Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wondering … would you stay with someone who is a brilliant parent but struggles with money?

184 replies

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 10:19

Someone who is a brilliant parent to two year old but contributes nothing really in the way of finances.

OP posts:
CarefreeMe · 24/10/2022 12:16

Why not both put a percentage into a joint account like 50% or 75% and pay all of the joint costs like food, childcare, mortgage etc out of that.

You are contributing much less financially but you are contributing in other areas too.

When your LO starts school FT there will be much fewer childcare costs and you can go back to work FT and contribute more.

I would have a chat with DP and explain your worries and recognise that you appreciate them contributing so much.
You’ll probably find they’re just as appreciative of what you bring to the table too.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:16

@SpacePotato upping my work hours would be an absolute last resort, I really genuinely feel that our DS gets a lot out of our time together.

But I do fritter money. Have tried the usual advice of writing things down, only withdrawing the cash I need and so on. Might have to try again this month.

OP posts:
Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:14

@Dixiechickonhols but in fairness if someone here earned what DH does and was married to someone crap with money then they’d be advised to keep finances separate. And that is largely why: to stop me impacting negatively on DH in a credit score sense.

OP posts:
SpacePotato · 24/10/2022 12:14

Car services and haircuts aren't surprise costs though.
You need to focus on what it is you are spending so much on credit cards on each month. Stop with the non essentials.

Are you bored? I found being the main carer incredibly dull and monotonous at times. Could you up your work hours? 4 days instead of 3 maybe?

Have you always been shit with money? Where does that stem from?

JFDIYOLO · 24/10/2022 12:13

That's basically the traditional working husband with part time working/SAH wife arrangement.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:13

@Berrylina I suppose because I am not very good with money. This is the crux of it, I am very very good at parenting but not with budgeting.

I am on £24,000, that is my PT salary.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 24/10/2022 12:13

I really don’t understand the mine and yours if married. Why not everything into pot and agree you each get £x personal spends. A haircut isn’t a luxury it’s necessary to look presentable for work.

BrieAndChilli · 24/10/2022 12:11

Also I think you are on 24k if full time not actually earing 24k if you only take home £900?

Berrylina · 24/10/2022 12:10

But why are you contributing like you're a lodger or paying your parents for letting you stay in their house?

Why do you not have a budget for whatever you do monthly as a family, bills, savings, mortgage, emergency money, etc - so things like car servicing, mot etc are accounted for, for the most part?

If you are both putting funds into the same pot and doing as above you know you're both contributing enough regardless of your incomes. If you're short monthly then one of both of you can find ways to increase your income or cut down on expenses.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/10/2022 12:09

I suspect you are spending on child and parent A isn’t contributing 50% eg what do you do on days you don’t work - activities, buying nappies or clothes etc.
Definitely read up on gender pay gap. Common scenario you and dh both earn £40,000 in professional job. Have child. You take a year maternity off. You go pt and do childcare. You earn £24,000. So you lose £16,000. But Other parent can work more overtime be more dedicated as they haven’t been off a year and don’t rush off for nursery. In 5 years they are on £50,000 you are on £24,000. As years go on their pay skyrockets yours is stagnant - you are stuck as pt advertised professional roles are pretty none existent. Years of reduced pension meaning you are potentially significantly worse off.

BrieAndChilli · 24/10/2022 12:09

you have a similar set up to us but we have a joint account so all finances are together.

I contribute a lot less financially as I earn less and until recently was part time.

This was a decision we made jointly when we have children as we both wanted a parent to be at home with them so I worked part time in the evenings. There were many reasons for this, partly due to our own childhoods that meant it was really important to us.
its fully accepted that fair isnt 'equal' I contribute less financially but more in other ways such as emotionally, mentally, childcare when they were smaller, housework, cooking etc etc. Now they are teens the split of chores etc is more equal and sometimes more from DH as he WFH but I will never be able to catch up with him financially as before we had kids we were earning equal amounts but his income and career have surged upwards and mine stalled. I am making strides and building a career but DH rceognises that I made a big sacrifice for the kids so income is something we view as joint not seperate as otherwise I would be penalised for taking time out for the kids.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:05

I have around £1000 left so in theory it should be plenty, in practice it does get eaten up rather. So this month I am getting my hair done - which I know very much counts as money on me - then my car is being serviced and will need a new tyre which won’t be cheap. I do pay for toddler groups on the days I am off work as well as childcare and for things like clothes for dc. But you are right and should probably be looking at how to contribute to the family as a whole. How much would people say is reasonable?

OP posts:
Berrylina · 24/10/2022 12:02

I think you have given too little information initially.
When you say they aren't good with money I assume you don't mean because they earn too little - I am guessing as you have confirmed it's due to poor credit. Do you spend your money on yourself OP after paying for nursery for the days your child attends when you are working?

I got the feeling you said you pay for groceries sometimes - why not all the time?
Even if you earn less surely you should know what your monthly outgoing are - a budget maybe together?

Some people do things differently but we pay everything into the same pot, then pay bills, save some and have the same personal allowances despite large differences in our income.

If you are saying you pay for nursery then buy groceries sometimes, I can see why you feel you are depending on your other half. Unless we have agreed I would hate it if my DH just spends all his income on what he wants, paid a couple of bills and left me to pay for everything else.

The other thing is whether you feel you could contribute more? i.e. more from your current earnings or earn more . . . Someone mentioned self worth . .

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:59

Not sure about the capable part Smile but quite, this is what I worry about DH feeling.

The problem with the CCs is that by the time I have paid them I literally have no money so I need them to live, vicious circle. Not sure what to do about that really.

OP posts:
SpacePotato · 24/10/2022 11:57

Parent A should pay half of the childcare costs though

Why when B pays for fuck all else?

All in all I am not very good with money, if I have it I spend it. And I do need to sort this

Well this is the crux for me.
£24k for 3 days work you must be a professional capable person.
I think on that amount you should contribute more. Especially if the other option is you just pissing it away, which, if you were my partner and I was paying almost everything, would really start to annoy me after a while.

If you can't control yourself when it comes to spending, perhaps you should ask you DH for help. Maybe transfer money into a joint savings account or something that you can't easily access or be tempted to spend, and lay off the credit cards.

JaNaJanice · 24/10/2022 11:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:50

No I don’t think he is being unfair or certainly if he is I also am. I was just struck how different things were once. Part of that is just having a child but also I think we’ve fallen into roles of carer (me) provider (him) and more of a mix would be good perhaps.

OP posts:
Mardyface · 24/10/2022 11:45

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:33

I don’t think it’s happened intentionally. I’m certainly not married to someone abusive or controlling.

But what has happened is we’ve fallen into roles for all sorts of reasons. These reasons are good but I think it would be good to address them. But I need to work out myself what I want addressing and before I accuse dh of being unfair have to consider myself if I might be being so.

I don't think you have to address it as him being unfair. In fact I would be very careful not to if you want to have a good conversation about it, not a defensive one (I think it vanishingly unlikely that you are being unfair either).

If you want things to change, that's OK. I think you're right that you have to know what it is that you want to change. If I were you I could not possibly endure being so financially blocked out. The income may not arrive in the account in your name but that does not mean that you have not contributed to the earning of it. Your H wants to live as a family, presumably, so he needs to recognise that you are now a type of financial unit and as adults you are both in charge of the decisions around that. The risk when you try to break everything down to every last contribution and spend is that you end up putting financial tags on things which shouldn't have them, like 'well I love you, and that's worth 20k a year, and then there's the blowjobs when I don't really feel like it' - I'm joking. Kind of.

It is very easy to fall into those traditional roles, I know. Feels a bit like a trap doesn't it. But there is a way out and it certainly doesn't have to mean the end of your marriage. It may mean more honesty and probably a few arguments as a result, but that's OK.

KhaleesiDothraki · 24/10/2022 11:38

This reply has been deleted

Previously banned poster - this has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Ponderingwindow · 24/10/2022 11:37

Person b, the op, doesn’t understand the economics of pregnancy and child rearing. The financial implications of being the primary parent can never be ignored.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:35

@riotlady well there are things like my own phone, petrol and so on.

Then I do have credit cards, I clear them every month but like the phoenix they return …

All in all I am not very good with money, if I have it I spend it. And I do need to sort this.

OP posts:
Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:34

It wasn’t just your post @neverbeenskiing and I will be talking to DH. I’d just like to work things out for myself first. But it would be good if bitching at me for not writing a thread to the exacting standards of MN could stop (I don’t mean you but even so, when I want to stop writing and talk to DH I will.)

OP posts:
MsPincher · 24/10/2022 11:34

I know a lot of women and some men like parent b. You are contributing financially and via childcare so I wouldn’t worry about that. I do think it’s an issue that you don’t know how much the mortgage is etc. that indicates to me that you are not taking equal responsibility for finances - you should know how much your outgoings are and manage your money

riotlady · 24/10/2022 11:33

I’ve read all the OPs messages but not the whole thread so apologies if I’ve missed something- if you earn 24k and pay for no bills other than £600 nursery and occasional grocery shop, where does the rest of your money go?

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:33

I don’t think it’s happened intentionally. I’m certainly not married to someone abusive or controlling.

But what has happened is we’ve fallen into roles for all sorts of reasons. These reasons are good but I think it would be good to address them. But I need to work out myself what I want addressing and before I accuse dh of being unfair have to consider myself if I might be being so.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread