Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wondering … would you stay with someone who is a brilliant parent but struggles with money?

184 replies

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 10:19

Someone who is a brilliant parent to two year old but contributes nothing really in the way of finances.

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 24/10/2022 11:32

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:25

@neverbeenskiing you are on MN, and on this thread, so assuming you get some pleasure or entertainment or enjoyment from it.

It is peculiar to me that so many people have taken umbrage with me anonymously writing out some things that are niggling and troubling me.

Ever since I have been very young, if I want to address something I write it down. Writing it down here, given it concerns a young child and is Mumsnet when all is said and done points out things I may not have thought of from both sides, clarifies my thoughts, allows me to get to the root of what the problem really is.

It’s possible that I am just really strange and normal people wouldn’t do this, but in that case I have to question how normal it is to get so cross about a peculiar person just doing something peculiar but harmless …

in other words

any chance the people

sniping at me
bitching at me
criticising me
doing the 🤣🤣at me

could please fuck off and let me have a helpful thread?

I was trying to help. You're obviously worrying about this so I'm simply pointing out that talking to your DP, who is the only one who knows how he really feels, about your family finances is likely to be more reassuring than a bunch of strangers who can only guess. You have asked for advice and opinions and my advice is that if you're worried about the inequality in your household then communicating with your partner about it is a good idea. Starting a thread to get others perspectives is fine, but if you're concerned about how your DP perceives the situation then nothing anyone says here can give you any clarity on that.

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 24/10/2022 11:31

Ok parent b is definitely not a leach.

That's an awful way to phrase the mother of a child. ..

What does parent b have left over after nursery?

Fwiw I was a sahm for ten years, I always bought the weekly food shop as a regular main cost .

Now I'm working i add to all our pots at what I feel I can afford eg I give DH 100 a month to go where he wants it to go .. savings or a fund we have for our childrens clothes, school cost.

I also give a further 150 again to go where he wants plus small overpayment on mortgage.

I give 75 towards Xmas per m. 75 to holiday's, and I have my own children's fund for tutors which I also pay into.

( Not exact figures but as a rough guide)

I pay for my own car costs, insurance etc and still pay for food. .

It's not set down as a % of what I earn it's more like what we both, every penny is assigned.

DH definitely cooks and will if I ask him but I do 75 % of meal planning, buying and Cooking, as well as the majority of washing and house work and 99% child admin, hospital appts and so on.
It's solely me who notices problems with house and gets them sorted out etc etc.

I earn nmw and earn around 940 p m.

Mardyface · 24/10/2022 11:30

This is one reason that SAH is tricky. Self-worth is a complicated thing.

OP when I was a SAHM we had a joint account and all the bills, groceries, any childcare came out of that. It is unsurprising you don't have a handle on your finances if you are the comparatively low earner and yet you pay for the child care and 'occasional groceries'. You are being kept in the dark about what money goes where so how would you know whether or not your financial contribution is enough? You might be living hand to mouth. You might be swimming in extra cash that you never get to see or spend. I'm not saying it's your H keeping you in the dark - it could well be you.

I completely get that things were more equal when you and DH were working full time. Now I am back at work full time my relationship is much more equal too because I feel like I can say 'your turn to do the laundry' or 'can you pick up DD1 at a time' (obviously the mental load still falls to me because I'm not a fucking genius man-wrangler) and I am not taking the piss. I don't intellectually think I was taking the piss before either but I would feel it and beat myself up about it. If I could go back in time I would just give myself a break about the whole thing.

mast0650 · 24/10/2022 11:28

This post it weird. You don't normally make a decision to stay with someone based on their financial contribution to the household. You're not assessing a joint business venture. How about whether they are a loving and committed partner whose company you enjoy?!?

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:28

I think you’ve misunderstood @KhaleesiDothraki , I am a woman, I am the lesser earner.

OP posts:
KhaleesiDothraki · 24/10/2022 11:26

This reply has been deleted

Previously banned poster - this has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:26

@@DarkShade i do worry about it sometimes. I worry that I am taking more than I am giving, this troubles me I suppose.

OP posts:
Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:25

@neverbeenskiing you are on MN, and on this thread, so assuming you get some pleasure or entertainment or enjoyment from it.

It is peculiar to me that so many people have taken umbrage with me anonymously writing out some things that are niggling and troubling me.

Ever since I have been very young, if I want to address something I write it down. Writing it down here, given it concerns a young child and is Mumsnet when all is said and done points out things I may not have thought of from both sides, clarifies my thoughts, allows me to get to the root of what the problem really is.

It’s possible that I am just really strange and normal people wouldn’t do this, but in that case I have to question how normal it is to get so cross about a peculiar person just doing something peculiar but harmless …

in other words

any chance the people

sniping at me
bitching at me
criticising me
doing the 🤣🤣at me

could please fuck off and let me have a helpful thread?

OP posts:
DarkShade · 24/10/2022 11:23

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:17

I probably do need to change my thinking. I was looking back at some old diaries, things were a lot more equal when I first met DH and now years later not so much. I’d like that to change which has to start with me.

Ok, but that might mean your partner taking one of your childcare days, at the loss of a whole day of their nice salary. Look if you want to earn more money, go for it - always a good idea if you can at no extra health or other sacrifice, but it doesn't seem like you need to? You guys combined earn almost 100k. That's much more than double what my partner and I earn, on a very very similar family set up (except we work the same hours and do the same childcare days, and split house jobs evenly).

Are you worried your partner will leave you, and so you will need to match that 75,000k to mantain your lifestyle ? Otherwise I think you're fine.

pollykitty · 24/10/2022 11:22

I'll never understand why people separate family finances. Yep I'm one of those married women who insisted on a joint account. Why? Because it was a joint decision for me to stay home with our baby for 14 months. He could have done it too, but wanted to work. Since then I have worked PT and made less that DH, but still enough to help with bills. I feel working PT is complete and utter sht, the worst of both worlds. I am sometimes jealous of women who work FT and drop their kid off at nursery all day or school (+afterschool care). I do two mentally loading jobs but I do it for our family. But enough about me -- there is no way I was going to 'divide' our finances while or DD lives at home. No. I told DH if he didn't like it, we could get a divorce, because to me having separate finances always disadvantages the person who makes less. I feel that in the long run it works out, he is now talking about quitting his job (which I'm fine with), and I'd be the main earner. If you are thinking, this person doesn't contribute financially very much RIGHT NOW, you are only thinking in the short-term. What is the bigger earner gets sick? Or dies? The PT person has at least kept their hand in and has the capability to earn more. Talking about the disparity in incomes within a family in this manner makes me feel ill. Why are you with the person if all you care about is how much they contribute money-wise?? So yes, I would stay with a person who is a brilliant parent but makes less. Because it should be about love and family, not MONEY.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/10/2022 11:22

Would it help if parent B worked out the extra hours parenting they do - charge at nanny rate. Plus housekeeping- charge at cleaner rate. Plus impact on career and pension by being pt, having to do nursery drop offs.
So they are contributing £1600 net but saving A 50% of nanny and cleaner. Plus acting to their detriment long term which needs addressing eg is A paying into a private pension for them.

FamilyTreeBuilder · 24/10/2022 11:21

You're not scoring points, but you are keeping a detailed ledger of earnings and outgoings and contributions and percentages and hours worked and housework... exhausting.

Not much of a partnership is it.

neverbeenskiing · 24/10/2022 11:20

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:18

@woff45 he hasn’t expressed any discontent or dissatisfaction so I have to assume he is fine with it.

Or instead of assuming you could talk to him about it properly, tell him it's worrying you and find out how he actually feels about it instead of asking strangers on MN.

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 24/10/2022 11:18

Does the brilliant parent also parent the child when not working?

I would argue that brilliant parent is hugely contributing through nursery costs and actually looking after the child?
Also added in cleaning? Probably cooking?
Washing and generally caring for child and I assume parent on 75 grand?
Do they also meal plan and sort out child admi like Doc's appt. Research school etc?

Sikaris · 24/10/2022 11:18

Parent A should pay half of the childcare costs though...

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:18

Well, that’s not really what I am trying to do. But thank you just the same,

OP posts:
Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:18

@woff45 he hasn’t expressed any discontent or dissatisfaction so I have to assume he is fine with it.

OP posts:
FamilyTreeBuilder · 24/10/2022 11:18

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 10:55

I’m getting just fine advice thanks, notacooldad.

So yes …the £24,000 person should be making more of a financial contribution, is that the general feeling?

This is so weird.

Have you never heard of a joint account? I cannot imagine being in a long term relationship, having a child, earning £100k between the couple and nit-picking over who contributes what in an attempt to score points.

monkeysmum21 · 24/10/2022 11:17

So… joint income is £99k. Parents A and B are not team players so they can organise a peaceful family dynamic? With that income no one should feel stressed about money.
Parent A must remember that higher income allows higher pension contributions before moaning about mortgage, etc.

SleeplessInEngland · 24/10/2022 11:17

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 10:55

I’m getting just fine advice thanks, notacooldad.

So yes …the £24,000 person should be making more of a financial contribution, is that the general feeling?

It's not the general feeling because you've been so obtuse no-one can give a worthwhile response. How much of the nursery bill do they pay for instance?

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:17

I probably do need to change my thinking. I was looking back at some old diaries, things were a lot more equal when I first met DH and now years later not so much. I’d like that to change which has to start with me.

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 24/10/2022 11:17

Well yes, this is what I’m asking @luxxlisbon , I don’t know because I don’t really contribute, to those bills at any rate

You should still know, you aren’t a child.
It’s immature to just sit back know so little about your family finances.
Not to mention stupid for your possible future.

woff45 · 24/10/2022 11:16

What's does Partner A think of the set up?

dammit88 · 24/10/2022 11:16

I think you are fine OP. This is a very normal set up. Different jobs pay different amounts, unpaid work in the home is also valuable. Has your OH expressed they are unhappy with the situation?

DarkShade · 24/10/2022 11:15

Parent B works three days a week and does all the childcare then, plus before and after work on the working days.

So Parent B is contributing something - without parent B, parent A couldn't have their nice career.

It all depends on prior expectations and decisions but in my view it's a weird way to look at a marriage - you don't leech in a marriage, you are one single family. You stay together if you like being in a family together. People not in families decide what % of their time to allocate to earning money, raising children, doing housework, relaxing. People in families do the same, taking all the adults in the family into the equation.