Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10% gratuity added to bill

739 replies

Byz · 24/10/2022 14:19

AIBU to be annoyed by a 10% gratuity charge being automatically added to my bill at a restaurant?

Seafood restaurant in the North East, a little town, not a city.

For four of us our bill came to about £230 and a £23 tip was automatically added to the bill. It did state at the bottom of the menu an optional charge would be added but they didn't ask me before actually adding it.
When the waitress brought the bill over she reminded us about the gratuity and said she would remove it if we prefer but I think I should have been asked if I wanted it adding in the first place. It was quite embarrassing to ask for it to be removed. She was polite about it but did seem a bit surprised.

Food was good, service was good and I would have left £10 but it soured the evening a bit so I left nothing. I don't think tips should be expected in this country.

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/10/2022 04:37

I understand the national minimum wage and customs and all that stuff but it just seemed to me that most people I knew growing up and being a grown up (I'm in my 50s) tipped waiters and waitresses. Nothing to do with the US or the NMW or anything - just it was the custom - and I don't see how tipping has anything to do with women being paid less or whatever.

When did it become a thing that tipping a waiter is bad? When for decades in the UK it was the norm?

That was just my response to the many people claiming that not tipping is tight because waiting staff supposedly earn very little anyway; and the idea that, because it's a custom, we pay it without complaining or even questioning why, because that's just what you do with longstanding customs, even though there are plenty of other longstanding customs that we've gladly seen the back of.

If we collectively happily accept the idea that being a waitress/waiter is a privileged job that deserves to be paid a lot more than other jobs - like retail (where it is very well-known that it's the norm to face customers who behave appallingly and often abusively); or cleaning toilets (literally dealing with people's messy poo); or caring (again frequently providing very personal care: cleaning up poo, wee and sick and often routinely looking after people with dementia, which may well cause them to shout/swear/verbally abuse/lash out at you); to name just three.

However, this makes no sense at all when so many people justify tipping waiting staff by claiming that they work especially hard and, paradoxically, earn especially little as a job - when, for the last 20+ years, they've been paid at least NMW, just like many other jobs (such as the three always/usually untipped jobs I mentioned above).

As I said above, the only 'reason' that so many people offer when defending expected and socially-enforced (i.e. 'what a mean, unpleasant person you must be if you don't) tipping of waiters and waitresses is 'because you must tip waiting staff' without questioning it. I don't see how this is really any different from the many, many years when the custom of paying male employees more was expected and socially-enforced with the equally circuitous 'reason' that 'it's because men need to earn more than women' - and those of us who are 'decent people' apparently just accept this without ever questioning it.

Pallisers · 26/10/2022 03:16

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/10/2022 23:03

was it always the norm for people in the UK not to tip or to be outraged at the expectation of tipping?

I'm not really seeing outrage; but just because something is a custom, it doesn't mean that it should just continue forever unchallenged. If that were the case, we would still have men being paid proper salaries 'as they have to provide for their families' whilst a woman doing the exact same job would be given a few quid with the assumption that it's just treat money for her to spend on a new frock or a lovely hairdo.

In fact, we wouldn't have the NMW at all, as the previous custom until right up to the end of the last century was that, if an employee would work for what the employer was willing to pay (however desperate they were and however little alternative they had), everything was all just great and everybody can be happy.

I'm guessing that these two customs went hand-in-hand for a long time - like they still do in the USA - where, pre-NMW, a tip was in recognition of the fact that you were paid very little indeed. How come we're happy to get rid of the old custom of exploiting workers by offering no NMW protection, yet we still insist that we mustn't even question continuing the aligned custom of tipping waiting staff?

to be honest this answer doesn't help me understand the reaction on MN to tipping.

I understand the national minimum wage and customs and all that stuff but it just seemed to me that most people I knew growing up and being a grown up (I'm in my 50s) tipped waiters and waitresses. Nothing to do with the US or the NMW or anything - just it was the custom - and I don't see how tipping has anything to do with women being paid less or whatever.

Honestly, someone having a 230 bill for food not tipping anything is really really mean - and would have been in any decade of the 1900s and is still now. whether in the UK or whereever. We all know that. Not tipping on a 10 pound meal is one thing. not tipping on a 230 pound meal is just mean.

When did it become a thing that tipping a waiter is bad? When for decades in the UK it was the norm?

Kidsx6 · 26/10/2022 02:19

This is all over social media BTW. Very outing if the friends you ate with or restaurant staff see it

FunnyGirl70 · 26/10/2022 01:53

You spent that that much on a dinner for 4 people, and you are complaining about a 10% gratuity? I would have paid the 10% and added another 10%, as I typically tip 20% for good service. That being said, I think the bigger issue is, that the waitress asked you if you wanted it to be removed, and did so while remaining polite, and you punished her for something that is the restaurant’s policy and not hers! Shame on you!

ZiriForEver · 26/10/2022 00:48

Does a cashier in a shop spend an hour, two hours, maybe more, attending to your needs? Providing personalised service? Recommending & possibly tailoring items for your consumption? Communicating with other departments (in the case of waiting staff - bar/kitchen/management) to ensure you have the best possible experience? Sort out problems? Take the flack when issues do arise? Chat to you if that's what you want? Take pictures of your party even though they have 10 other tables to tend to? Order a taxi for you when you're ready to leave? Recommend where to go next? Ultimately making a contribution to your enjoyment of your lunch or your night out? All the while making everything seem smooth & effortless, whilst doing the same for however many other tables/customers they need to take care of in the space of their shift, for hours on end, on their feet, with a half hour break (may be paid or unpaid / food may or may not be provided at a staff rate).
@sentientpuddle

Why thought? I just want to eat my meal. I don't need any photos taken or taxi ordered, I can read the menu and I know what are my plans after. I don't see the waiting staff as my personal servants thankful for a coin I might toss on them, I consider them part of restaurant organisation and want to deal with them in professional manner, and being able to set and communicate the price is part of the business.

BananaGrana · 25/10/2022 23:05

I think this is area dependent. Wages generally aren’t high in the North East. It’s much cheaper to get someone to fit a kitchen, or decorate a room, or cut your hair than it is in the South. That’s why £23 seems like a huge amount to give to one person for providing a service.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/10/2022 23:03

was it always the norm for people in the UK not to tip or to be outraged at the expectation of tipping?

I'm not really seeing outrage; but just because something is a custom, it doesn't mean that it should just continue forever unchallenged. If that were the case, we would still have men being paid proper salaries 'as they have to provide for their families' whilst a woman doing the exact same job would be given a few quid with the assumption that it's just treat money for her to spend on a new frock or a lovely hairdo.

In fact, we wouldn't have the NMW at all, as the previous custom until right up to the end of the last century was that, if an employee would work for what the employer was willing to pay (however desperate they were and however little alternative they had), everything was all just great and everybody can be happy.

I'm guessing that these two customs went hand-in-hand for a long time - like they still do in the USA - where, pre-NMW, a tip was in recognition of the fact that you were paid very little indeed. How come we're happy to get rid of the old custom of exploiting workers by offering no NMW protection, yet we still insist that we mustn't even question continuing the aligned custom of tipping waiting staff?

OneFrenchEgg · 25/10/2022 22:59

I feel like this is a reverse.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/10/2022 22:53

Maverickess - I 100% agree.

mycatisannoying · 25/10/2022 22:50

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 24/10/2022 14:24

£10 is a bit tight on a £230 bill, especially as you say food and service was good. 23% would have been 10% and much fairer

She gave absolutely nothing though!

Maverickess · 25/10/2022 22:50

ShouldIdo · 25/10/2022 13:59

The story changed too much over a few hours to think that OP is anything other than tight and then trying to justify it.

14:19:- Food was good, service was good and I would have left £10

15:08:- She was a good waitress, quite attentive and did look after us but we weren't a demanding table and for £23 I would have expected a bit more

16:44:- We saw her at the bar, doing that stupid fancy shaking thing, messing about with the bartender, so definitely her fault. It was only 4 espresso martinis, waited about 15 minutes for them.

17:51:- I started thinking about all the ways she could have earned the 10% and it made me realise that she made too many mistakes and wasn't actually that good.

In three hours (after OP had been told yabu), the service went from good to actually it wasn't, I think the "she did that fancy shaking thing" was particularly nasty and uncalled for comment.

I don't think the OP is tight wanting to have the service charge removed - it's optional, as is tipping and each to their own.

What is unreasonable, and honestly a bit nasty is how the OP is going to take out their discomfort and possibly embarrassment at wanting the charge removed on the waitress by leaving a poor review of her - even though she'd already said she was happy with the service, the waitress was attentive etc, she's actively gone looking for things to complain about here to alleviate her own feelings about asking to have the service charge removed. So many people do this, and not just about a service charge, they get themselves wound up over complaining if something is wrong and then go in all guns blazing, I had someone do it to me tonight over something really, really easy to solve and that I had no issues solving at all, they just assumed I would have and went on the attack.

That's massively unfair. As I said in a pp if you don't want to tip or pay a service charge that's your decision, but don't try and alleviate any feelings you may have about that by making out the person serving you was at fault.

PinotPony · 25/10/2022 22:45

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/10/2022 22:33

if you can afford 230 quid on a meal you can afford the tip

How do you arrive at that, though? Most people have a finite amount of money in their bank accounts (or on available credit, I suppose). They aren't able to keep magicking an extra 10% on top and then another 10% on top of that, and then another 10% on the grounds that 'well, if you could afford the original amount....'.

You can't just set an arbitrary threshold above which you assume people have unlimited funds. Even a billionaire with exactly £50bn can't afford to pay a fiver more without going into credit reserves.

I know you will probably say that you have to allow for the tip and presumably order cheaper meals than you would like in order to have leeway for the extra charge; but this is my whole point about tipping in general and additional charges for the basics (whether technically 'optional' or not): I much prefer the business owner to tell me how much they want from me in exchange for the goods/services on offer rather than leave me guessing and/or doing the maths on their behalf.

It's an absolute fundamental of business that you add up all of your many costs and overheads, add on the amount of profit you need/want, and then present a price to the customer. If they are able and willing to pay that price, they will; if they can't or won't, you clearly don't have a business agreement, so the transaction could never take place anyway.

Would you be happy if a petrol station advertised its prices at the roadside and then, when you got to the pump, there was a very small notice saying that there is a 10% surcharge for using the pump or for parking next to it for two minutes?

I have a finite amount of money. When I eat out with friends, my budget for the evening includes the tip. If I couldn't afford the meal plus the tip, I either wouldn't go out or I'd suggest we dine at a cheaper establishment.

Dining out is a luxury purchase, in my opinion. It's not an essential cost, especially when money is tight. If OP can afford to foot the bill for a £230 food bill, she's not that hard up. Of course she could afford the tip. She freely admits that she gave nothing not because of a lack of funds but because she's a tight arse she chose not to.

Pallisers · 25/10/2022 22:43

was it always the norm for people in the UK not to tip or to be outraged at the expectation of tipping?

I know it is different in the US but growing up in Ireland if we went out for lunch or dinner, whether it was a hotel restaurant or a greasy spoon place, my parents would always have tipped - maybe not 10 percent but close enough. They are long dead now but they would think someone refusing to leave any tip at all on a 230 meal desperately mean.

once when we visited my very wealthy third cousin, I saw them saying thanks and tipping his live-in housekeeper when we left. I asked what they were doing and they said "well us staying her created more work for her so of course we tip her" I suspect they tipped my weekly cleaners too. My cleaners loved them.

Worriedddd · 25/10/2022 22:38

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/10/2022 22:33

if you can afford 230 quid on a meal you can afford the tip

How do you arrive at that, though? Most people have a finite amount of money in their bank accounts (or on available credit, I suppose). They aren't able to keep magicking an extra 10% on top and then another 10% on top of that, and then another 10% on the grounds that 'well, if you could afford the original amount....'.

You can't just set an arbitrary threshold above which you assume people have unlimited funds. Even a billionaire with exactly £50bn can't afford to pay a fiver more without going into credit reserves.

I know you will probably say that you have to allow for the tip and presumably order cheaper meals than you would like in order to have leeway for the extra charge; but this is my whole point about tipping in general and additional charges for the basics (whether technically 'optional' or not): I much prefer the business owner to tell me how much they want from me in exchange for the goods/services on offer rather than leave me guessing and/or doing the maths on their behalf.

It's an absolute fundamental of business that you add up all of your many costs and overheads, add on the amount of profit you need/want, and then present a price to the customer. If they are able and willing to pay that price, they will; if they can't or won't, you clearly don't have a business agreement, so the transaction could never take place anyway.

Would you be happy if a petrol station advertised its prices at the roadside and then, when you got to the pump, there was a very small notice saying that there is a 10% surcharge for using the pump or for parking next to it for two minutes?

This is what I don't like about the USA, they don't have transparent pricing at all. You get to the till and have to pay sales tax plus 20 percent tip on top of the menu price. I hope that never becomes common over here.

surreygirl1987 · 25/10/2022 22:33

I ate out at lunch today. 12.5% tip was added to the bill. We only ate there because I had a 15% off discount voucher... the discount just about covered the tip 🙈

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/10/2022 22:33

if you can afford 230 quid on a meal you can afford the tip

How do you arrive at that, though? Most people have a finite amount of money in their bank accounts (or on available credit, I suppose). They aren't able to keep magicking an extra 10% on top and then another 10% on top of that, and then another 10% on the grounds that 'well, if you could afford the original amount....'.

You can't just set an arbitrary threshold above which you assume people have unlimited funds. Even a billionaire with exactly £50bn can't afford to pay a fiver more without going into credit reserves.

I know you will probably say that you have to allow for the tip and presumably order cheaper meals than you would like in order to have leeway for the extra charge; but this is my whole point about tipping in general and additional charges for the basics (whether technically 'optional' or not): I much prefer the business owner to tell me how much they want from me in exchange for the goods/services on offer rather than leave me guessing and/or doing the maths on their behalf.

It's an absolute fundamental of business that you add up all of your many costs and overheads, add on the amount of profit you need/want, and then present a price to the customer. If they are able and willing to pay that price, they will; if they can't or won't, you clearly don't have a business agreement, so the transaction could never take place anyway.

Would you be happy if a petrol station advertised its prices at the roadside and then, when you got to the pump, there was a very small notice saying that there is a 10% surcharge for using the pump or for parking next to it for two minutes?

OneTC · 25/10/2022 22:22

Higher bottom line price excludes more people. I appreciate the reason some people might be leaving me a fiver or a tenner rather than the 23

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/10/2022 22:17

Like I said before prior say tight about non tippers because mostly the people that don't may have a hundred words to explain why they don't, but it mostly boils down to being tight, regardless of whatever they profess.

But you can't just assume you know people's motivations for their actions, even if there is a common cause. That just makes me think back to all the Brexit arguments, where it was taken as read by many that anybody voting leave was racist. Yes, I'm sure probably all the racists did vote to leave, but it would be faulty logic to take that to mean that all leave-voters were racist. Just like some of the Scottish independence supporters hate the English, but the vast majority don't in the least.

But I digress....

I mean you tip, so I don't know why you're arguing their side

I'm categorically not on the side of people who are rude to waiting staff and who blame them for policies made by management. I'm on the side of people who grudgingly follow a custom involving an opaque and (imho) dishonourable means of charging for goods/services - partly because of the narrow assumptions as you highlighted above but also because I don't want to ruin a waiter/waitress' day when they've come to expect being given extra as the norm - but who would far rather pay THE SAME AMOUNT OF MONEY AS YOU WOULD WITH TIPPING but presented in a fair, honourable and transparent way, not deliberately relying on social pressure, confusion and/or awkwardness - the same as most businesses seem to manage.

Devoutspoken · 25/10/2022 22:17

Health advice, oh come on, if you can afford 230 quid on a meal you can afford the tip

PhotoDad · 25/10/2022 22:08

As a PP has said, tips encourage good service. If nobody got them, it's likely that service levels would fall; what's the point in going above and beyond when you can get away with the minimum? There's a big difference between not giving a tip on the one hand, and actively complaining about a server on the other. Similarly, it's easier to give a tip than to praise a server to the management, so tips can be seen as a proxy for a satisfaction rating. Even if the restaurant operates a tip-sharing system, the high-tip-earners will be noted by the business.

OneTC · 25/10/2022 22:04

And will people stop pretending this is something new that's suddenly been foisted on our culture, tipping is completely standard in hospitality, both restaurant and bar work for as long as I've been alive and as long as my 90 year old mother has been alive. Those advocating not doing it are simply saying let's pay people less, let's change the cultural norm.

Why do this?

There's a wealth of places that already cater to your ways, why not stick with em?

PinotPony · 25/10/2022 22:02

I think you should simply avoid eating out in future OP. You clearly don't understand how to behave.

If you can afford a £230 meal, you can afford a £23 tip... but I suspect your mean disposition is what enables you to afford a £230 meal in the first place.

hiyaqwerty · 25/10/2022 21:56

I hate this service charge -tip, why should i feel obliged to pay when this is quite clearly your job, to wait and offer a good service.

NewYorkLassie · 25/10/2022 21:51

I'm annoyed and I've just received an email from the booking site to review the restaurant so definitely going to mention it.

Mention what? That you were too much of a tight arse to pay a tip? Your poor friends were probably so embarrassed, I would have been. (And yes, they could have left a tip but that would have been pretty awkward after you asked for the service charge to be removed).

OneTC · 25/10/2022 21:50

All the people who are doing it because of tips will stop doing it, and they're the people that make your night good. They'd have to stay recruiting from the miserable nmw lot who begrudge others tips and then restaurants would be fucked.

I wouldn't have spent years in hospitality if I thought I was gonna get paid slightly more, I wanted to get paid lots more and I put the effort in to achieve that