Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10% gratuity added to bill

739 replies

Byz · 24/10/2022 14:19

AIBU to be annoyed by a 10% gratuity charge being automatically added to my bill at a restaurant?

Seafood restaurant in the North East, a little town, not a city.

For four of us our bill came to about £230 and a £23 tip was automatically added to the bill. It did state at the bottom of the menu an optional charge would be added but they didn't ask me before actually adding it.
When the waitress brought the bill over she reminded us about the gratuity and said she would remove it if we prefer but I think I should have been asked if I wanted it adding in the first place. It was quite embarrassing to ask for it to be removed. She was polite about it but did seem a bit surprised.

Food was good, service was good and I would have left £10 but it soured the evening a bit so I left nothing. I don't think tips should be expected in this country.

OP posts:
Conkersareback · 25/10/2022 17:31

ShouldIdo · 25/10/2022 13:59

The story changed too much over a few hours to think that OP is anything other than tight and then trying to justify it.

14:19:- Food was good, service was good and I would have left £10

15:08:- She was a good waitress, quite attentive and did look after us but we weren't a demanding table and for £23 I would have expected a bit more

16:44:- We saw her at the bar, doing that stupid fancy shaking thing, messing about with the bartender, so definitely her fault. It was only 4 espresso martinis, waited about 15 minutes for them.

17:51:- I started thinking about all the ways she could have earned the 10% and it made me realise that she made too many mistakes and wasn't actually that good.

In three hours (after OP had been told yabu), the service went from good to actually it wasn't, I think the "she did that fancy shaking thing" was particularly nasty and uncalled for comment.

This!

reigatecastle · 25/10/2022 15:10

Devoutspoken · 25/10/2022 12:54

Does the op tip anyone anywhere ever? Tipping is random, i must admit I'm not a big fan of tipping black cab drivers and hairdressers, both are so expensive, but I still do, cos I can't help myself

I didn't even know that tipping hairdressers was a thing until I joined MN.

With a taxi, I'll usually round up, so if it's eg £8.50 I'll round up to £10. If it costs £10, that's what they get, they win some, they lose some.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/10/2022 15:05

Carers, like health care assistants or teaching assistants, aren’t usually allowed to accept tips. Their employers tell them not to because it’s unethical. Unlike restaurants who tell their clients they either have to tip exactly the amount they are told or go through the palaver of having this extra charge taken off.

You really can’t compare restaurant servers to carers. And cleaners usually earn more ph than minimum wage.

MillennialFalconer · 25/10/2022 14:45

@Worriedddd I don't have a cleaner or a carer, but if I did, yes I would tip - assuming they're via an agency (multitude of reasons, but let's assume the agency is taking a hefty cut of their rate). If they're independent and I'm dealing with them directly, then probably not, because they're setting their own rates.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/10/2022 14:41

Because you’ve already paid for food to be cooked as well as whatever they put on for overheads in the price of the meal.

If they think back of house staff should be paid more then they should pay them more, not subsidise their wage with tips that are supposed to have been earned based on the service the waiter/waitress provided.

Redup · 25/10/2022 14:40

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/10/2022 20:06

I get so annoyed when customers are the ones penalised for questioning tips when low wages and insecure work are the biggest problem facing service staff and that is an employers responsibility. Customers pay for the food, drinks and those prices ought to be enough for owners to to also cover wages of staff, if it doesn’t then their business model is failing.

I absolutely agree with you there.

Of course, I would never advocate being rude to the serving staff or blaming them for the policies of their employers that they're forced to be the public face of.

However, I'd love some of the people on this thread who are calling people 'tight' - even those of us who would be very happy to pay the full price that the business is wanting/expecting, but would just like to be given an inclusive price upfront - to explain exactly WHY they believe a tipping culture is a good thing in restaurants, when it isn't in almost all other NMW jobs. Not just to shout "Because it's tradition/customary" - because we have loads of traditions that haven't been maintained in modern times.

The tradition stems from putting the different classes in their place and forcing the working classes to rely on the arbitrary charity of the wealthy. NMW, although not amazing, was brought in specifically to entitle people to be paid a baseline amount and not to have to rely on altruism or charity for a living.

Anybody who has ever said "Why does XXX even have to be a charity and rely on public donations to do XXX essential work when it should be centrally funded by the government?" but who nevertheless actively wants to preserve the custom of tipping - not just as an occasional possibility for somebody to show gratitude for outstanding service but following the '10/15/20% is the accepted norm' line - I would ask how they square that manner of thinking.

If you want to campaign for a higher NMW across the board - or even just for restaurant staff, if they are your primary concern - then by all means go for it; but why is somebody a 'tightwad' for even questioning why they should have to pay the stated price of something and then be expected to pay another price on top of it in a restaurant?

Nobody says that if you only have £50 available, then you 'can't afford' £50-worth of shopping from Tesco, because you should somehow expect something priced at £50 to cost you £55 or £60.

I usually tip when I go to a restaurant, as I realise that it's customary, but I do not like this custom in the least. It's awkward and condescending if you do it, but because it's so ingrained, sends ambiguous messages if you don't. I am NOT looking to pay less, but I would really love it if restaurants would raise their prices accordingly and then make it abundantly clear that the stated price is an all-in price and is the total of what you pay - so you should settle your bill as given and pay not a penny more. Most other businesses can manage to do this - even other service/hospitality-based ones such as pubs and hotels - so why do we cling to this archaic, patronising, anti-egalitarian practice for restaurants?

You've said it so much better than I could have but I totally agree.

Gloryofthe80s · 25/10/2022 14:36

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/10/2022 14:30

If it’s all about tipping someone who has provided personalised one to one service, then why are so many people agreeing it’s ok for the restaurant to take the tips and share it out amongst everyone?

Restaurants can’t have it both ways.

It takes a team of people to get the food and restaurant ready for you to be able to get one one one service. How is that the restaurant having it both ways?

ClocksGoingBackwards · 25/10/2022 14:30

OneTC · 25/10/2022 10:35

lot of people here seem to be unable to distinguish between personal one on one service and someone who just happens to be employed by a company to provide an none personal service.

They're able to distinguish they just want to obfuscate their real motive

If it’s all about tipping someone who has provided personalised one to one service, then why are so many people agreeing it’s ok for the restaurant to take the tips and share it out amongst everyone?

Restaurants can’t have it both ways.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/10/2022 14:21

You sound rude, mean and pedantic.

Who was that to - and why?

It's on the menu. It says a tip will be added to your final bill. Don't want to pay that? Fine, eat elsewhere.

But why do they call it a tip when it isn't? And the discussion has expanded to all restaurants where tipping appears to be expected, not just the ones that tell you how much 'tip' they're going to take from you, unless you go through the extreme awkwardness of declining.

Notadramallama · 25/10/2022 14:05

I went for a meal with three friends. The service was terrible. So terrible that without us saying anything they took the cost of our desserts off the bill - then added the service charge!

We didn't pay it.

OneTC · 25/10/2022 14:03

Did all the people who claim that tipping is a recently imported concept from America have really tight parents by any chance? Cos where did anyone get the idea that it's recent? My 90 year old Scottish mum says it was standard practice when she was young. Also pretty standard to tip a small amount in cafes

ShouldIdo · 25/10/2022 13:59

The story changed too much over a few hours to think that OP is anything other than tight and then trying to justify it.

14:19:- Food was good, service was good and I would have left £10

15:08:- She was a good waitress, quite attentive and did look after us but we weren't a demanding table and for £23 I would have expected a bit more

16:44:- We saw her at the bar, doing that stupid fancy shaking thing, messing about with the bartender, so definitely her fault. It was only 4 espresso martinis, waited about 15 minutes for them.

17:51:- I started thinking about all the ways she could have earned the 10% and it made me realise that she made too many mistakes and wasn't actually that good.

In three hours (after OP had been told yabu), the service went from good to actually it wasn't, I think the "she did that fancy shaking thing" was particularly nasty and uncalled for comment.

OriginalUsername3 · 25/10/2022 13:58

We had 15% added to ours. Bloody ridiculous I think. It feels so rude to ask the waitress to remove it and I'd never tip that much.

Worriedddd · 25/10/2022 13:56

Guess that's why I'm having little problems with the COL crisis because I don't tip just about everyone just my hairdresser, cleaner and small amounts elsewhere. Take care of the pennies and the pounds look after themselves. To be honest I would pay a 10 percent service charge but if the restaurant was shite I just wouldn't go back. I have no issues being seen as tight.

JenniferJareau · 25/10/2022 13:53

I'd have no issue if somebody actively wanted to give them a tip, but it's the expectation that I think is all wrong. It's kind of socially enforced that you must pay extra

It's on the menu. It says a tip will be added to your final bill. Don't want to pay that? Fine, eat elsewhere.

roarfeckingroarr · 25/10/2022 13:52

You sound rude, mean and pedantic.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/10/2022 13:51

Why do you think an employer paying someone a wage would make them exempt from receiving a tip from a customer?

I'd have no issue if somebody actively wanted to give them a tip, but it's the expectation that I think is all wrong. It's kind of socially enforced that you must pay extra - as seen on this thread by all of the accusations of meanness hurled at people who disagree with tipping as a custom - by people who without a shadow of a doubt regularly enjoy many services provided by people on NMW and wouldn't even think of tipping the vast majority of them.

KatherineJaneway · 25/10/2022 13:51

Exactly! why would I tip for good service? that's what their job is about. Over and beyond, I will tip.

What is over and beyond?

Gloryofthe80s · 25/10/2022 13:41

Valid8me · 25/10/2022 12:42

I wasn't being patronising - just pointing out that someone who is doing their job gets paid for doing just that and therefore shouldn't get a tip as well.

Why do you think an employer paying someone a wage would make them exempt from receiving a tip from a customer?

Choconut · 25/10/2022 13:22

I can't remember the last time I went to a restaurant where this didn't happen, I've never been asked if I wanted it taken off either. Where do you live that this is so unusual?
Tipping has got ridiculous - £23 for how much work? Plus basic pay on top and the tips from all the other tables.

Jalepenojello · 25/10/2022 13:15

Why so many people are keen to push and encourage a tipping culture I have no idea.

id be baffled too OP

Unseelie · 25/10/2022 13:10

Lilithslove · 24/10/2022 14:27

I find it appalling that people who are happy to spend £230 on a meal begrudge someone on minimum wage a tip for good service. It's pretty disgusting that you decided not to tip on the basis of something that the waitress had no control over when she had given you good service.

I am guessing that you are in the fortunate position of never having had to work for minimum wage in the hospitality industry.

This.

A 10% tip being added to the bill has been standard in most of the UK for around forty years, OP, so dunno why it’s a shock to you.

You were just looking for an excuse not to tip. You obviously know on some level that you’re in the wrong, otherwise this wouldn’t be bothering you enough to post.

Go give £23 to a food bank to make yourself feel better. Or don’t, and carry on being someone who spends £230 on food and drink but doesn’t tip good food and good service. The world is lucky to have you 🙄

hotdiggetydog · 25/10/2022 13:08

The op is that tight I bet she squeaks when she walks.

Heartsofstone · 25/10/2022 13:02

I hate tipping. Isn’t that the benefit of NMW. Opinion is divided in tipping. Do what you want.

Devoutspoken · 25/10/2022 12:54

Does the op tip anyone anywhere ever? Tipping is random, i must admit I'm not a big fan of tipping black cab drivers and hairdressers, both are so expensive, but I still do, cos I can't help myself