Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This may be unpopular - but what about the squeezed middle?

590 replies

AndroidUsername · 24/10/2022 07:43

They are talking about raising taxes on the average person now. Which will really effect lower middle class families who are already feeling the pinch due to increases in cost of food, gas and electic, increasing childcare costs and rent or morgage increases. They are going to increase pensions and benefits with inflation but lots of middle class earners are not having their wages increased with inflation but will now have their taxes increased. What about help for the middle class, especially lower middle class and working class who earn slightly to much to qualify for any help but will now stuggle with all these increases.

OP posts:
Loubelou14 · 25/10/2022 22:43

I wonder if people stopped spending the government would soon take note. During COVID they were desperate to get us back on the High street. I know people are feeling the pinch but they're still spending. If we all stopped it would affect things more and make government listen. At the moment we're all struggling but retail isn't being affected . I think if it was there'd be a panic and an urgency to sort it out.

StressedOutMumBex · 25/10/2022 22:39

Noangelbuthavingfun · 25/10/2022 20:24

Only read first 2 pages so forgive Me if this came up already...
Why can't the government raise the tax bracket overall from bottom up ? That way almost everyone benefits . .. lower income and higher income benefits up to say 150 or 200k and then you won't benefit anymore ? Raising the threshold by an amount - I'm not sure by how much but let's say 5k ? And then to fund the gap get the damn companies like amazing Google etc that avoid paying tax here to do the right thing.
I've never understood why the answer is always to tax people doing a bit better for themselves but by no means 'rich' all the time while the super rich don't feel it ever.
The tax thresholds are ancient and in no wag reflect reality. This way you will get a big proportion of people holding onto money they make - instead of just making the shortfall up again in benefits. Not sure I'm explaining it well bug hopefully you get the drift.....
I don't see how dragging everyone down further is a solution - rather raise everyone up a bit and tax where there is clearly only shareholder greed at play😏

This I totally agree with. It’s the people that make millions that dont pay their tax through some tax loophole that need to pay up not ordinary hardworking people.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 25/10/2022 21:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Alexandra2001 · 25/10/2022 21:12

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 25/10/2022 21:02

I think the borderline for benefits and help needs to rise considerably.

l bet Rishi and Jeremy aren’t even thinking about it.

Completely agree..... i know many people whose children have left home, single & with salaries in the low 20k's and get nothing at all, they really struggle.

but again, how is it affordable?

..... I'd have a wealth tax of the UK's 171 billionaires, with a combined wealth of almost 600 billion..

Pensions relief costs the UK around 43 billion, why is it given to higher rate tax payers?

No, they wont be thinking about any of this.

Queenmarie · 25/10/2022 21:08

Queenmarie · 25/10/2022 21:07

A household is only entitled to 15 funded hours childcare (not 30) if a single incone is under £100,000.

I only know this because a colleague told me they weren't entitled to 30 hours (because their DW earnt over this).

I mean over £100k obviously!

Queenmarie · 25/10/2022 21:07

bercan · 24/10/2022 10:10

@mast0650 a family with an income of 100k could qualify for child benefit, 30 free hours & tax free childcare. The last 2 a 200k income family could get. I don't have an issue with that though.

A household is only entitled to 15 funded hours childcare (not 30) if a single incone is under £100,000.

I only know this because a colleague told me they weren't entitled to 30 hours (because their DW earnt over this).

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 25/10/2022 21:02

I think the borderline for benefits and help needs to rise considerably.

l bet Rishi and Jeremy aren’t even thinking about it.

JessTD · 25/10/2022 20:45

We’re definitely in the ‘middle’ and feeling squeezed every day. Toddler and baby so childcare costs are ridiculous. Mortgage and energy and now higher taxes. Combined income is about £100k (both work full time) BUT this does not protect us from raising costs. Haven’t had a pay rise in 3 years. We get no help at all from the govt. feeling very exposed.

