Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I should report parent sitting in car with nursery child.

337 replies

wellstopdoingitthen · 23/10/2022 22:58

I live opposite a primary school. There's a mum who collects her nursery child at 11.30 then sits in the car with her until the older children finish at 3pm. She usually sits there with the engine running which is right next to the playground. I'm not sure if I should do anything or if I'm being a busy body.
I know the little one is in there because I did ask the mum to turn off her engine during the really hot weather. I got an earful because apparently she needed it on because it was hot in the car.
Yabu- keep your nose out
Yanbu- you should notify the school/authorities

OP posts:
RedWingBoots · 24/10/2022 10:23

SendHelp999 · 23/10/2022 23:50

Eh? How do you know she sits there for hours unless you watch her for hours?

If you are working from home and sitting near a window it isn't hard to see someone sitting in their vehicle for hours. You also start recognising the vehicles that park in front of you every day.

Septemberintherain · 24/10/2022 10:21

How have the school/nursery not noticed a parent sitting there for hours? Or any other parent?
And why do people start a thread and not respond for hours/days?

Ellyess · 24/10/2022 10:20

Sometimes we do not understand everything about another person's life. It would seem better if she could sometimes take her child to a park or go for a little walk. But what do we know? Maybe the little one is exhausted after Nursery, and they share lunch, and she sleeps. Maybe she has special needs. This time in the car might be some of the happiest times with mummy that the child has. It's just not up to us to judge.
I used to regret having to put my toddler in the car to collect her sisters from school, then take them to piano lessons. I'd drive her home during the lessons, and she'd fall asleep, and I would stay in the car with her until it was time to go back for her sisters. It was a strange life. But later when she started school I used to pick her up and take her to the park with our dog. We'd have a snack and a drink. She said these picnics were one of the things she enjoyed most in her childhood. Swings and roundabouts, I suppose.

oakleaffy · 24/10/2022 10:20

VimFuego101 · 23/10/2022 23:01

I wonder if they're in temp housing that they have to leave during the day between certain times. I would tell the school, in case there's anything they can to do offer support - not 'reporting' in the sense of complaining.

I heard of this happening to someone.. Horrible!
They weren't allowed to be in their 'Bed and breakfast' between certain hours?
I couldn't believe it.
What if someone was ill? What if it was raining or cold?

I do think that they should shut off the engine, though, the sound of a chuntering engine is very irritating, plus very polluting.

warmeduppizza · 24/10/2022 10:18

‘Reporting’ doesn’t mean to say anyone is doing anything wrong. It’s just reporting a potential concern. It is perfectly possible to flag something up with the school’s safeguarding lead without social services jumping on the case. That’s what they’re for - not to blame anyone, but to advise. They’ve done all the training and are better at discerning what is and what isn’t a concern than the average member of the public.

greenbradket · 24/10/2022 10:07

How do you know she keeps her engine running all that time?
Unless you actively sit and watch her for all those hours you have no idea
I would mind my business

NewHopeNow · 24/10/2022 10:06

I thought the main message over the last few years has been that too many people have been minding their own business and children have been getting no help because of it. You can't move around my kids school or read a letter without "safeguarding is everyone's responsibility" jumping out at you.

In this instance there would be nothing wrong with making the school aware.

CarefreeMe · 24/10/2022 10:05

It is not possible to keep a nursery aged child occupied for 3.5hours in a cramped car.

It’s surely not possible to keep the engine running for 3.5 hours every day.

It’s unlikely that the women has not needed the toilet in that time on any occasion.

It’s also highly unlikely that OP has nothing better to do that to stare out a window for 3.5 hours.

What is more likely is that yes this women parks there everyday but they go for walks, to the toilet, for some food etc in between which OP doesn’t see.

WrongWayApricot · 24/10/2022 10:03

NCtonotgetroasted · 24/10/2022 09:50

@WrongWayApricot it's not good though! Ideally children of early years age shouldn't be in cars/car seats/prams for hours on end as it impacts on their gross and fine motor development.
It's one of the things we used to look out for on home visits. Babies and toddlers constantly strapped in and not able to move freely. 3.5 hours is a pretty long time. 1 hour is quite long to be stationary for no purpose every day for a baby. Different if it's a journey but to just be sat there idling the car.

I would definitely report. Things may seem trivial but you don't know the full picture for this little one

It's a toddler, I bet nearly anything it's asleep for the majority of the time. Pick up at 11.30am, perfect time for lunch and a nap, which is what they would probably be doing at home anyway. We don't know if they are strapped in or laying across the back seat. Or, maybe they have a lie flat car seat like we did from birth, because I was very concerned about mine falling asleep in a car seat.

