Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wondering … would you stay with someone who is a brilliant parent but struggles with money?

184 replies

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 10:19

Someone who is a brilliant parent to two year old but contributes nothing really in the way of finances.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 24/10/2022 12:52

To me, a household income of 99k is large and comfortable and so I don't think that anybody inside that set up is being a leech. Presumably to earn a 75k salary and have a child, one needs support from a partner. 75k jobs tend not to be especially friendly towards nursery pick up times nor frequent time off for minor illness nor school terms. And I would also assume that a 75k job required some working up to meaning performing well, and I would imagine that in the majority of heterosexual relationships, a man recieves support from his partner/wife in taking the majority or at least some of the household admin, cleaning, cooking, shopping off his plate entirely therefore freeing up mental energy for him to devote to work and perform well.

It might be different if the household is struggling financially, but 99k is not.

If it helps give perspective, our household income is much (maybe 60% ish?) lower, we are comfortable, DH earns all of it and when I've expressed anxiety about contributing he just says absolutely no, my contribution (in terms of childcare/pregnancy/baby care/presence) is incredibly valuable and I should not feel like I need to earn. I want to anyway, but it's for personal reasons to me, not because I feel like I owe it to the family, and I expect/accept that the flip side to me earning would be that I will have less availability to the younger DC and less capacity to support DH mentally/physically (which I'm not very good at TBH, luckily he doesn't seem to mind or need this, though I'm sure it would benefit him if I did). Somebody on 75k does not need a partner to support them financially and if he's suggesting you do or make you feel guilty for "only" bringing in 24k then he can fuck off TBH. That's not a partnership, that's just someone thinking of themselves.

TeenDivided · 24/10/2022 12:50

I think if neither of you have anything left at the end of the month you need to sit together, examine all of the spending, and go from there. On that income I'd expect there to be money left / regular savings going on.

if you are doing the bulk of childcare then you are pulling your weight, but neither of you having money left is a concern I think.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/10/2022 12:46

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:36

@Dixiechickonhols i think I did misinterpret your intentions so apologies for that but I am partly playing devils advocate here - but I have to confess I am a bit hurt by the ‘are you autistic’ - I realise autism isn’t an insult but it’s not generally said as a compliment and it does usually refer to awkward social communication. It came out of the blue rather and did wrong foot me a bit.

I certainly don’t mean autistic as an insult at all. It was just from how you came across and some of your thoughts and responses. I was aiming for supportive not criticising you.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:45

But how much is reasonable @LemonsAndCherries ? (And saying you’re shocked isn’t helpful without further info re what you’re shocked about.)

@emptythelitterbox it varies, I’ll try to answer

How many hours per week do you both spend working and on household tasks and childcare? Dh does five days at work I do three. I care for DS the two days I’m not working. Weekends it does more fall to me I’d say. But hard to say as it varies.

How much do each of you have left at the end of the month? Nothing for me, don’t think DH has anything left either at the moment

Would you consider yourselves in a traditional marriage? No not deliberately or consciously but that’s nonetheless what’s happened.

OP posts:
LemonPledge555 · 24/10/2022 12:42

My household is v similar to yours but my earnings are less and DH more. Basically I’ve had to face up to the fact that in the here and now, my time is much better spent at home supporting DD as DH often away with work. I could earn more, but there would be significant impact on time/consistency with DD, and more childcare costs.

My DH has been v reassuring about it, as it’s hard for me to have much less financial independence. When we met, he was a higher earner but the gap has got far wider over the last 5/6 years for multiple reasons. I would definitely have a chat with your DH and see how he feels about it. Our finances are separate too. Basically he gives me what I budget that I’ll need and I break it down into pots for various things.

Something that has really helped me is putting aside money for set bills every month, and then splitting remaining money by how many weeks in the month and giving myself that money weekly. Like you, I cover most of the bits and pieces for DC. I would also try and factor in a small savings pot so that when you have stuff for you car that you’ll be able to use that. It took me a v long time to realise that monthly wages just don’t suit me and that I go a bit mad and end up with nothing, the same as I did when I was a student. I’m now pushing 40 for reference.

emptythelitterbox · 24/10/2022 12:42

Ok I'll try to help but need more info.

How many hours per week do you both spend working and on household tasks and childcare?

How much do each of you have left at the end of the month?

Would you consider yourselves in a traditional marriage?

LemonsAndCherries · 24/10/2022 12:41

To answer your 'how much us reasonable' question, you contribute all of it and then have an agreed amount each to spend as you wish/on essentials as you perceive them for you! Phone, petrol, kids clothes, hairdressers, an agreed amount on your clothes - all come from the joint pot.

I'm a bit shocked.

Luckydip1 · 24/10/2022 12:37

Leave unless you want to end up bankrupt.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:36

titchy · 24/10/2022 12:35

How the fuck would anyone know that based on what you've posted. Mortgage and bills could be £100 a month as far as we know, and nursery could be £2000 a month. Hmm

Chill, it’s half term Confused

OP posts:
LemonsAndCherries · 24/10/2022 12:36

If all money is pooled then absolutely fine as one parent is doing more childcare, I assume. Parent AB's money should be pooled though.

My DH is a stay at home dad. I do the earning. He does the childcare and enables me to earn. Works fine because we are a team. If he does get a part time job in the future, that money would be joint money too.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:36

@Dixiechickonhols i think I did misinterpret your intentions so apologies for that but I am partly playing devils advocate here - but I have to confess I am a bit hurt by the ‘are you autistic’ - I realise autism isn’t an insult but it’s not generally said as a compliment and it does usually refer to awkward social communication. It came out of the blue rather and did wrong foot me a bit.

OP posts:
titchy · 24/10/2022 12:35

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 10:55

I’m getting just fine advice thanks, notacooldad.

So yes …the £24,000 person should be making more of a financial contribution, is that the general feeling?

How the fuck would anyone know that based on what you've posted. Mortgage and bills could be £100 a month as far as we know, and nursery could be £2000 a month. Hmm

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:33

I think that my worry is just that he’ll resent me. As PP have said I do contribute in ways that aren’t financial but I’m also conscious that finances are a pretty big thing.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 24/10/2022 12:33

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:29

I don’t think you’re being kind, @Dixiechickonhols , are you?

I do grasp it thanks, the whole thread is about it.

I will bow out as I was trying to help. As a third party reading it I think you are being very hard on yourself and looking at it very black and white - I only pay x. I was trying to frame it in a way that made you understand your valuable contribution to family life. But it’s obviously not come across to you that way.

Mardyface · 24/10/2022 12:32

A car service is not a personal spend. A haircut, possibly, but it's hardly a fucking fox fur is it?

You seem determined to be in the wrong here. Not sure why. But if you marry and have children with someone the finances have to become joint otherwise in your case one of you is potentially living in luxury while the other is forgoing hair cuts so they can fix the car. That doesn't HAVE to mean joint accounts but it is the easiest way to do it, with a personal spend amount each. That can be equal or not depending on how much you want to flagellate yourself for 'not contributing' just doing all the childcare and housework.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 24/10/2022 12:31

Everyone works their finances differently I guess.
For what it's worth...

DH earns 4 times what I do.
He's FT, I work 3 days.
I have ds2 the days im not working
We split the housework - if anything he does more because he does bits in between meetings etc while I do nothing the days im out at work.
He's able to build he career because I work PT and in a job that fits well with childcare - ie, if he needs to go on away days etc, im always around to pick up at home.
DH is firmly of the opinion that if I can't build my career (I swapped jobs and took a pay cut after children) because of our children then I shouldn't be penalised financially because their OUR children. We have no family around to help at all so it makes sense to us that one of us is always on hand/local etc for children because there is no plan B if something happens.

We just pay the bills and share the rest and it works for us. To me, that's the key - work out what you're both happy with or work out what you're both unhappy with and make changes to that.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:29

I don’t think you’re being kind, @Dixiechickonhols , are you?

