Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wondering … would you stay with someone who is a brilliant parent but struggles with money?

184 replies

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 10:19

Someone who is a brilliant parent to two year old but contributes nothing really in the way of finances.

OP posts:
Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:15

I’m fine thanks @Mardyface Smile just have a rare moment of peace and thinking about stuff.

OP posts:
Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:14

Well yes, this is what I’m asking @luxxlisbon , I don’t know because I don’t really contribute, to those bills at any rate.

@Merryoldgoat its certainly not helpful to have the thread squabble bicker argue is it’s. Just leave it if you don’t like it.

OP posts:
Notcreativeatall · 24/10/2022 11:14

I don't think you stay with or leave someone on that basis though- firstly there are lots of other factors that go into a good relationship parenting skills, money being only part.
And even on the parenting/money there is no absolute number/level- it is really what is agreed between you and if one partner resents what the other partner contributes than it isn't working

Mardyface · 24/10/2022 11:14

Did you post on Mumsnet just so you would get a big whipping about it? I'm sure people will oblige.

If it is working for both of you, just don't worry about it. It is actually OK to enjoy life. It doesn't HAVE to be a struggle and a slog.

If it isn't working, change something. You should be talking to your higher earning spouse about it not asking for judgement on a quite shouty internet forum and that makes me wonder if you are quite all right tbh.

user1473878824 · 24/10/2022 11:13

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:09

Neither of us have a SL, pension is taken out before it reaches paypacket Smile so figure of around 4.5 and 1600 are roughly correct.

I will confess I am not sure how much mortgage etc is which tells everyone I am indeed parent b, but I know it’s a lot.

With all the money talk I am conscious I am not contributing much and worry about it. I also don’t seem to get as much cleaning and housework done as I’d like.

Wouldn’t it be better then to talk to your spouse about whether they think it’s fair? If they’re fine with the split as is rather than worrying about you contributing more put money towards a cleaner if you don’t feel you’re doing enough or work on your credit score.

Merryoldgoat · 24/10/2022 11:13

It’s because you want opinions without giving relevant information.

Plus the use of the word leech when describing someone one is in a relationship with is vile.

I’m going out on a limb:

You’re the leech (as your higher earning partner describes) and you think they’re wrong but feel so done in by them wearing you down you aren’t sure.

They tell you that they could do better than you, someone who pulls their weight, your contribution is nothing.

Am I close?

luxxlisbon · 24/10/2022 11:13

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:09

Neither of us have a SL, pension is taken out before it reaches paypacket Smile so figure of around 4.5 and 1600 are roughly correct.

I will confess I am not sure how much mortgage etc is which tells everyone I am indeed parent b, but I know it’s a lot.

With all the money talk I am conscious I am not contributing much and worry about it. I also don’t seem to get as much cleaning and housework done as I’d like.

It seems crazy to me that you have a child with someone and don’t know your basic outgoings.
4.3k sounds like a lot but it really depends on outgoings, mortgage could be £500 for a tiny 2 up 2 down in parts of the north, equally it could be anywhere from 1200 to 2000.
Then there’s energy £300 a month, council tax maybe £150-200, water, internet, insurance, a car or travel? the rest of the food for the month, baby items, furniture, days out, household repairs, the list goes on. It might leave parent A with 2k, it might leave them with £500. That depends on your actual situation.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:13

@ExtraOnions I’m bad with money too, but am the lower earner.

OP posts:
Comedycook · 24/10/2022 11:10

Doesn't sound too outrageous to me. You're probably describing the financial set up of loads of families, although usually the woman is the lower earner. I get the feeling in this case, the man is the lower earner, but I could be wrong

ExtraOnions · 24/10/2022 11:10

I am the primary earner in our house (£70k), my husband has always been in less, and has now retired with a £22k pension.

I am awful with money, so leave it all to him. I never have anything at the end of the month (I transfer all the money for mortgage, bills, food etc etc etc, into an account he manages ) - he does all the savings, ISAs, financial planning etc . We are comfortable.

I’m great at all the parenting, and household stuff though …, Play your strengths,

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:09

Neither of us have a SL, pension is taken out before it reaches paypacket Smile so figure of around 4.5 and 1600 are roughly correct.

I will confess I am not sure how much mortgage etc is which tells everyone I am indeed parent b, but I know it’s a lot.

With all the money talk I am conscious I am not contributing much and worry about it. I also don’t seem to get as much cleaning and housework done as I’d like.

OP posts:
HauntedCabinet · 24/10/2022 11:09

So yes …the £24,000 person should be making more of a financial contribution, is that the general feeling?

Not my feeling. My feeling is that there is nowhere near enough info to tell.

One way to split this would be to pool all the costs (including the nursery fees) and split them 1/4 and 3/4. 'Costs' should include all family expenditure, including similar level pensions for both adults.

Then ON TOP OF THAT, you need to balance the hours workedwith childcare and household. So, for exmple, if the person working PT is doing 20 hours a week and the FT is 40 hours a week then the part-timer (for want of a better term) should do around 2/3 of the childcare and housework. The full timer should do around 1/3.

Any left over money after costs have been paid could be pooled, split into 2 and handed back to each person as personal money.

That way, no one is doing better (long term or short term) than the other because of family workload split or commitments.

But, of course, this is just one way of spliting it and makes some huge assumptions. Which is why more detail is needed.

bravelittletiger · 24/10/2022 11:08

The set up you have described is just a normal family set up where one person earns more. You are both contributing equally in the sense that you both pay what you can towards the household income.

It would be a very shallow thing indeed to break up with your partner and father of your child because you want them to earn more. You're meant to be a team.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:07

I get that it’s frustrating reading but I want opinions, there are tonnes of threads here I find dull, irrelevant or whatever, I just don’t post on them. I honestly don’t see why that’s so hard. It’s my thread, I’m finding it helpful.

OP posts:
Sciurus83 · 24/10/2022 11:07

Sounds fine, you're rolling in it compared to most.

luxxlisbon · 24/10/2022 11:07

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:03

Sorry I did miss some questions …

Parent B works three days a week and does all the childcare then, plus before and after work on the working days.

Nursery is around £600 p/m.

So 1700 - 600 for nursery and occasionally a food shop. Really depends on how occasionally. £100? £150? Per month.
Partner A is left about 1k to themselves.
Partner B takes home about 4300, they pay the mortgage, internet, car, travel, utilities, the rest of the food shops, clothes, household items, holidays etc. It really depends on how much these come to.
This is basic take home ignoring additional pension contributions or SL.

Imo both partners should be left with the same amount.
Are they?

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/10/2022 11:07

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:04

Yes, it means taking more than getting in that context.

If they’re the brilliant parent you say they are, and are doing childcare on the two days a week they are not working, they are not leeching or taking more than they give. They’re supporting the family by providing childcare.

If they’re working part time and then fobbing the child off elsewhere on their non-working days so they can relax or please themselves then yes, they’re leeching.

Financially, each partner should be contributing to all bills proportionately to their income so that they each have similar amounts of money for themselves to do as they please leftover.

Jellybella · 24/10/2022 11:06

Personally I would find this a fine set up. My husband and I work out our total take home pay (I am part time and he is full time) and make sure we give ourselves the same amount of money to ourselves each month. The rest goes into the joint account to cover bills and all other house finances (including nursery). You could always do something like that if one parent not happy

Mardyface · 24/10/2022 11:06

I forgot to mention too that a lower earner does not necessarily work less hard than a higher earner! Far from it. Cf nurses vs bankers.

Merryoldgoat · 24/10/2022 11:06

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:04

Yes, it means taking more than getting in that context.

I’m incredulous, not unable to understand the disgustingly pejorative language.

notacooldad · 24/10/2022 11:05

I’m getting just fine advice thanks, notacooldad
You reckon!🤣🤣
It's not even half a story you gave and it's like pulling teeth trying to get info to help you but they need a starting point. The first post in proves that.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/10/2022 11:05

Needs more info. On £24,000 and paying all the nursery fees the pt earner probably hasn’t much left. Depending on pension and student loan their net may only be £300 ish a week - if they are paying 3 or 4 days nursery and commute costs, work clothes they may just be breaking even and effectively working to avoid gap in cv/get pension.
If you are married you need to look at finances as a whole and none monetary contributions.

Mardyface · 24/10/2022 11:04

No. I don't think the 24k earner should necessarily be financially contributing more.

In theory a family with married parents is an economic unit. That is the point of it. So the family earns more or less 100k and perhaps the lower earner makes it possible for more of that income to be kept because they do things like childcare and cleaning that would otherwise come out of it and definitely need to be done. Not only that but they allow the higher earner to get on pretty much unfettered by childcare and home commitments, which makes for a more successful career.

In practice people do whatever works - and of course not every single thing has a financial price tag whatever the Tories would like us to think. Being cared for by a parent might seem cheaper than nursery for example, but why should it be and in fact is it? It isn't of lesser value is it? Some would argue it's of greater value.

The main thing is that family units are meant to love each other and make life easier for each other. So if it seems that one isn't pulling their weight and therefore is making things more difficult for the other partner (whether financially or in practical or emotional terms) then this needs discussing. But if it's working then who gives a shit?

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:04

Yes, it means taking more than getting in that context.

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 24/10/2022 11:03

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:01

I’ve answered questions, but I am finding the opinions helpful. I am wondering if parent b should be contributing more, if parent b is being a bit unintentionally leech like on parent a.

Well if you want to work that out you need to look at what you both actually contribute. Maybe partner A is contributing a higher amount of their salary, maybe it’s partner b. No one can say because you haven’t given any information.