice about spending £230 on food, but then think just £10 is a generous tip!

Unless you mean you would leave a £10 tip and the other diners would leave similar, four people leaving a £2.50/head tip on a £230 bill is tight as..... a very tight thing

Roselilly36 · 28/10/2022 16:56

This post is in the DM today

sentientpuddle · 28/10/2022 16:55

ZiriForEver · 26/10/2022 00:48

Does a cashier in a shop spend an hour, two hours, maybe more, attending to your needs? Providing personalised service? Recommending & possibly tailoring items for your consumption? Communicating with other departments (in the case of waiting staff - bar/kitchen/management) to ensure you have the best possible experience? Sort out problems? Take the flack when issues do arise? Chat to you if that's what you want? Take pictures of your party even though they have 10 other tables to tend to? Order a taxi for you when you're ready to leave? Recommend where to go next? Ultimately making a contribution to your enjoyment of your lunch or your night out? All the while making everything seem smooth & effortless, whilst doing the same for however many other tables/customers they need to take care of in the space of their shift, for hours on end, on their feet, with a half hour break (may be paid or unpaid / food may or may not be provided at a staff rate).
@sentientpuddle

Why thought? I just want to eat my meal. I don't need any photos taken or taxi ordered, I can read the menu and I know what are my plans after. I don't see the waiting staff as my personal servants thankful for a coin I might toss on them, I consider them part of restaurant organisation and want to deal with them in professional manner, and being able to set and communicate the price is part of the business.

The point was that it is a hugely different job to a cashier in a shop. Those interactions/transactions are usually pretty short. When you go out to eat you may be looked after for 2+ hours. From start to finish. Haven’t you ever had your eating out experience ruined by shite service? I know I have. Or had it made so much better by really good service? I certainly have.

Waiting/bar/hotel staff etc. are expected to, and often do, go above and beyond*, whether you want, need or get that from them or not is neither here nor there.

*above and beyond the bare minimum of taking orders, bringing food/drinks, taking payment.

You want to eat your food and be left alone? Competent waiting staff know which customers want to be left alone to eat in peace and leave. They step it up or hold back, they react to each new interaction as it happens. There is, although some are unwilling to believe it, more to the job than simply taking and clearing away orders, sometimes for very large parties (and getting them right the vast vast majority of the time, or efficiently sorting out mistakes if they do happen), then bringing the bill.

When I first started in a restaurant having had no experience, I watched other experienced staff rake it in. I wondered how I could improve to make decent tips like they did. It made me improve very quickly. Tips are a great incentive. No doubt there should be workplace bonuses for lowly waiting staff but it’s management who get bonuses.

There were people who came into my old place of work who got reputations for being tight-fisted. We never went out of our way for those people, they got consistently very good basic service (because of the nature of the establishment) but nothing more. Same in the pub I moved onto. I think people who don’t tip are a bit tight, but I still respect their decision not to.

It is horrible though when you're out with a group and one stingy effer refuses to contribute to the tip. It sours the experience.
The worst ones are when everyone from the table contributes cash + tip for their portion of the bill, ONE person puts the entire bill on their card (sans tip if no service charge) & pockets the cash including tip. So the cheap bastard has taken everyone else's tip contribution & the rest of the party are none the wiser! I've seen that happen quite a lot over the years. Even if you disagree with the practice of tipping, you'd have to agree that that's a really shitty thing to do.

Since working in hospitality, I am more discerning and have higher expectations of service, and I am less inclined to tip when the service isn’t up to standard. For eg. if someone fucked up my order but dealt with it well and sorted everything out, I’d still tip. If someone was efficient but treated me like an inconvenience, I wouldn’t tip. I don’t believe in tipping no matter what, and I would take issue with automatic service charges applied to all bills, unless the service was consistently v.good or I was part of a large party. Where I worked we stated VERY clearly on the menu ‘10% service charge applied to tables of 8 or more’. At xmas this was applied to 6 or more. Again, made very clear on the menu and at the time of booking.

Whether you agree or disagree with the custom of tipping, the fact remains that it is part of restaurant culture here. Your choice to not partake. No big deal.

I think the major reason for the OP pile-on is because she came on MN to bitch about it and ended up being really knobby about the server.

lilila · 28/10/2022 16:03

'above and beyond' to me would be making every every effort to make the experience as good as it can be, and giving the impression that they want to achive this. Examples would be attentive (I don't mean overbearing though!), happy to liaise to the chef with any queries (for example, to check if an ingredient may be changed)
I used to work in hospitality, always nice to recieved tips, but never expected
I now work in a hospital, I would sat that everyone in my team absolutely goes above and beyond for those in our care, and wouldn't dream of asking for anything in return. It is our job to help, which we do with pleasure.
I realise I might have contradicted myself a bit, but I don't begrudge giving a tip as much if I recieve great service (generally give tips because I feel I have to though)

BigAl66 · 28/10/2022 16:00

That should be 10% not 105

BigAl66 · 28/10/2022 15:59

If any restaurant adds a 10% optional tip, I always take it off and leave nothing extra.

On the other hand, if they don't add a tip, I will normally tip them 105, but only 10% of the food, not the drinks, wine, beer etc.

In some of these establishments a 330ml bottle of Bud is £4.99 (that's £9.98 a pint), the same bottle in the supermarket is 60p.

The same with wine, a bottle can be £18 - £22 but only £6 - £8 in the supermarket.

They make enough profit on it already without adding a further 10%

OneTC · 28/10/2022 15:37

BigAl66 · 28/10/2022 14:55

I did not mean take the tip back, I meant deducing 10% from the original bill, and giving no tip.

I've not paid for part of a meal before because it wasn't right and waiting for it to be remade would have messed with the overall meal.

You could try I suppose but you agreed the price for the food and drink when you ordered and they didn't offer an OPTIONAL 10% reduction do it's not really comparable

limitedperiodonly · 28/10/2022 15:33

Brokendaughter · 27/10/2022 22:15

Seriously, if a waitress had saved someones life then got back to work & I'd seen it even on another table, I'd be leaving that woman an extra tip.

If that is not above & beyond I don't know what is!

Seriously no I wouldn't give that person an extra tip.on top of what I was planning to leave. How could you repay someone for saving someones life? If you can do it that's what you do. It's grotesque to imagine that someone could save your life but started negotiating.for a tip before doing it.

I've given an example of an extraordinary happening of choking which may not be that extraordinary in a restaurant setting.

People are banging on about only leaving a tip for service that goes above and beyond. It's only fair to ask them what they mean by that.

I've asked @lillila but she's not the only one. What is the above and beyond service that would loosen their purse strings? It can't be that hard.

BigAl66 · 28/10/2022 14:55

OneTC · 28/10/2022 14:13

I've never had what I would say is bad enough service to withhold a tip.

I normally boost the added service charge with cash tip of I consider the service to be very good. What I consider to be very good service varies from place to place and meal to meal though, ie it has to be appropriate for the type of restaurant or night out

I did not mean take the tip back, I meant deducing 10% from the original bill, and giving no tip.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/10/2022 14:30

If your pay is shit either take it up with your employer or find a better job. That's what 99% of all other employees do on other industries

Precisely

FWIW I'm another who does tip unless the service has been really poor, but it's a bit ironic to read accusations of "selfish entitlement" directed at people who object, when perhaps the truly "entitled" are those who expect extra without ever offering a sensible reason beyond "It's always happened in hospitality"

OneTC · 28/10/2022 14:13

BigAl66 · 28/10/2022 13:39

So, if a customer was to decide that they have had a BAD service, would it be OK to automatically deduct 10%

I guess not.

I've never had what I would say is bad enough service to withhold a tip.

I normally boost the added service charge with cash tip of I consider the service to be very good. What I consider to be very good service varies from place to place and meal to meal though, ie it has to be appropriate for the type of restaurant or night out

portico · 28/10/2022 13:39

I think service charges/gratuities are a check. The vendors assume presumed agreement. I tip, but I tip what I based on the value I feel I have been offered by the waiters/waitresses. I don’t like having this tip pre-defined in the receipt. They do do this, so customers feel to embarrassed to kick up a fuss to have the service charge removed.

BigAl66 · 28/10/2022 13:39

So, if a customer was to decide that they have had a BAD service, would it be OK to automatically deduct 10%

I guess not.

Newmum0322 · 28/10/2022 11:45

@ivykaty44 because that’s what the cool kids read

KillingLoneliness · 28/10/2022 11:12

How is it mean and stingy to not give (a completely optional) tip? Your dd is paid a living wage, why should others who are also on the same wage pay her extra for just doing her job?
I don’t understand why servers are seen as deserving of tips when others on minimum wage aren’t, you don’t go round tipping care workers and they have a much harder job but imo they are more deserving due to the responsibilities they have and what they have to endure.

KillingLoneliness · 28/10/2022 11:08

@theddorai not in the UK.
Servers are paid minimum wage or more depending on where they work, they don’t need tips and it’s not a requirement, it’s always been optional and by the responses on this post those that do tip see it as some sort of social norm which I personally don’t agree with so therefore I don’t tip.

ivykaty44 · 28/10/2022 10:57

Newmum0322 why are you reading DM?

Newmum0322 · 28/10/2022 10:51

Anyone else see this thread in the daily mail today?!? 😂😂

Maverickess · 28/10/2022 10:46

memorial · 28/10/2022 04:40

I have reached the point where I wish tipping would stop tbh because all the shit that goes with it just is not worth an extra £20/30 a week. It's really not. I'd settle for just being treated like a human being at this stage 🤣.

I dunno where you work but my daughter makes a couple hundred pounds a week in tips. She works exceptionally hard as well as going to uni and earns every penny.
She works for a big chain and gets to keep cash tips and 50% of card tips/service charges (the other 50% going to kitchen/bar/managers etc NOT the company). She doesn't mind this at all and prefers it because it's amazing how many stingy bustards there are out there.
This thread is quite sad in its gaslighting meanness and attempts to justify just being stingy and mean hearted.
It's not a race to the bottom and I'm pretty sure those on here trying to justify their self indulgence aren't on minimum wage. Stop being so ridiculous and don't pretend you don't tip out of misplaced loyalty to other low paid workers. Just own your mean selfish entitlement.

Um ok 🤷🏼‍♀️

a) I tip if I go out to eat, which isn't very often admittedly, unless service is awful. But up until now I haven't said, so nice assumption there.

b) We share tips among everyone who works where I do, so they're lower than if you don't, because everyone from maintenance to FOH has a bearing on the level of experience you can provide. I realise I'm not some kind of rockstar because I'm FOH, and we get 100% of tips minus the tax paid. It's also shared based on hours worked.

c) I'm talking about my own experiences here of the treatment of service staff in general and how tipping for some, is another stick to beat them with and how the militant tippers who are so keen on defending waiting staff and getting tips don't seem to actually give a shit about that bit, but just want to virtue signal over their massive generosity, and slate those who feel differently. And an added service charge just adds to the issue there because it's a potential source of conflict for the customer who feels pressured to pay it and then takes that out on the person serving them (with unjustified shitty reviews like the OP here).

d) I actually made the same point further upthread about if you don't want to tip, then own your decision and don't make out like you haven't tipped because the service was lacking and then go be a keyboard warrior.

e) I do wonder why you felt the need to shoehorn in there how hard your DD works and that she's at university?

dutysuite · 28/10/2022 10:04

I decide how much to tip not the restaurant therefore, I hate any service being added and if the staff aren’t receiving it then I will ask for it to come off and personally tip them.

Codfishermen · 28/10/2022 10:01

Stop being so ridiculous and don't pretend you don't tip out of misplaced loyalty to other low paid workers. Just own your mean selfish entitlement.

Amen to that, sister!

BecksOclock · 28/10/2022 09:59

The way you're clutching at straws here to try and make yourself feel better because you've been pulled up on not leaving the £10 tip is really laughable.

OneTC · 28/10/2022 09:50

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 28/10/2022 08:54

Where are you all eating that tipping is normal? Think I've only been to half a dozen places in my life that add tip on.
Its not normal at all and more people need to stand up and call places out on it.

The UK in almost anywhere with table service