Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to totally separate finances from DH?

59 replies

Jane054848 · 24/10/2022 13:53

DH hates his job and wants to quit. He does have a plan to retrain in something but will be a couple of years before he can earn anything, and it might always be quite minimal. I can't persuade him to retrain first.

I earn enough to support the family, including supporting DH not working/only working a little bit...but it would impact on things I want to save for such as retirement, kids' uni, helping kids with house deposit in the future.

We've had completely joint money (one joint bank account) since we started living together 20ish years ago.

But if he's going to be significantly reducing his work/income, I'd like to move to having our own separate money. My proposal:

  • he'd do more housework/childcare (kids are teenagers)
  • we'd contribute to all bills, household expenses, family stuff, outings, holidays etc in proportion to our incomes (so if he's earning nothing he'd pay nothing, if earning 20% of what I earn he'd contribute 20%)
  • whatever is left, we keep separately and do what we want with it. So in theory if he did no work he wouldn't have any "fun" money (but he'd have a year's redundancy pay to tide him over the first couple of years).

Why I'm proposing this:

  • He's quite unmotivated to earn money (because my earnings cover our needs) and doesn't always place much value on our joint money.
  • I think I'd find the situation less annoying if I don't feel like I'm the only one taking a "hit" in my lifestyle/saving goals because of his career change.

But he hates this idea. His view is, we can afford for him to do this and our money is "our" money and we should keep it that way. He says if it wasn't for me he would have quit ages ago - and that if our positions were reversed, he'd be happy to support me. Both probably true.

AIBU? I really can't tell. I'm sure a nicer person would just say that there's no reason for him to work if we can afford for him not to, and no reason why this should impact our financial arrangements.

(And apologies for even asking this question when others have genuine and serious financial problems. I know this is pretty self-indulgent and privileged).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jane054848 · 24/10/2022 22:13

This was all really really helpful and has given me a lot to think about.

Just wanted to say, @Obki - he doesn't actually work for a charity! I wanted to avoid saying his real job to avoid it being recognisably him. It's just that TYPE of job. Don't want to be the reason people stop donating to charity!

OP posts:
Luckynumbereight · 24/10/2022 18:10

He’s taking the piss, OP. There is no way on God’s green earth that he will ‘blag’ a redundancy payment if he willingly resigns. Absolutely no way.

Keep your money separate. It will focus his mind.

Mojoj · 24/10/2022 17:38

He's taking the piss. If you allow him to just continue sharing your income, where's the incentive to find another job? Absolutely maintain separate accounts and if he doesn't like it, then he doesn't get to quit his job.

Ihadenough22 · 24/10/2022 17:34

I would feel the same as you.

He wants to give up his job. The reality is that yes your probably making enough to keep you afloat now but the cost of living is continuing to rise and your coming to an expensive family stage with children going to college. You also have to think about retirement and funding that.

In your case I gather bank account details, credit card details, mortgage ect and look at both your incomes and outgoings on 2 incomes. Then look at things if you had to manage on just your income. Then I get him to take a day off work and you do the same. Sit down when the kids are not in the house and show him your income and out goings with 2 incomes and what happens if you go to just your income only.
Let him see that if he gives up his job that it will effect the family budget. I would also tell him what you said here about the joint account. He can't be spending what he likes when you just have 1 income.

I think that he is being very selfish at the moment. His married with teenaged kids and thinks that he can just leave his job and expects you to carry the whole family?
He has no plan but just expects you to keep working. His redundancy money won't last forever. What about his ni stamps if he stops work and state pension? What about funding his private pension?
The reality is that on one income you are going to take a financial hit now and in the future.

I know he may not like his current job but he can't just walk away from it just yet as he needs to make a proper plan.

His plans can't include you supporting him or impact his kids further education. He needs to retrain when he is still working if he wants to go into a new/different area job wise. He needs to looking for and have a new job before leaving his current job.
Tell him that he needs either a full time or part time job. If he works PT you will expect him to do more in the house than you. He will be paying a % of his income towards the bills into the joint account and you do the same but the rest of your salary will be going into your own account because financially you can't afford to sub his spending.

LolaSmiles · 24/10/2022 17:23

Fenella123
My experience is similar.

Well qualified, experienced professionals are totally different to the wannabe armchair counsellors who don't like their job and like the idea of having limited hours working with a few people.

It scared me when I realised how many online/night school type courses are out there and has made me deeply suspicious about a lot of practitioners.

Fenella123 · 24/10/2022 17:17

Oh Jesús, not counselling.

That seems to be code for "nothing at all really" (from people who hate their job and want out).

NB - proper qualified counsellors who have trained like stink and learned a shedload of stuff about psychology and trauma and are actual professionals - I DON'T MEAN YOU, YOU ARE HEROES.

I've had 2 people close to me "retrain in counselling" and then discover that
a) no money;
b) very difficult, stressful, people have horrific traumas that don't bear thinking about;
c) you can do more harm than good if you don't know what you're doing, which you may well not without rigorous degree-type training and extensive experience;
d) did I say I don't know any rich counsellors?

Has he not got any sensible mates who can find him a normal salaried job in a normal company who make the world better by selling people they want and need?

Excuse the rant, OP. Clearly I don't know you or your DH and you of course do.

ehb102 · 24/10/2022 17:07

Friends had a similar thing - he was starting his own business. There followed three years of financial hardship. You can't always trust someone when it comes to money, even if you would trust them with your children.

Toomuchstufftodo · 24/10/2022 16:54

Obki · 24/10/2022 16:19

Because women are still the lower warner in many relationships and so many women seem to think their salaries should pay for childcare and things for the baby/kids.

The % system works. Don't act so superior.

Also just to add to this, you absolutely can have a strong partnership and maintain some financial independence.

Toomuchstufftodo · 24/10/2022 16:42

YANBU. Your proposed set up is exactly what I have with DP. We both work full time but he earns more so we contribute proportionately to bills and agreed savings (60%/40%). We each put our contribution into joint account each month and we spend/save our disposable income as we like. Even as the lower earner I much prefer this, I don't want to have to justify what I spend money on.

KettrickenSmiled · 24/10/2022 16:41

PS also if you get into a situation where he is long term not working/house husband, getting older and is less able to re-enter the labour market, you’ll still potentially be funding him if you divorce. I know that sound awful. But don’t let that happen.
This concerns me too. Cold though it sounds, I think OP needs to look at this whole situation with a very cold head.
Her H is doing exactly what HE wants & taking no account of how it impacts her. Or even their DC, whose uni funds OP says will be compromised when he jacks in working.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 24/10/2022 16:38

I would feel the same as you
The Unmotivated is a big clue to how he is

ICanHideButICantRun · 24/10/2022 16:35

I love how he wants to be a counsellor yet isn't listening to your legitimate concerns.

Stankonia · 24/10/2022 16:27

What if the OP decides to stop working should they be jointly lodged in a shelter?

Why Should she have less savings and less spending money because he's decided not to work?

Obki · 24/10/2022 16:24

WarblingEttie · 24/10/2022 16:20

YABU money should be jointly shared in a marriage.

So should contribution to a marriage. DH wants to reduce his contribution but reap the same rewards as OP.

WarblingEttie · 24/10/2022 16:20

YABU money should be jointly shared in a marriage.

Obki · 24/10/2022 16:19

GreyElephantsWearingYellowPyjamas · 24/10/2022 16:17

You’re asking for opinions, so here’s mine. I think it’s really shit when couples do this absolutely ridiculous % thing with their money 😆 I’ve never once met anyone in real life who does this. How can you even call yourself a partnership?

Because women are still the lower warner in many relationships and so many women seem to think their salaries should pay for childcare and things for the baby/kids.

The % system works. Don't act so superior.

GreyElephantsWearingYellowPyjamas · 24/10/2022 16:17

You’re asking for opinions, so here’s mine. I think it’s really shit when couples do this absolutely ridiculous % thing with their money 😆 I’ve never once met anyone in real life who does this. How can you even call yourself a partnership?

Obki · 24/10/2022 16:17

He is a wannabe cocklodger and your proposal is very fair.

Be prepared that if you split when he's jobless you will have to pay him spousal support.

Tell him no, he has to work.

he is resigning but would probably be able to blag redundancy pay.

Yet another reason to stop giving money to UK charities.

DelurkingLawyer · 24/10/2022 16:12

I have been there as the non-earning partner and your proposal is not financially abusive.

I took a 3 months sabbatical because I was really down about my job and wondered if I wanted to quit the sector and retrain as something different. DH and I have separate finances and I paid for all my outgoings from savings. I also took on more at home such as dealing on my own with probate when his father died.

DH was supportive of the break and of me retraining if that’s what I decided but was also pretty blunt about what would happen if I didn’t get a new job and gave up altogether: the effect on our finances, the stress on him of having to make our finances up by earning more (we are both self employed so this was a possibility) and also that if the arrangement became permanent he would want me to do stuff he has always done himself like his own laundry. I thought that was all entirely reasonable.

Most important was the fact that not having an income focused my mind on how much I valued the job. I went back to it refreshed and motivated. If he had funded me I’d probably still be arsing around at home.

PS also if you get into a situation where he is long term not working/house husband, getting older and is less able to re-enter the labour market, you’ll still potentially be funding him if you divorce. I know that sound awful. But don’t let that happen.

Paq · 24/10/2022 16:06

KettrickenSmiled · 24/10/2022 15:52

also @ lots of people - he would genuinely do stuff around the house. He already works part time whereas my job is very full on, and he does most of the housework and child wrangling.

So you've been the main breadwinner for how many years? & now he wants to dob out of earning any money at all?
With teenage DC who don't need full-time parenting?
All based on a half-baked "plan" to take a 4 year course training to be a counsellor, when he doesn't actually want to be a counsellor?

Tota'ly taking the piss.

In fairness parenting teens can be pretty full on, especially if you are taxi-ing them here, there and everywhere. It sounds like the OP has been happy with the balance so far.

Stankonia · 24/10/2022 15:54

If he's working part time he can study part time.

oldstudentmum · 24/10/2022 15:54

I never had a joint account with my ex. This was due to my own history of being in a ltr and him working me setting up a joint account plus credit cards. He jacked in the job after a while but unknown to me was spending over 500 per month on the credit card, plus cash ! When I left (very abusive relationship) I was left with the debt. I learnt a harsh lesson.

Mynoodlesareoodles · 24/10/2022 15:53

I dropped to 30 hours to train to be a counsellor. I absolutely loved it though don't do it as my job. It's very competitive - there are an awful lot of experienced, qualified counsellors out there.

KettrickenSmiled · 24/10/2022 15:52

also @ lots of people - he would genuinely do stuff around the house. He already works part time whereas my job is very full on, and he does most of the housework and child wrangling.

So you've been the main breadwinner for how many years? & now he wants to dob out of earning any money at all?
With teenage DC who don't need full-time parenting?
All based on a half-baked "plan" to take a 4 year course training to be a counsellor, when he doesn't actually want to be a counsellor?

Tota'ly taking the piss.

hoorayandupsherises · 24/10/2022 15:40

KettrickenSmiled · 24/10/2022 14:58

Happiness is more important than a salary.

FFS. I find that happiness tends to be a little hard to sustain when skint.
Maybe you should try extreme poverty for a while @katieak before making such glib remarks.

Also doesn't take into account the effect on OP's happiness!

Swipe left for the next trending thread