Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to totally separate finances from DH?

59 replies

Jane054848 · 24/10/2022 13:53

DH hates his job and wants to quit. He does have a plan to retrain in something but will be a couple of years before he can earn anything, and it might always be quite minimal. I can't persuade him to retrain first.

I earn enough to support the family, including supporting DH not working/only working a little bit...but it would impact on things I want to save for such as retirement, kids' uni, helping kids with house deposit in the future.

We've had completely joint money (one joint bank account) since we started living together 20ish years ago.

But if he's going to be significantly reducing his work/income, I'd like to move to having our own separate money. My proposal:

  • he'd do more housework/childcare (kids are teenagers)
  • we'd contribute to all bills, household expenses, family stuff, outings, holidays etc in proportion to our incomes (so if he's earning nothing he'd pay nothing, if earning 20% of what I earn he'd contribute 20%)
  • whatever is left, we keep separately and do what we want with it. So in theory if he did no work he wouldn't have any "fun" money (but he'd have a year's redundancy pay to tide him over the first couple of years).

Why I'm proposing this:

  • He's quite unmotivated to earn money (because my earnings cover our needs) and doesn't always place much value on our joint money.
  • I think I'd find the situation less annoying if I don't feel like I'm the only one taking a "hit" in my lifestyle/saving goals because of his career change.

But he hates this idea. His view is, we can afford for him to do this and our money is "our" money and we should keep it that way. He says if it wasn't for me he would have quit ages ago - and that if our positions were reversed, he'd be happy to support me. Both probably true.

AIBU? I really can't tell. I'm sure a nicer person would just say that there's no reason for him to work if we can afford for him not to, and no reason why this should impact our financial arrangements.

(And apologies for even asking this question when others have genuine and serious financial problems. I know this is pretty self-indulgent and privileged).

OP posts:
NotLactoseFree · 24/10/2022 15:39

I don't think the issue is shared /seperate finances. The issue is that you don't seem to be a partnership - he wants to quit and retrain, is quite happy to take the financial hit, and does not believe your concerns/desires regarding finances are relevant

There needs to be a compromise. Yes, he has to now take on ALL of the domestic and household chores. Also, that perhaps he has to take on some part time/casual work as a way to contribute to his share of the cost of any social/fun activities. Or he has to take the bulk of the hit when it comes to "extras". Or whatever it is that you both decide.

For the record, DH earns a fraction of what I do. We've had entirely shared finances since we had DC. But I am not resentful because we are a partnership. When money is tight, we both pull back. He does loads to make it easier for me to work and earn the money (including working part time and doing all the childcare etc).

singlemomof3 · 24/10/2022 15:34

I agree with you OP wholeheartedly but many women on are effectively your DH in this scenario and would be up in arms crying emotional abuse

I always earned more than my STBEXH through his own lack of motivation. Spending money/fun money was proportioned to income

Paq · 24/10/2022 15:33

He needs to compromise. Marriage/partnership doesn't mean unconditional, open ended financial support for another adult.

Your proposal seems fair tbh. He will have some redundancy money plus he can choose to work part time around his studies.

Jane054848 · 24/10/2022 15:23

These responses are so helpful! Thank you.

@katieak - beautifully phrased, this is exactly what I want to say but you put it so much more tactfully!

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune - currently he's a senior policy person for a charity, future would be counselling, but he's only moderately keen on that and it's 4 years to fully train.

@Discovereads he is resigning but would probably be able to blag redundancy pay.

@ lots of people - he genuinely plans to retrain, but I do think there's a reasonable chance he will realise it's not for him, and he would be OK with it being a relatively low key time commitment.

also @ lots of people - he would genuinely do stuff around the house. He already works part time whereas my job is very full on, and he does most of the housework and child wrangling.

We'd originally said he should retrain while working but he hates it so much, he wants to accelerate & quit now.

@hoorayandupsherises - I know exactly what you mean. Feel like proposal comes across as (and maybe is) punitive. But I don't like the alternative either.

OP posts:
ForgottenNurseryRhymes · 24/10/2022 15:20

I'd do it your way, I would end up resenting him and it would eventually end in a break up.

Quartz2208 · 24/10/2022 15:15

Is he just quitting or taking redundancy?

Because it is an important distinction. I have been made redundant through no fault of my own (there were 30 of my position in Jan, 10 took vol redundancy in May, 3 have left and another 7 of us were made redundant last month as the work is being offshored). And I am changing career - but I am doing something. Still working and have picked up some zero hour contracts in what I want and applying for jobs. I am moving into public sector so the pay is much less than private so it will be a hit. I will supplement this with freelance work if possible from my old job but cant for a year and it also may have all gone.

he'd do more housework/childcare (kids are teenagers)

Goes without saying. I think you also need to see the retraining as something to support.

Not doing anything though is where the line should be drawn

KettrickenSmiled · 24/10/2022 15:01

To answer your question OP - do you want separate finances?
If you do, then have them.

Your husband, after all, is doing exactly what HE wants without caring how it affects you. Don't be a mug, don't enable an emergent cocklodger.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 24/10/2022 14:59

DH and I have totally separate finances. Don't even have a joint account.

We don't have children together though. We pay "our" bills, which we split fairly equally when we moved in. Mine include the gas and electric, so I'm now kicking myself for that 🤦‍♀️

KettrickenSmiled · 24/10/2022 14:58

Happiness is more important than a salary.

FFS. I find that happiness tends to be a little hard to sustain when skint.
Maybe you should try extreme poverty for a while @katieak before making such glib remarks.

LolaSmiles · 24/10/2022 14:58

I generally think family money is family money, but that's based on the premise that both adults are on the same page about money, spending, saving, their long term future. Ordinarily it's entirely reasonable to me for a marriage to have give and take financially as life can throw ups and downs at couples.

The red flag for me is when anyone in a partnership wants to opt out of their financial responsibilities indefinitely and assumes that the partner will happily shoulder the household finances.

If he wants to retrain he should make a plan, do what he can whilst working (like most other people) and if he isn't willing to make a plan and keep pulling his weight then it's clear he is hoping to drift into becoming a long term cocklodger.

KettrickenSmiled · 24/10/2022 14:53

But he hates this idea. His view is, we can afford for him to do this and our money is "our" money and we should keep it that way. He says if it wasn't for me he would have quit ages ago - and that if our positions were reversed, he'd be happy to support me. Both probably true.

Are they?
Because the situation isn't reversed. Words are cheap.
If I won tje lottery I'd send you a million quid, See? It's that easy. So send me a million quid now won'
t you OP? - because you KNOW I'd do it for you!

And he is bullshitting for Britain with his "if it wasn't for you I would have quit years ago". If it wasn't for you, being there to cover all his expenses, he would be able to afford to quit would he?

DH hates his job and wants to quit. He does have a plan to retrain in something but will be a couple of years before he can earn anything, and it might always be quite minimal. I can't persuade him to retrain first.
Don't sit back & let him ride roughshod over you like this OP.
He's not talking about being a SAHP, he's talking about jacking in his job, retraining "in something" (how much happy confidence that nebulous phrase must strike in your heart!), earning fuck-all for 2 years, then probably only earning beans, if he ever gets back to earning.

People can retrain while in work.
People manage entire university degrees while supporting themselves with work.
Why does he feel entitled to leech off you like this?

He agreed to buy or rent your home together. He doesn't get to just jack that responsibility in & live off you.
Do you even have DC? If you do, how does he plan to support them?
If you do not, how can you tolerate this level of disrespect & bullshit?

Don't do it OP. I've been where you are now & it cost me my dream home.

Discovereads · 24/10/2022 14:50

he'd have a year's redundancy pay to tide him over the first couple of years

So is he resigning or being made redundant? If he’s being made redundant your whole proposal is punitive as a pp said. It’s also a major change from how you have managed finances as a couple for twenty years. I don’t think a redundancy combined with a realisation that retraining is needed for future employment really warrants the whole “I don’t trust you to not become a cocklodger” narrative you’ve used to justify separating out finances.

AnneLovesGilbert · 24/10/2022 14:43

He should be working. If he can’t hack his current job he should find something less stressful and retrain at the same time. Very easy for him to claim he’d be fine with you loafing around when he won’t have to do it!

What benefit is there to you or the DC of him hanging out at home? You know he wont take over the household stuff, he’ll be “busy” working on some project or scheme or other and you’ll end up doing everything on top of your job and single handedly funding the whole family.

satelliteheart · 24/10/2022 14:42

If he's quitting why would he get redundancy?!

I agree this doesn't quite compare to bring a sahp as your kids are old enough to not need constant hands on parenting. Before we got married/had kids I quit my job in order to change industry. I took some time out of work before deciding what to do. I didn't expect dh to support me at all, I saved up enough for a year of unemployment before quitting. However, dh did financially support me, but that was entirely his choice and it then meant when we got married I still had my savings to put towards the wedding. But I wouldn't have expected him to find my choice to quit work when I wasn't adding any value to the relationship (ie childcare of young kids)

44PumpLane · 24/10/2022 14:42

Rightly or wrongly I'd feel exactly the same as you OP!!

C8H10N4O2 · 24/10/2022 14:40

How old are the children? Will you save childcare costs by him being at home and will he take over household management tasks (ie own them instead of needing a list of things to do and constant chasing)? How many hours per week will be used by retraining/paid work?

What matters is that both are contributing roughly equal efforts and time and both feel the benefit of the arrangement. So in the classic example which crops up here where a SAHP manages everything at home to facilitate a WOHP's high paid job I'd say they are sharing the load to mutual benefit (albeit the SAHP is taking quite a risk).

If you still handle much on the home front and the DC are at school and to some degree self managing then it doesn't sound like an equitable split. Plus if he doesn't see saving for retirement and the DC future as important I'd question his priorities.

How serious is the retraining and will it lead to a regular job in a different space or is it just some faffy notion which ends up being a displacement from working or simply never earns any money?

Lcb123 · 24/10/2022 14:39

Seems sensible to me. I'd never do all money in joint account, tried it before and didn't work! We contribute same amount to a joint account for mortgage, bills etc. I earn more than DH but I have student loan and 10% pension contributions (which is non changeable!) so fairly similar take home.

hoorayandupsherises · 24/10/2022 14:28

This situation is different from the threads we often see (where a SAHP/part-time partner) is essentially being financially abused because they have no joint money and are contributing 50/50 etc., because in those threads the decision for one parent to stay at home or go part time or have children in the first place was a joint one and so should not affect one partner disproportionally.

I do not believe that one partner should be able to unilaterally decide to quit their job and not earn for up to two years. However the approach you've suggested seems punitive, really, and I'm not sure that it will result in a healthy relationship in future. That said, I'm also not sure that I would be able to get past my partner doing what yours is either.

Have you or he floated any kind of compromise solution, i.e. taking another job he can fit around retraining? A different job in a similar area to now but that would cause him less stress?

CarolShields · 24/10/2022 14:24

I think what you’ve set out is very fair. You see on here all the time women who aren’t even married (so no protection in law) living in boyfriend’s house and contributing 50% to everything whilst earning nothing like as much as the homeowner, who gets to keep 100% of his house should they split .

I know that’s an extreme and you might say incomparable but if you were my friend I would say you have to find a way of making him see it’s unfair. I think it would cause resentment in your relationship if you capitulated and isn’t resentment one of the four horsemen of the marital apocalypse?

I think the most worrying aspect is he is quite cavalier about what it takes for the money to be earned, so it doesn’t hold the same value for him.
This attitude and a lot of time on his hands could spell financial difficulties. Which he’d probably expect you to sort out.

Fenella123 · 24/10/2022 14:23

YANBU, mooching about without the self respect and social interaction and regular timetable of a job can be utterly corrosive. No good for him. He needs to put effort in and achieve and that will make him feel better about himself. He's an adult, not a pet. He has to pull his weight and stand on his own two feet within reasonable limits.

I'm not saying he's a terrible person for not being, you know, a high flying barrister or whatever. But he needs to wrench that attitude right round. Nor am I saying that it is easy when he has a hateful job which wrecks his outlook and confidence. I have been there and it is tough.

But it has to be done, even though it will take time (so, start now!).

There are millions of different careers out there. He needs to find one that pays something commensurate with his actual potential (not his "what he feels like/hobby job" level, which is likely a lot lower!). Then train part-time or evenings/weekends while doing another job to ensure the family finances don't rely on you 100%.

As a family it's daft to just rely on the one earner long-term. One ill-timed stroke and everyone is in the shit. Much better to have both partners with a foot in the workplace (once the kids can be trusted not to burn the house down).

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 24/10/2022 14:19

What redundancy money would he get as a proportion of his/your current annual incomes?

middleofthelittle · 24/10/2022 14:15

Did he support you when you were off work after having your children?

rookiemere · 24/10/2022 14:14

I think if I were you I'd be tempted to start putting a bit more into your pension or AVCs.
It's all very well him being unfulfilled but that doesn't mean you should be working past your 60s to make him a bit happier.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 24/10/2022 14:13

I'm with you. He's taking the piss.

Without being outing can you give us a sense of his current and hoped-for occupations? How drastic a change is it?

katieak · 24/10/2022 14:11

This is a tough one. On the one hand, do you really want an unhappy husband who is miserable in his job just so you can have a more financially comfortable life? That doesn't sound much fun. Happiness is more important than a salary. But at the same time, if he brings nothing in and is unmotivated I can see that this would quickly build resentment toward him on your part, understandably. I think if he really wants this new career with retraining and it isn't just a phase that he will lose interest in then you should probably support him with that, given it is affordable, but with some compromise on his part. For example, he retrains before he quits or he works part time whilst retraining so there is at least some money coming in so you don't feel taken advantage of. In the adult world, we don't often just get to chase our dreams with no compromise or consequence so think he will need to change his expectations slightly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread