Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10% gratuity added to bill

739 replies

Byz · 24/10/2022 14:19

AIBU to be annoyed by a 10% gratuity charge being automatically added to my bill at a restaurant?

Seafood restaurant in the North East, a little town, not a city.

For four of us our bill came to about £230 and a £23 tip was automatically added to the bill. It did state at the bottom of the menu an optional charge would be added but they didn't ask me before actually adding it.
When the waitress brought the bill over she reminded us about the gratuity and said she would remove it if we prefer but I think I should have been asked if I wanted it adding in the first place. It was quite embarrassing to ask for it to be removed. She was polite about it but did seem a bit surprised.

Food was good, service was good and I would have left £10 but it soured the evening a bit so I left nothing. I don't think tips should be expected in this country.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ivykaty44 · 03/11/2022 15:52

And if you believe a cash in hand tip is declared by the business or staff your being daft.

having been questioned over tips by HMRC, its something that has to be done in many cases - its an expectation that waiting staff are tipped. HMRC can change your tax code to reflect this if they deem appropriate

MercedesD · 03/11/2022 00:58

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 10:25

And if you believe a cash in hand tip is declared by the business or staff your being daft.

i wasn’t talking about cash in hand tips I was talking about service charge. However yes by law they should be declared and taxed, the fact that it is difficult to do and keep track of if another reason why service charge works better/ is easier.

mast0650 · 02/11/2022 14:51

But don't you see how much more honest and transparent that would become?

But don't you see that if you read my next paragraph I agree with you that it would be a better (fairer, more transparent) system! But it's not the system we have. And given the system we have, the unfair subsidy primarily goes from the restaurant goers like me who pay the service charge to those who don't pay but still benefit from the lower prices. I don't think the overall level of wages or restaurant profits are affected.

DesdamonasHandkerchief · 01/11/2022 13:29

I hate the fact that service charge is added as standard in so many places.
If food and service is good I will leave a 10% tip, it would have to be exceptional to leave more than that so I'm particularly pissed off when 12.5% is added.

I have never asked for service charge to be removed (despite lack lustre service on occasion) because I think doing so would be embarrassing, but I'm sure that adding it to the bill as a matter of course does nothing to encourage good service.

Maverickess · 01/11/2022 10:46

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 10:25

And if you believe a cash in hand tip is declared by the business or staff your being daft.

Mine is, it's shared out between all staff once a month and put on your wages, have worked places it wasn't but it's a lot tighter these days and HMRC do investigate things like this so it's a risk not doing it properly.

Dinoteeth · 01/11/2022 10:25

MercedesD · 31/10/2022 16:25

They do have to declare them as Income, they are taxed and are taken into account for benefits.

And if you believe a cash in hand tip is declared by the business or staff your being daft.

BellaCiao1 · 01/11/2022 10:23

Minxy0717 · 31/10/2022 14:42

Definitely are. It's just entitled and rude to not leave a tip. Most people who get tips live off of them. I used to get maybe 300 in tips a month and less then 200 on my checks. It would be $70 here and there cuz tips are what they live off of. If you don't want to me a decent human being and pay the basic 15% then make the food at home.

Talk about misplaced blame.

The onus is on the restaurant to pay its staff a fair, living wage. Not on the public to subsidise wages.

I find the expectation of tips for doing a job where providing is expected is entitled. A tip should be reserved for when staff go above and beyond, not for completing their expected duties.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 01/11/2022 10:20

Nowadays most people tip between 15% and 20%.

Regardless of which country we're discussing, I still don't get why it seems to be expected that percentages should rise over time. If prices rise with inflation, surely that's already covered?!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 01/11/2022 10:16

Yes, MichelleScarn - very good analogy. I was trying to think of one, but couldn't!

OnTheRoll · 01/11/2022 09:44

xanaduimages · 31/10/2022 22:17

Seriously...you need to stop going to restaurants, and eat at home. This is how waitresses earn a living. So this poor waitress waited on you and your friends all night long; and because you got your little keester been out of shape... You punished her? Everybody knows a minimum of 10% is standard. Nowadays most people tip between 15% and 20%. So even 10% was hitting way below the belt. Most of the time these are management rules, not the servers. You should have complained to the management. Not punish this poor waitress. Shame on you! The right thing to do would be to go back and give her a cash tip; and apologize for your bad attitude. Cuz personally... I would never want to see you in that restaurant ever again, if I was her.

For God's sake... the "poor waitresses" earn a living by earning a wage, like anyone in this country.

Subbaxeo · 01/11/2022 07:22

I would’ve been embarrassed if I’d hosted a meal and then got the SC removed after good service. Especially if I’d tried to justify it by claiming the service was poor because she ‘didn’t work hard enough’ rather than the real reason was me being stingy.

MichelleScarn · 01/11/2022 07:16

Quite right @WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll it'd be (not as extreme!) like discussing needing medical treatment like insulin or epipen and someone from UK saying to someone from US, "I would absolutely not accept getting asked to pay for that! Go to the papers and complain to your mp!".
(If that makes sense?)

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 01/11/2022 00:50

It's really interesting to hear of the tipping customs in different countries, but I think we're running the risk here of arguing apples against oranges, if we don't distinguish where we're talking about.

MichelleScarn · 31/10/2022 22:53

@xanaduimages are you also in the US?

xanaduimages · 31/10/2022 22:17

Seriously...you need to stop going to restaurants, and eat at home. This is how waitresses earn a living. So this poor waitress waited on you and your friends all night long; and because you got your little keester been out of shape... You punished her? Everybody knows a minimum of 10% is standard. Nowadays most people tip between 15% and 20%. So even 10% was hitting way below the belt. Most of the time these are management rules, not the servers. You should have complained to the management. Not punish this poor waitress. Shame on you! The right thing to do would be to go back and give her a cash tip; and apologize for your bad attitude. Cuz personally... I would never want to see you in that restaurant ever again, if I was her.

MissConductUS · 31/10/2022 19:43

Orchidland · 31/10/2022 19:31

It is not. What you may not know it that servers MUST pay buss boys, runners, hostess etc... 90% of restaurants, hotels have this policy. Doesn't matter if the guest tips or not. So, you think is it fair for the server to pay theirs coworkers at the end of the day for serving you?. It is SO unfair. I understand your position regarding tips but you should think about the servers paying from their own pockets for serving you and next time you go out, go to a place where your presence doesn't cost money to other people.

This is the common practice in the US. The server has to tip out a percentage of his or her sales, not tips. So a non-tipper will cost them money.

Orchidland · 31/10/2022 19:31

It is not. What you may not know it that servers MUST pay buss boys, runners, hostess etc... 90% of restaurants, hotels have this policy. Doesn't matter if the guest tips or not. So, you think is it fair for the server to pay theirs coworkers at the end of the day for serving you?. It is SO unfair. I understand your position regarding tips but you should think about the servers paying from their own pockets for serving you and next time you go out, go to a place where your presence doesn't cost money to other people.

Bukybuky · 31/10/2022 17:11

ZiriForEver · 31/10/2022 16:54

The forum in general isn't Europe only or more specifically UK only, but is is kind of UK default.

This thread was started in UK context, it was acknowledged many times here that American situation is different (starting with lower minimal wage for tipped proffesions in America, which isn't a thing in the UK/Europe).

You are welcome to the discussion, just be aware of the context and don't call everyone else spoiled brats :)

Ok. Thank you for the info. Just to be clear, I called majesty, not a spoiled brat. Oh I also said. entitled. Now I'm not sure what I said, but spoiled brat doesn't sound like me. :-)

ZiriForEver · 31/10/2022 16:54

Bukybuky · 31/10/2022 15:13

My apologies, I didn't know this was only for Europeans.. I'm American and proud to support our hard-working staff with tips.

The forum in general isn't Europe only or more specifically UK only, but is is kind of UK default.

This thread was started in UK context, it was acknowledged many times here that American situation is different (starting with lower minimal wage for tipped proffesions in America, which isn't a thing in the UK/Europe).

You are welcome to the discussion, just be aware of the context and don't call everyone else spoiled brats :)

MercedesD · 31/10/2022 16:25

Dinoteeth · 31/10/2022 13:06

Aye, maybe I'm a cynic, but they aren't putting that law through for the benefit of waiting staff.
How long before people are forced to declare it as income, taxed / IN and taken into account for benefits?

They do have to declare them as Income, they are taxed and are taken into account for benefits.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 31/10/2022 16:05

No, not really. Without the tipping system (and I still believe that most guests in the restaurants I eat at accept that it is a system) the wages would increase and the prices would increase and on average employers would be unaffected. Those people who tip like me would be slightly better off. Those people who don't tip would be worse off. It's pretty clear who benefits from the voluntary tipping system!

But don't you see how much more honest and transparent that would become? Instead of subbing low-paying employers who are then able to drum up more turnover by advertising artificially-low prices - with the caveat that, if the customer doesn't then bump it up as expected, they aren't the ones who lose out - you would then be supporting respectable employers who pay their staff a fair guaranteed wage and present an honest upfront price for you to decide whether or not to give them your business.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 31/10/2022 15:59

How long before people are forced to declare it as income, taxed / IN and taken into account for benefits?

But why shouldn't they? If they work in a job that is mainly NMW, BUT they routinely often get given extra money as part of a longstanding socially-enforced custom, which has the effect of bumping up their earnings quite considerably, why should they pay a lower effective tax rate than somebody else on NMW who does actually only take home NMW?

It's not even like most of the tips are given as a response to amazing service (not that that counts when assessing earnings for tax) - most tips are given because people (as we've seen many times on his thread) assume that you are expected to hand over more money, without even considering whether or not you should.

In general, the economy works on the basis of the more you earn, the more tax you pay - but you still get to keep the majority of the extra earnings, so you should always be better off the more you earn. Nobody has to pay any income tax at all if they don't want to - as long as they're prepared to earn no more than their personal tax-free allowance.

essex42 · 31/10/2022 15:37

I always tip in restaurants and prefer it when it is automatically added. Never quite sure what to do in hotels though - we stayed at a gorgeous hotel in the Lakes last week and I asked them to add 10% to the total bill. What do most people do? You don't tend to tip at the table when eating in a hotel. These sorts of conversations are interesting as we enjoy cruising and mainly travel on American cruiselines where around $18 dollars pppd is added to your bill but people generally still tip more - sometimes considerably more. Some tip the bartender $2 for every single drink. Very different culture.

mast0650 · 31/10/2022 15:16

Do you never think that you may be subsidising low-paying employers, though, rather than random other customers who are given a price and expect that to be the price - as with just about every other business where goods and/or services are being sold?

No, not really. Without the tipping system (and I still believe that most guests in the restaurants I eat at accept that it is a system) the wages would increase and the prices would increase and on average employers would be unaffected. Those people who tip like me would be slightly better off. Those people who don't tip would be worse off. It's pretty clear who benefits from the voluntary tipping system!

I agree that it is odd that it only works like this in the restaurant sector. I agree that it would probably be better that it didn't work like this. But as long as this is the social norm that most of us follow, we are subsidising those people who refuse to pay.

I'd love to see figures on this. Based on my experience i would have thought 95%+ of diners tip 10% or more, whether or not it is automatically included. Based on posters here, perhaps I am wrong.

Bukybuky · 31/10/2022 15:13

ZiriForEver · 31/10/2022 15:10

In what dream is 20% standard and compulsory tip anywhere in Europe?

Those people are employees of the restaurant at the first place and their salary is responsibility of their employer.
Actually, the servant terminology works the other way round, they aren't my servants waiting for a coin I might drop. They are employees of a business which should deal with the money for everyone (they state a price and I pay it by one tap of my card, they employ staff and pay them, no need for extra bills changing hands like in medieval times)

My apologies, I didn't know this was only for Europeans.. I'm American and proud to support our hard-working staff with tips.

Swipe left for the next trending thread