Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a Christmas one!

135 replies

Puddinggulper · 24/10/2022 12:17

NC as potentially outing and wouldn’t want to upset family. Not really an AIBU but more of a what is reasonable.

We have an almost 1 year old so this will be baby’s first Christmas. DH and I can’t work out what’s fair to everyone. We usually alternate years between my DPs and DH parents house. This year it’s technically ILs turn. I know my DPs will be devastated if they don’t see baby on Christmas. A few relevant points:

  • ILs have 3 other grandchildren so they’ve had GCs on Christmas before. This is my DPs first GC.
  • DH’s siblings et al all live abroad and spend Christmases sporadically at other places such as their own ILs. This would be the first time the entire family would be together.
  • My DPs are very shy and stuck in their own ways and would not wish to combine Christmas with the ILs so that isn’t an option.

Luckily both DPs and ILs live fairly locally so it would be possible to split up the day. Although I don’t know which part of the day would be seen as more important - opening presents in the morning or Christmas dinner? I feel like no matter how it’s split both families will feet put out when we leave to go and see the other one.

Also, a 1 year old won’t be as entertaining as a 2, 3 year old so are we going to have to split the day every year? I have already said to DH when baby reaches 4 years old and understands the magic of Christmas it’s important to me to spend Christmas Day in our own home and people are welcome to visit us but I won’t be dragging them around elsewhere. I want them to wake up and open presents under their own tree and have dinner in their own home like I experienced as a child. Although I’m sure we’ll have to make a few exceptions as we’ll be expected to visit ILs abroad some years but I’m hoping this won’t be until they’re teens.

How do I navigate this whilst keeping everyone happy?

OP posts:
Benjispruce4 · 24/10/2022 13:53

We used to drive to my grandparents in London on Christmas Day. We weren’t ‘carted about!’It was fun and exciting. Sometime they came to us. People are so precious about Christmas Day these days.

Wam90 · 24/10/2022 13:53

We split the day and alternate lunches.
Last year we had lunch with my family so this year it’s lunch with my ILs and then we do breakfast on Christmas Day and spend the day with them on Boxing Day with the opposite.
it’s not very relaxing but the children love seeing every one and the excitement and happiness of it all makes it worth it.

greenteafiend · 24/10/2022 13:52

Do one on Xmas eve, one on Boxing day, and do Xmas day at home.

Don't want to sound unkind, but people who don't make any efforts to get over shyness/stuck-in-the-mud syndrome will inevitably lose out on wonderful experiences as a result, so I wouldn't feel too bad.

Benjispruce4 · 24/10/2022 13:51

I doubt your parent will be devastated.
It’s only a meal. Can you not see them in the morning? Or Boxing Day?

Brefugee · 24/10/2022 13:50

You used a lot of words to say "i want to go to my DPs because meh ILs" or something.
Either you say: from now we are staying at home and you can come and visit (and then alternate without all the bollocks justifying why your parents should have all the choicest dates) or you say "ok from now on we'll do one year at DPs, one home, one ILs, one home, one DPs... or whatever.

Splitting Christmas day is poop, and when your DC is older it's horrible to drag them away from their presents

Worthyornot · 24/10/2022 13:49

KitchiHuritAngeni · 24/10/2022 12:20

I would just say that from this year you'll stay at yours and people are welcome to visit.

No point tying yourself in knots trying to please everyone and end up unhappy yourself.

This, you are trying to please everyone except your own family. Your DC carted between houses won't be fun either at that age. Please stop this and stay at home.

Taillighttoobright · 24/10/2022 13:48

I'd start as you mean to go on. Just say you've heard horrendous stories about driving young children from place to place and you'd like to start the process of enjoying Christmas at home as your own little family unit. You could go one further and say that you're happy to have visitors or visit on Christmas Eve or Boxing Day, but the Christmas Day is now your family's dag, and without the pressure of entertaining...

BlueRidge · 24/10/2022 13:47

I would think stockings and gifts with a nice breakfast with your parents first thing. Then go to the in-laws for lunch.
But then, we always have Christmas lunch late afternoon by candlelight so we're hungry again by then.

Obki · 24/10/2022 13:47

luckylavender · 24/10/2022 13:43

OP has already said that her parents would find that difficult

Interesting how these shy people who are are unable to function in someone else's home are happy to show their dd how devastated they are that their dd and son in law are having their alternate turn at the in-law Hmm

Badger1970 · 24/10/2022 13:45

Our baby's first Christmas was horrendous and we spent most of the day in the car driving from one place to another with a horribly grumpy baby that had missed of all her naps.

The following year, we stayed at home and did what was right for us!

luckylavender · 24/10/2022 13:43

GothMilk · 24/10/2022 12:40

Could you ask your in laws if they would be willing to have your DP over?

That's what we did.

OP has already said that her parents would find that difficult

SurlejTiger · 24/10/2022 13:43

There is no way to make everyone happy, so you need to find which way is acceptable for you.
The problem with taking turns is it sets a precedent. Some then want to stick to it rigidly - but what happens then if you have an ill family member, it's their last Christmas but your turn is with the other side?

In your position, figure out what you and your DH think will be ok for your DC. Two days of "Christmas" too much? Space it out. DC won't know. Either the 24th or 26th with your DP's? Or breakfast on 25th and promise New Year's Day. Or the closest Sunday (haven't looked at calendar, won't know when it is!)?

Don't forget to plan some time for just you, your DH and your DC.

imeldagolightly · 24/10/2022 13:41

When we were children we saw one set of Grandparents on Christmas Eve and the other on Boxing Day. Christmas Day was spent just as us, no visitors and we rushed home after church as we had presents to play with.

As adults we have to work around a family member's work commitments as they have a job that gets incredibly busy at Christmas. We spend Christmas morning at home opening presents. We then travel 50 minutes to my sister's house where all my family are and arrive at midday. We have Christmas lunch there, open presents afterwards. Then around 4pm we move onto IL's for nibblles as too full from Christmas lunch, open presents and we stay till about 8pm. Luckily we are all from the same town but we are the ones who don't live locally now.

Boxing day is ours alone, we stay in our pyjamas. That way we see both sets of family on Christmas day itself and have done since the children were born and are now mid-late teens. It is just normal for them. Again my family member only gets 2 days off over Christmas and wants to see the other side of their family.

Start as you mean to go on, do what you want to do, establish your own traditions, maybe just spread Christmas over several days rather than everyone concentrating on one day. We see everyone on Christmas day but we also then have family here between Christmas and New Year.

Freddiefox · 24/10/2022 13:41

overtaxedunderling · 24/10/2022 13:32

This is lovely, rather than a hurried three or four hours on Christmas Day, five or six on Christmas Eve - then they're getting a bigger slice of the angel. Looks like a win-win to me.

Honestly don’t stay at your mum, you’ll start a precedent, and you’ll want to be at home making your own traditions. Maybe they could stay at yours Christmas Eve.

Mammyloveswine · 24/10/2022 13:40

We spent Christmas Eve at my im laws and had Christmas morning there then went to my parents for Christmas dinner...

Was great!

Now the kids are older and my parents live in the same city as us we go to my mams then travel down to the in laws for Boxing Day.

Cottoneyejoemama · 24/10/2022 13:40

I haven’t RTFT so it might have already been suggested but how about your parents stay over Xmas Eve and watch DC open presents and then you visit your IL’s midday?

Blacksheepcat · 24/10/2022 13:40

Could you spend Christmas Eve with your parents? Maybe let them give presents on that day? Or Boxing Day?

Squellyolwelly · 24/10/2022 13:40

My son had his first xmas last year, it was the IL turn for us. We went to theirs for the day and then had Xmas with my parents on New Year’s Day instead.

You just need to explain to your parents that just because there’s now a baby involved, it doesn’t mean you must change your plans to prevent upsetting them. There are plenty of days over Christmas that they could choose from to have their own Xmas day with you, and next year they will get actual Christmas Day with you all, at which point, baby will probably enjoy and understand it a little more anyway.

My little one is 18 months now and he will 100% enjoy Christmas more this year than last, although he was a little younger at Christmas than your baby will be this year. He had absolutely no interest in presents etc last year 😂

Umbrellabee · 24/10/2022 13:35

Either you start at home now and make that the rule every year going forward or you carry on with turns. There is no way to make every one happy, it’s not possible and in trying to do so you will be unhappy. So do what works for you. Either stay at home or go to the in laws as it’s their turn. There is Christmas Eve and Boxing Day to see your parents.

overtaxedunderling · 24/10/2022 13:32

Holly60 · 24/10/2022 12:44

Honestly do Xmas eve with your parents - you can even do a proper 'Xmas day' set up with them.

If they are shy are they really going to mind stopping at home on Xmas day, having just spent the day with you all the day before??

This is lovely, rather than a hurried three or four hours on Christmas Day, five or six on Christmas Eve - then they're getting a bigger slice of the angel. Looks like a win-win to me.

BrieAndChilli · 24/10/2022 13:32

I would do

you parents come to you on christmas eve - in some ways xmas eve is more magical with the putting stuff out for santa, new pjs, tracking santa and watching a xmas film etc.

Then just your little family on xmas morning to open santa presents etc.

Then go to in-laws for xmas dinner and family time.

Then next year alternate. or you could do one for xmas day and one for boxing day.

We were quite crafty and never got tied into a strict rota for xmas, some years with my family (no longer see my mum so just my sister and family) some years DH family, some times his dad, sometimes his mum, sometimes we got to stay with them, sometimes they come stay with us, sometimes it is just us or we have gone to a friends family once too.

This way no-one has any expectations and we can just do what suits us or what fits around other people best etc.

Dreamingcats · 24/10/2022 13:32

I'd go to the ILs (assuming I wanted to, and it sounds like you do).

I'd invite my parents if the ILs didn't mind, regardless of whether my parents would refuse. If they want to see GC on Christmas day so much (and they must know its an IL year), they need to be flexible.

Assuming they refuse, I'd visit them on Boxing Day and do gifts with them then. Tbh my baby got such a ridiculous number of gifts from relatives that spreading them over two days was a good thing.

FourChimneys · 24/10/2022 13:32

The way I saw it when the DC were small was that Christmas was just a made up date, tacked onto the pagan winter festivities and months away from when any supposedly special child was born. Which meant that it was no more logical to faff about with family arrangements towards the end of December than at any other time of year. We used to have our "Christmas" with my family sometime in August. Far less pressure, better weather for driving halfway across the country and far less chance of having to be stuck indoors due to cold or wet weather.

Could you start something like that?

Dodie66 · 24/10/2022 13:30

Are they going to be at in-laws on Boxing Day? If so have christmas at home and go to them on Boxing Day . We used to have Christmas morning and dinner at home and go to parents for tea.

Wishingwell2022 · 24/10/2022 13:30

In our house (we have a 5 year old) -

Christmas Eve - go out for an early dinner with my Dad/Step-Mum
Christmas Day - my Mum comes to us
Boxing Day - we travel 3 hours to my IL's and stay for 2-3 nights