Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to totally separate finances from DH?

59 replies

Jane054848 · 24/10/2022 13:53

DH hates his job and wants to quit. He does have a plan to retrain in something but will be a couple of years before he can earn anything, and it might always be quite minimal. I can't persuade him to retrain first.

I earn enough to support the family, including supporting DH not working/only working a little bit...but it would impact on things I want to save for such as retirement, kids' uni, helping kids with house deposit in the future.

We've had completely joint money (one joint bank account) since we started living together 20ish years ago.

But if he's going to be significantly reducing his work/income, I'd like to move to having our own separate money. My proposal:

  • he'd do more housework/childcare (kids are teenagers)
  • we'd contribute to all bills, household expenses, family stuff, outings, holidays etc in proportion to our incomes (so if he's earning nothing he'd pay nothing, if earning 20% of what I earn he'd contribute 20%)
  • whatever is left, we keep separately and do what we want with it. So in theory if he did no work he wouldn't have any "fun" money (but he'd have a year's redundancy pay to tide him over the first couple of years).

Why I'm proposing this:

  • He's quite unmotivated to earn money (because my earnings cover our needs) and doesn't always place much value on our joint money.
  • I think I'd find the situation less annoying if I don't feel like I'm the only one taking a "hit" in my lifestyle/saving goals because of his career change.

But he hates this idea. His view is, we can afford for him to do this and our money is "our" money and we should keep it that way. He says if it wasn't for me he would have quit ages ago - and that if our positions were reversed, he'd be happy to support me. Both probably true.

AIBU? I really can't tell. I'm sure a nicer person would just say that there's no reason for him to work if we can afford for him not to, and no reason why this should impact our financial arrangements.

(And apologies for even asking this question when others have genuine and serious financial problems. I know this is pretty self-indulgent and privileged).

OP posts:
Stankonia · 24/10/2022 14:10

Yeah, I bet he wants to quit and become a stay at home parent now that the children don't need parenting! Would I fuck out up with this. He's effectively retiring early on your dime. It's easy to say he would be happy for you to do it when he know that you can't and won't because he will be unemployed.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 24/10/2022 14:07

Our money has been separated for years, ever since H ran up an enormous overdraft on the joint account that I didn’t use at all. I didn’t even have a debit card for it but the bank chased me for the money 🤬because it was still in joint names.
I don’t trust him for a number of reasons so if you have doubts OP you should separate the money now.
I’ve ended up being the major breadwinner and paying for nearly everything because H won’t contribute.
If it wasn’t for the fact that I an damned if he’s getting half the house (that I have paid for nearly single handed), my pension etc I’d have left years ago.

Theredjellybean · 24/10/2022 14:07

I would feel exactly the same.
If he had a firm plan..had retraining organized and had got a small job at weekend or evening already sorted, and he'd been pro active ..showing clear budget of what he was proposing, how long you'd both have to halt pensions/savings etc
Then I'd be happy to support as you are a team..but your post implies he is rather looking to quit as he doesn't like working at current job but plans going forward are vague.
My fear would be he'd drift along rather liking not working...

SudocremOnEverything · 24/10/2022 14:06

DashboardConfessional · 24/10/2022 14:01

Well. On Mumsnet a lot of people say all the money is family money but I'm not sure I think that's unilaterally the case.
DH currently earns 3x what I do so I can work part time with a 3 year old but also because I'm retraining. Once 3 year old is at school I'm not sure how he'd feel if I remained on 20 hours a week because I felt like it. The idea is my hours and earnings will match his again eventually.

I think this is fair. The principle at work is about both of you putting in equivalent levels of effort to the household. You might be working and earning less but your contribution is of incredible value.

The OP is in a situation where her husband has decided that he doesn’t want to contribute to the house hold. He doesn’t want to work but he isn’t offering anything of value in return. He wants to put less in but get the same out. That’s not ok.

xogossipgirlxo · 24/10/2022 14:06

At first, I wanted to say YABU, because if he's miserable in current job then if I were you, I'd support him, but then I saw "He's quite unmotivated to earn money (because my earnings cover our needs) and doesn't always place much value on our joint money." and I think YANBU. I think he's bit too late to retrain and work PT or nothing, since you have kids to provide for... I also agree with him taking the burden of housework.

Mynoodlesareoodles · 24/10/2022 14:02

Is he planning on getting another job? When is he going to start training? I don't think you're out of order at all. I'd be cross anyway that he didn't value my contribution and i wouldn't support him unless he could be trusted to start training asap and return to work as soon as he qualified. Can he train and work p/t?

DashboardConfessional · 24/10/2022 14:01

Well. On Mumsnet a lot of people say all the money is family money but I'm not sure I think that's unilaterally the case.
DH currently earns 3x what I do so I can work part time with a 3 year old but also because I'm retraining. Once 3 year old is at school I'm not sure how he'd feel if I remained on 20 hours a week because I felt like it. The idea is my hours and earnings will match his again eventually.

SudocremOnEverything · 24/10/2022 13:57

and that if our positions were reversed, he'd be happy to support me. Both probably true.

I wouldn’t assume this one is true. It’s easy to say, especially when you’ve not asked him to financially support you like that. But the reality is, I doubt he’d be that keen to be the one supporting the family while you decided to piss about. And wanted your spending not to be curtailed.

fatshitcrazy · 24/10/2022 13:56

I'm pretty sure there will be lots of reply's stating your way of thinking is financially abusive and not in the spirit of partnership but honestly I'm with you in this one. I would be extremely resentful at my partner unilaterally deciding they weren't going to contribute anymore and that they expect you to just be alright about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread