Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wondering … would you stay with someone who is a brilliant parent but struggles with money?

184 replies

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 10:19

Someone who is a brilliant parent to two year old but contributes nothing really in the way of finances.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BertieBotts · 25/10/2022 08:32

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 13:53

Like I say he certainly isn’t abusive or anything. It’s me I’m worried about, that I’m being inconsiderate without meaning to be.

You aren't. The reason people are talking about him being abusive is because if he was the one making you feel as though you're being inconsiderate, that would be so out of line/unreasonable that it would be abuse.

Since it's coming from you, you need to give yourself a break!

Imagine a small company of four people: One makes a product, one researches the best and new ways to make the product and feeds this back to the maker, one advertises and sells the product, the fourth person cleans the office, does the accounts, orders and keeps track of materials, makes the tea.

The salesperson is the one bringing all the money in, but they don't take home the largest salary. The money that the salesperson brings in is used to pay for materials, the electricity bill, the advertising costs etc and then whatever is left over is profit, to be divided between the four people as their take home pay.

It would not be fair for the salesperson to take everything, and say well - research person, you need to go online and sell your ideas to bring in some money. Making person, you need to keep some product back and sell it. It's not fair that I am the only one bringing in money here. This would be stupid because the person who is good at sales should be doing all of the selling, it would stretch the other people too thin if they were doing their jobs and also thinking about how directly they could bring money into the company.

A family should be the same IMO. You have two people who directly bring in different amounts of money (perhaps one of them all of it, perhaps just different amounts) but once it's in the family, it's just all one pot. It's used for the family expenses (housing, heating, childcare, food, cars toys clothes, savings etc) and the rest is either divided out between a small amount of pocket money for older children and an amount of spending money for adults, or put into a communal pot for general spending.

If you are having issues budgeting as a family I recommend YNAB, it's not free but it's paid for itself in our family and it's helped me understand DH's wage and everything seems less confusing.

Hello12345678910 · 24/10/2022 17:44

@Broccolicelery
I'm also parent b! (However, I earn significantly less than you and parent a also significantly less than your other half!)

I contribute half towards the mortgage/CT/energy/water - he pays the rest, we live predominantly on his wages..

If your OH hasn't made any indication of being discontent, I'm not sure I'd suggest changing anything at the moment! :)

Topgub · 24/10/2022 17:35

@Mardyface

You think the aibu board specifically is a support group?

Huh

Mardyface · 24/10/2022 17:14

But it... is a support group isn't it? Mumsnet?

Topgub · 24/10/2022 16:14

@Broccolicelery

No. You'll not have seen me post anything helpful.

This isn't a support group.

What kind of help were you looking for? Your op isn't really clear

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 14:12

Thanks. It is hard because anything I do contribute is so minimal it barely seems worth it. I do think I do a very good job of caring for our child and that’s probably what is important.

OP posts:
AprilHeather · 24/10/2022 14:08

I do think you need to reframe how you think you are contributing. Financially isn’t the only way you are contributing and you need to consider the childcare you contribute as equally valuable as paid work. Once you have reframed your thinking on this way, then you could start to think about the split of finances, taking into consideration your unpaid work with the children and home. Couples/families/etc have different ways of splitting finances. We used to split ours proportionate to income but this didn’t account for other things we did to contribute to our family. So now we keep the same amount of money each per month for personal
stuff like clothes, hair, mobiles, etc and all the rest of our money goes in a joint account for everything else to do with children/family/house. So that part would be your and your DH’s personal preference, but I really do think you need to appreciate the value in the childrearing and housework you are doing. In my opinion, at least x

TeenDivided · 24/10/2022 14:05

@ChiefWiggumsBoy
your earnings are approx. 1/3 of his. Therefore, on a very basic level, you should put in approx. 1/3 to the family pot.

NO her earnings are 1/3rd of his. So they are 1/4 of the total so she should put in approx 1/4 of the family pot. (Or pay into the pot in a ratio 1:3)

AnathemaPulsifer · 24/10/2022 14:02

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:16

@SpacePotato upping my work hours would be an absolute last resort, I really genuinely feel that our DS gets a lot out of our time together.

But I do fritter money. Have tried the usual advice of writing things down, only withdrawing the cash I need and so on. Might have to try again this month.

Open a Monzo account. Work out how much money you have per week and transfer it to the Monzo account weekly. If you don’t have enough money on the Monzo account the spending will have to wait until next week (do grocery shopping early in the week!).

This approach has been brilliant as helping me budget. Spending in Monzo is also categorised so you can see where you could be cutting back.

MolliciousIntent · 24/10/2022 13:55

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 13:52

I suppose we’ve just never really needed a household pot as such. We each just pay what we pay for. But financially that probably is unfair.

Yup. You need to sit down, total up all your income and all your expenditure. You have about 100k between you, he pays in 75% of that and you 25%. So he should be paying 75% of the bills and you 25%.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 13:53

Like I say he certainly isn’t abusive or anything. It’s me I’m worried about, that I’m being inconsiderate without meaning to be.

OP posts:
Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 13:52

I suppose we’ve just never really needed a household pot as such. We each just pay what we pay for. But financially that probably is unfair.

OP posts:
emptythelitterbox · 24/10/2022 13:40

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 12:45

But how much is reasonable @LemonsAndCherries ? (And saying you’re shocked isn’t helpful without further info re what you’re shocked about.)

@emptythelitterbox it varies, I’ll try to answer

How many hours per week do you both spend working and on household tasks and childcare? Dh does five days at work I do three. I care for DS the two days I’m not working. Weekends it does more fall to me I’d say. But hard to say as it varies.

How much do each of you have left at the end of the month? Nothing for me, don’t think DH has anything left either at the moment

Would you consider yourselves in a traditional marriage? No not deliberately or consciously but that’s nonetheless what’s happened.

Thanks for the responses. That helps.
So your paid and unpaid labor add up to 7 days per week and his adds up to 5 days per week. In no way are you a leech.
Unpaid labour is worth something!
Were you aware that women's unpaid labor worldwise is valued at over 10.9 trillion US dollars!

So that is my answer for that.

If he truly has nothing left at the end up the month, then obviously you have some big expenses.

I do think you need more transparency with finances from him to help with future planning even. Some others have given suggestions wrt talks, monitoring finances, budgeting.

My next questions are does he make you feel like you're not doing enough? Are you happy with how things are now? What changes would you like if any?

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 24/10/2022 13:40

Your earnings are approx. 1/3 of his.

Therefore, on a very basic level, you should put in approx. 1/3 to the family pot.

(Making up numbers here, but let's say for example):

£600 nursery
£800 mortgage
£300 other misc. home payments
£200 insurances
£150 wifi / phones etc.
total: £2050

So the minimum you need to cover all bills is £2050, but there will obviously be other incidental family costs, like fuel, soft play, swimming - whatever you're doing with your son during the week, groceries, maybe a sneaky takeaway here and there.

Monthly take home:
You - £1680
Him - £4300

One of two ways to spin it (bear in mind my completely made up figures!) - either you both pay in a proportion of your salary to cover the spends, which would be about £680 for you and £1370 for him. That leaves him with a lot more disposable funds than you.

Better would be for you to each keep £1000 of your salary in your accounts as your own spends for the month. The rest goes into a joint account for family spends, that will include all of those incidentals. And you both have a nice amount of 'fun money'. Anything left over in the joint account to be siphoned off into savings.

Of course I'm not taking into consideration things like, he has higher income but also has a David Lloyd membership, or you pay £40 a month for an iPhone. I would consider all those to be family spends if I'm honest but some would put them into the 'fun money' category.

This is how I would do it anyway. Hope that's helpful!

MolliciousIntent · 24/10/2022 13:25

Why don't you have a household pot?

TeenDivided · 24/10/2022 13:24

I think you need to sit down together to go through 6 months worth of bank & credit card statements and get an idea of where the money is going.
We often see on MN that the SAHP ends up spending on the child without realising that should be counted as a joint expense.

You are a team (or you should be). I think you are being unduly negative on youself.

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 13:15

I’m sure you’ve posted helpful things somewhere @Topgub , I’ve never seen it though.

I think since we don’t really have a household pot things inevitably are paid for by me or DH so yes I probably buy more toys etc but DH pays for the mortgage which is arguably more important!

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 24/10/2022 13:15

TBH it doesn't sound like much of a partnership.

I work part time and have always earned less than DH. However, we are a partnership in the true sense of the word. We have a joint account. I was the primary carer when DD was little. I did all the life admin, most of the cooking, washing and cleaning.

A partnership is not just a financial transaction. If your other half is financially abusing you he will get a shock if you separate and finds that he will be required to pay out a lot more than he does now.

Topgub · 24/10/2022 13:13

Well if it entirely depends on your sex

If you're a woman then its perfectly acceptable and in fact desirable. You shouldn't even really be working at all. Being a sahm should be your ultimate goal.

If you're a man it's obviously completely unacceptable and you're just a cocklodger.

TeenDivided · 24/10/2022 13:12

Struggles with money

  • doesn't earn much (because busy being the go to parent?)
  • often runs out of money (because doesn't have much to start with?)
  • is a demonstrably profligate spender (buys unnecessary expensive items???)

OP. As a matter of interest, who pays for your DC's clothes, toys etc? Does that count as 'household spending' or do you feel it should come out of your own spends? (HINT: It should be household).

FinallyHere · 24/10/2022 13:07

Struggles with money is IMO a very different thing to does not earn outside of the home.

Earning money especially in a corporate, management role is very much easier than parenting a two year old round the clock.

Which is it here @Broccolicelery

The split of money you describe does not sound at all they way would do it.

Much fairer to work out what it hosts to run your household including the children. You work out how to contribute to a household account from which all costs are paid for.

Some people contribute in proportion to your contribution. Others so you end up with equal spending money.

The way you are dividing the hills at the moment does not seem fair to me. The fact they you post about them 'struggling with money' tells you all you need to know about the unfairness.

Do you have any intention or making things more fair?

Broccolicelery · 24/10/2022 13:03

There are all sorts of reasons there’s nothing left at the moment. But phrases like grow up, while they may be much loved by MN, are not helpful. They just aren’t.

@BertieBotts I’m not trying to argue that it isn’t a good income. That is really not what the threads about.

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 24/10/2022 12:57

You both need to grow up and have an open discussion about your finances.
A 100k income, only 1 child and you don’t even have £100 saved.

outdoorcushions20 · 24/10/2022 12:56

A salary of £24k is a take home pay of around £1650. Assuming PT nursery is around £700-£800 a month and that Parent B is looking after DC and household responsibilities the rest of the time, plus occasional contributing to shopping, I'd personally say this is pretty fair.

If parent A is not happy with the arrangement, parent A should talk to parent B.

Mardyface · 24/10/2022 12:55

I would be very very surprised if your H has no money left at the end of the month.

It is your responsibility to know this. It is legally half your money. In the event you did divorce a court would be looking at your potential earnings which are way less than your H's so you may well be awarded more than half.

I don't think you are leeching at all but I do think you need to protect yourself and be a bit more aware about what your family money situation is.