Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This may be unpopular - but what about the squeezed middle?

590 replies

AndroidUsername · 24/10/2022 07:43

They are talking about raising taxes on the average person now. Which will really effect lower middle class families who are already feeling the pinch due to increases in cost of food, gas and electic, increasing childcare costs and rent or morgage increases. They are going to increase pensions and benefits with inflation but lots of middle class earners are not having their wages increased with inflation but will now have their taxes increased. What about help for the middle class, especially lower middle class and working class who earn slightly to much to qualify for any help but will now stuggle with all these increases.

OP posts:
Kabalagala · 24/10/2022 13:37

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 24/10/2022 13:34

Except practically the whole world did them.

Look at the state of the NHs now. How much worse would it have been without lockdown?

All the money wasted on testing and furlough could have been invested in the NHS.

BorisIsaSpider · 24/10/2022 13:35

Middle-class people get salaries, not wages. I am fed up with this nonsense.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 24/10/2022 13:34

Cuppasoupmonster · 24/10/2022 13:32

The lockdowns were a waste of time and a criminal waste of money. They should never have happened.

Except practically the whole world did them.

Look at the state of the NHs now. How much worse would it have been without lockdown?

Cuppasoupmonster · 24/10/2022 13:32

The lockdowns were a waste of time and a criminal waste of money. They should never have happened.

Roomytrouser · 24/10/2022 13:29

I think the problem for the government is people notice if they feel less financially secure, even if that means moving from a very comfortable to an averagely comfortable position, it’s a relative shift that they notice. Someone might be ok missing their holiday and stopping eating out for a year but when they realise that downshift is permanent they will start to ask more questions. And a lot of those in the “middle” are used to feeling that they aren’t completely ignored by the political classes.

SafeMove · 24/10/2022 13:29

Quveas · 24/10/2022 13:17

I am not going to respond to the sweary unevidenced rant, but for those interested in how the wealthy reduce their tax with the full support of the government, here's a starter for 10:
www.oxfam.org/en/inequality-and-poverty-hidden-costs-tax-dodging#:~:text=Through%20a%20complex%20and%20loosely,the%20heart%20of%20this%20system.
www.theguardian.com/news/2022/sep/27/super-rich-uk-non-doms-avoiding-32bn-in-tax-each-year-report-finds
www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/wealthy-uk-tax-cost-rate-capital-gains-income-tax-a9566211.html
leftfootforward.org/2022/04/prof-prem-sikka-tax-legislation-in-the-uk-benefits-the-interests-of-the-rich/
www.taxjustice.uk/taxing-wealth.html

Tax cuts are not just about reductions in the rate of income tax. In fact, reductions in the rate of income tax generally have little impact at all on government income. This is because the likes of most of us don't have enough money, even collectively, to give much to the government anyway. So cuts in income tax broadly are pocket change to the government. Governments have many other taxes, and many other ways of cutting taxes, and by enabling those, they effectively can raise or cut taxes and target those cuts. The vast majority of them are aimed at cutting taxes for the extermely wealthy - both individuals and corporations - and this "tax avoidance" is worth £billions every year. There is a reason why the rich get richer and the poor get poorer, and government polices are at the root of it.

The issue in this country (and I don't think we are alone in it) is evidenced on this thread. Too many people are intent upon finding some group to blame - whether that is the sick, the disabled, or benefit claimants - and then justifying why whatever they have is "deserved" or that they "deserve more", rather than placing the blame firmly where it stands, with government policy on economics. And I don't care whether the party in government is blue, red or polka-dotted - economics is not a "one-size fits all" area, and needs intelligent debate and approaches, not vitriol and scapegoating.

But that is probably beyond us, if this thread is anything to go by.

100% correct.

And the offer of changing that system, reducing the inequality gap and closing the grip the 1% have on that equality gap was resolutely rejected by the electorate in 2019. People didn't want a party who believed in collectivism - it was shouted down as loony lefties being 'dangerous' because they wanted to give people who they thought were 'undeserving' their money and they did not want to share. It was in the oppositions campaign slogan 'many/few' and it was rejected. People thought it would be better to elect an individualist who believed in neo liberalism and the everyman for himself ideology. Johnson is the living embodiment of it. Everyone knew and knows what he is and they like it. What did people expect to happen?

Worriedddd · 24/10/2022 13:25

kittensinthekitchen · 24/10/2022 13:20

People who are obviously just not as bright as @Worriedddd

Of course, it couldn't be that a whole bunch of people didn't have the luxury of stopping to think about repayment; rather had to focus on survival- nah, it must just have been that they thought it was free Hmm

Come on really how many people were gloating about sitting in their gardens in the new hot tub? Some were struggling many were not

WahineToa · 24/10/2022 13:24

rather had to focus on survival what are you talking about? I wasn’t at all worried about my survival as throughout the entire thing it was crystal clear I was never at any real risk. According to the experts. I had covid the first time before the first lockdown started.

PeachyPoppedBack · 24/10/2022 13:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I disagree.

The biggest problems the U.K. faces right now is that blinkin 50/50 split that seems to mean we can’t work together in anything, to survive this we all need to pull together and move in from that.

I’d get it whatever with means testing but shared welfare means it’s in the interests of all to keep the system working- there are many less generous than you who would merrily turn in the less fortunate if they didn’t have some investment. You see it in social media all the time anyway, the hate to those who need help.

Besides if you’re taking the cash fora pension you have to return it, and the way the system is designed means you couldn’t pay those who need it any other way- the money is paid straight out to current retired people rather than saved for them, so if the only people claiming were those who could not pay much or anything in it would sink rapidly.

WahineToa · 24/10/2022 13:23

Those raising the cost of furlough and lockdown overall I assume are saying that the costs of lockdown were far greater than the benefits of doing so. At the time, as we know, nobody did a cost benefit analysis and lockdowns didn’t do much to ‘save lives’ as everyone was hysterically screaming at the time. We should have had a targeted approach to covid, protecting the most vulnerable, while everyone else carried on. You can’t just shut down everything. Beyond the initial 3 months to get a grip on things, every lockdown thereafter was a cost we could never afford.

neverbeenskiing · 24/10/2022 13:23

I work in a school and we are haemorrhaging experienced support staff. They are all leaving to work in the private sector because they simply cannot afford to stay. It's not right that people who are working full-time are lying awake at night worrying about how they're going to pay for essentials, but an increasing number of our staff are in that position. We've always given food bank vouchers to parents who are struggling, but for the first time I'm now having to give these to school staff too. Competition for support staff roles in schools used to be fierce, but now we're struggling to fill vacancies because people cannot manage on what schools can afford to pay them. It is a really worrying time.

kittensinthekitchen · 24/10/2022 13:20

bercan · 24/10/2022 13:03

Many people thought the magic money tree would go on forever surely people knew inflation and depression was coming after printing so much money ?

who are these people you are talking about?

People who are obviously just not as bright as @Worriedddd

Of course, it couldn't be that a whole bunch of people didn't have the luxury of stopping to think about repayment; rather had to focus on survival- nah, it must just have been that they thought it was free Hmm

WahineToa · 24/10/2022 13:19

I recall even MN - a business that is run predominantly digitally, and I would have thought a great example in how to work from home - claimed to have furloughed around 90% of their staff (maybe be misremembering the figure, but it was high).

Are you kidding me? What a disgrace. @MNHQ should be ashamed if that’s the case.

OMG12 · 24/10/2022 13:19

Yep it’s those middle earners who were the ones supporting the hospitalised and entertainment sectors (who in turn supported the lower paid) who are going to be the worst hit, but this then hits the people who were supported by their spending. We’re currently in holiday, previously we would have eaten out most lunches and dinners, now we are SC and having one dinner out this week. Entertainment is free stuff, not going to the theatre etc

having to ditch this discretionary spend might seem a first world problem, and for us it is absolutely, but for the people (often on minimum wage) who work in these sectors it’s going to be the difference between employment and unemployment

Quveas · 24/10/2022 13:17

I am not going to respond to the sweary unevidenced rant, but for those interested in how the wealthy reduce their tax with the full support of the government, here's a starter for 10:
www.oxfam.org/en/inequality-and-poverty-hidden-costs-tax-dodging#:~:text=Through%20a%20complex%20and%20loosely,the%20heart%20of%20this%20system.
www.theguardian.com/news/2022/sep/27/super-rich-uk-non-doms-avoiding-32bn-in-tax-each-year-report-finds
www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/wealthy-uk-tax-cost-rate-capital-gains-income-tax-a9566211.html
leftfootforward.org/2022/04/prof-prem-sikka-tax-legislation-in-the-uk-benefits-the-interests-of-the-rich/
www.taxjustice.uk/taxing-wealth.html

Tax cuts are not just about reductions in the rate of income tax. In fact, reductions in the rate of income tax generally have little impact at all on government income. This is because the likes of most of us don't have enough money, even collectively, to give much to the government anyway. So cuts in income tax broadly are pocket change to the government. Governments have many other taxes, and many other ways of cutting taxes, and by enabling those, they effectively can raise or cut taxes and target those cuts. The vast majority of them are aimed at cutting taxes for the extermely wealthy - both individuals and corporations - and this "tax avoidance" is worth £billions every year. There is a reason why the rich get richer and the poor get poorer, and government polices are at the root of it.

The issue in this country (and I don't think we are alone in it) is evidenced on this thread. Too many people are intent upon finding some group to blame - whether that is the sick, the disabled, or benefit claimants - and then justifying why whatever they have is "deserved" or that they "deserve more", rather than placing the blame firmly where it stands, with government policy on economics. And I don't care whether the party in government is blue, red or polka-dotted - economics is not a "one-size fits all" area, and needs intelligent debate and approaches, not vitriol and scapegoating.

But that is probably beyond us, if this thread is anything to go by.

RosaGallica · 24/10/2022 13:16

Weonlyhavealoanofit · 24/10/2022 11:49

The older I get, and I’m retired, the more it’s apparent that ‘the system’ doesn’t work. Post war, there was plenty of work in factories and the nation produced a huge amount of things which the rest of the world wanted. For a variety of reasons, not least Thatcher’s determination to destroy the unions, successive governments have embraced the ideology of globalization and light touch regulation. Now we have an economy which is about ‘financial services’ and dominated by activity in the City of London. The SE has seen growth, but the rest of the UK (bar some isolated pockets of wealth) has struggled and part of the struggle is the failure to tax fairly and squarely, the very rich including corporations. For far too long, the rules have been deliberately designed to benefit the very rich, be it the use of ‘non-dom’ status or the use of secretive trusts, contrived off shore arrangements and the use of off the shelf companies, to hide monies. The tax burden is heaviest on those who are not rich. It is lightest for those at the top who are most able to pay. Until ‘we’ insist on a fairer tax system and stop pretending that “small government: low taxes” improves our society, the squeeze will continue. Very rich people can bypass all of the things funded by the state. They don’t need a good Public Health Service, good state schools, libraries, geriatric care facilities and a functioning transport system. These same people/corporations don’t need a functioning robust parliamentary democracy, their influence is bought using lobbyists and donating to its party of choice. Does the economy exist to benefit the nation or is it the other way round?

This. Neoliberalism was a theory that promoted international movement of capital, and paid no attention to actual production and how the things we need are made. Similarly home-grown sustainability was waved aside in favour of the idea of a globalised market and - can’t remember what it’s called - the idea that each region of the world should specialise in one area. Lovely idea if all the world cooperated and was at peace and there were no transportation impacts on the environment. London’s economy boomed with all that “lovely” international investment they went on about, and with deregulation freed up those who made money from everyone else’s work to buy the country out from under us. The house prices were the start of the practical impacts, coupled with the reduction in jobs that saw the massive competitive push into more qualifications, which then had to be paid for by someone.

To a pp who asked why ‘we’ allowed it, it was because money for nothing was waved at the boomers, who were the first generation to face consumerism and teenagerdom. In large part they got irritated with complaints from what was then the much smaller population of under-30s who they exploited to make their wealth. They concocted every excuse they could to ignore us. It’s only when the millennium generation grew up and sheer numbers tipped things over that we had the numbers to make them hear.