Thatsnotmycar · 25/10/2022 20:38

Sabrinamay · 25/10/2022 20:29

We get low rate care for hyper mobile child - but still pending more diagnosis for the 8 year old - ASD/add and fragile x so may increase the amount but not yet - 12 year Old waiting a high functioning adhd assessment and can claim but not until medication has been listed and given.

thanks about the grants I had never heard about these or the UC I did apply previously and they refused - but I’ll try again - thank you so much something to look into x

DLA is based on needs rather than diagnosis, so you can apply for DC1 now, and can ask for a change of circumstances for DC2 if you think they fulfil the criteria for a higher rate &/or the mobility element.

When calculating whether you are eligible for UC you would get the disabled child element for DC2, but you wouldn’t for DC1 without DLA, and you wouldn’t get the the carer elements either.

There are several grants out there for days out/holidays, tech etc. depending on your specific circumstances e.g. merlin’s magic wand. It’s well worth looking in to.

Sabrinamay · 25/10/2022 20:29

We get low rate care for hyper mobile child - but still pending more diagnosis for the 8 year old - ASD/add and fragile x so may increase the amount but not yet - 12 year Old waiting a high functioning adhd assessment and can claim but not until medication has been listed and given.

thanks about the grants I had never heard about these or the UC I did apply previously and they refused - but I’ll try again - thank you so much something to look into x

Livelovebehappy · 25/10/2022 20:26

100% agree with you OP. There’s a lot of lower middle class people struggling. And they’re the ones who are never looked after, by either Labour or Tory.

Noangelbuthavingfun · 25/10/2022 20:24

Only read first 2 pages so forgive Me if this came up already...
Why can't the government raise the tax bracket overall from bottom up ? That way almost everyone benefits . .. lower income and higher income benefits up to say 150 or 200k and then you won't benefit anymore ? Raising the threshold by an amount - I'm not sure by how much but let's say 5k ? And then to fund the gap get the damn companies like amazing Google etc that avoid paying tax here to do the right thing.
I've never understood why the answer is always to tax people doing a bit better for themselves but by no means 'rich' all the time while the super rich don't feel it ever.
The tax thresholds are ancient and in no wag reflect reality. This way you will get a big proportion of people holding onto money they make - instead of just making the shortfall up again in benefits. Not sure I'm explaining it well bug hopefully you get the drift.....
I don't see how dragging everyone down further is a solution - rather raise everyone up a bit and tax where there is clearly only shareholder greed at play😏

Thatsnotmycar · 25/10/2022 20:13

Sabrinamay · 25/10/2022 19:18

I totally agree that he punch for people who work and not entitled to help in any capacity will become worse - me and my partner work full time always have - we have 2 children, never claimed any benefits ever - privately rent in London - both have disabled mums in London. Both boys are pending diagnosis and EHCP in London and just told we will
bw homeless shortly after Christmas - we had fixed rent but average now in London is over £2100 per month without bills that is an increase of £700 per
month - if we move out of London I’ll have to start my2/3 year fight for boys assessments again which is ridiculous - my free childcare is in London so would need to pay childcare to move out, also I work in central london so fares and travel time increases and time away from disabled children seems harsh on them. We have applied for 18 houses and didn’t get any as too many people were applying - so far nothing in or out of London available so almost homeless - also move out means that both disabled mums
will not have support unless I pay privately for care but haven’t got the money.
what can we all do - so far we don’t have holidays my children have never been abroad, we don’t really go out much to save money, I have changed brands to own brand, haven’t been big in heating in generally usually only if really bitter cold, don’t have a new car - do have a car for 8 year old due to chronic pain condition - no savings either
i sought advise and was told I would have more chance if I didn’t work or took a pay cut and kicked
ky partner of 18 years out and then I might get support - any ideas ps I always worked and built a good career so not willing to not work and would rather my kids had their dad around as they have so far -
help
me

Have you not applied for DLA? If you apply for DLA and are successful the income threshold for UC is often higher than many imagine when there are disabled DC, especially as you also rent. DH earns a good wage, but we would be eligible for UC if we didn’t have savings because of disabled DC and we wouldn’t have a rent element.

Also have you applied for grants? Many of them for things like days out/holidays, tech don’t require a diagnosis as they are based on need.

Seymour5 · 25/10/2022 20:10

Lozzybear · 25/10/2022 19:58

@Seymour5 not necessarily true. Some actually get more than the new state pension because they weren’t contracted out of SERPS/S2P. My dad gets over £220 per week. For background, he was never on a high income. He was earning around £20k per year when he retired 10 years ago.

His pension is made up of the Basic State Pension of around £141, the rest is extra due to him paying a bit extra National Insurance to benefit from SERPS etc.

My husband gets some extra due to SERPS. I was merely pointing out that state pensions for those retiring more recently are over £40 a week more.

Fatredwitch · 25/10/2022 20:09

It's true that the pension for older people is less but, if it is your only source of income, Pension Credit will top it up to within a couple of pounds of the newer pension. Plus it entitles you to things like Council Tax reduction, Warm Homes allowance, free dental care, etc. I was originally pleased when I got my notification that I qualified for the full pension but think now l would be better off - slightly - if I didn't. Not that you're going to be well off whether you get the new pension or the old, or whether you get Pension Credit or not.

The Tories have cunningly turned this into a young-vs-old issue. I saw Norman Lamont going on about it on the news today. Really, it's us-vs-them - it's rich-vs-poor. When they say that there are going to be hard decisions, I can guarantee it won't be hard for them or their backers. The lower you are on the ladder, the more you will feel the pain.

MarvellousMonsters · 25/10/2022 20:03

FreddyHG · 24/10/2022 08:01

It's the price demanded by so many of the vocal people on here who want raised benefits and health spending. Someone has to pay for it.

Of course someone has to pay for it, but it should be the top earners and big corporations, not the working people who will struggle to hear/eat if their taxes go up!

Lozzybear · 25/10/2022 19:58

@Seymour5 not necessarily true. Some actually get more than the new state pension because they weren’t contracted out of SERPS/S2P. My dad gets over £220 per week. For background, he was never on a high income. He was earning around £20k per year when he retired 10 years ago.

fetchacloth · 25/10/2022 19:52

sst1234 · 24/10/2022 08:08

The people who always take the biggest hit are those with are net contributors and don’t qualify for any help. They are the cash cows. And their resentment of concern is understandable.

Totally agree and the current government need to bear this in mind before the next general election otherwise they are toast.

Seymour5 · 25/10/2022 19:51

Fatredwitch · 25/10/2022 19:02

The OP says that pensions and benefits are going to rise in line with inflation. Are they? I wouldn't be surprised if they break the Triple Lock again and link pensions and benefits to earnings.

I am sure that it's hard to be part of "the squeezed middle" but it's definitely hard to live on the state pension. And if you get the full pension - the entire glorious £185.15 per week - you don't qualify for Pension Credit, so it's a delusion to think that people who are struggling will automatically qualify for any extra help that is on offer. We don't.

People on UC etc are similarly struggling.

Only younger pensioners get this. Those eligible for the state pension before 2016 only get Basic State Pension of £141.85. Those who have saved for even a modest extra pension won’t qualify for Pension Credit.

@Diamondsareforever123 I feel for you. Together, DH and I have enough, as long as we are careful. But when the inevitable happens, the survivor will be very stretched on a single pension income.

Manekinek0 · 25/10/2022 19:41

Whenever there are posts about those on a low income or benefits struggling we always get the same old advice; retrain, get a better job, take in ironing and stop wasting all the poor tax payers money on takeaways and cigarettes. We also get the stories about someone's mums, neighbours, cousin who has a 20 bedroom council house, gets given 6 figures in benefits and has 50 kids.

There seems to be a distinct lack of this helpful advice on these threads about the poor middle (insert class or earners as most don't know the difference anyway).

So many of you were happy to vote Tory when it was the "working class" and benefit claimants who were suffering. Those individuals should have worked harder at school or take on more hours. Well the same advice applies to you.

AnnieSnap · 25/10/2022 19:21

You are not being unreasonable. Both DH and I are retired professionals with private pensions. Neither pension is a full one. He took early retirement due to ill health with no enhancement for that and I hadn’t been in the scheme long enough for a full pension. DH now has his state pension, I won’t get mine for another 3 years. It’s far from certain that state pensions will increase with earnings next year (Truss said it would off the top of her head. Hunt said it won’t and Sunak is yet to comment). Remember pensions only rose by 3.1% this year! Our pensions place us, like so many working family, above the threshold for extra help, but significantly below the level of not having to be concerned or careful with money. Despite many who set groups in society against each other (e.g. working families and pensioners), it’s really about the establishment and the rest of us. Some pensioners are well off, like some families, many are not. Due to late divorces, many (me included) still have large mortgages and moderate incomes.

Sabrinamay · 25/10/2022 19:18

I totally agree that he punch for people who work and not entitled to help in any capacity will become worse - me and my partner work full time always have - we have 2 children, never claimed any benefits ever - privately rent in London - both have disabled mums in London. Both boys are pending diagnosis and EHCP in London and just told we will
bw homeless shortly after Christmas - we had fixed rent but average now in London is over £2100 per month without bills that is an increase of £700 per
month - if we move out of London I’ll have to start my2/3 year fight for boys assessments again which is ridiculous - my free childcare is in London so would need to pay childcare to move out, also I work in central london so fares and travel time increases and time away from disabled children seems harsh on them. We have applied for 18 houses and didn’t get any as too many people were applying - so far nothing in or out of London available so almost homeless - also move out means that both disabled mums
will not have support unless I pay privately for care but haven’t got the money.
what can we all do - so far we don’t have holidays my children have never been abroad, we don’t really go out much to save money, I have changed brands to own brand, haven’t been big in heating in generally usually only if really bitter cold, don’t have a new car - do have a car for 8 year old due to chronic pain condition - no savings either
i sought advise and was told I would have more chance if I didn’t work or took a pay cut and kicked
ky partner of 18 years out and then I might get support - any ideas ps I always worked and built a good career so not willing to not work and would rather my kids had their dad around as they have so far -
help
me

Diamondsareforever123 · 25/10/2022 19:16

I'm a retired pensioner and get a small pension from my previous job. I am just over the threshold for any benefits. TBH I am terrified. I pay rent, own nothing, and am alone. I am counting every penny about the financial stress is destroying me. I am in torment about fuel bills this winter. TBH I'm 68 and hope I won't be here much longer.

juleswatford · 25/10/2022 19:11

What we forget is not only happening here in the UK. I was talking to an American, Californian last week ......he was paying 65% tax, paying astronomical health insurance, people are leaving the state in droves. Many USA high earners are leaving the country. I read that the Government was reluctant to raise tax here in the UK because they are worried that there would be an exodus of the high income earners. I don't know what the answer is..big money has the power, huge companies support parties with election donations, sometimes they are giving donations to both parties standing for election at the same time, once a party gets in power and then these big companies put their lobbyist to apply pressure and recruit the MP's who have lost. Actually the lobbyists of these huge industries are running the country.... they have bought the party elected, paid for their election by donations so they need to get payback. I am getting the feeling our vote means nothing. Secret meetings are held between the big businesses, the likes of Google, Amazon....etc with the HMRC to keep their tax obligations low.

Another thing which we need to think about is that some of those who lack integrity are representing us in Parliament are using it as a stepping stone to greater things. Look at what happened to Clegg.

Fatredwitch · 25/10/2022 19:02

The OP says that pensions and benefits are going to rise in line with inflation. Are they? I wouldn't be surprised if they break the Triple Lock again and link pensions and benefits to earnings.

I am sure that it's hard to be part of "the squeezed middle" but it's definitely hard to live on the state pension. And if you get the full pension - the entire glorious £185.15 per week - you don't qualify for Pension Credit, so it's a delusion to think that people who are struggling will automatically qualify for any extra help that is on offer. We don't.

People on UC etc are similarly struggling.