Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This may be unpopular - but what about the squeezed middle?

590 replies

AndroidUsername · 24/10/2022 07:43

They are talking about raising taxes on the average person now. Which will really effect lower middle class families who are already feeling the pinch due to increases in cost of food, gas and electic, increasing childcare costs and rent or morgage increases. They are going to increase pensions and benefits with inflation but lots of middle class earners are not having their wages increased with inflation but will now have their taxes increased. What about help for the middle class, especially lower middle class and working class who earn slightly to much to qualify for any help but will now stuggle with all these increases.

OP posts:
WatchoRulo · 24/10/2022 10:48

DullAndOvercast · 24/10/2022 10:44

No because you are just creating a pyramid scheme. Everyone gets old including unskilled migrants they will also need health, social care and pensions.

The idea with such immigration isn't to perpetuate the pyramid but to get a softer landing with the decrease in working population happen over a longer time period so tax increases being spread over more people.

So yes the immigrant population will eventually add to their cohort retirements numbers but after decades of paying working people's taxes - making the bump to smaller population less of a huge jump.

However politically it's difficult - different cultures and then as resources for working population a decline schrodinger's immigrants stuff surfaces - immigrates taking all the jobs but same time doing nothing and getting all the benefits - and fact there're needed and mean more workers to pay the tax burden gets ignored.

This seems a very vague "explanation" of how it's not a ponzi scheme - and it's a legitimate question about things like housing provision, too - that's Schrodinger's in the sense of them apparently not needing any extra housing, transport etc provision.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 24/10/2022 10:48

DamnUserName21 · 24/10/2022 10:44

Again. Means-tested.
I will add that many people can afford the fees but they expect/prefer cheaper or free NHS dentistry because they don't want to pay for it.

And will the means testing allow for current inflation, power bills etc? And for the payment of medical fees?

Because the means testing bar is set very low in the country, and the people who are just above it won’t be able to afford it. Or even those who are quite high above it.

so that will mean a significant amount of the population not being able to afford it. And what about those with chronic conditions who need to see go often?

bercan · 24/10/2022 10:47

We still need young people.

Also how does a society grow & progress without youth?

DamnUserName21 · 24/10/2022 10:47

Worriedddd · 24/10/2022 10:43

No, they are going to have to look at automation and technology. This pyramid scheme isn't sustainable there's 7 billion humans on this planet and we are destroying it. Pushing out more humans doesn't solve the problem. Just further kicking the can down the road.

How is automation and technology going to pay taxes to fund 25% of the populations pensions, social care, health care (2043 prediction)?

How will automation and technology look after the elderly and infirm in homes and hospitals?

We still need young people.

midgetastic · 24/10/2022 10:46

Because in most cases those at the very top got that through theft , war, generally not being good people

Most of the very rich are direct descendant of William the conqueror cronies

And they tend to be the ones who have wielded significant political powers - so got us in the mess

Why should those with less be expected to pick up the tab for the upper classes greed and mismanagement?

Rather simplifying I know

And in practise I wouldn't bring them down to average - I was just trying to illustrate how many people could have their lives substantially improved if those people were not so outrageously wealthy

But instead the 90% are squabbling amongst themselves

Just as the rich like it

bercan · 24/10/2022 10:46

@Worriedddd you do know that global population in most of the west have started to decline. There really aren't loads of countries having loads of dc.

We are all going to be fighting for immigrants!

healthadvice123 · 24/10/2022 10:45

@WahineToa £40000 is not that huge a wage nowadays when you have to pay childcare , run a car etc to work
You can be on less and have a more disposable income

Chocdropsandbuckfast · 24/10/2022 10:45

bluetongue · Today 08:35
I know this is a parenting site but single, childless people are always left behind. We also were among the worst impacted by lockdown.

totally agree with you. My sister is in her own, I think she gets 12 ish pounds per hour. Not entitled to any help whatsoever? Has to pay a small mortgage, I think 350 pm. Gas/electric, council tax, plus petrol. She travels roughly 30 miles per day. She cries because how skint she is. My dad had to buy her her car, to help her out. An old runaround. It’s a disgrace. The family next door, don’t work, no disabilities. Have 4 kids and live very comfortable. They have way more disposable income than her. This is what the government need to focus on too. The bloody bone idle.

Cornettoninja · 24/10/2022 10:44

WahineToa · 24/10/2022 10:31

I think access to the NHS should be means tested. £15 for a Dr appt if you earn more than £40k.

The stupidest idea I’ve ever heard. Ridiculous. You’d be better off spending money targeting people who don’t follow basic health and lifestyle advice now. They burden the NHS.

There is no health advice that will permanently halt ageing. Lifestyle changes can make some difference but ultimately we have an ageing population living to ages that the body simply can’t function at.

DullAndOvercast · 24/10/2022 10:44

No because you are just creating a pyramid scheme. Everyone gets old including unskilled migrants they will also need health, social care and pensions.

The idea with such immigration isn't to perpetuate the pyramid but to get a softer landing with the decrease in working population happen over a longer time period so tax increases being spread over more people.

So yes the immigrant population will eventually add to their cohort retirements numbers but after decades of paying working people's taxes - making the bump to smaller population less of a huge jump.

However politically it's difficult - different cultures and then as resources for working population a decline schrodinger's immigrants stuff surfaces - immigrates taking all the jobs but same time doing nothing and getting all the benefits - and fact there're needed and mean more workers to pay the tax burden gets ignored.

DamnUserName21 · 24/10/2022 10:44

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 24/10/2022 10:41

*The NHS is it's current form is not sustainable.

People should co-pay. I very much hope we follow social insurance schemes as in France and Germany. It should be means-tested.*

And yet when we had an nhs dental service, people couldn’t afford the fees.

Will we have a huge reduction in tax for this? I would rather pay higher taxes and have a functioning nhs.

Again. Means-tested.
I will add that many people can afford the fees but they expect/prefer cheaper or free NHS dentistry because they don't want to pay for it.

bercan · 24/10/2022 10:44

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow how much extra tax are you prepared to pay?

Worriedddd · 24/10/2022 10:43

DamnUserName21 · 24/10/2022 10:40

Well, unless, Brits start pushing out more children then encouraging younger immigrants to the country is exactly what will need to happen...so they can pay taxes, look after old and sick, and, generally, keep the country going.

No, they are going to have to look at automation and technology. This pyramid scheme isn't sustainable there's 7 billion humans on this planet and we are destroying it. Pushing out more humans doesn't solve the problem. Just further kicking the can down the road.

bercan · 24/10/2022 10:43

So if lots of retired people are not paying income tax it's because they have an income less than the personal allowance

Hardly rich then!

But they could still be asset rich, that's the point.

midgetastic · 24/10/2022 10:41

Yes I do

But I think lots of people here don't

Hence weird suggestions of raising taxes / cutting pensions from people based on the value of their home rather than waiting and raising inheritance tax

But you see there I managed to extract income from a physical asset ?

We just need to ensure we extract the value form those with the most

Lily073 · 24/10/2022 10:41

Why should the10% with half the wealth of the country not fund stuff ?

Why should they? They're not cash cows to be milked at will.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 24/10/2022 10:41

*The NHS is it's current form is not sustainable.

People should co-pay. I very much hope we follow social insurance schemes as in France and Germany. It should be means-tested.*

And yet when we had an nhs dental service, people couldn’t afford the fees.

Will we have a huge reduction in tax for this? I would rather pay higher taxes and have a functioning nhs.

PrestonNorthHen · 24/10/2022 10:41

hettie · 24/10/2022 09:12

We are all about to get a reality check as to UK PLC's real place in the world, both ecenomic and influence. We are a declining nation clinging to the idea that e are special 'great' or should somehow just because be better than Germany, France or Poland. I think the national malaise is an inability to think long term. We don't plan let alone complete and finish a plan. We are chancers addicted to a quick fix (quantative essing, tax cuts btexit miraculously giving us instant cash for the nhs) with a complete buy now pay later mentality that operates in the personal and private and state sector's. An aging population, climate change/switching from fossil fuels/skills shortages etc were all utterly predicted...The NHS for example had been begging for a work force plan for 15 years. Did we plan for any of these raging certainties. Did we bollocks. So here we find ourselves... declining.... which means our overall standard of living will decline. Because every time any politician goes to the electorate with any whiff of something that's about investing now for our future the 'people' reject in favour of quick fixes and absurd promises of jam tommorow. We are a nation of toddlers with poor impulse control. Honestly I reckon if you did a country by country league table rating the population on the Stanford marshmallow test we'd be bottom third...

👏
In regard to the NHS we knew in 1988 that 2020 would see 35% of nurses reaching retirement age.
What was done to mitigate this?
Nothing.
I have to laugh reading the governments Covid plan was to pull retired NHS staff back into service when actually what has happened is that anyone remotely near retirement age has retired early.
The average age (special classes) has dropped from 55 to 51
Its a disaster!

DamnUserName21 · 24/10/2022 10:40

Worriedddd · 24/10/2022 10:35

No because you are just creating a pyramid scheme. Everyone gets old including unskilled migrants they will also need health, social care and pensions. Then you need increasing numbers of people to fund this.

Well, unless, Brits start pushing out more children then encouraging younger immigrants to the country is exactly what will need to happen...so they can pay taxes, look after old and sick, and, generally, keep the country going.

bercan · 24/10/2022 10:40

No because you are just creating a pyramid scheme. Everyone gets old including unskilled migrants they will also need health, social care and pensions. Then you need increasing numbers of people to fund this.

well now we have the upside down pyramid. How is that funded?

bercan · 24/10/2022 10:38

@midgetastic do you understand there is a difference between income & assets?

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/one-in-seven-own-a-second-property-at-age-70-fgrklhmlg

midgetastic · 24/10/2022 10:38

Our GDP is considered to be 5% lower as a direct result of brexit

midgetastic · 24/10/2022 10:37

Most people actually are not money motivated

Most people once they have around 50k income are more motivated by the job itself or the work life balance or the status - not the money

The lack of understanding of human nature on this thread is astounding yes -

( yes not everyone but on average , so if you are strongly money motivated you are unusual )

DamnUserName21 · 24/10/2022 10:37

WahineToa · 24/10/2022 10:31

I think access to the NHS should be means tested. £15 for a Dr appt if you earn more than £40k.

The stupidest idea I’ve ever heard. Ridiculous. You’d be better off spending money targeting people who don’t follow basic health and lifestyle advice now. They burden the NHS.

It's not stupid.
The NHS is it's current form is not sustainable.
People should co-pay. I very much hope we follow social insurance schemes as in France and Germany. It should be means-tested.

Alexandra2001 · 24/10/2022 10:36

Lozzybear · 24/10/2022 10:08

@midgetastic do you know what the average inflation rate is in the EU? It’s 10.9 so higher than the UK. Brexit is not the driving force.

The EU isn't a country, should the UK's inflation rate be taken as the average across the Common Wealth? or the USA's across Nafta countries?

Look at comparable economies in Europe, France has inflation at 6%, Spain at 9% and falling.
Germany is similar to ours, driven by their very high reliance on imported gas.
Italy 9.4% again imported gas prices.

UK should not be comparing itself to Bulgaria or Portugal.

The £ is weak, driving up import costs and it costs more to export to the UK from the EU... thats what you voted for.

BUT the real difference is in Govt borrowing costs, only Italy has similar, international investors are charging a premium to lend to the UK and have done for several years, long before Truss doubled them.