Worriedddd · 24/10/2022 13:15

bercan · 24/10/2022 13:11

energy prices have been hugely impacted by the war though so not sure how the gov could have warned people about that?

No but they should have told the public the reality of printing lots of money. We can hand out this money but things will get very painful for UK PLC going forward. They simply don't have the money to bail everyone out now, interest rates are going up including the national debt. Taxes will need to probably rise.

bercan · 24/10/2022 13:11

energy prices have been hugely impacted by the war though so not sure how the gov could have warned people about that?

bercan · 24/10/2022 13:10

People now asking for energy and mortgage bailouts.

so most of the population then?! 😆

GoGoose · 24/10/2022 13:10

Worriedddd · 24/10/2022 12:53

People were taking bounce back loans to use as house deposits when stamp duty was frozen. Or taking the money then running abroad. I know this my OH earns 6 figures as a self employed contractor and some of his colleagues were doing it.

HMRC are methodically combing through small businesses and prosecuting those were evidence points to loans not being used for business purposes. Sole traders and 'one-man companies' are a specific target as are those put into liquidation or an informal 'strike-off' at Companies House. Banks are routinely supplying HMRC with details of borrowers, company numbers and bank records. Not using a BBL for business purposes is likely to be fraud and this includes drawing the money back out to pay the sole trader or director's domestic costs. There are regular prosecutions and being banned from directorships for 5 plus years. Voluntary disclosure to HMRC will avoid this. Business insurance policies will shortly be asking the question if BBL / CBILS were used wholly for qualifying purposes - lie and the policy is invalid.

MichelleScarn · 24/10/2022 13:07

Ginandthings · 24/10/2022 11:00

The idea of means testing to decide if you pay to use a service we already pay for is a very scary thought! I understand that things can’t go on as they are but rather than taking more from people someone needs to take an honest look at how things are run.
I’m a single parent to 2 dc who works full time and earn £60k, on paper it looks ok, until you deduct childcare, mortgage (cheaper than rent), the fact I’m entitled to nothing, not even child benefit. I genuinely struggle to pay all the bills each month, my ex pays the absolute minimum but obviously means testing just looks at income rather than outgoings.

Agree with this, very scary to be what it feels like to be double charged for this. But I've found you often get vitriol for saying that. "Oh well it's your fault for choosing these outcomes/lifestyle. Just move or earn more"

Worriedddd · 24/10/2022 13:05

bercan · 24/10/2022 13:03

Many people thought the magic money tree would go on forever surely people knew inflation and depression was coming after printing so much money ?

who are these people you are talking about?

People now asking for energy and mortgage bailouts.

bercan · 24/10/2022 13:04

logically people are always going to care what they have in their pockets now then in 2 yrs time.

bercan · 24/10/2022 13:03

Many people thought the magic money tree would go on forever surely people knew inflation and depression was coming after printing so much money ?

who are these people you are talking about?

goldfinchonthelawn · 24/10/2022 13:03

Magn · 24/10/2022 08:11

I had a bit of a look in to this after a recent thread. Apparently fewer than half the people in this country are net contributors via tax which is much lower than it was say 50 years ago, largely driven by the percentages of retired people. This makes it much harder to raise support as fewer people are worth taxing so you need to raise their taxes more for the same outcome, and at a point where all their costs are going up too. I don't know what the answer is.

This is what I've never understood. If the vast majority of people are struggling on low wages they can't pay much tax nor can they boost the economy by spending as they have no free cash. It goes on mortgage, commute, utilities and food.

If all the wealth bottlenecks at the top it can't trickle down. If the super rich were forced to pay a healthy living wage to all their employees, if we changed the law so that companies could prioritise wages, customer value and work environment over shareholder dividends, then surely, eventually everything would start moving again. We'd all be richer, we'd all spend more. Even the most extravant wealthy people can't eat out in more than one restaurant at a time - how can that wealth trickle down?

And if we were all better paid, then we'd all pay more tax instead of the money being siphoned off into tax avoidance schemes for the super rich. So we could then invest in NHS, schools, transport. The wealthier the minions, the healthier the economy, I would have thought. But it's never put to the test.