Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a Christmas one!

135 replies

Puddinggulper · 24/10/2022 12:17

NC as potentially outing and wouldn’t want to upset family. Not really an AIBU but more of a what is reasonable.

We have an almost 1 year old so this will be baby’s first Christmas. DH and I can’t work out what’s fair to everyone. We usually alternate years between my DPs and DH parents house. This year it’s technically ILs turn. I know my DPs will be devastated if they don’t see baby on Christmas. A few relevant points:

  • ILs have 3 other grandchildren so they’ve had GCs on Christmas before. This is my DPs first GC.
  • DH’s siblings et al all live abroad and spend Christmases sporadically at other places such as their own ILs. This would be the first time the entire family would be together.
  • My DPs are very shy and stuck in their own ways and would not wish to combine Christmas with the ILs so that isn’t an option.

Luckily both DPs and ILs live fairly locally so it would be possible to split up the day. Although I don’t know which part of the day would be seen as more important - opening presents in the morning or Christmas dinner? I feel like no matter how it’s split both families will feet put out when we leave to go and see the other one.

Also, a 1 year old won’t be as entertaining as a 2, 3 year old so are we going to have to split the day every year? I have already said to DH when baby reaches 4 years old and understands the magic of Christmas it’s important to me to spend Christmas Day in our own home and people are welcome to visit us but I won’t be dragging them around elsewhere. I want them to wake up and open presents under their own tree and have dinner in their own home like I experienced as a child. Although I’m sure we’ll have to make a few exceptions as we’ll be expected to visit ILs abroad some years but I’m hoping this won’t be until they’re teens.

How do I navigate this whilst keeping everyone happy?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ItsaMetalBand · 25/10/2022 16:29

LuckySantangelo35 · 24/10/2022 15:19

I never understand this obsession of wanting to spend Christmas Day in your own home just with your own “little family”…battening down the hatches…and staying in pj’s all day.

It’s seen as bliss to most on here!

but

its so boring and anti social !

DH has social anxiety. We both work full time, with long commutes and DS goes to breakfast club, then school then afterschool. So when we do get our summer holidays, and Christmas day itself - it's for just us. That's 15 days out of the entire year that we reserve. The rest of the time is up for grabs - and with a poorly DM to drive three hours to every other weekend, I do relish the days that I get to stay home in the PJs.

I go visit my siblings in and around Christmas - just not ON the day itself - and they are happy with that too, because they don't want to be dragging their kids away from their toys, drive on icy roads to visit us when a 20 minute face time in the morning is enough.

This year for the first time in 3 years, DM is going elsewhere. The subtle pressure of a guest to look after for 10 days is not on me this year, and I want to savour that.

This year we are doing the panto with one sibling's family, going to do a get together with another set of cousins, and boxing day with DH's brother who's within walking distance of us so we can have a few drinks and the rest of his family go to that. And other meetups will fall into place so we are usually very busy socialising from the 22nd right though to New Year.

We just don't travel on Christmas Day itself.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 24/10/2022 18:26

LuckySantangelo35 · 24/10/2022 15:19

I never understand this obsession of wanting to spend Christmas Day in your own home just with your own “little family”…battening down the hatches…and staying in pj’s all day.

It’s seen as bliss to most on here!

but

its so boring and anti social !

It couldn’t just be that different people like different things, and your way isn’t the one and only enjoyable Christmas, could it, @LuckySantangelo35?

Newsflash - and I hope you are sitting down for this - different people like different things.

QuiltedHippo · 24/10/2022 16:11

ILs this year definitely, works well that the abroad relatives are there and it's their turn. We had the exact same situation for our little ones first Christmas last year, it was lovely to see everyone and see LO with their cousins.

Next Christmas day with your parents, then start staying at home on year 3. Thats what we're doing.

SpongeBob2022 · 24/10/2022 16:06

Even though I'm not a huge fan of the restriction of having to rotate it every year, in your case I'd say it makes it easy...it's your in laws turn and you should go to them...none of the things you've said give any weight to the alternative.

When I was younger we did Christmas Day with one set of family and Boxing Day with the other. Personally now I have my own family I prefer to see both on Christmas Day...one for lunch and one for tea...and have day to ourselves Boxing Day. You will never please everyone.