I also don't believe the car is idling everyday, I think it is during heatwaves and when it's very cold. Because OP said she asked and got an earful because of the a/c and OP has been irked enough to post now when the weather has turned cold. I don't think the car has idled all the months in between. If it has report the car for idling. Don't report for a toddler having lunch and a midday nap in a car fgs.

pinkolu · 24/10/2022 10:00

toomuchlaundry · 24/10/2022 09:53

For those saying maybe she is scared to go home, don’t you think school should know about that.

If ever police are called to a domestic incident and there are children in the home they are meant to alert their school as soon as possible under Operation Encompass

She could be. Or it could be too long a drive.

But why not go to the park or a walk? She needed the air conditioning on so this was obviously in good weather.
Or go to a local library or something in bad weather

Icouldabeenalawyer · 24/10/2022 09:57

Is she feeding the child? How is the child going to the bathroom? How are they staying sane in there?
Odd. If its true I'd tell the nursery.

toomuchlaundry · 24/10/2022 09:53

For those saying maybe she is scared to go home, don’t you think school should know about that.

If ever police are called to a domestic incident and there are children in the home they are meant to alert their school as soon as possible under Operation Encompass

CruelworldKindwords · 24/10/2022 09:52

If it was me and I lived opposite, I'd invite her in for a cup of tea. Toddler could have a drink and watch Cbeebies.
I'd let her talk if she wanted to and figure out if there was a way I could help her.

I'm not saying OP should do that, and there is always the risk of the woman taking advantage, but that's what I would do.

NCtonotgetroasted · 24/10/2022 09:50

@WrongWayApricot it's not good though! Ideally children of early years age shouldn't be in cars/car seats/prams for hours on end as it impacts on their gross and fine motor development.
It's one of the things we used to look out for on home visits. Babies and toddlers constantly strapped in and not able to move freely. 3.5 hours is a pretty long time. 1 hour is quite long to be stationary for no purpose every day for a baby. Different if it's a journey but to just be sat there idling the car.

I would definitely report. Things may seem trivial but you don't know the full picture for this little one

Begoniasforever · 24/10/2022 09:44

If she was running her car on idle for four hours a day I’m surprised it’s still working.

toomuchlaundry · 24/10/2022 09:41

@RGinaPhalange and maybe the school can signpost her to some support to make her life a little better.

PeloFondo · 24/10/2022 09:40

Riapia · 24/10/2022 09:35

Do you take a lunch break during your 3.5 hr vigil.

Confused I'm pretty sure you don't have to be on a vigil to notice a car there
I work facing a window. If I look up, I can see what's happening outside
Plus when a car is idling, you can hear it

Xenia · 24/10/2022 09:38

She must be using a lot of petrol to have the car on all that time.

RGinaPhalange · 24/10/2022 09:35

My nursery age daughter naps form
about 12.00 until 2.30. I wonder if the child is a poor napper and she maybe drives around to get them to sleep and parks up once they’ve nodded off. Maybe she keeps the engine running so the won’t wake up and she gets a bit of time to herself?

Im not condoning it in any way, it’s far too long to be in a car seat or cooped up in car. Definitely not ok to keep the engine running either but it might offer and explanation.

I don’t thing you’re being unreasonable to be concerned but I probably wouldn’t report it to anyone. Being a mum is hard and maybe she’s just doing what she needs to
do to get by

Riapia · 24/10/2022 09:35

Do you take a lunch break during your 3.5 hr vigil.

Inyournewdress · 24/10/2022 09:34

I would definitely alert the school initially and see what they do.

theDudesmummy · 24/10/2022 09:30

It is your business. People saying that it's not are entirely wrong. I would contact the school and/or the duty social worker.

RiftGibbon · 24/10/2022 09:29

Hellocatshome · 23/10/2022 23:20

Sounds like a welfare concern to me. Is she scared to go home during the day .does she not have a home to go to etc? I would tell the school but in a safeguarding sense not a reporting her sense as no one would choose to do this for no reason.

That would be my issue.
The environmental issue is a big deal for me too, but I don't think there are any channels for this one to pursue.

How you keep a small child sitting in a car for that long regularly is mindblowing.

CarefreeMe · 24/10/2022 09:28

Im confused ..what is she doing wrong?
There must be a reason why shes doing it, so instead of reporting her for the crime of sitting in her own car

I agree.

She’s obviously not doing this by choice and reporting her because she’s kept the engine running for the heater because they’re cold is pretty messed up.

It’s very difficult to keep a young child entertained for so long even if they are climbing around.
So it’s highly likely they are going for walks in between and OP can’t know this unless she’s sat at the window for all those hours too.

itsgettingweird · 24/10/2022 09:21

Safeguarding is everyone's business.

If there's nothing to see it won't be found.

If there's something to find it won't be found with silence.

The child and/or the mum could be at risk of harm.

It could just be a family that moved house and they cannot afford the travel back and forth and are waiting or a local school place.

But by staying silent no one will know and you could be ,issuing a chance to help someone who needs it.