Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This may be unpopular - but what about the squeezed middle?

590 replies

AndroidUsername · 24/10/2022 07:43

They are talking about raising taxes on the average person now. Which will really effect lower middle class families who are already feeling the pinch due to increases in cost of food, gas and electic, increasing childcare costs and rent or morgage increases. They are going to increase pensions and benefits with inflation but lots of middle class earners are not having their wages increased with inflation but will now have their taxes increased. What about help for the middle class, especially lower middle class and working class who earn slightly to much to qualify for any help but will now stuggle with all these increases.

OP posts:
bercan · 24/10/2022 11:12

@MintyFreshOne Japan has put in policies to plan for it, China are unsuccessfully trying to raise birth rates.

DullAndOvercast · 24/10/2022 11:11

You then need more migrants to fund the previous migrants pensions and healthcare. More housing and more schools. Moving the problem forward for our great grandchildren to solve. Kicking the can down the road is what we are best at.

Yes - it a slower decline meaning tax burden is spread out over more people and possible several generations. It's not a hard concept to grasp - still a decline but over a longer period.

Also not sure about the more schools - as number of children is in steep decline and has been for decades and most immigrants tend to follow the native population and decline in number of children as children tend to be expensive and they have the same pressure against large families.

More housing been needed for decades - and in next 12-15 years population bulge of after war years will start to die off and suggestion are that it will happen in such significant numbers it will act as a 2% decline in house prices a year as supply starts to increase.

MintyFreshOne · 24/10/2022 11:10

bercan · 24/10/2022 10:46

@Worriedddd you do know that global population in most of the west have started to decline. There really aren't loads of countries having loads of dc.

We are all going to be fighting for immigrants!

Not in East Asia! Demographic decline without the large scale immigration. But they are healthier to begin with … and lean on family for support

WahineToa · 24/10/2022 11:09

Didn't the government start a campaign to bring down obesity rates during covid once it was found that overweight people were more likely to suffer badly?

Yes it did and people complained it was too ‘nanny state’. But with 2/3rds of the population in the category they’re targeting, you can understand why people were against it. So what do they do? People don’t want to be told they’re too fat and lazy and we cannot afford for them to carry on that way, we can’t afford to pay their health costs forever. We have to try better incentives. The campaign they started was piss poor, incentives work better than taxing sugar and removing junk food ads. Covid was enough of an incentive for my DH, he’s dropped so much weight. I just wonder why everyone else was afraid enough to stay indoors but not scared enough to lose weight.

bercan · 24/10/2022 11:08

free prescriptions over 60 won't be around much longer

bercan · 24/10/2022 11:07

If only we had put a pot aside out of peoples taxes over the years for pensions

you pay for those above you, that's the system.

MintyFreshOne · 24/10/2022 11:07

DullAndOvercast · 24/10/2022 10:44

No because you are just creating a pyramid scheme. Everyone gets old including unskilled migrants they will also need health, social care and pensions.

The idea with such immigration isn't to perpetuate the pyramid but to get a softer landing with the decrease in working population happen over a longer time period so tax increases being spread over more people.

So yes the immigrant population will eventually add to their cohort retirements numbers but after decades of paying working people's taxes - making the bump to smaller population less of a huge jump.

However politically it's difficult - different cultures and then as resources for working population a decline schrodinger's immigrants stuff surfaces - immigrates taking all the jobs but same time doing nothing and getting all the benefits - and fact there're needed and mean more workers to pay the tax burden gets ignored.

The better way is to give out temporary work visas so they will mostly go home before really needing to use the health system.

Lozzybear · 24/10/2022 11:07

@PigletJohn she mentioned net contribution. That’s what net contribution means.

bercan · 24/10/2022 11:06

You then need more migrants to fund the previous migrants pensions and healthcare. More housing and more schools. Moving the problem forward for our great grandchildren to solve. Kicking the can down the road is what we are best at.

You're completely missing the point that we aren't going to see such a bulge again & there needs to be a softer landing. The school population is sent to shrink by almost 1m, 1 million in the next 10 yrs!!

PigletJohn · 24/10/2022 11:05

Then the conclusions @Magn draws are not explained.

healthadvice123 · 24/10/2022 11:05

If only we had put a pot aside out of peoples taxes over the years for pensions

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 24/10/2022 11:05

Two thirds of our population are overweight or obese. That is not sustainable. You can’t stop people growing old but you can work to help people become more responsible for their own health when they’re young. This includes better menopause care to limit osteoporosis.

Great idea. But I don't think it works in practice. Didn't the government start a campaign to bring down obesity rates during covid once it was found that overweight people were more likely to suffer badly? The vast majority of people that I know (old and young) know what a healthy lifestyle involves but very few can actually be arsed doing it. Most people live for today and don't plan for possible problems in the future. Which means that the NHS is pretty fucked.

walkingonsunshinekat · 24/10/2022 11:04

WahineToa · 24/10/2022 10:54

Wrong. Brexit will cost the country £100 billion a year. It’s the biggest act of economic self harm in the developed world.

a prediction from a think tank using modelling. Look how well modelling helped us during the pandemic.

Economic modelling isn't the same as modelling an unknown new virus though is it?
Was thatcher wrong to want the UK in the Single Market?

Brexit caused gilt yields to rise (we know all know how important they are) slowed foreign investment, reduced trade amounts.

This all has an economic cost, even Steve Baker of the ERG says we got it wrong with our negotiating stance with the EU.
Lord David Frost admitted on R4's Political Thinking, that Brexit has cost the UK but he thought it worth doing as we have "sovereignty"

BTW pre 2016 he was an ardent Remainer.

healthadvice123 · 24/10/2022 11:03

@PigletJohn thats not what a net tax contributor is
Most of us will never pay enough tax to cover what its costs
I.e you have kids , therefore nhs care, education etc etc

NightmareSlashDelightful · 24/10/2022 11:03

RincewindsHat · 24/10/2022 10:58

Are we to assume you seriously have no idea who has the power to implement tax raises?

It's alright, you can switch off your sneer setting.

It just all seems a bit vague and unsourced. Hunt may not even be chancellor by teatime.

bercan · 24/10/2022 11:03

why did we all sit back and allow it to happen

I didn't have any choice but to gulp & pay up. But people feel rich when their house is expensive on paper I think, it encourages spending, equity release is booming.
My MIL the other day said she was very worried about house prices, it doesn't make any sense. Her mortgage was paid off years ago & her house is worth 1.4m 🤷🏻‍♀️

DamnUserName21 · 24/10/2022 11:03

@healthadvice123
Feel free to Google about health taxes per country. I'm not getting into that. Below is a good article explaining the differences between NHS and French system.

www.connexionfrance.com/article/Practical/Health/A-guide-for-residents-and-second-homeowners-to-the-French-healthcare-system-in-2021

Xtraincome · 24/10/2022 11:02

Me and DH are in the Lower Middle group and it's been tight for ages for us. Desperately trying to sell our house and it fell through twice!!

We have no debt other than a mortgage, so borrowing more won't bother us too much as it will be short term so when we finally sell and downsize we will be considerably better off!

It's a crap time for most tbh

AchillesLastStand · 24/10/2022 11:02

@WahineToa it’s not just think tanks saying this, the OBR is as well:

twitter.com/otto_english/status/1544001397628104709?lang=en-GB

Please tell me how the economy has benefited from Brexit. I’m all ears.

Lozzybear · 24/10/2022 11:01

@Alexandra2001 I’m comparing the UK inflation rate against the rate in the institution that we have left, that departure being the reason some are blaming our current inflation rate on. So of course it’s relevant. It’s interesting that you refer to Portugal and Bulgaria but conveniently ignore Sweden, Netherlands, Denmark, Belgium and Austria, all of which have similar or higher inflation rates than the UK. France is the outlier because it doesn’t have the same energy cost pressure that the rest of Europe is facing due to its use of nuclear energy.

Worriedddd · 24/10/2022 11:01

DamnUserName21 · 24/10/2022 10:57

Whilst I love the idea of robots assisting with ADLs for people that need it, I can't see it happening before, say, 2043 which is when 25% of the population is expected to be over 65.
And, yes, migrants need healthcare (aside from short-term needs) and pensions but not for, possibly, 40-50 years after arriving in Britain.

You then need more migrants to fund the previous migrants pensions and healthcare. More housing and more schools. Moving the problem forward for our great grandchildren to solve. Kicking the can down the road is what we are best at.

DullAndOvercast · 24/10/2022 11:01

This seems a very vague "explanation" of how it's not a ponzi scheme - and it's a legitimate question about things like housing provision, too - that's Schrodinger's in the sense of them apparently not needing any extra housing, transport etc provision.

It is a Ponzi scheme in that current working population are one paying the state pensions - and for NHS services overwhelming used though not exclusively used by older people.

If there aren't enough workers - tax burden gets too high for them to cope and/or services get cut or completely lost.

A less steep slump means that's more gradual processes - rather than upside down pyramid most of western world is looking at.

Housing is a massive problem successive government for decades have ignored or made worse.

Transport - well they need paying customers - and often some government support so yet more money from taxes - so having more working population there is a good thing.

healthadvice123 · 24/10/2022 11:00

@Worriedddd its not their fault it wasn't earned is it
Where has everyone been for the last 20/25 years when house prices started going crazy
Many people including a lot on here will of been rubbing their hands as they made £20000 in their house
My mum and dad made a lot on their house due to house prices but then sold and moved out of london as on pensions they couldn't afford to live in london so released some equity
There 3 bed terraced went for £600000 their lies one of the biggest problems
Its a small family house , an old working mans house built for railway workers I believe years ago, why did we all sit back and allow it to happen

Ginandthings · 24/10/2022 11:00

The idea of means testing to decide if you pay to use a service we already pay for is a very scary thought! I understand that things can’t go on as they are but rather than taking more from people someone needs to take an honest look at how things are run.
I’m a single parent to 2 dc who works full time and earn £60k, on paper it looks ok, until you deduct childcare, mortgage (cheaper than rent), the fact I’m entitled to nothing, not even child benefit. I genuinely struggle to pay all the bills each month, my ex pays the absolute minimum but obviously means testing just looks at income rather than outgoings.

bercan · 24/10/2022 10:59

Sure. Can you elaborate

i'm trying to watch House of Dragons here people!

There's a reason why poorer areas have higher obesity rates, etc etc