Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I should report parent sitting in car with nursery child.

337 replies

wellstopdoingitthen · 23/10/2022 22:58

I live opposite a primary school. There's a mum who collects her nursery child at 11.30 then sits in the car with her until the older children finish at 3pm. She usually sits there with the engine running which is right next to the playground. I'm not sure if I should do anything or if I'm being a busy body.
I know the little one is in there because I did ask the mum to turn off her engine during the really hot weather. I got an earful because apparently she needed it on because it was hot in the car.
Yabu- keep your nose out
Yanbu- you should notify the school/authorities

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hoplesscynic · 29/10/2022 11:46

CarefreeMe · 27/10/2022 09:52

The update is very different to your OP.

You implied that she spends the entire time sat in the car but your update says that the car is parked there all that time but you don’t actually know if she’s sat in there. Which she can’t be if you’ve only just noticed a child in there too.

The only reason you have made a thread/want to report her is because you happened to walk past and told her to turn her engine off and she was rude to you - but now all of a sudden you’re concerned about a child’s welfare?!

OP explained this already - she did know the woman was in the car due to her engine being constantly on.
The day OP went over and asked her to turn off her engine is when OP realised the child was also in the car.

What's so hard to understand?

LololaLo2012 · 27/10/2022 20:57

So let me get this right… she sits in the car presumably with a 3/4 year old from 11.30 until 3pm? So 3.5 hours?! Wtf!!

There must be something more going on here right?

Having had children in big school and one in preschool (and a baby) at similar pick up times, I do understand that the backwards and forwards of multiple drop offs and picks ups is hard work at time. But this is not normal behaviour or something that I ever would have done. Like I said there must be more to it. Why wouldn’t you go home? Park? Cafe?

Maybe ask her if she is ok? I mean if something is wrong it could take her a few “are you okays” for her to say something?

Maybe mentioned it to the school isn’t a bad thing.

I felt like I had to let the preschool teacher know that I constantly saw a family drop and collect there child/children in the car each day not using seat belts, car seats and a baby on their lap. I know it was NONE of my business how people parent but I just felt if anything happened that I wouldn’t be able to forgive myself. The teacher was lovely and agreed that I did the right thing in telling her. Not sure if anything was actually said but I tried not to look after I mentioned it as I just felt really uncomfortable every time I saw them getting in the car.

xx

Blondeshavemorefun · 27/10/2022 20:50

Seems very weird doesn’t go home - obv not a petrol cost issue is there for 3.5hrs with engine running

and with a park locally as well - why not go there if weather nice

you could knock on window and ask if she is ok as you see her there daily for a long time

or mention it to the school if worried

WrongWayApricot · 27/10/2022 20:02

@toomuchlaundry I've seen lot of hand wringing on this thread about a lack of exercise and exploring. Napping toddlers (which is a lot of them between 11.30 and 3.30) are not exercising and exploring. Idling has already been nearly unanimously agreed as bad.

toomuchlaundry · 27/10/2022 18:52

@WrongWayApricot not angry people, concerned people. People who know about safeguarding. If it turns out the child is napping that might be fine but I can think of more comfortable places and the car cannot have its engine idling all that time

WrongWayApricot · 27/10/2022 18:47

I'm baffled at the angry people who want to report saying the toddler should be running around in the park. Nearly everyone that said don't report thinks/thought the toddler is napping. You can't get exercise while napping? Most toddlers nap in the early afternoon? How many toddlers across the country do you think are being neglected by having nap time instead of going to the park?

luxxlisbon · 27/10/2022 17:29

So a provocative and pointless thread for absolutely no reason. At times you have seen this car outside the school between 11ish and 3ish and one single time you have seen a woman and child in it. 🙄

sue20 · 27/10/2022 15:54

drkpl · 26/10/2022 22:00

The car idling is one thing. The welfare of the mother and her reasons for doing so are another. But importantly, NO CHILD should be subjected to being strapped into a car for 3.5 hours EVERY DAY regardless of circumstances.

I’m not saying we should look down on the mother. However, all this “reporting” fear mongering nonsense is ridiculous and trivialising.This needs to be raised with either the school, social services, or the police so that adequate support can be provided. Believe it or not, the police don’t see it as being in the child’s best interest to be whipped away from its mother- they will try to offer support and investigate why the mother is behaving in this way. Believe it or not, she probably won’t get into any shit for the idling either- they do use their discretion, and prob why would in this circumstance.

Shame on the ones who would look the other way.

Assuming it’s the mother…..?

Dinomum79 · 27/10/2022 15:44

Yanbu

DangerousAlchemy · 27/10/2022 13:22

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 24/10/2022 00:49

YABVU to give a shit. I’m assuming the nursery child naps? I’ve spent many an hour sat in a car while my kids slept! And she was right about keeping the engine running, she’d need the air con on. Seems like you just wanted to go out and make a point. Maybe find a hobby that’s not curtain twitching?

Bloody he'll she can take the kid out, pop in a pushchair & go for a walk so it can nap!! and YOU shouldn't have your engine idling for ages either @LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet while your kids nap because it is ILLEGAL & YOU are polluting the environment 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

TheBiologyStupid · 27/10/2022 11:01

toomuchlaundry · 27/10/2022 07:14

It’s called safeguarding @Berrylina not being nosy.

If the child was with the nanny or childminder would any parent be happy with this arrangement?

That's a good point - do we know that this woman is the child's mother?

CarefreeMe · 27/10/2022 09:52

The update is very different to your OP.

You implied that she spends the entire time sat in the car but your update says that the car is parked there all that time but you don’t actually know if she’s sat in there. Which she can’t be if you’ve only just noticed a child in there too.

The only reason you have made a thread/want to report her is because you happened to walk past and told her to turn her engine off and she was rude to you - but now all of a sudden you’re concerned about a child’s welfare?!

AloysiusBear · 27/10/2022 09:47

How old is the kid? At 18m DS would have had a minimum 3 hour nap from 11.30 - 2.30....

GreyCarpet · 27/10/2022 09:46

cherry2727 · 23/10/2022 23:16

I refuse to believe a child this age will remain in a car for this long!!! Do they leave and go for long walks ?? Is the child napping ?? There is more to this story!

They will if it is want they are used to. The same as children who are severely neglected don't cry because they've learnt there's no point and no one will come to them even if they do.

caramac04 · 27/10/2022 09:44

FlibbertyGiblets · 23/10/2022 23:02

I would alert nursery. The child should not be contained in a vehicle from 11.30 to 3pm. There may be a reason why they can't go home.

This. The child should be moving around, park on a nice day or even a museum/ library. The child’s physical, mental, emotional development is being hindered.
There might be a reason they can’t go home but the child’s needs are nowhere near being met. What about needing a toilet?

anastaisia · 27/10/2022 09:40

My initial assumption was that it would be to do with naps. My eldest kept up an afternoon nap for ages and could sleep for up to 3 hours.

If I’d had other kids at the time, and found myself in this circumstance then I could definitely see myself bringing a book/work to do and getting her to have her nap in the car after nursery, while I had a few hours to read or do admin before picking the others up and going on to do something fun and active with them so she would be tired out again for bed later. She was much happier when she had a good afternoon sleep.

But I wouldn’t have kept the car running for hours. I might have had a quick drive round to get her to sleep and then parked up with the engine off. So I probably wouldn’t have done it in extreme temperatures where the car couldn’t stay cool/warm without the air con.

POTC · 27/10/2022 09:16

angela99999 · 26/10/2022 20:03

Unlikely to have a car if they are homeless or in emergency accommodation.

@angela99999 that's absolutely incorrect and very judgemental! I was homeless and in emergency accommodation. I had a car. I know numerous people who have had to live in emergency accommodation and had their cars. My current car cost less than the monthly rent on my son's uni accommodation, if I became homeless again selling it wouldn't get me enough money for somewhere to live but would make it impossible get to work to earn money to pay the rent on temporary accommodation (which was the same as for a 3 bed house incidentally, for one room in a hostel, it's not free.)

5yearplan · 27/10/2022 09:11

Yes I used to live opposite a primary school and you do get to know the cars and faces and people’s routines. There was not enough space in the car park and it was a nightmare on the road so some parents did arrive really early for pick-up in the afternoon to get a space.

In op’s position I wouldn’t think to report it to the police but might mention it to the school.

I would imagine the parent doesn’t want to drive home and back again although I agree it’s a concern.

SkaterGrrrrl · 27/10/2022 08:54

Haven't rtft but to all those saying OP is nosy/ how on earth can OP know/ is she on her pavement or looking out her window 4 hours a day:

I live opposite a primary school. You 100% get to recognise parents and kids. There is the mum in the blue car who always parks across our neighbour's driveway because she can't be bothered to walk half a block. There is the family who rides on the pavement on tricycles, scattering pedestrians. There is the dad who ties a dachshund to a railing and leave it barking while he takes his son inside.

I'm not a particularly nosy person but I know what's happening on my road generally. I walk DS to a (different) nearby primary school, I open the front door to get the milk in or let the cat out or to receive parcels. (I also struggle to find a parking space at 9 a.m. or 3 p.m!)

TLDR: if you live opposite a primary school, you will get to know the habits of parents doing drop-offs and pick-ups.

LuckyLil · 27/10/2022 08:52

LoisLane66 · 26/10/2022 17:32

@Whowhatwherewhenwhy1
Typical, thinking of reasons why she should, not reasons why she shouldn't. It matters not what her circumstances are, it's against the law. Would you make a similar excuse for someone who commited theft? Both are against the law.

Opposite ends of the scale though. You'll get the police out to a burglary in progress. You won't get the police out because someone was idling.p their engine. In fact they'd probably reprimand you for time wasting. It's about perspective.

dayswithaY · 27/10/2022 08:04

The most obvious explanation is the mother doesn’t want to do more than one trip from the school to home. I used to see this a lot outside my children’s school, although that was mainly women without children in the car who had just finished work and didn’t want to do two trips.

The child is obviously staring at the Mum’s phone for the majority of the time, or she’s asleep. It’s not great and most people wouldn’t choose to do it but some parents don’t care.

She’s already spoken aggressively to OP so she’d be mad to invite her inside for cups of tea and a nice chats.

The engine running is a problem but if this child was sat at home staring at a phone while Mum ignored her, we wouldn’t know about it. Social services have got emergencies to deal with.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 27/10/2022 07:37

BananaCocktails · 23/10/2022 23:19

Ring social services who the f does that to a child
horrendous

Perhaps someone who doesn't have a home life which enables her to be there in the day.

Shamrock77 · 27/10/2022 07:34

P.S I'm pretty shocked too at how people are saying mind your own business! This is concerning behaviour and like others have said, Mum may need help and it is certainly not helping the child's development.

Shamrock77 · 27/10/2022 07:32

Definitely mention this to the school. For whatever reason the Mum is doing this, it is certainly not normal behaviour!! Poor child being stuck in the car for that long, especially in the hot weather and playing on a mobile phone at that age for so long. Why not take the child to the park etc during that time? Very odd. Good luck x

Plopplopplopplopplopploppy · 27/10/2022 07:25

This is a concern, I would be mentioning it to the school/nursery, they may not know and then can find out why this is happening. If this was happening in my place of work we would want to know. Could be a safeguarding issue if they are avoiding something, also that’s a long time to be sat in a car everyday.

Swipe left for the next trending thread