Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10% gratuity added to bill

739 replies

Byz · 24/10/2022 14:19

AIBU to be annoyed by a 10% gratuity charge being automatically added to my bill at a restaurant?

Seafood restaurant in the North East, a little town, not a city.

For four of us our bill came to about £230 and a £23 tip was automatically added to the bill. It did state at the bottom of the menu an optional charge would be added but they didn't ask me before actually adding it.
When the waitress brought the bill over she reminded us about the gratuity and said she would remove it if we prefer but I think I should have been asked if I wanted it adding in the first place. It was quite embarrassing to ask for it to be removed. She was polite about it but did seem a bit surprised.

Food was good, service was good and I would have left £10 but it soured the evening a bit so I left nothing. I don't think tips should be expected in this country.

OP posts:
misssunshinenow · 26/10/2022 13:11

I didn't read the whole thread but we always leave a tip. If I paid the whole bill it would have been up to my friends to tip.

IndysMamaRex · 26/10/2022 13:10

Wow a whole £10 for bill of over £200. If I was the waitress & you left £10 Id give it back since your clearly hard up for cash 😑you are aware the waitress has no control over restaurant policy. So you took her too away for something that isn’t her fault.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/10/2022 13:08

And my one and only point is that stop making up reasons. You don't want to give someone some money. You don't need a reason. No amount of flannel makes a difference. I don't even care if people don't want to tip. It makes no difference to my life now

I can't speak for others on this thread, but I've been quite active; and I have repeatedly said that I don't want to pay less than the true/expected price. Instead of charging, say, £100 for our food and drinks and then expecting a socially-enforced additional £10 or whatever, just charge me £110, with no awkwardness, no making staff have to 'perform' for half of their earnings, no tax-avoidance (or temptation to do so), no PA judgment of people who can't read your mind.

It's not a difficult business concept to give a customer a price that they are required to pay in order to get goods or services from you.

Again, it's very telling that none of the white-collar professions are happy to customarily invoice for half-market rates and then risk half of their income on whether or not somebody decides to tip them.

Helptoddlertroubles · 26/10/2022 13:04

You made it on to my fb feed OP 😆

Miserable to leave nothing. Not BU to be annoyed it was added automatically.

10% gratuity added to bill
mouse70 · 26/10/2022 12:48

I do not agree with giving a tip. Why should anyone get extra for doing their job.

OneTC · 26/10/2022 12:38

And my one and only point is that stop making up reasons. You don't want to give someone some money. You don't need a reason. No amount of flannel makes a difference. I don't even care if people don't want to tip. It makes no difference to my life now Grin

OneTC · 26/10/2022 12:35

The optional service charge addition has been pretty common for at least 25 years.

I imagine some restaurants started doing it in response to the knots that people tie themselves into to describe why they want someone to have less money

healthadvice123 · 26/10/2022 12:27

@OneTC no restaurant added a service charge years ago
Tipping is not new but always seen as a choice and the amount a choice
Years ago people also tipped bin men ,postmen etc not many younger generation do mow and they aren't allowed it
I asked at my local tip if I could take in some bits as couple guys were really helpful over and beyond as was told no

sentientpuddle · 26/10/2022 12:01

flowerycurtain · 26/10/2022 09:22

Genuine question, if the service charge is split out between staff and added to their payslip are they taxed on that?

Above was in response to this Q

sentientpuddle · 26/10/2022 11:58

Yes, it counts as taxable income.
Which is why, in the 1st restaurant I worked in, we always preferred cash tips, because we didn't have to declare it. The restaurant should have declared cash tips of course but didn't, and I imagine that's still the norm when cash tips are distributed amongst staff, ie don't go through management. We were told if cash tips go through management they had to be declared. It depends on how the management operate which, as I said before, depends on how they choose to operate / individual in-house policy. It ain't a regulated system.

OneTC · 26/10/2022 11:45

Squirelnutkins · 26/10/2022 11:05

Agree OP, If you want to reward the staff pay them a decent wage or add the cost on to the price of the meal. Optional Service charge no, I will not reward businesses expecting customers to make up a short fall or bonus for their staff.

As with any other job either do it well or employ some one who will. Its not my job to reward staff being paid to do a service they are employed and paid to do.

So you don't eat out?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/10/2022 11:33

If you’re doing well enough to eat out at table service restaurants you can afford to tip service staff surely.

There's a wide range of table-service restaurants, though - you could be at the Ivy, a two-for-a-tenner pub or anything in between. Even if you are at the Ivy, I don't get why you'd be expected to tip somebody not really for their service but essentially because you yourself are wealthy.

I’m in my 40s and have never not considered tipping.

But then it ceases to be 'tipping' as such, which is surely meant to be a special, considered way of thanking somebody for great service, if it's just something you do automatically? Not getting at you: it's the norm for most people to do it automatically; but that's what I personally have been going on about throughout this thread!

Squirelnutkins · 26/10/2022 11:05

Agree OP, If you want to reward the staff pay them a decent wage or add the cost on to the price of the meal. Optional Service charge no, I will not reward businesses expecting customers to make up a short fall or bonus for their staff.

As with any other job either do it well or employ some one who will. Its not my job to reward staff being paid to do a service they are employed and paid to do.

wonderstuff · 26/10/2022 10:55

I’m really surprised at this thread, I always give 10% unless service is poor. If you’re doing well enough to eat out at table service restaurants you can afford to tip service staff surely. If it’s stated that service is included I would only leave for very good service.
i don’t think this is a recent thing, I’m in my 40s and have never not considered tipping.

PhotoDad · 26/10/2022 10:41

flowerycurtain · 26/10/2022 09:22

Genuine question, if the service charge is split out between staff and added to their payslip are they taxed on that?

Yes, as far as I understand it. More detail on this page. I have just learned the rather wonderful word "troncmaster."

www.gov.uk/government/publications/e24-tips-gratuities-service-charges-and-troncs/guidance-on-tips-gratuities-service-charges-and-troncs

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/10/2022 10:20

It just adds even more to the opacity of the transaction when, as appears to be common, the service charge doesn't go straight to the server - at least not in full. Plus, do we know that it's accounted for fairly for tax purposes?

If the restaurant owner is going to randomly split out the cost of somebody taking your order and bringing your meals, why stop there? Why not have an extra separate charge for using their table and a chair, crockery charge, charge for using the toilets, charge for benefitting from their light and heating, charge for use of the cooker and fridge? Absurd and unrealistic? Yes; but what's the actual inherent difference, really?

flowerycurtain · 26/10/2022 09:22

Genuine question, if the service charge is split out between staff and added to their payslip are they taxed on that?

pimlicoanna · 26/10/2022 09:21

See the different reaction if you suggest they remove the tip from that bill and give it to them in full in cash. A small amount may go to them, but not all in the vast majority of cases.

QuebecBagnet · 26/10/2022 09:07

pimlicoanna · 26/10/2022 09:03

I'm amazed at how many people think that tip goes to the waiting staff when it's added directly to the bill like this.

Ok always ask the waiting staff and they always say it does go to them. 🤷🏻‍♀️ Guess they could just be told to say that?

pimlicoanna · 26/10/2022 09:03

I'm amazed at how many people think that tip goes to the waiting staff when it's added directly to the bill like this.

Passwordfail · 26/10/2022 06:52

OneTC · 25/10/2022 14:03

Did all the people who claim that tipping is a recently imported concept from America have really tight parents by any chance? Cos where did anyone get the idea that it's recent? My 90 year old Scottish mum says it was standard practice when she was young. Also pretty standard to tip a small amount in cafes

It’s absolutely been normal to leave a tip for a long time . The added service charge hasn’t though. At least you know leaving a tip on the table that it goes to the staff directly. And you can leave what you feel like , some posters are suggesting it’s embarrassing to leave £10. When lots of people earn that per hour , not just service staff .

SnackSizeRaisin · 26/10/2022 06:40

I would always tip 5-10% but I still think it needs to be optional. In the UK minimum wage applies and the cost of paying staff needs to be included in the prices. The tip is an extra. It's customary to tip but it's never been universal in the UK, plenty of people don't, and that is normal too.
Restaurant owners should include the cost of paying staff in the listed price just like any other business. Staff should do the job they are paid to without expecting extra money, just like any other business. I expect some places are doing this on response to a reduction in tips now everyone pays by card. But if you pay a tip on a card not much probably goes to the individual waitress. At best it gets split between all staff present at the time , at worst is goes to the owners of the business.

ivykaty44 · 26/10/2022 04:48

When you ordered, it would have been a good time to let the waitress know you didn’t want the 10% service charge added to your bill at the end of the meal.

you didn’t though, you could have said if you a add led for the bill.

strange that you were informed something was going to happen & are then upset it happens?

Badgirlriri · 26/10/2022 04:44

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/10/2022 04:37

I understand the national minimum wage and customs and all that stuff but it just seemed to me that most people I knew growing up and being a grown up (I'm in my 50s) tipped waiters and waitresses. Nothing to do with the US or the NMW or anything - just it was the custom - and I don't see how tipping has anything to do with women being paid less or whatever.

When did it become a thing that tipping a waiter is bad? When for decades in the UK it was the norm?

That was just my response to the many people claiming that not tipping is tight because waiting staff supposedly earn very little anyway; and the idea that, because it's a custom, we pay it without complaining or even questioning why, because that's just what you do with longstanding customs, even though there are plenty of other longstanding customs that we've gladly seen the back of.

If we collectively happily accept the idea that being a waitress/waiter is a privileged job that deserves to be paid a lot more than other jobs - like retail (where it is very well-known that it's the norm to face customers who behave appallingly and often abusively); or cleaning toilets (literally dealing with people's messy poo); or caring (again frequently providing very personal care: cleaning up poo, wee and sick and often routinely looking after people with dementia, which may well cause them to shout/swear/verbally abuse/lash out at you); to name just three.

However, this makes no sense at all when so many people justify tipping waiting staff by claiming that they work especially hard and, paradoxically, earn especially little as a job - when, for the last 20+ years, they've been paid at least NMW, just like many other jobs (such as the three always/usually untipped jobs I mentioned above).

As I said above, the only 'reason' that so many people offer when defending expected and socially-enforced (i.e. 'what a mean, unpleasant person you must be if you don't) tipping of waiters and waitresses is 'because you must tip waiting staff' without questioning it. I don't see how this is really any different from the many, many years when the custom of paying male employees more was expected and socially-enforced with the equally circuitous 'reason' that 'it's because men need to earn more than women' - and those of us who are 'decent people' apparently just accept this without ever questioning it.

I agree. “It’s just the done thing” doesn’t make it right.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/10/2022 04:42

Apologies, the above confusingly-unfinished paragraph beginning 'If we collectively....' should have ended with 'to name just three - then all well and good, as long as we're all on the same page when it comes to how much we particularly value waiting staff as a more difficult and/or more important job'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread