Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This may be unpopular - but what about the squeezed middle?

590 replies

AndroidUsername · 24/10/2022 07:43

They are talking about raising taxes on the average person now. Which will really effect lower middle class families who are already feeling the pinch due to increases in cost of food, gas and electic, increasing childcare costs and rent or morgage increases. They are going to increase pensions and benefits with inflation but lots of middle class earners are not having their wages increased with inflation but will now have their taxes increased. What about help for the middle class, especially lower middle class and working class who earn slightly to much to qualify for any help but will now stuggle with all these increases.

OP posts:
MinervaTerrathorn · 26/10/2022 19:40

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 19:34

If you don’t automatically qualify for free prescriptions etc. but you have a low income and have limited savings/capital you can complete a HC1 form and may be eligible for full help with health costs or partial help towards costs.

That's good to know if I ever need it. My only medical cost right now is a yearly dental check up (maybe not even that as my dentist has suspended check ups for adult NHS patients). I was just pointing out that there doesn't seem to be any additional help for a full time working parent.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 19:34

MinervaTerrathorn · 26/10/2022 19:19

It's all very low then, £935 a month income if on UC with a child. DS is not PP as I have worked full time since moving to the UK. If you work full time on a low income then it seems there is no additional help besides UC/tax credit top ups.

If you don’t automatically qualify for free prescriptions etc. but you have a low income and have limited savings/capital you can complete a HC1 form and may be eligible for full help with health costs or partial help towards costs.

MinervaTerrathorn · 26/10/2022 19:19

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 18:50

Here are the criteria for free dental treatment, and here are the criteria for free prescriptions. There are the specific rules for those on UC here.

Free transport to college will be LA specific. Support with school trips etc. will be related to pupil premium which is for anyone eligible for FSM or has been eligible in the previous 6 years.

And here is how you are assessed for student loans.

It's all very low then, £935 a month income if on UC with a child. DS is not PP as I have worked full time since moving to the UK. If you work full time on a low income then it seems there is no additional help besides UC/tax credit top ups.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 18:50

Here are the criteria for free dental treatment, and here are the criteria for free prescriptions. There are the specific rules for those on UC here.

Free transport to college will be LA specific. Support with school trips etc. will be related to pupil premium which is for anyone eligible for FSM or has been eligible in the previous 6 years.

And here is how you are assessed for student loans.

lookoutkid · 26/10/2022 18:27

@MinervaTerrathorn I'm not sure what the cut off is, they make it very hard to find out! The free bus was to do with our tax credit entitlement, not our actual income.

I don't regret it as ultimately when the dc have grown up and it's just me and DH we will be in a far better position now. But I was expecting a big leap in actual money in our pocket for the difference in salary, and that has not happened!

If your DC go to uni I'm pretty sure you'll get the full whack on 22k if that's any saving grace

MinervaTerrathorn · 26/10/2022 17:35

lookoutkid · 26/10/2022 12:37

I consider myself to be in this category and also worried.

DH and I were on tax credits until recently, we ran a business that we loved but made very little profit and in the end had to concede it wasn't enough long term. We made about 15k. DH has now retrained and had a job with a 40k salary. I work school hours and earn about 9k a year as we now have to pay all our childcare. That is nearly £50k! I thought we'd feel so much better off but little seems to have changed in terms of disposable income.

Previously we had around 10k a year in tax credits to top us up, mist of the childcare was covered.

We also had free travel to college for our eldest, this is now £700 a year. She also used to get a free breakfast and lunch, and a bursary for books. Books have cost me over £100 this year.

The loss of free dental treatment, prescriptions, the money off school trips.

But the biggest ones is going to be uni, she don't get the full loan anymore and we need to top her up by thousands. And there's two more who also might want to go.

Obviously we won't get the targeted help with bills either.

I know how sneery people are on here about "high earners" moaning about money and I would have been the same before but all I can say is we don't seem to have any more money in our pockets and taking even more tax is going to make me wish we'd never made that lifestyle change in the first place!

That doesn't just happen going from £15k to £49k, the cut off must be very low. I'm on £22k and paying over £900 a year for the college bus for DS, never had subsidised school costs. I don't get free dental. I'm getting the £650 cost of living payment so that's something.

chaosmaker · 26/10/2022 16:08

Sorry, meant to quote the poster that said taxing the wealthy doesn't work

chaosmaker · 26/10/2022 15:28

Why don't they work?

Givenuptotally · 26/10/2022 15:16

FFS. Never said that. You simply are unable to accept there is more you could be doing to help yourself.

Applesandcarrots · 26/10/2022 15:13

Can I join on on who has ot worse a trump most with.

People who still pay taxes but have no recourse to public funds when shit hits the fan?

VeronicaFranklin · 26/10/2022 15:05

Givenuptotally · 26/10/2022 12:39

I still stand by my opinion which is SOME of the hardest hit families will be those with two working parents who are not entitled to any financial help because they do not meet the criteria/ earn above the threshold for any help

and that’s full circle to my previous comment you objected to which is, as a two adult household, your ability to earn a second income is greatly improved on that of a single parent. It frustrates me no end to read posts like yours, arguing that being a SAHM is the only sensible option. I have been single for the last 13 years and have managed to teach full time, exam mark twice a year, tutor in the evenings and run holiday clubs in the summer. All without family support, I might add, and a fairly lacking in responsibility ex. As two people, you (that’s a general ‘you’) have endless possibilities to increase your household’s income to help weather this current storm. And yes, of course, I recognise there are situations that make it difficult when there is a travelling partner, caring responsibilities, ill health etc. Those are not the households I’m referring to.

the current situation is dire for everyone. But unfortunately, to get through this, there is a need for some people to recognise that the government can’t do it all for us. We’re going to have to maximise our income and spend it on boring stuff like electric. That’s all the much more difficult when, like me, you’ve been at maximum capacity for years already.

as a two adult household, your ability to earn a second income is greatly improved on that of a single parent.

Yes a two parent household that earns a second income is greatly improved than that of a single parent, that is stating the obvious though isn't it?

Not sure really what your point is other than, you're a single parent and because I'm not I shouldn't be allowed in your view to say we might struggle with no help because in your opinion it's a luxury for me to have a partner who works and co-parents because you don't.

My original comment was absolutely NOTHING to do with single parent's you have just taken it upon yourself to lecture me about how lucky you think I am and tell me I have no right to comment. Jeez...

It frustrates me no end to read posts like yours, arguing that being a SAHM is the only sensible option.

I didn't say being a SAHM was the only option, I said that the system is broken as there is no incentive to go back to work when the majority if not all of at least one parent's earnings go on childcare costs for those who are not eligible for any help towards childcare.

have been single for the last 13 years and have managed to teach full time, exam mark twice a year, tutor in the evenings and run holiday clubs in the summer. All without family support, I might add, and a fairly lacking in responsibility ex.

Good for you! Again not sure what you demonstrating this is trying to achieve, as it still doesn't mean my opinion isn't valid that families with two working parent's will be hit hard and struggle in current times. I haven't anywhere said single parents won't I just didn't mention them in my post...but you have made it all about your personal circumstances.

the current situation is dire for everyone. But unfortunately, to get through this, there is a need for some people to recognise that the government can’t do it all for us. We’re going to have to maximise our income and spend it on boring stuff like electric. That’s all the much more difficult when, like me, you’ve been at maximum capacity for years already

Oh I thought the current situation in your eyes was only dire for single parents.

Walkaround · 26/10/2022 15:02

Multinational corporations make their tax affairs so opaque, they get to negotiate what they are willing to pay in tax with HMRC, because it would be far too difficult and time consuming for the underfunded HMRC to wade through the paperwork and work out the truth. Tax legislation therefore picks on the low hanging fruit, instead: there’s nothing easier than taking money out of someone’s salary before they’ve even been paid (and it’s nice and easy to work out how much tax income you’ll make from it, too); or going through the tax return of an individual with nice, simple tax affairs, looking for their mistakes and and misdemeanours, then punishing them for said mistakes and misdemeanours. Meanwhile, a blind eye is turned to the billions of pounds being siphoned away by the more sophisticated operations of big business. This will only get worse as cutbacks to government spending make government departments even more astonishingly inefficient than they already are. Efficiency and effectiveness are never achieved through starvation. We will therefore increasingly be at the mercy of the whims of those too big to pay tax unless they want to, which they generally don’t.

As for tax avoidance versus tax evasion - there is legitimate, straightforward tax avoidance, like saving money in an ISA that is, in fact, encouraged by Government in order to encourage people to have savings; there is using your financial and political muscle to lobby and cajole and direct what ends up in tax legislation so as to suit your own ends, which is mainly open to super-wealthy party donors and big business, although accounting bodies representing SMEs do their best to be heard; and there is finding unintended loopholes in tax legislation, or unintended/unexpected uses for legitimate ways of structuring a business and exploiting them until they are closed, which is tax evasion in all but name. Obviously, the wealthy can afford to pay tax advisers to exploit the system in ways that are technically legal but morally bankrupt, and also make sure it is too difficult and expensive to unpick what they have done. That sort of corruption is not open to the less well off.

The result is, there is an awful lot of wealth swilling about in the world, but mostly in private hands which are clearly not making good use of it, as the world is in a bit of a mess! Buying up private islands, blasting your rockets into space, playing at being a President, manipulating world markets for personal financial gain, buying up Twitter for vast sums - so much for private individuals and corporations making the best use of money! Seems more like an effort to destroy the planet and then try to escape it, leaving the rest of humanity behind.

Givenuptotally · 26/10/2022 14:58

We've handed out trillions in furlough for all regardless of wealth, people like the Beckhams and the Sunaks claimed it, support loans for the super wealthy too. We are making the same mistake with energy support

The administrative cost of working out who is/isn’t eligible for energy support would, I would hazard a guess, be far greater than just giving everyone £400. Same, I suspect, with furlough if you tried to put some kind of cap on it. And it’s precisely because of this that we have the unfair situation of households with 2 people earning £98k each being able to claim child benefit but a household with one person earning £60k being excluded. It’s just easier, more cost-effective, from an administrative perspective.

midgetastic · 26/10/2022 14:57

I suspect t anything macron did was ideology driven

sst1234 · 26/10/2022 14:40

Alexandra2001 · 26/10/2022 08:39

Different place now, we have huge national debt across the entire developed world now, we did not in 2017.

We've handed out trillions in furlough for all... regardless of wealth, people like the Beckhams and the Sunaks claimed it, support loans for the super wealthy too... we are making the same mistake with energy support....

Sunak (i use him as an example because he is charged with changing this) will be getting help to heat his new swimming pool.

Is this right? are we all happy with the super rich.. individuals and companies.. getting help whilst a working family on UC will see energy bills double and a below inflation UC increase, just as their foodbank run out of donations.

Extra taxes on the super wealthy are inevitable or you take it off the poor.. Your choice.

Your opinion, entitled as you are to it, doesn’t change the outcome. Wealth taxes don’t work. Hollande also thought it was a different time post 2008 financial crash and he needed to introduce these taxes. And it didn’t work. Macron reversed it for a reason, and he’s not exactly a right wing ideologue. There is always a need for higher taxation, but there’s no point doing it if you actually lose revenue. That’s not smart.

WahineToa · 26/10/2022 14:12

Paying everyone properly would be a good start.

Yes I said it earlier. Never mind ridiculously high taxes for them, many multi millionaires & billionaires etc are owners of businesses that pay poor wages. We must campaign to keep pushing up minimum wages, Labour aren’t even making it a priority

goldfinchonthelawn · 26/10/2022 14:08

@chaosmaker for PM!

chaosmaker · 26/10/2022 13:49

Magn · 24/10/2022 08:11

I had a bit of a look in to this after a recent thread. Apparently fewer than half the people in this country are net contributors via tax which is much lower than it was say 50 years ago, largely driven by the percentages of retired people. This makes it much harder to raise support as fewer people are worth taxing so you need to raise their taxes more for the same outcome, and at a point where all their costs are going up too. I don't know what the answer is.

Paying everyone properly would be a good start. Then more would be paying taxes. Personally I'd rip up all existing tax laws and rewrite them from a fair perspective to stop loopholes that can be used to evade tax or avoid it. Current ones seem to be written by and for the richest individuals and companies.

Givenuptotally · 26/10/2022 12:39

I still stand by my opinion which is SOME of the hardest hit families will be those with two working parents who are not entitled to any financial help because they do not meet the criteria/ earn above the threshold for any help

and that’s full circle to my previous comment you objected to which is, as a two adult household, your ability to earn a second income is greatly improved on that of a single parent. It frustrates me no end to read posts like yours, arguing that being a SAHM is the only sensible option. I have been single for the last 13 years and have managed to teach full time, exam mark twice a year, tutor in the evenings and run holiday clubs in the summer. All without family support, I might add, and a fairly lacking in responsibility ex. As two people, you (that’s a general ‘you’) have endless possibilities to increase your household’s income to help weather this current storm. And yes, of course, I recognise there are situations that make it difficult when there is a travelling partner, caring responsibilities, ill health etc. Those are not the households I’m referring to.

the current situation is dire for everyone. But unfortunately, to get through this, there is a need for some people to recognise that the government can’t do it all for us. We’re going to have to maximise our income and spend it on boring stuff like electric. That’s all the much more difficult when, like me, you’ve been at maximum capacity for years already.

lookoutkid · 26/10/2022 12:37

I consider myself to be in this category and also worried.

DH and I were on tax credits until recently, we ran a business that we loved but made very little profit and in the end had to concede it wasn't enough long term. We made about 15k. DH has now retrained and had a job with a 40k salary. I work school hours and earn about 9k a year as we now have to pay all our childcare. That is nearly £50k! I thought we'd feel so much better off but little seems to have changed in terms of disposable income.

Previously we had around 10k a year in tax credits to top us up, mist of the childcare was covered.

We also had free travel to college for our eldest, this is now £700 a year. She also used to get a free breakfast and lunch, and a bursary for books. Books have cost me over £100 this year.

The loss of free dental treatment, prescriptions, the money off school trips.

But the biggest ones is going to be uni, she don't get the full loan anymore and we need to top her up by thousands. And there's two more who also might want to go.

Obviously we won't get the targeted help with bills either.

I know how sneery people are on here about "high earners" moaning about money and I would have been the same before but all I can say is we don't seem to have any more money in our pockets and taking even more tax is going to make me wish we'd never made that lifestyle change in the first place!

WahineToa · 26/10/2022 11:41

Realistically I might as well give up work, then we're under the threshold to get help and I can spend time raising my child instead of paying all my salary out to someone else to!

You could, that’s your choice. It will affect future earnings once your children are older, and your pension.

midgetastic · 26/10/2022 11:20

So as a family you have more than the single parent after they get support but you want more ?

It's a safety net for when you can't cope

midgetastic · 26/10/2022 11:18

No short term incentive
Keeping a job for when childcare costs ease and hopefully advancing over time is a long term incentive

( but at the same time there should be some investigation into what percentage of parents are caught in this trap - it should t be the norm in a functioning society)

VeronicaFranklin · 26/10/2022 11:15

midgetastic · 26/10/2022 10:57

If it's based on joint income - which is right - you can't automatically say they haven't got enough

Yes in the early years it's often the case that one person's salary goes mostly in childcare - what you are doing is protecting your long term income

Instead of thinking it as all my income on childcare it's really half my income and half my husbands on childcare

( clearly single parent family have different problems )

It doesn't change the fact that one parent is realistically working wholly just to pay childcare costs...

No incentive for mums to go back to work when there is no benefit of them doing so, they don't come out with any income of their own and they don't get to spend time with their child. So working mums are penalised.

Single parent's rightly so, get help with childcare costs, Universal credit, housing. I'm not arguing their case.

What I'm saying is on paper me and my husband aren't entitled to any help, we live within our means but we will struggle if I go back full time, no salary increase, cost of living increase, petrol costs plus now childcare costs.

Realistically I might as well give up work, then we're under the threshold to get help and I can spend time raising my child instead of paying all my salary out to someone else to! I'm not saying it's right or what I'd want to do but it's a broken system and as per my original post, two working parents will be some of the hardest hit as they are often overlooked on paper.

VeronicaFranklin · 26/10/2022 11:02

Givenuptotally · 26/10/2022 10:24

Sorry I didn't realise I had to mention every single representation in my comment. Why is there always someone come forward to argue that they have it harder than somebody else!

then don’t say the hardest hit families are those with two working parents when quite clearly, in very general terms, that isn’t the case?

Please re read my comment, and you will see I said SOME of the hardest hit not THE hardest hit.

You are taking my comment personally and insinuating it means I think single parents won't be hit hard. Which I have not said.

I just haven't specifically mentioned single parent's in my initial post, is that the issue? This isn't a competition, everyone will be affected.

I still stand by my opinion which is SOME of the hardest hit families will be those with two working parents who are not entitled to any financial help because they do not meet the criteria/ earn above the threshold for any help.