COS2102 · 24/10/2022 15:40

We always said we would alternate dinner but then my husband came to my parents for dinner one year and we went to his parents for pudding and then he realised it felt like a much more relaxed day like that and so it has stuck. We'd never invite over for present opening as think that is about the kids waking up and rushing to see what santa has brought. Family time happens from lunch. Also, both sets of parents sometimes have presents that santa left to be played with there so they get a bit of present opening experience.

Honestly what works for one won't work for the other. Only you and your OH can decide what will work for you, we can only give you ideas of our days! Good luck

iwantmyownicecreamvan · 24/10/2022 15:40

Sorry, haven't RTFT but this strikes a chord with me. I would consider whether either set of parents travelled a lot when their children were young to see GPs/inlaws. If they didn't do this and spent Christmas in their own house, then they won't really have any idea of how unsettling and disruptive it is.

I spent years ferrying my poor kids between GP's houses and we always upset one or the other of them - either the one where we opened presents, or the one where we had dinner. The kids ended up over-tired, would then be naughty and have to be told off on Christmas day. I was always doing the driving so could never have a drink, they couldn't play with their toys (unless they were small enough to take with us). TBH it was often miserable. Neither set of GPs had had to do this as young parents - they had spent Christmas in their own houses.

Then my SIL moved back from living abroad and she and BIL announced that they would be having Christmas in their own house and that anyone would be welcome to come or not, but they would not be travelling anywhere. MIL was upset, but then I found my voice and said I didn't blame them, and I was tired of driving around with overtired children every Christmas. She listened and our Christmases were transformed - better late than never. Find your voice now - have your Christmas at home if that's what you want.

eatsleepwinerepeat · 24/10/2022 15:38

Go and see your parents in the morning and then off to the IL's for the rest of the day. I dont really see what the issue is.

NippyWoowoo · 24/10/2022 15:36

Growing up for me it was:

Presents at home with just parents

Brunch/Lunch (light bites) with one set of GPs with their presents

Dinner with the other GPs with their presents.

FWIW I hated it as a child, just wanted to be at home with my own parents and play with my toys. But hey ho.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 24/10/2022 15:35

The precedent you set now will be the one that's apt to stick.

It will be very much harder t break that four years down the line.

WitchDancer · 24/10/2022 15:32

Do yourself a favour and start a new tradition of staying at home for Christmas as your little family. If you don't then you will be forever stuck in the pattern, so will be dragging your children away from their presents to go visiting rather than them playing with them. Even worse you are stuck with running around cooking instead of enjoying seeing your kids open their presents because you have 20 people coming for lunch and you daren't be late with your timings.

I speak from bitter experience!

Milesty1 · 24/10/2022 15:30

It’s your IL’s turn, so I would do dinner with them. Plus there will be other relatives. I’d extend the invite again to your parents but if they say no, then they can pop in on Xmas morning for a mince pie and some presents before you leave.

Soubriquet · 24/10/2022 15:28

Have Christmas at yours and have everyone come round there.

Refrosty · 24/10/2022 15:27

I have already said to DH when baby reaches 4 years old and understands the magic of Christmas it’s important to me to spend Christmas Day in our own home and people are welcome to visit us but I won’t be dragging them around elsewhere.

You are forgetting that the experience of Christmas for your child could actually be much more fun with cousins/family around. My DC would not enjoy their day as much if it were just us/always at home. It would be boring tbh, they like a noisy house with loads of food and fun. I have a large family and so does DH. My DC get much more presents than their cousins on both sides, so we always opt to open gifts from the family we aren't visiting alone, at home. We then carry the gifts from the ones we are visiting with us/ or open them when family have arrived at ours. That way, they can say thanks yous etc in person.

MissMarplesGoddaughter · 24/10/2022 15:27

I am a MiL and have GC.

I do not see my DC and GC every single Christmas. I accept that they have ILs and that they also want to see my DC and our shared GC at Christmas too. So I see DC / GC alternate Christmases. The year DC are going to the ILs, we arrange to meet up a weekend in December and celebrate our Christmas then. This means that GC get to see both sets of grandparents at Christmas and it works well.

I would really hate to think my DC were in the same dilemma as you are now...

AxolotlEars · 24/10/2022 15:26

Time for new traditions. We made it a tradition that we hadn't got one! It was my husband who was fairly fixed on this as he had seen his parents haring around the country every Christmas.
I would personally, this year, try to make it to your husband's family at some point if they are all going to be present even if that did mean Christmas day.

Mrsjayy · 24/10/2022 15:21

TheDuck2018 · 24/10/2022 15:13

Pretty sure that once ops parents are settled in her house they won't want to shift, and I don't think op will insist.
It's the in-laws turn this year, so you should go there, it's only fair, especially as the rest of the family will be there. If I was your dh, I'd be really disappointed you were thinking otherwise.

This imagine if your husband insisted his mum would be devastated not to see the baby so you must go!

Solmum1964 · 24/10/2022 15:20

TempName01 · 24/10/2022 12:37

Christmas Day is for stopping at home, Boxing Day is for visiting

I agree with this - although in-laws were some distance away so involved a few days away. Therefore cats had to go to the cattery which wasn't open Christmas Day or Boxing Day. We, therefore, had both days at home and went to them on 27th for a second Christmas. DH's work was shut between Christmas and New Year so always able to do this and we enjoyed a more relaxed Christmas at home.
Be careful what traditions you start now - your child(ren) won't want to be dragged away from their new toys as they get older.
Also, thinking about a different post, manage expectations. Santa filled the (pillowcase sized) stockings with little bits (annuals, selection box, drawing pad/crayons, socks!, small game. We found it cheaper to fill a small sack rather than a traditional stocking.); bigger presents were from other people, and labelled, because my children were expected to write thank you letters to people they didn't see in person.

LuckySantangelo35 · 24/10/2022 15:19

I never understand this obsession of wanting to spend Christmas Day in your own home just with your own “little family”…battening down the hatches…and staying in pj’s all day.

It’s seen as bliss to most on here!

but

its so boring and anti social !

theremustonlybeone · 24/10/2022 15:18

Do it in your own home. Once I had children i put my foot down.

You will find your DC will be aware of xmas younger than 4. it is lovely creating memories and traditions in your own homw.

TheDuck2018 · 24/10/2022 15:13

Pretty sure that once ops parents are settled in her house they won't want to shift, and I don't think op will insist.
It's the in-laws turn this year, so you should go there, it's only fair, especially as the rest of the family will be there. If I was your dh, I'd be really disappointed you were thinking otherwise.

Fiddledeedeeee · 24/10/2022 15:08

I would (and have) start by spending Christmas at home as the default position. If situations arise such as the rare occasion the extended family are in the same place at the same time, then you could have odd years where you do something outside of that default.

We usually have a version of Christmas or some sort of celebration with both sides of the family around the period (either Christmas Eve of the few days after Christmas) and everyone seems to have accepted it well.

almondflake · 24/10/2022 15:03

When we had children we made the decision to stay at home for Christmas inviting everyone to us if the wanted to come ,some years we had all the in-laws other years we had none . It worked well for us .
Now there's only my mum and stepmum all the other in-laws and parents are gone we seem to reminisce about Christmas past . We still have a lovely day with the children, their partners and our grandchildren .
Make Christmas yours, do what's best for you and have a happy one 😊

Waitingfordecember · 24/10/2022 15:03

Usually I’d say invite everyone to yours and if people turn down the invitation, that’s their decision. But, if it’s really unusual for DH’s siblings to all be in the same country for Christmas, it seems really mean not to spend it with them.

In your shoes I’d invite your parents round for presents and a light breakfast and go to in-laws for lunch.

Inertia · 24/10/2022 15:00

Woukd your parents come to you for Christmas Eve if there are no other siblings to consider? Big celebratory meal, they stay overnight, open presents with you and the baby, nice relaxed breakfast. It means you wouldn’t have 2 lots of travelling, because jumping the baby stuff around is a pain.

Then you go to ILs for lunch and Christmas afternoon/ evening, second round of presents.

bewarethetides · 24/10/2022 14:57

Stripyhoglets1 · 24/10/2022 12:31

Christmas morning and brunch at yours and invite your parents. Then go for lunch and Christmas afternoon at inlaws.

Then invite everyone on boxing day for an easy snack buffet lunch.

Nailed it!

OP, this would work and set the tone for doing Christmas mornings in your own home with your family going forward.

Swipe left for the next trending thread