I do grasp it thanks, the whole thread is about it.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 24/10/2022 12:27

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:19

I suppose this is the point, he wouldn’t, which would mean taking money from him and he would feel resentful which obviously isn’t what I want!

You still don’t appear to be grasping the massive none monetary contribution you are making.
I mean this kindly op but are you autistic? From your writing style. You appear hung up on I only pay x. It’s not how families work. You are really doing yourself down.
If you died tomorrow how would his life look? Could he work his current job and do nursery runs? If not would be need a nanny - all of a sudden his net income is vastly reduced. Then take off expense of a cleaner as you do that currently. All of a sudden his available money is a fraction of what it was when you were alive.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:25

Neither of us have savings in the form of bank accounts, there is some money tied up in property.

In terms of the CCs it is most day to day stuff but I could definitely make cutbacks and should.

OP posts:
EllieQ · 24/10/2022 12:23

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 11:35

@riotlady well there are things like my own phone, petrol and so on.

Then I do have credit cards, I clear them every month but like the phoenix they return …

All in all I am not very good with money, if I have it I spend it. And I do need to sort this.

So what kind of things are going on the credit card - your personal spends (clothes, haircuts, work lunches, daily coffee) or household/ child costs (food shopping, child’s clothes/ shoes / classes or activities)?

I’d say that household/ child costs should come from joint money, not your own money, but that might be harder to split out with the way you and your DH/ DP seem to organise your finances - I’m guessing he pays most bills from his account and you pay childcare & food from your account. You should not be expected to contribute equally to finances due to the disparity in your income - something like a 75:25 split would be fair.

In my experience, it’s a lot easier with a joint account as well as your own personal accounts. We have a joint account for everything household/ child/ food/ pet related costs, and know how much needs to be put in there each month to cover usual monthly costs plus any extra costs like birthdays, Xmas etc.

The monthly amount is split between us (currently 60:40 as I work part-time). The rest of my money is mine to spend as I want. This makes it easier for me to budget as I know how much free money I have each month.

As to the feeling of imbalance in your relationship, I think that happens a lot when one partner (and it’s usually the mum) goes part time or becomes a SAHM. You do sound as though you’ve let things drift a bit by letting DH deal with all the finances - this is disempowering you as you’re not aware of the full financial position. Does he acknowledge that you going part time means you do more childcare/ household stuff? Is there a reason he can’t do any of the nursery runs (commute etc) or has it just fallen to you bu default? Have you thought about how to manage when your DC is at school and you need to cover holidays etc? All things to think about if you’re feeling uncomfortable with the way things are happening now.

SpacePotato · 24/10/2022 12:21

I've never had a joint account with DP.
It's not always necessary or wanted.

But you could have a joint savings account which would remove some of the money and temptation to spend from your own account.

Does he know the extent of your spending? Assume he knows you are rubbish with money?

Dixiechickonhols · 24/10/2022 12:20

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:14

@Dixiechickonhols but in fairness if someone here earned what DH does and was married to someone crap with money then they’d be advised to keep finances separate. And that is largely why: to stop me impacting negatively on DH in a credit score sense.

I don’t see how you’d impact his credit score by having a joint account unless you run it overdrawn and cancel dds etc. I’d get some independent financial advice.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:19

I suppose this is the point, he wouldn’t, which would mean taking money from him and he would feel resentful which obviously isn’t what I want!

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 24/10/2022 12:18

If you aren’t good at budgeting then surely all the more important to have a family pot and designated individual spends.
Car example. If you can’t pay for it fixing your husband lets you walk to work and your child has to miss activities. What if you decide to get a part worn tyre as that’s all you can afford and he says it’s not safe with his child in - does he pay difference. It’s no way to live when you have a child.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:18

I could but probably won’t or if I do we’ll end up with private school which isn’t really conducive to saving money of course! I could talk to DH about the joint account, it is one possibility but the worry is inadvertently negatively impacting on his credit.

OP posts: